Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pros and cons of relying on parents for childcare

61 replies

slamskunk · 19/02/2024 14:10

30 hours a week or there abouts.

We have two days off each, but will overlap a day for family time.

One day of nursery.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Chickenrunning · 20/02/2024 13:49

Pros - cost.
Building a great bond

Cons - changing it is hard and it is hard to think of all the situations that might cause change, and they tend to sneak up on you gradually.
Biggest change is if you have a second child, particularly if the gap means there will be significant time when they look after 2, that is much more challenging.
Can bring challenge to your sibling relationship. A a sibling has similar age children they may get jealous/envious of the help/relationship your children have, even if it is not possible due to distance etc if they live far away. If they have children later your parents may not be able to look after their children in the same way now they are older, which can also lead to resentment.

I would also do a minimum of 2 days nursery for all reasons above, plus adding extra days at nursery to over grandparents holiday would be easier in that situation.

CuttingMeOpenthenHealingMeFine · 20/02/2024 13:49

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 20/02/2024 13:30

I will say that DS is never sick since he's not in group childcare which is a big plus

But doesn't that mean he'll just get sick and miss loads of school in reception instead?

My DS was looked after by grandparents from around 10 months until 3 when he got a place in the nursery of the primary school that he now goes to. My Mum took him to loads of toddler groups so he was exposed to other DC but when he went to nursery he was ill constantly for two years until he started P1.

On the other hand my DD had the exact same circumstances and hardly caught anything (still hardly does) so I think it’s more individual child than whether they go to nurseries as babies but probably on balance it helps to expose them younger.

Whoknowsohyoudo · 20/02/2024 13:36

NoCloudsAllowed · 20/02/2024 13:03

@Whoknowsohyoudo the lack of sickness bugs is a big plus now, but you have to go through it at some point - they can miss a lot of reception if that's the first time they're exposed to the filth pond!

Very true. He's a healthy big lad so I'm not so much worried for him as what he'd traffic back home to the baby. I've read plenty of horror stories on here about how often people's dc get ill from school and nursery and it does make you worry a bit😩

RosePetals86 · 20/02/2024 13:34

Pros : you know your children are as well looked after and as loved as if they were with you.

cons: you will feel less able to ask for baby sitting favours when you and dh want a date night as your parents will have already had them all week!

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 20/02/2024 13:30

I will say that DS is never sick since he's not in group childcare which is a big plus

But doesn't that mean he'll just get sick and miss loads of school in reception instead?

Arabels · 20/02/2024 13:27

Excellent post @NoCloudsAllowed

Arabels · 20/02/2024 13:25

Pros, best case scenario:
Huge savings in cost
GP’s love DGC with all their hearts and children need love to flourish.
Opportunity to build strong, lasting relationships

Cons, best case scenario:
Everyone has to agree the same holiday schedule
Differences in care style can be more tricky to negotiate
Children are exhausting and GP’s may not keep up

For the worst case scenarios you can read the rest of mumsnet…30 hours pwk is a huge commitment and I’d have been skeptical if my own fit, caring, competent parents would have managed it.

Bobskeleton · 20/02/2024 13:15

We use a childminder, nursery and my parents.
The GP generally don't have them for long or many days of the week, it's more to plug gaps in other childcare as both me and my partner work shifts, days/nights.

It's obviously great as they can provide childcare outside of normal working hours.
My children are spending time with their GP and building relationships.
And we are massively appreciative that it helps us save some money.

Luckily I haven't had any cons. The only thing I would suggest you think about is do they have other dependables? My nan is very unwell ATM so things have had to (rightly) change so my mum can be there for her. But luckily we can fall back on other relatives and childcare.

NoCloudsAllowed · 20/02/2024 13:03

Whoknowsohyoudo · 20/02/2024 13:00

This is spot on. My DM is now in the habit of canceling at the last minute due to "headache, diarrhea, stars were not lined up properly in last night's sky, etc" She loved watching ds when he was small, but once he hit 4 she was over it. Too much running after him I suppose. And as pps have said DG feed them junk(even if you pack healthy food), they let them have too much screen time etc. I will say that DS is never sick since he's not in group childcare which is a big plus

@Whoknowsohyoudo the lack of sickness bugs is a big plus now, but you have to go through it at some point - they can miss a lot of reception if that's the first time they're exposed to the filth pond!

Whoknowsohyoudo · 20/02/2024 13:00

Mumofteenandtween · 19/02/2024 14:30

The big problem is that grandparents often agree to do childcare when the child is a lovely little baby that lies still and looks cute.

And then they blink and find themselves looking after a toddler who likes to climb the bookcases, shouts “CHARGE!” every 8 minutes, likes to switch on the washing machine when they aren’t looking, doesn’t understand the word “no” and most definitely does not lie still and look cute.

This is spot on. My DM is now in the habit of canceling at the last minute due to "headache, diarrhea, stars were not lined up properly in last night's sky, etc" She loved watching ds when he was small, but once he hit 4 she was over it. Too much running after him I suppose. And as pps have said DG feed them junk(even if you pack healthy food), they let them have too much screen time etc. I will say that DS is never sick since he's not in group childcare which is a big plus

NoCloudsAllowed · 20/02/2024 09:45

To add to things said above.

When kids are aged around 1-2.5, some days and stages you just barely sit down and need to be watching child attentively all the time. They'll be tottering around and need to be walked, or pulling at plants on a shelf, trying to climb on work surfaces etc. It's exhausting. Are your DP retired and usually rest when they want? They can tag team a bit but it's still a lot.

Would they care for DC at your house or their house? If theirs, probably there's a bit of childproofing to be done - do they have pale carpets, china ornaments, nice furniture? If they watch child at your house, prepare to find it a bit weird that they're using your stuff, putting things in wrong place, seeing things you might prefer they didn't etc.

A big one - attitudes to discipline have changed a lot, even in a few decades. Now there's lots of emphasis on emotional and mental health and wellbeing, helping children express themselves, validating their anger and trying to help them with it etc - previous generations are way less sensitive to this stuff and often think it's namby pamby nonsense, think best way to deal with tantrums is laughing or ignoring them and so on.

The likely thing is that the nursery would have a very gentle and sensitive, conflict-resolution based approach to discipline, you'll mimic this a bit but wing it and lose patience sometimes because you're only human, your parents will not bother with the softly-softly stuff and resolve situations with chocolate biscuits. Probably also way more TV and maybe phone or tablet time than you would ideally like.

What do you actually want your DC's relationship with DP to be like, and what do they want? The more hours they do, the more they will be hands-on with things like discipline, potty training, shaping behaviours etc. I think being a GP is much nicer when it's about a short burst of full attention, being taken somewhere nice and doing something nice, a bit away from the everyday routine.

It would also interfere with your DP routine - say they get invited to lunch with friends, or want to go to an event - do they say no as they have your DC?

If you rely on DP and then one gets ill/injured etc it's extra bad as you have the stress of the health aspect plus stress of trying to find childcare at short notice.

Personally we had childminder from 12 months for 2 days, GP for one day, I did two days. It worked fine. Then 4.5 days at nursery from age 3 and GP started doing overnight babysitting sometimes or taking them for days out here and there. Now DC are primary school age and will go for the odd overnight or stay with DP a couple of days in school holidays.

MsSquiggle · 20/02/2024 09:16

I’ve always operated on the philosophy of not employing someone that will make Christmas really difficult/awkward if you fired them.

I know that the benefits of grandparent care are extensive, however, my parents have sporting commitments, extensive oversea holidays, illness, regular coffee dates with friends - they genuinely would not fit in caring full time for a toddler and wouldn’t want to be tied down. However, they’re more than happy to step in for occasional nights out, holidays at grandparents for a few nights, emergency care of child if sick or daycare is closed.

If I were you, I’d try for three days in nursery and one with your parents/his parents (alternating if both are keen). Save their offers of care for emergencies or nights out. Don’t blur the role of grandparents and active parenting, cause with that many hours they cant help but to feel like they are entitled to have a say on parenting decisions… or at least that’s what I’ve witnessed in my friendship group.

ToothFairy2023 · 20/02/2024 07:59

Its tricky unless your current relationship with them is absolutely excellent, they and you are on the younger side and they don’t have a lot of social commitments it could work but I think maybe one or two days max would be more workable and doable all round. Anymore could be problematic.

Can you not reduce your overheads and or reduce your hours for a few years OP it is a massive ask. To put in several long days of childcare as you get older, stiffer a bit less mobile can take its toll once mid 60’s and beyond etc.

lanthanum · 20/02/2024 00:50

A lot is going to depend on the grandparents. You need to know that they're going to cope with the child when they are a stroppy toddler, and of course their health and stamina is likely to decline, although hopefully not too fast. I think it's probably worth setting regular review points, so that it's relatively easy for the grandparents to say if it's getting too much.

Where grandparents are on the younger side, there may be problems if the great grandparents start needing more help, and the grandparents are stuck trying to help everyone.

TheSoundThatIWasHearing · 20/02/2024 00:32

It all depends on your relationship with them. If you have any issues, it will all be magnified once they are doing childcare.

My mum did an afternoon a week for me. She tried many times to use it as a way to manipulate me. I refused to let her, and in the end it settled down and was an overwhelmingly positive thing for all of us.

But it's a huge commitment for everyone. There needs to be a lot of give and take on both sides. They will take holidays, be ill, get invited places. So if you need rock solid childcare, you'd be better with a more formal solution.

Passingthethyme · 19/02/2024 23:50

Depends on the age if under 2ish:
*Have 1:1 care with a loved one
*Grow bonds with family
*Always a priority and you don't have to worry about being neglected, hurt by another child as well as picking up bad habits. Also nappy gets changed quickly, fed when they need it etc
*With someone you can trust
*Have more flexibility
*Won't get constantly sick

All pros to me, if over 2 then a couple of days in nursery are good as they may need more stimulation, will learn more things than they would at home and also socialise with other children and start to make friends

daffodilandtulip · 19/02/2024 23:33

I'm a childminder and the amount of times I've heard "do you have a space, grandparents have changed their mind about having baby and I go back to work next week." Or I start off sharing care but by the end of the first year, grandparents do just an afternoon.

Onabench · 19/02/2024 23:33

The pros and cons depend on the grandparent

Flexability and reliability are the pros, in the right setting

Potential cons
not following your rules, ie feeding them before 6 months because that’s how they raised their children, feeding them crap in general, skipping naps, cuddling to sleep, seatbelt rules? Giving dummies after we’ve with held them. These things matter less as they get older I suppose. My FIL took my child to hospital for ankle pain without telling me 🙃 I didn’t “know” these things before they helped with childcare. But they sure as hell don’t have my second child.

Escaperoom · 19/02/2024 23:30

Grandparent here. We looked after DGD1 and DGS2 for two days a week from babyhood up to 3 when they went to pre-school. DGD started pre-school while DD was still on maternity leave with DGS so only ever had one at at time, apart from school holidays. I don't think we could have done 30 hours - 2 days a week was fine but any more would have been too tiring/tying. Now both are at school/pre-school we are redundant! Still do some school holiday care though. Have never had an issue with DD and SiL over food, naps, TV time, etc as we all respect each others opinions (which don't differ much anyway). Have always taken them out to playground, country park, swimming, soft play and read to, done crafts with, played with them. Have to say though that we probably couldn't have gone on much longer as we are getting older now and DH has been diagnosed with an incurable cancer (although currently well). Not likely to have any more DGC so no issue there but could be for some people I guess. Whether it works or not depends on the people involved I think but it can be good for all concerned and we have definitely built a bond with the DGC that we might not otherwise have done.

Lightnose · 19/02/2024 21:59

It worked really well for us and meant DC had a very close relationship with GPs, which is lovely, but

  • our relationship with DPs was very good beforehand. If anyone had any concerns about anything, they'd just be discussed and resolved without anyone worrying about stepping on eggshells
  • it was always on the understanding that it would be their rules when DC were with them. I was happy that their way would be good enough/perfectly fine, even if it wasn't the way I'd do it.
  • we always accepted that they could/would cancel for any reason. They'd give as much notice as they could, but ultimately if they fancied a gee days away. They'd have it and we'd have to make alternative arrangements/take leave.

A PP said problem if GPs are ill, which is true, but my DPs were happy to have DC when DC were ill, which other childcare won't, so swings and roundabouts

ToothFairy2023 · 19/02/2024 21:56

For:
Its cheaper so you save money.
Kids have a closer relationship with GP’s.
GP’s in theory likely to have a more vested interest in your childs welfare and educational development and they will have more 1 to 1 time than say they might have with a couple of 19 year old nursery staff. They may be quick communicators and appear bright initially from all the 1 to 1 time (but other kids over take them educationally so it evens out).

