Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a 3rd child?

260 replies

broodybaby85 · 19/02/2024 10:12

I turn 39 this year. I have 2 children already with a large age gap (eldest turns 18 this year and youngest is almost 3). Been with my partner for almost 19 years (he's not the eldest's father).

I know my age will go against me, but I cannot shake the feeling that I want to do it "one last time". However, I also know that with 2 children already and the age gap, there are many cons to adding another.

Please Mumsnet, talk me out of this and help me to just be happy with the two beautiful children I have and get over with my longing for a third?? 😭

Maybe I need to see some of those cons in black and white?! 😂

OP posts:
chaosmaker · 20/02/2024 10:04

Why on a thread where you've asked people to give you all the downsides of having a third is this thread full of people banging on about having a third being great. We're overpopulated on a tiny island where having more kids is making more adult competition for them in terms of jobs etc. All of which will probably be done by AI anyway then. As a few people have pointed out, sensibly, it's just your bio clock clanging. Enjoy the little one you have and go with what your husband thinks. Also remember your 2nd pregnancy, was it ever life threatening? Could it leave your husband and little child without you and with another baby to cope with?

pontipinemum · 20/02/2024 09:53

I don't think you are too old. Also I don't think you will be too stretched time wise since your eldest is pretty much off to Uni. Although I am sure she will need you in other ways. Will having the baby affect what/ where / how etc she goes to uni?

There was a thread that made me thing there a few weeks ago, a woman was saying she had her DD at 40 and all was fine she didn't feel too old but now at 50 dropping her 10 yr old DD to school she feels old. It made me think a little, I am 36 having my 2nd.

My sister had her 3rd at 38 (nearly 39) she had a few more complications with him and ended up spending 6 weeks in hospital but I don't think that was age related just bad luck.

DH is the youngest of 3, his 2 older siblings are a year apart then 10 years until him. He always says he felt like he grew up as an only child.

ShakeNvacStevens · 20/02/2024 09:53

broodybaby85 · 20/02/2024 09:33

Yes this is one of my reasons in the pro column I guess. My eldest will be off to uni living her own life in the next few years, possibly even getting married and having her own baby, who knows! So my 3 yo is more likely to grow up as my eldest did - an only child (my eldest was an only child until age 14). It didn't do my eldest any harm obviously- she's a lovely well rounded young lady.

But having that fuller family unit for my youngest is definitely a pull for me. My partner thinks slightly differently and this is where we don't entirely agree - he feels we have a lovely family unit currently and that our youngest completes us, and we can give her all of our attention (and finances) as she grows up, and that adding another to that mix dilutes some of that and potentially "spoils" what we have. Having said that, he's not a 100% no either. 😬

I agree with PP that maybe you could ask your eldest how she might feel. Did she ever express any opinions about being an only child for so long, if it’s something she would have liked growing up would she resent you for giving your younger child a sibling?

Not that it’s her decision of course, but seeing as your DH isn’t fully behind trying for another it might help swing the decision either way.

p1ppyL0ngstocking · 20/02/2024 09:50

If you honestly want reasons to put you off, then I have to say I'm with your DP.

The likelihood is that your eldest will be home for most of the Uni holidays and possibly live with you for several years after, she may (even unwittingly) feel resentful that every time she visits home the baby gets all the focus, or she's expected to pitch in with childcare (even if it's just while you have a shower/use the loo) and she doesn't get to spend time with you the way she used to; it could harm your relationship with her.

Financially it will be a burden and push back your retirement age considerably; you may not be thinking about that yet, but when you're 60 and knackered and realise you need to work for a decade longer to pay for retirement, you'll feel it then.

Lastly, and like most people, you are assuming you will have a healthy birth and a healthy baby. As you age, the chances of that decrease. Are you physically, financially and mentally able to raise a child whose full-time needs mean that you can never work again? If you were to die during childbirth, would your DP raise your eldest as their own and would he cope mentally and physically as a single father to a motherless baby, a 4/5yr old and a teen?

Obviously, this is at the extreme end of what might happen, but you did ask to be put off and I can fully understand why your DP doesn't want to take that risk, which ultimately is the real reason why you shouldn't try for a third - your partner doesn't want to 🤷‍♀️

G535600 · 20/02/2024 09:49

Just adding another perspective…currently pregnant with an unplanned third and have a termination booked for this week.

