Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

1 child every 10 seconds

86 replies

AliceA2021 · 19/02/2024 11:17

1 child dies every second in the world of starvation. Most in sub saharian Africa. That's 3.1 million children per year. Somalia has the highest rate of starving children in the world.

You probably know about Gaza since on the news daily. Starvation of children in other countries continues and at a higher rate.

Why don't we care more? The sheer numbers in some countries Somalia, Yeman, Sudan.

Is it a problem that cannot be sorted. War, high birth rate, low food production.

AIBU that the world's doesn't care for most of these children?

OP posts:
CommentNow · 19/02/2024 12:20

Solving starvation doesnt equal a happy life with opportunities. Starvation is an abhorrent, truly awful way to die but if you solved it tomorrow, you still have sognificant and, arguably as bad ir worse cumulative issues, like a lack of education making contraceptive a non starter, FGM, child marriage and child rape, HIV,... what opportunities are there for those children and their children?

I hate thinking of a child starving, but I cannot even imagine the grief i would feel bringing multiple daughters into a world where they will suffer not one, or two, but all of those awful things and more.

Solving starvation is a small part of a bigger problem. If you solved the contraceptive issue, youd make a bigger impact in terms of lives preemptively saved.

It's similar issue to the pro life movements - every supporter wants to save a foetus or a baby but how many stick up funds and offer support for those children once they are born. How much of your personal funds do you put into solving world hunger? Every time we make a choice, we make several - designer bag or charity donation?

Its not fair to boil the argument down to saving hungry kids, it's far too simplistic.

How often have you bought cut flowers, a non essential, non-food crop, grown on land that could have been used to feed local populations if the world wasnt demanding these products? Or should those farmers be encouraged to grow those in demand crops for the economy?

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 19/02/2024 12:19

AliceA2021 · 19/02/2024 12:00

I don't have a brilliant solution. I would hope the richer countries would do more.

I'm not a brilliant mind, with brilliant solutions, I just feel that starving children are ignored.

It's possible to care for people who don't have enough food down the road as well as those in Sudan. It depends on rich governments, countries, people to do more... who needs a yacht worth hundreds of millions, cars worth millions, hordes of money and things.

Greed is awful.

There is a marked difference between greed and self made success. We shouldn’t not want to succeed and for those who do, why is it their responsibility to solve world hunger?

To be honest, more than money is needed. It’s about culture and education as well as funds.

Itscatsallthewaydown · 19/02/2024 12:14

AliceA2021 · 19/02/2024 12:13

There's not much I can personally do about corruption. Aid agencies can do more than I. Governments can do more.

Men in power, greed, religion, etc all contribute to starvation of children.

I guess just hope the lens of the world hangs around a bit and tries to help.

So you don’t actually have any solutions of any kind. To anything.

AliceA2021 · 19/02/2024 12:13

Itscatsallthewaydown · 19/02/2024 12:05

It’s not a question of throwing money at the problem though, is it? The corrupt elites in developing countries tend to steal, and those further down the pecking order tend to like feathering their nests too. What are you going to do about the levels of corruption?

There's not much I can personally do about corruption. Aid agencies can do more than I. Governments can do more.

Men in power, greed, religion, etc all contribute to starvation of children.

I guess just hope the lens of the world hangs around a bit and tries to help.

OP posts:
AndThatWasNY · 19/02/2024 12:11

ComtesseDeSpair · 19/02/2024 11:44

It’s very sad for their parents I’m sure, but on a personal level I don’t have any feelings about children I’ve never met whose lives and deaths don’t impact me in any way whatsoever. I suspect most people feel likewise tbh; in addition to “caring” being very abstract and only having any purpose if you turn your “care” into actual action.

I find this extraordinary. I think this is how people have such different politics from my own and happily vote purely on self interest.
Of course I care about my family first and foremost but very much care about people I have never met.
I vote in this country in a way that I hope improves the lives of people abroad. I gift money and work with refugees here. I would like to do more and DH and I I'm looking at the possibility of VSO when we retire (both medical backgrounds).

OP it is horrific and very messed up. The UK has helped create this situation (just look at the straight line maps in this area completely cause false nation states purely for European greed.)Divide and rule illustrated.

