Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a 3rd child?

260 replies

broodybaby85 · 19/02/2024 10:12

I turn 39 this year. I have 2 children already with a large age gap (eldest turns 18 this year and youngest is almost 3). Been with my partner for almost 19 years (he's not the eldest's father).

I know my age will go against me, but I cannot shake the feeling that I want to do it "one last time". However, I also know that with 2 children already and the age gap, there are many cons to adding another.

Please Mumsnet, talk me out of this and help me to just be happy with the two beautiful children I have and get over with my longing for a third?? 😭

Maybe I need to see some of those cons in black and white?! 😂

OP posts:
Apollo365 · 19/02/2024 11:27

Are you helping your oldest out with costs such as house deposits, uni, wedding, other.
can you afford to do this for potentially two more children

WhereIsMyLight · 19/02/2024 11:24

You will have the costs of nursery, wrap around childcare for the middle one and helping the eldest at university at a time when you might want to consider building your pension contributions. That’s probably the biggest negative. The age gap will mean it’s more like having two children with a normal age gap. It’s just the expense.

Shiv861 · 19/02/2024 11:24

RiderofRohan · 19/02/2024 11:05

I disagree with this.

I always thought that if they told me at the 12 week scan that there was something wrong with the baby (for instance trisomy 21), I would have an abortion, no two ways about it. And yet at my 12 week scan, once I'd seen the baby on the screen, some weird gear clicked in my mind and I knew I wasn't going to be able to have one, even if there was something wrong. I was kicking myself for not doing the NIPT testing privately.

Luckily all was fine with this baby, but I know if I ever get pregnant in the future, I'll be doing private testing as soon as possible, because abortion was no longer an option for me at the 12 week scan.

It's not a question of morality. I don't think women who have abortions due to downs syndrome after 12 weeks are immoral. In fact, it's pretty brave either way, whether they decide to abort or keep the baby. Both options are terrifying.

I just knew I personally couldn't do it, but I don't want to be in that situation again. Hence why I'll be testing early next time.

I also think it is distasteful to say you couldn't do it in XYZ scenario, women have been through harrowing experiences,

Say the situation was you had 2 children and found out your third would have a life limiting condition past 12 weeks, would you carry on the pregnancy knowing your existing children's life would be so negatively affected?

I think carrying on regardless is way more selfish

Sara40n · 19/02/2024 11:23

RiderofRohan · 19/02/2024 11:05

I disagree with this.

I always thought that if they told me at the 12 week scan that there was something wrong with the baby (for instance trisomy 21), I would have an abortion, no two ways about it. And yet at my 12 week scan, once I'd seen the baby on the screen, some weird gear clicked in my mind and I knew I wasn't going to be able to have one, even if there was something wrong. I was kicking myself for not doing the NIPT testing privately.

Luckily all was fine with this baby, but I know if I ever get pregnant in the future, I'll be doing private testing as soon as possible, because abortion was no longer an option for me at the 12 week scan.

It's not a question of morality. I don't think women who have abortions due to downs syndrome after 12 weeks are immoral. In fact, it's pretty brave either way, whether they decide to abort or keep the baby. Both options are terrifying.

I just knew I personally couldn't do it, but I don't want to be in that situation again. Hence why I'll be testing early next time.

Absolutely, it must be the most heartbreaking decision to have to make either way, worrying about what life will be like for your child in the future or going through the awful process of abortion at that stage. I would never judge a friend going through this, whichever they decided, most horrible situation to be in. On the other hand quite shocked when had an unplanned pregnancy which would have quite a big impact on my life and in far from ideal circumstances and some people’s attitudes were well of course you should terminate. It was quite hurtful that they were even suggesting that as an option for this baby inside of me plus the implication being that I didn’t deserve to feel in turmoil by the changes the pregnancy would bring because I was ‘choosing’ to continue with the pregnancy. For me I wasn’t ‘choosing’ to continue with the pregnancy, abortion was simply not what I felt was a justified option

broodybaby85 · 19/02/2024 11:21

Ok the thread has become so derailed with a debate around abortion that I can't actually sift out the posts that help me with my question🤦🏼‍♀️

Sorry can we focus please on the question or start your own thread about abortion, thanks.

OP posts:
Firsttimebabymama · 19/02/2024 11:20

I vote go for it :)

AngeloMysterioso · 19/02/2024 11:18

RiderofRohan · 19/02/2024 11:05

I disagree with this.

I always thought that if they told me at the 12 week scan that there was something wrong with the baby (for instance trisomy 21), I would have an abortion, no two ways about it. And yet at my 12 week scan, once I'd seen the baby on the screen, some weird gear clicked in my mind and I knew I wasn't going to be able to have one, even if there was something wrong. I was kicking myself for not doing the NIPT testing privately.

Luckily all was fine with this baby, but I know if I ever get pregnant in the future, I'll be doing private testing as soon as possible, because abortion was no longer an option for me at the 12 week scan.

It's not a question of morality. I don't think women who have abortions due to downs syndrome after 12 weeks are immoral. In fact, it's pretty brave either way, whether they decide to abort or keep the baby. Both options are terrifying.

I just knew I personally couldn't do it, but I don't want to be in that situation again. Hence why I'll be testing early next time.

But it is an option for you. Just because it’s not an option you would take for whatever reason doesn’t mean it’s not an option that is available to you, because that is not the case.

Shiv861 · 19/02/2024 11:16

RiderofRohan · 19/02/2024 11:05

I disagree with this.

I always thought that if they told me at the 12 week scan that there was something wrong with the baby (for instance trisomy 21), I would have an abortion, no two ways about it. And yet at my 12 week scan, once I'd seen the baby on the screen, some weird gear clicked in my mind and I knew I wasn't going to be able to have one, even if there was something wrong. I was kicking myself for not doing the NIPT testing privately.

Luckily all was fine with this baby, but I know if I ever get pregnant in the future, I'll be doing private testing as soon as possible, because abortion was no longer an option for me at the 12 week scan.

It's not a question of morality. I don't think women who have abortions due to downs syndrome after 12 weeks are immoral. In fact, it's pretty brave either way, whether they decide to abort or keep the baby. Both options are terrifying.

I just knew I personally couldn't do it, but I don't want to be in that situation again. Hence why I'll be testing early next time.

I should not have posted, can we just get back to question the OP asked,

Everybody's opinion will be different on this subject but I just think its a very sensitive topic to just say it wasn't an option.

If it was me, I would consider my existing children and the impact it would have on them.

RiderofRohan · 19/02/2024 11:05

AngeloMysterioso · 19/02/2024 10:50

It’s shitty shorthand. Unless you mean it literally isn’t an option because the pregnancy has progressed past the cut off point (as in the PP’s case- but it’s rare that people mean it that way) there absolutely is a judgement being made in that statement, whether consciously or not, because abortion is an option. It may not be an option you’d take for whatever reason, but it’s still an option, and saying “it wasn’t an option for me” implies that you are somehow on a different moral plane to those that it is an option for.

I disagree with this.

I always thought that if they told me at the 12 week scan that there was something wrong with the baby (for instance trisomy 21), I would have an abortion, no two ways about it. And yet at my 12 week scan, once I'd seen the baby on the screen, some weird gear clicked in my mind and I knew I wasn't going to be able to have one, even if there was something wrong. I was kicking myself for not doing the NIPT testing privately.

Luckily all was fine with this baby, but I know if I ever get pregnant in the future, I'll be doing private testing as soon as possible, because abortion was no longer an option for me at the 12 week scan.

It's not a question of morality. I don't think women who have abortions due to downs syndrome after 12 weeks are immoral. In fact, it's pretty brave either way, whether they decide to abort or keep the baby. Both options are terrifying.

I just knew I personally couldn't do it, but I don't want to be in that situation again. Hence why I'll be testing early next time.

Apollo365 · 19/02/2024 11:05

I think you are massively overthinking my post.
I was trying to say to OP that mine was unplanned but I wouldn’t change it now. I’ve gone on to explain this but you must’ve missed my update.
Lets stop derailing this now?

Shiv861 · 19/02/2024 11:05

The question was to have a third child, anyway dont want to change to thread to an abortion debate, just thought I would highlight my thoughts on when women say these things. I have read so many threads of women that are heartbroken from the decision they made, just think its nice to bare that in mind

Shiv861 · 19/02/2024 11:01

Sara40n · 19/02/2024 10:55

No it means it’s just not quite as bigger deal as for some people, which in reality is quite true e.g. some people terminate as they don’t feel in the best circumstances with their finances, age, career, relationships etc, whereas other in exactly the same circumstances continue with the pregnancy and accept life might be a bit tough for a while and not the life they had hoped for. No doubt those who terminated would of far rather just rather turned back the clock if they’d had the choice as not a decision anytime wants to have to make or go through and no doubt too they don’t forget the date, due date etc so they are still sad

I dunno , I just dont think that needs to be said, you had a third child...I had a second I wouldn't be bringin up into conversation why I didnt abort, its not relevant

Sara40n · 19/02/2024 11:00

AngeloMysterioso · 19/02/2024 10:50

It’s shitty shorthand. Unless you mean it literally isn’t an option because the pregnancy has progressed past the cut off point (as in the PP’s case- but it’s rare that people mean it that way) there absolutely is a judgement being made in that statement, whether consciously or not, because abortion is an option. It may not be an option you’d take for whatever reason, but it’s still an option, and saying “it wasn’t an option for me” implies that you are somehow on a different moral plane to those that it is an option for.

