Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
whiteboardking · 20/02/2024 11:31

@DogsAreBetterThanHusbands yep. Ours would have to add a form time session at the end of the day as currently all pupils at thus end of period 5 every day could be anywhere on site as they don't do lessons in forms. Our site is quite spaced out too re some areas like PE or art / tech building

WhatNoUsername · 20/02/2024 11:28

whiteboardking · 20/02/2024 08:27

@WhatNoUsername I agree re addictive nature of insta / you tube shorts / Tik tok etc
But teens use snap / WAp to organise their whole lives so hard to take that away without socially isolating them.
I work with a group of 24 teens which includes a lad who isn't allowed anything. He's socially impacted and left out of things all the time

Yes but if none of them had it, it would take that pressure away. That’s exactly why I think it needs to be “banned” (if that’s possible!!). Otherwise there’s always going to be pressure on parents to allow their children to use it, even if they are aware if the harms, because otherwise as you say their child is socially isolated. It puts parents in an impossible position.

DogsAreBetterThanHusbands · 20/02/2024 11:10

whiteboardking · 20/02/2024 08:24

@DogsAreBetterThanHusbands point is that schools with 'out of sight' policies are ok without a total ban. For big state highs collecting in & accounting for 1800 smart phones every day wouldnt work.
Phone seen is a phone confiscated.
I can only imagine your school is smaller and possibly private.

It's not private, there's 960 pupils total in year 7 to 11. Plus about another 200 in 6th form. Though 7 & 8 are 7 form entry. So there will be approx 1250 in 3 years time. Though I'd imagine the 6th formers don't have to hand their phones in. I will ask my children and see if they know.

I think it could definitely be implemented in larger schools but they would need the children to be in their form groups at the beginning and end of the day.

Mumof2teens79 · 20/02/2024 08:31

There's already laws about knives and U16s. I don't think they need to ban them from schools specifically.

whiteboardking · 20/02/2024 08:27

@WhatNoUsername I agree re addictive nature of insta / you tube shorts / Tik tok etc
But teens use snap / WAp to organise their whole lives so hard to take that away without socially isolating them.
I work with a group of 24 teens which includes a lad who isn't allowed anything. He's socially impacted and left out of things all the time

whiteboardking · 20/02/2024 08:24

@DogsAreBetterThanHusbands point is that schools with 'out of sight' policies are ok without a total ban. For big state highs collecting in & accounting for 1800 smart phones every day wouldnt work.
Phone seen is a phone confiscated.
I can only imagine your school is smaller and possibly private.

DogsAreBetterThanHusbands · 19/02/2024 23:18

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 22:15

@DogsAreBetterThanHusbands all the high schools round us operate much the same. They defo don't all go back to one point at the end of the day for another registration. As for 'trusted pupil' collecting & giving out phones... I wish state comps, even great ones, were that civilised. What about when the latest ££££ phone goes walkabout?

Don't bring it to school then. Every parent knows the policy when their child joins the school, if they don't like it then they can enrol their child somewhere else.

WhatNoUsername · 19/02/2024 22:39

@cardibach There are secondary schools that do this already so it's obviously logistically possible.

I support the banning of phones completely in school. It gives children a good solid long break from their phones, reduces bullying, helps ensure that they can concentrate on their eduction and encourages children to be present. Children should also not be in fear of being photographed at school and having that uploaded to social media.

And if it were possible a ban on social media for all under 16s. It's a bloody scourge in society and completely unnecessary. It fuels bullying, addictive behaviour, poor mental health, and is effectively giving a while generation of children difficult with attention and concentration. It's a public health emergency and something drastic needs to be done about it.

I also think that the "attention" model that these companies use should be outlawed, in the same way that other things that are bad for you are outlawed or made harder to obtain. If they cant do this, the companies won't be able to make their apps addictive in order to make money. The algorithms and other tactics they use to draw you in and keep you there won't be able to be used. This will fundamentally change how they work and they'll probably have to move to a subscription based model which would make than much less accessible to younger people and much less attractive generally. No one should be making money by surreptitiously drawing in and holding your attention for hours at a time, let alone children.

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 22:26

@Grandmasswag 99% of schools have 'no phones in sight' 'off in school' policies.

Grandmasswag · 19/02/2024 22:16

They should 100% be banned in school. Can’t really believe schools have let it slide to it being normal to have them in the classroom. Piss poor leadership. I heard a scientist/data cruncher on the radio earlier saying how studies had shown how distracting they are in a classroom environment. Basically it’s a miracle kids are learning anything. There is a benefit to limited use in leisure time so they weren’t totally against all phone use.

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 22:15

@DogsAreBetterThanHusbands all the high schools round us operate much the same. They defo don't all go back to one point at the end of the day for another registration. As for 'trusted pupil' collecting & giving out phones... I wish state comps, even great ones, were that civilised. What about when the latest ££££ phone goes walkabout?

tillytown · 19/02/2024 22:06

Phones are used to sexually harass female pupils and staff. Why wouldn't you want girls to be safe from sexual bullying at school? Both knife crime and the misuse of phones is a male violence issue, just because the victims of misused phones are overwhelmingly girls doesn't mean it isn't a serious problem.

DogsAreBetterThanHusbands · 19/02/2024 22:05

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 21:57

@DogsAreBetterThanHusbands
No ours is eleven form entry. Registration in form 4x week only. Otherwise on assembly day it's in first lesson. But that's not a form group as they mix up for everything & some lessons are set or streamed. They don't do most lessons in forms. Each lesson signs them in so no end of day registration. Site is big.
Teachers form rooms aren't necessarily their teaching rooms and ks3 and ks4 offices aren't near every class too,
To collect & sign in 1800 odd phones, walk them all to an office & sign them in and then out at some point would literally add at least 30 min to a teachers day. And they'd be late for own first lessons

I can see that it wouldn't work in your school because it doesn't have registrations like most schools do. As for taking up 30 minutes of teaching time, this doesn't happen as a trusted student takes/picks up the phones from the relevant office and the registration length is more than enough to cover it.

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 22:03

In our 5 form entry primary the class handed phones in at start of day, stored in classrooms and collected as they left at the door. Except they were all constantly forgetting & the TA / teacher didn't know whose was whose. Kids having to go back & get them etc Phones mixed up

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 21:57

@DogsAreBetterThanHusbands
No ours is eleven form entry. Registration in form 4x week only. Otherwise on assembly day it's in first lesson. But that's not a form group as they mix up for everything & some lessons are set or streamed. They don't do most lessons in forms. Each lesson signs them in so no end of day registration. Site is big.
Teachers form rooms aren't necessarily their teaching rooms and ks3 and ks4 offices aren't near every class too,
To collect & sign in 1800 odd phones, walk them all to an office & sign them in and then out at some point would literally add at least 30 min to a teachers day. And they'd be late for own first lessons

UneFoisAuChalet · 19/02/2024 21:51

I was a secondary teacher for several years at 2 different schools and this phone crap is just that - crap from the government.

Students weren’t allowed phones. Phones were confiscated - it just wasn’t an issue that needed government guidance. TBH I’m surprised this is even an issue. I wrongly assumed most, if not all, schools followed a similar policy.

I can’t imagine having to tell 30+ students to put away their phones. It’s hard enough to reign them in as it is. And the possibility that they film me, their fellow students and put it online??! The children had the use of iPads but I could login in and see what each child was doing so if anyone dared stray away from the Kahoot I would know about it.

BTW I taught at bog standard state schools. If this makes schools who allow phones to change their rules - great. But I still think they’re in the minority and I think this is just some more bullshit from the Tory government trying to win votes.

Topofthemountain · 19/02/2024 21:50

Knife crime was an issue years before smartphones.

The use of smartphones in school is a totally different matter.

Topofthemountain · 19/02/2024 21:50

Knife crime was an issue years before smartphones.

The use of smartphones in school is a totally different matter.

PeridotSparkle · 19/02/2024 21:41

Both important

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 20:20

@TinkerTiger a phone seen is a phone confiscated. Seen again and it's lost until a parent comes in to collect in person. Hence why it's 99% adhered to

coastingcoffee · 19/02/2024 19:40

@cardibach this is what my children's school does so it can be done

If schools allow pupils to come into school with a phone then they need to work out how to manage it.

I wouldn't be happy to send my child to a school which allowed phones in classrooms. I don't understand why anyone would argue phones are required during school time.

If schools can't cope then they should be banned outright

TinkerTiger · 19/02/2024 16:16

whiteboardking · 19/02/2024 13:48

Ours have to have them off in blazer pockets. It's not a significant issue.

I guess it depends on the type of school your child attends. There are some rough schools out there

itsgettingweird · 19/02/2024 16:13

It also says schools could allow pupils to keep possession of their phones but "only on the strict condition that they are never used, seen, or heard" during the day.

My ds left school in 2020. This was their rules back then. Hardly new guidance or earth shattering news.

They were asked to use them though for some lessons like accessing kahoot and the article does mention about "limited and specific use" (a government favourite phrase!)

I think both things are an issue but to pretend this guidance is doing something to bring about change is a little presumptious!

DogsAreBetterThanHusbands · 19/02/2024 16:12

That makes it very difficult to implement if they only have one registration or registrations at random times of day. My children's school used to have the second registration after lunch but they changed it to the end of the day so it worked.

I do think schools need to find a way to make something like this work. I imagine it would be chaotic when it is a new policy but once it becomes routine it would be much better.

Christmastree455555 · 19/02/2024 16:12

LakeTiticaca · 19/02/2024 15:19

Regarding knife crime , we should be looking towards the courts and their virtually non existent sentencing. Don't we already have a law that can issue a five year sentence for carrying a knife,?
Isn't it about time the judges started actually acting upon it?
It might make perpetrators think twice about carrying them

Sentencing guidelines for young people are very very different to those as an adult, you wouldn’t get custody for carrying a knife in school as a young person.
Tougher sentences for young people wouldn’t stop them carrying, education needs tp start at primary level into the dangers of carrying -the impact of using. The signs for parents to look out for in their own children who could be being exploited…. Signs for teachers to look out for. Better community resources and 3rd sector agencies, more funding for schools, councils and clubs in the heart of the community.