LittleGreenDragons · 19/02/2024 12:10

Too much aid is taken by war mongering men.

Once you have found the solution to this you will find everything else will slot into place quickly and easily. Do you have one?

MadeOfAllWork · 19/02/2024 12:09

Why don’t we care?

Look at it this way.
A neighbour falls down the stairs and breaks their leg. You might well help them out by driving them to hospital appointments or cooking.
The same happens to a neighbour up the street then you might well help again, but less so.
The same happens to someone three streets away, you don’t help unless you know them personally.

It’s the same here. If it was happening in France or Germany then we would likely help more, but this is so far away, so removed from our lives that we are much less likely to help unless we have a personal connection.

I can’t care about every injustice in the world.

Itscatsallthewaydown · 19/02/2024 12:05

It’s not a question of throwing money at the problem though, is it? The corrupt elites in developing countries tend to steal, and those further down the pecking order tend to like feathering their nests too. What are you going to do about the levels of corruption?

AliceA2021 · 19/02/2024 12:05

Cazpar · 19/02/2024 11:49

Why don't we care more?

At the most basic, biological level, I don't think we've evolved to care about what is happening to another group of humans many thousands of miles away.

Go back a few thousand years and while what happened to those tribes / groups living nearby might be of interest (trade, plague, war etc), what happens to those elsewhere wouldn't have featured.

Now of course, we are not living thousands of years ago and we have technology that enables us to get real time updates on those many many miles away. But I still think that level of emotional investment remains low in most cases. We can objectively agree that it is a tragedy, but we don't feel the pain however much we may empathise. We don't see the effects. It is remote to us.

I don't think this makes anyone a bad person. It is an evolutionary hangover.

There is also the question of "what can I as an individual actually do to stop such an awful situation?". It's a pragmatic if perhaps defeatist view. For example, if I donate £100 would that stop it? Probably not. And for many people they feel like they cannot help.

And for those who are old enough to remember LiveAid etc, they have seen this time and time again. No matter what is done, the same situation will keep arising around the world. Now that is not to say that nothing should be done, but compassion fatigue sets in, the dreadful images cease being shocking, and people's focus will return to difficulties that are right in front of them once again.

Thank you for your thoughtful response. I appreciate it.

OP posts:
AnnieBuddyHere · 19/02/2024 12:04

I'm in my late 50s and churches and charities have been raising money for the starving in Africa, since long before I was born.

Yet nothing changes.

Cesarina · 19/02/2024 12:02

@Cazpar
An excellent, pragmatic, thoughtful, measured post 👏

AliceA2021 · 19/02/2024 12:00

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 19/02/2024 11:52

What’s your brilliant solution OP?

i think we should care for the people down the road who are starving and the kids down the road living in extreme poverty before we offer more aid overseas.

I don't have a brilliant solution. I would hope the richer countries would do more.

I'm not a brilliant mind, with brilliant solutions, I just feel that starving children are ignored.

It's possible to care for people who don't have enough food down the road as well as those in Sudan. It depends on rich governments, countries, people to do more... who needs a yacht worth hundreds of millions, cars worth millions, hordes of money and things.

Greed is awful.

OP posts:
Perkatory · 19/02/2024 11:59

I do care. But I have to not lose too much time, energy or sleep on things I cannot change. I can't dwell in despair too long. I focus on things I can do, even if that's just putting a few things in the food bank basket at the supermarket or some old clothes to the charity shop. I don't have the means or the power to make a big difference to these things. But I do sign petitions and raise awareness and do the bits I can. That's all we've got isn't it?

IncompleteSenten · 19/02/2024 11:53

People don't care except in a sort of oh dear how sad vague sort of way.
Sadly, if you believe the shit you read online, there are people who actually feel that it's a good thing otherwise populations would be even larger.

In general, people only 'care' up to the point that caring affects them in any even slightly negative way. Higher taxes would be a good example of the Caring Ends Here mentality.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 19/02/2024 11:52

What’s your brilliant solution OP?

i think we should care for the people down the road who are starving and the kids down the road living in extreme poverty before we offer more aid overseas.

WhatNoRaisins · 19/02/2024 11:51

It feels beyond anything I can do even though I do care. Helping out more locally by buying stuff for the foodbank feels more realistic.