For goodness sake anything is an option, putting your child up for adoption is an option but not something a lot of us would consider is an option for us. Of course in the most extreme circumstances it may be an option any of us would have to consider but the poster was simply saying that abortion wasn’t an option she would of considered

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 19/02/2024 10:57

There was an informal MN survey a few years back, and a huge majority - I think it was 84 percent - said that much as they loved their third child, if they had their time again they'd stick with two. Lots of reasons given by different people, such as the logistics of three different after-school clubs (not a problem for you!), holidays, the expense, and the fact that our planet is already overcrowded.

Somanystupidpeople · 19/02/2024 10:57

Due to your age it might take you longer than you think to conceive. There's also additional risks for an older mum and child to an older mum. Your youngest might be 4 or 5 by the time you give birth and that's quite a big age gap (and there's already a huge age gap between your current two children).

Sara40n · 19/02/2024 10:55

Shiv861 · 19/02/2024 10:36

And for others it wouldn't be as they are heartless?

I just dont think it needed to be said

No it means it’s just not quite as bigger deal as for some people, which in reality is quite true e.g. some people terminate as they don’t feel in the best circumstances with their finances, age, career, relationships etc, whereas other in exactly the same circumstances continue with the pregnancy and accept life might be a bit tough for a while and not the life they had hoped for. No doubt those who terminated would of far rather just rather turned back the clock if they’d had the choice as not a decision anytime wants to have to make or go through and no doubt too they don’t forget the date, due date etc so they are still sad

Maireas · 19/02/2024 10:53

Think of how much time and effort you can devote to your 3 year old, how much attention as she starts school etc with no small baby as well.

Suchardchoccy · 19/02/2024 10:51

I'm pregnant with my 3rd and my other two are ages 2 and 1 😅 your eldest is technically an adult so I agree a pp is right in saying that it will be technically 2 children. No need to get a new car? Plus your 3 yo will have someone to grow up with 😊 go for it!! You're not 40 yet.

AngeloMysterioso · 19/02/2024 10:51

Apologies OP I didn’t mean to get sidetracked

AngeloMysterioso · 19/02/2024 10:50

Sara40n · 19/02/2024 10:41

Think that’s a bit unfair, it’s just a short hand way of saying you would personally not consider it for moral reasons or perhaps how you perceive the baby inside of you. Just as people who wouldn’t consider eating meat as they find the whole idea of killing that cute little lamb to eat awful. People are allowed to find things personally sad and distasteful. It doesn’t necessarily mean they are judging you

It’s shitty shorthand. Unless you mean it literally isn’t an option because the pregnancy has progressed past the cut off point (as in the PP’s case- but it’s rare that people mean it that way) there absolutely is a judgement being made in that statement, whether consciously or not, because abortion is an option. It may not be an option you’d take for whatever reason, but it’s still an option, and saying “it wasn’t an option for me” implies that you are somehow on a different moral plane to those that it is an option for.

broodybaby85 · 19/02/2024 10:49

@RiderofRohan
Finances are good, both partner and I have secure well paid jobs. Health is good, albeit my second pregnancy was brutal on my body as per my previous post. However, not enough to make me say never again, obviously as I'm considering it😬

OP posts:
broodybaby85 · 19/02/2024 10:47

@LovelyTheresa
He is unsure and torn on it at the moment (we both are really, hence my post here). But he's not a definite no. I'd say he's definitely got less of a longing than I have.

OP posts:
RiderofRohan · 19/02/2024 10:46

What are your finances like? That would be my main concern.

If that and your health is in order, why not?

WhatNoRaisins · 19/02/2024 10:45

I think it comes down to if you want to do anything else in life beyond looking after children. Do you have good childcare that would give you the freedom to do the things to want as well as being a mum?

Being responsible for a child under 18 from age 21 to potentially 57 is a large chunk of your life. For some motherhood can be really restricting.

LiveOutLoudRose · 19/02/2024 10:45

I would go for it (sorry you didn’t want that post).

Your eldest is 18 and independent (in the sense you don’t need to do school runs to take to doctor). You aren’t going to be thinking, “how do we get 3 car seats in a car”.

Your 3 year old will have a sibling much closer in age.