Prior to falling pregnant I was desperate for a third but DH wasn’t keen, but as soon as I saw the positive test I just felt scared.

The lovely life we have at the moment - 2 beautiful, happy, healthy children who love each other, we are financially comfortable, life is getting easier and we are about to have a lot more disposable income as dc2 is due to start school (they are 5 and 3 atm, would be 6 and nearly 4 when this one due)…a third puts all of this at risk. Yes we would love a the baby but if anything goes wrong then it’s my existing kids who suffer - if my health is affected, or if dc3 had additional needs, and even if not, there is less time and money for dcs1 and 2. I think if the age gap had been smaller the balance might have tipped again, but when DC1 is 8 I want to be doing fun things with him, not dragging him round activities with a 2 year old.

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 20/02/2024 09:46

Age is definitely a deciding factor too. I was the same age as you and felt I was a lot harder on my body, and the post natal hormonal fluctuations were much tougher. It was, as I've read, equivalent to the hormone levels dropping at menopause... it's really made me dread the menopause, totally 😫

Lenny326 · 20/02/2024 09:46

I’ve just had my 3rd child, aged 38.
Shes the perfect addition to our family. I say go for it!

user146990847101 · 20/02/2024 09:43

My experience - I felt the same at late 30’s. I’m convinced now it was just a change in hormones as now I’m more informed of peri-menopause symptoms i can see I was just starting to get aching joints and change in cycle etc.
my body’s last hurrah I suppose.
No regrets as now 44, two expensive teenagers and fully menopausal.
If you're sure you really want to and can afford it, go for it OP, but just be sure it’s not hormones playing tricks on you!

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 20/02/2024 09:42

Going to add a bit of a negative post here... I posted on MN nearly 4 years ago about whether I should have an abortion with my 3rd baby (who's now nearly 4 and sleeping next to me).

I posted in AIBU (yes, I know...!) about how both my DH and parents were asking if I could consider an abortion as it was an unplanned pregnancy, and basically they thought I wasn't fit/healthy enough and we couldn't afford it. I understood their reasons, yet I had huge issues with having an abortion. In spite of this, I even went along to the abortion clinic at around 3 months, and when the nurse said "why do you want an abortion?" I think I burst into tears and said I didn't.

An extremely long thread on MN, with many people telling me I was selfish etc, how I wasn't considering all the options, and I did get extremely flamed... it obviously resulted in me keeping DD.

However, I did end up having a c-section on my own, at the start of the first lockdown, which was pretty scary. I also had horrible PND which I hadn't had with either of my previous pregnancies - the toll on my health was much worse. My ferritin levels were very low which contributed to my depression and made my neurological involuntary movement disorder much worse too.

I'm not painting a great picture here, but I promise it's not all bad. I love my beautiful daughter with all my heart and don't regret having her. She is beautiful, funny, kind and a real character, she lights up our lives.

But she did nearly break me and my marriage. So I have to say, in all honesty, 3 children may not have been the best thing ever for me, but I still wouldn't ever change anything about my family.

Palava57 · 20/02/2024 09:40

Children in the global north put 240x the pressure on global resources - many of which are becoming scarce - compared to children in eg Africa. You are blessed to have 2 children & a good life.

marathon123 · 20/02/2024 09:38

I'm not sure I'd want to have another child if my husband was not really keen to have another one, especially if my last pregnancy was terrible. I had my last child at 40 and it contributed to the destruction of my health and i've never been able to work since.....you have to be sure your OH is prepared to deal with this! Are you unmarried?? if not i'd also want to have all my financial ducks in order.

broodybaby85 · 20/02/2024 09:33

EndlessTreadmill · 19/02/2024 23:15

With such a big age gap, you are basically completing your family for your 2nd child. Without a 3rd child, the 2nd child will almost be like an only child.
I have 3, and had the 3rd at 38. Most of my friends have had a child when they were in their 40s (my best friend had hers at 40 and 44!). Nowadays, it's totally fine!

Yes this is one of my reasons in the pro column I guess. My eldest will be off to uni living her own life in the next few years, possibly even getting married and having her own baby, who knows! So my 3 yo is more likely to grow up as my eldest did - an only child (my eldest was an only child until age 14). It didn't do my eldest any harm obviously- she's a lovely well rounded young lady.