AliceA2021 · 19/02/2024 11:51

Cazpar · 19/02/2024 11:49

Why don't we care more?

At the most basic, biological level, I don't think we've evolved to care about what is happening to another group of humans many thousands of miles away.

Go back a few thousand years and while what happened to those tribes / groups living nearby might be of interest (trade, plague, war etc), what happens to those elsewhere wouldn't have featured.

Now of course, we are not living thousands of years ago and we have technology that enables us to get real time updates on those many many miles away. But I still think that level of emotional investment remains low in most cases. We can objectively agree that it is a tragedy, but we don't feel the pain however much we may empathise. We don't see the effects. It is remote to us.

I don't think this makes anyone a bad person. It is an evolutionary hangover.

There is also the question of "what can I as an individual actually do to stop such an awful situation?". It's a pragmatic if perhaps defeatist view. For example, if I donate £100 would that stop it? Probably not. And for many people they feel like they cannot help.

And for those who are old enough to remember LiveAid etc, they have seen this time and time again. No matter what is done, the same situation will keep arising around the world. Now that is not to say that nothing should be done, but compassion fatigue sets in, the dreadful images cease being shocking, and people's focus will return to difficulties that are right in front of them once again.

Very true.

OP posts:
Cazpar · 19/02/2024 11:49

Why don't we care more?

At the most basic, biological level, I don't think we've evolved to care about what is happening to another group of humans many thousands of miles away.

Go back a few thousand years and while what happened to those tribes / groups living nearby might be of interest (trade, plague, war etc), what happens to those elsewhere wouldn't have featured.

Now of course, we are not living thousands of years ago and we have technology that enables us to get real time updates on those many many miles away. But I still think that level of emotional investment remains low in most cases. We can objectively agree that it is a tragedy, but we don't feel the pain however much we may empathise. We don't see the effects. It is remote to us.

I don't think this makes anyone a bad person. It is an evolutionary hangover.

There is also the question of "what can I as an individual actually do to stop such an awful situation?". It's a pragmatic if perhaps defeatist view. For example, if I donate £100 would that stop it? Probably not. And for many people they feel like they cannot help.

And for those who are old enough to remember LiveAid etc, they have seen this time and time again. No matter what is done, the same situation will keep arising around the world. Now that is not to say that nothing should be done, but compassion fatigue sets in, the dreadful images cease being shocking, and people's focus will return to difficulties that are right in front of them once again.

TigerRag · 19/02/2024 11:49

What happened with all the money raised for live aid, etc?

And people starving in the UK. What about them?

AliceA2021 · 19/02/2024 11:48

It seems a problem the world is unable to solve or doesn'twant to solve, children dying of hunger in 2024.

OP posts:
AliceA2021 · 19/02/2024 11:46

onemoremile · 19/02/2024 11:32

There is no real solution let alone an easy one. people can and do send money, but that can entrench other problems or postpone solving difficult political issues.

I think some countries such as Gaza capture the news due the horrendous war. People march, talk about it but other countries don't get the news, the talking about, even though a far higher number of children die each day of starvation.

I think some children matter to some more than others. Sudan, Yeman doesn't seem to matter to many. Gaza has a story of dominance and so captures people. Yenan not so interesting.

OP posts:
ComtesseDeSpair · 19/02/2024 11:44

It’s very sad for their parents I’m sure, but on a personal level I don’t have any feelings about children I’ve never met whose lives and deaths don’t impact me in any way whatsoever. I suspect most people feel likewise tbh; in addition to “caring” being very abstract and only having any purpose if you turn your “care” into actual action.

AliceA2021 · 19/02/2024 11:43

x2boys · 19/02/2024 11:42

What are you doing other then starting a thread on here ?

I donate monthly too.

What are you doing other than being critical.

OP posts:
Snowypeak · 19/02/2024 11:42

I agree with you about the war mongering men.

AliceA2021 · 19/02/2024 11:42

TallulahBetty · 19/02/2024 11:39

I do care. However, there is a lot going on here too - we can't fight every battle.

Also, It's very hard to do anything in an area/culture where people are told that contraception is a sin. Thus, the problem continues

Education on contraception is needed too.

OP posts: