Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 16:11

Our registration is in first lesson after lunch. They only go form class 4x week and assembly once. Don't return. Pm registration is in their first class after lunch - they dont do lessons in forms as all different sets etc
If you finished period 5 in PE eg it could take at least 5-10 mins to get back to opposite end of the school & up three floors

Bluevelvetsofa · 19/02/2024 15:57

Well, clearly some schools manage to have systems for phones that don’t have an impact on learning time, are clearly understood by the pupils and are workable.

cardibach · 19/02/2024 15:52

DogsAreBetterThanHusbands · 19/02/2024 15:49

Do they not have 2 registrations a day with their form? My children's school does. One at the beginning and one at the end. 30 phones are put in a box, taken to the corresponding head of year's office and locked in for the day. Then at the end of the day they are collected from the office and handed out. My children's school is smaller than yours, granted, but it's still the same concept.

No, they do t. Most have only one now and electronic registration in lessons the rest of the time. In some schools (one I work in regularly) this isn’t at the start or the end of the day. I’ve never worked in a school where reg is at the end of the day (35 years on contracts and several as supply. I have experience if a lot of schools).

cardibach · 19/02/2024 15:50

coastingcoffee · 19/02/2024 13:35

Phones are not needed in school. Pupils can hand them in at the start of the day and collect when they leave. No one can possibly think phones have a positive influence in a learning environment.

Of course knife crime needs to be tackled but our government should be more than capable of doing both and also MUCH more. We're too accepting of government failures. They're meant to work for all of us.

Who is going to collect in the between 1000 and 2000 phones at a big secondary? Where will they be kept? How will the correct phone go back to the correct student? How long will it take to get through giving them out at the end of the day?
people who say this haven’t been in a school or even thought about it. It’s not a practical solution. And since you can’t be searching everyone’s bags, you’ll never know you’ve got them all anyway. What’s needed is more parental support of sanctions applied by the school for inappropriate phone use in school.

DogsAreBetterThanHusbands · 19/02/2024 15:49

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 14:33

@coastingcoffee getting 1800 kids back to their form classroom which could be the opposite end of school to sign out phones from a storage location would add a min 20min a day to each teachers timetable. An extra 1.5 hours a week min.
That's Assuming all teachers are also in those same form rooms at 3.19 and not elsewhere or gone home etc ( ours aren't). Our 8 PE teachers all have forms and extra curricular stuff too at 3.10 Or maybe off site.
I can not see how on Earth it could work in a big school

Do they not have 2 registrations a day with their form? My children's school does. One at the beginning and one at the end. 30 phones are put in a box, taken to the corresponding head of year's office and locked in for the day. Then at the end of the day they are collected from the office and handed out. My children's school is smaller than yours, granted, but it's still the same concept.

DogsAreBetterThanHusbands · 19/02/2024 15:43

My children go to a 6 form entry secondary school (year 7 & year 8 are 7 form entry) and the children's phones get collected at morning registration and given back out at the end of the day at afternoon registration. It works fine. Children can lie and say they didn't bring their phone but they do random spot checks with strong punishments if they are caught.

LakeTiticaca · 19/02/2024 15:19

Regarding knife crime , we should be looking towards the courts and their virtually non existent sentencing. Don't we already have a law that can issue a five year sentence for carrying a knife,?
Isn't it about time the judges started actually acting upon it?
It might make perpetrators think twice about carrying them

coastingcoffee · 19/02/2024 14:47

@deeprealisation I don't know the logistics apart from the morning routine. I think it's a case of trying to make the best of a situation which could have severe consequences and repercussions if there was misuse of a phone as per PP posts.

If they didn't have this policy then I would support no phones at all in schools.

TheTimeIsNowMaybeNow · 19/02/2024 14:38

Ours don't see their form tutor until 3rd period so couldn't leave them with him, they ask them to turn them off in school and if they are caught using them they have them confiscated until Friday when a parent picks them up

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 14:33

@coastingcoffee getting 1800 kids back to their form classroom which could be the opposite end of school to sign out phones from a storage location would add a min 20min a day to each teachers timetable. An extra 1.5 hours a week min.
That's Assuming all teachers are also in those same form rooms at 3.19 and not elsewhere or gone home etc ( ours aren't). Our 8 PE teachers all have forms and extra curricular stuff too at 3.10 Or maybe off site.
I can not see how on Earth it could work in a big school

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 14:29

@coastingcoffee getting 1800 back to their classroom

coastingcoffee · 19/02/2024 14:00

@Changer123 thats horrifying and exactly the reason why phones should be removed from pupils all day. Next issue would be to understand why these boys think this is acceptable behaviour. It should be a crime to do that to someone.

Changer123 · 19/02/2024 13:58

My dd ( Yr 8 ) had boys taking photos of her under the desk with their phones the other week so I would definitely 100% be in favour of banning phones on school premises. Bullying with phones is a huge issue, apparently its called " mugging " they take photos of unsuspecting people in class and share them on social media, luckily my dd was wearing tights on that particular day.

AndThatWasNY · 19/02/2024 13:54

What a ridiculous post.
I genuinely can't see why anyone would be against it.
In the very rare cases where a child has such bad and anxiety that they need to be able to contact apparent at breaks etc this could be arranged.
The lovely lad that was stabbed on the next road was stabbed following a incident in which a group of young people had wild themselves up on line into such a frenzy over some perceived misdemeanor this young man done that they killed him.

coastingcoffee · 19/02/2024 13:53

The registration teachers takes them in the morning so each class does it at the same time but with a different teacher. Same again at home time. Don't know where they are kept.

Because they are stored away, there is no temptation or blatant rule breaking. Plus no chance of them getting broken falling out of pockets, stolen or getting lost when changing for sports.

I would imagine the time taken up by schools dealing with phone issues would be significantly higher than 5 minutes at either end of the day. I would rather my childs school focus on teaching rather than dealing with students who need their phones every 5 minutes.

HotSauceNow · 19/02/2024 13:53

DC’s school uses Yondr pouches - when they go into school they put the mobile into their own pouch and use a device inside the main doors to lock it. At the end of the day they use the device to unlock it. Anyone caught with a phone outside a Yondr can expect automatic detention.

Talipesmum · 19/02/2024 13:51

Our gigantic secondary school has no phones out or in sight during the school day. They don’t hand them in but they must have them off, and away. I’m sure a tiny handful of kids turn them on in the loos etc but basically there are no phones out in school. They don’t use them in lessons. It’s very easy.

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 13:48

Ours have to have them off in blazer pockets. It's not a significant issue.

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 13:47

@coastingcoffee where do they put 1800 phones? Time taken would be impossible at both ends of the day

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 13:46

They'd be better tackling the massive SEN funding crisis and the vast number of kids with no school places as no where suitable for them

coastingcoffee · 19/02/2024 13:45

@deeprealisation at my daughters school they do this everyday. It's part of the school day and organised well so it's not a huge issue. I would be really unhappy with a school that allows phones in the classroom nevermind break time.

They use chromebooks in class. She's year 9.

CantDealwithChristmas · 19/02/2024 13:43

I'd say they're massively linked given that if you read the sentencing transcripts for young people convicted for knife crime (the ones that are publicly available that is) there's often a period of swapping threats / trolling etc on sm platforms, whatsapp, text and telegram before the actual crime occurs

plus ofc a lot of knife crime is linked to street gans which are often linked to drugs trade which these days is primarily done on mobile phone

BoohooWoohoo · 19/02/2024 13:40

Fixing small things quickly doesn’t mean that the big things don’t matter or shouldn’t be fixed.

Refucing knife crime is expensive and complicated as it involves so many angles and agencies. We are also in an election year and the party in power avoids resourcing public services properly so nothing will happen in the short term.

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 13:40

@coastingcoffee I assume yours are young and below yr6
My teen schools has 1800 kids.
Can you imagine them all handing them in?!?!
They sometimes use phones in class.
Entire teen social existence needs a phone.

AtomicBlondeRose · 19/02/2024 13:40

Luckily, knife crime is something that is rare in schools (rarer in some than others - basically non existent in the majority I’d say) whereas mobile phone use affects all schools, every day, many many times. So pretty important, I’d say.