Against:
It’s very tying and tiring for your parents. They may not be in the best of health and be frightened to let you down and it could take a toll on their health. It could put a strain on your relationship with your parents as the child grows up if they are overly close with your child. You may have to bite your tongue a lot and go along with your parents views on child rearing even if they are out of step with current thinking and your thinking as you are not paying for a service you have to keep stum. Children may grow up to be a bit old fashioned, out of step with peers, less good at sharing, less sociable with peers, be a bit spoiled and more demanding and attention seeking than children who go to nursery and mix mainly with kids their own age. If your parents are ill you will have to take time off work at short notice.

We had no free childcare whatsoever and my parents didn’t even babysit for us for the occasional night out even for one of our birthdays. Yet they practically brought up my niece up who lives 5 mins closer and is just over a year older than my eldest. This took everything out of them so they had nothing left for a relationship with my children.

My Niece is 21 now lots of arguments between my sis, niece and my mum over the years and this is still going on. As my niece is forever telling tales to my mum who always takes my nieces side over her mums and everyone else, she has a boyfriend now but has no friends her own age now. She spends an unhealthy amount of time at my mums house now with her boyfriend and she always seems to hold court at my mums and would speak down to other adults as though she knew best and she has done this from a very young age. I was a bit jealous of the free childcare at first and the fact that my mum always raved about my niece and barely mentioned my children. But I think my two have turned out better for it.

89redballoons · 19/02/2024 21:49

I think it depends on the relationship that you have with your parents/in-laws, and the kind of relationship that you build and maintain while they're doing the childcare.

The massive pro is, or at least should be, that grandparents actually love your DC almost as much as you do. No matter how warm, knowledgeable and energetic nursery staff or childminders are, they won't love your children like family members do. Especially for very young children, having a loving caregiver and building a close bond with a grandparent are really positive and pretty much irreplaceable.

The other obvious pro is that it can be free or waaaay cheaper than childcare. This might make you feel guilty. Be very grateful and if they won't accept money then treat them in other ways.

Cons are that it can be awkward telling your loving parents, who are giving up their time of their own volition, that you want or need things done in a particular way with your DC. If they are set in their ways and won't stick to your nap routine, or they feed your kid things you wouldn't want them to, or even if they refuse to take things like safe sleep guidance and carseat safety seriously, that can lead to some nasty family rows. Complaining to a nursery or childminder is easier because it's ultimately a business relationship.

Things like holidays and illness are an issue but that's the same with a childminder. However, older age can make illnesses more likely. This of course hugely varies from family to family. That said it's worth considering that if you have 2 kids with a 3 year gap, that's 6 or 7 years you might be relying on grandparents for pre-school childcare for, and people's health can change significantly in that time, especially for people in their 60s or thereabouts.

Birch101 · 19/02/2024 21:29

Most nurseries would want min 2 sessions a week so one day might cause problems settling in.

Your holidays will be set by when GP want holidays
Your child will only be exposed to things they want to do (my ILs won't do things like soft play or library classes only going on walks)
The GP may feel they spend more time with child so have right to have say in things
GP sickness short notice time off work for yourselves
You still need to spend time with ILs as well as a whole family even thought they see child regularly

My aunt and uncle care alot for their grandchildren and they do find it tiring what seems to work well for them is a mixture of full days and then afternoons collecting from nursery after morning session and lunch - obviously you then would have to provide additional car seat if nursery not walkable

Key thing to make everyone away of is they can't just change their minds if they find it too much and you would have to wait for availability in nursery to add hrs and one would assume the extra subsided hours mean that might be hard.

SushiMayo · 19/02/2024 21:29

I'd go for 1 or 2 days and the rest in nursery- they learn so much from both

CuttingMeOpenthenHealingMeFine · 19/02/2024 21:25

We did it with both of our DC, my parents were retired and were desperate to have them, they watched them full days 3 days per week from about 10 months until the free nursery sessions kicked in at three.

Pros - money obviously, saved us a fortune, also very good knowing that DC were getting one to one attention (and totally spoiled), my Mum loved doing bookbug sessions and toddler groups with them and my Dad is very outdoorsy so he had them out all the time. Also they were happy to take DC even if they were ill, no phone calls asking me to pick them up because they had a temp.

Cons - very restricted with holidays etc as my parents went on at least two fortnight holidays per year and we had to use annual leave to cover. We didn’t get much leave then so we had to divide and conquer with it leaving very little time to be off together as a family. Also hospital appointments etc, one would take the other so we had to take time off to cover. Then if they were both ill at the same time we were a bit screwed but that didn’t happen often.

Overall I think it was good for the DC and they are very close to my parents as a result.