But having that fuller family unit for my youngest is definitely a pull for me. My partner thinks slightly differently and this is where we don't entirely agree - he feels we have a lovely family unit currently and that our youngest completes us, and we can give her all of our attention (and finances) as she grows up, and that adding another to that mix dilutes some of that and potentially "spoils" what we have. Having said that, he's not a 100% no either. 😬

OP posts:
mushroom3 · 20/02/2024 09:32

I had no 3 at almost 41. 4.5 years gap from no 2. All siblings get on really well. Your eldest will be doing her own thing and so for holidays etc within a couple of years you will be a family of 4 as eldest will be going on holiday with friends/partner etc. . No 3 was the easiest pregnancy and post-partum recovery! I would say go for it. Loads of women have babies at your age. My middle one was starting school while I was with the youngest so it meant I could give them time, so better than the 2.5 year gap I had with nos 1 and 2 . 3 is the magic number!

Dogdilemma2000 · 20/02/2024 09:30

LauritaEvita · 19/02/2024 10:23

Are you in good health? How did your other pregnancies and births go? I know a lot of friends who are on the fence can be influenced by these things esp any potential toll it could take on your physical / mental health.

This was the deciding factor for me. My health is not good.

saffy2 · 20/02/2024 09:28

broodybaby85 · 20/02/2024 09:17

Yes it makes sense and it's certainly something to consider, as I'd never want her to feel that way. She's a fantastic elder sister to her younger sibling, and has never expressed feeling pushed out of the family unit (she's obviously very much a part of that unit!!), but she is more naturally more independent due to her age so she comes and goes to college / work / her boyfriends, and I suspect she'd have been doing that regardless of a new sibling as it's something that comes with age? But when she is here it's clear she dotes on her little sister. But you're right. I'm not sure how a 2nd little sibling would feel to her.

But she is old enough to talk to her about it if you wanted to and find out. I didn’t specifically ask my eldest if it was ok, he was 13 when I fell pregnant. But he knew it was something I’d wanted, and he once spoke to his step dad without my knowledge about why he (the step dad) was saying no. Afterwards my partner told me that this conversation was a bit factor in him deciding it was a good idea because my son seemed quite keen on the idea. And he is very excited, said to me the other day ‘mum when the baby os born and you need a little break I’ll be able to take him out for a little walk in the pram wont i’.
lots of people won’t realise the differences between pregnancies and having a baby with a larger age gap. Eg last night I left the two kids downstairs having dinner while I went to lie down, my eldest got them some fruit and pudding when they’d finished and cleared the dishes away afterwards. Then put the tv on for the youngest before going to do his homework. She is also not a little one, so is perfectly capable of coming up to find me if she needs something. You get a lot more rest in your pregnancies when the kids are older and at school etc. I have 5 days a week with no children with me for 6 hours a day! I can literally sleep all day if I feel like it 😂 that makes for a much easier pregnancy than someone going through pregnancy with a 18 month old and leading to a 2 year age gap. So that’s also something to consider. x

Lka8 · 20/02/2024 09:24

Apollo365 · 19/02/2024 10:18

32 with my third. Honestly it didn’t make a huge difference to much as they are quite close in age and I still had all the stuff. (Aside from car as we couldn’t get the seats in).
My third was unplanned and for me abortion wasn’t an option (no judgment on anyone else of course).
I would however think, what if you did have twin?

Might have been said but aren’t twins more likely as we get older when two eggs may be released?

TonTonMacoute · 20/02/2024 09:23

It's just a biological urge, a very strong one, but that's the truth.

If you were lucky and fell pregnant very quickly then fine, go for it. But TTC at your age can be very stressful, in which case it can become all consuming and suck the joy out of life. (I speak as someone who knows.)

Grapefruit7 · 20/02/2024 09:22

I’m one of three and had three myself. I love it! Sorry not sure that’s the answer you wanted : )

broodybaby85 · 20/02/2024 09:21

Caravaggiouch · 20/02/2024 08:35

It’s not age that would deter me in your situation, you’re not too old at all, but your experience of your second pregnancy. You could be in a situation where you’re so ill you’re hardly able to look after your DC2 for months and I wouldn’t personally want to risk that.

Edited

Yes, very valid point, I couldn't even get out of bed to get myself a glass of water some days with my 2nd pregnancy. I dread to think of looking after a toddler in that situation if I were to have another awful pregnancy.

OP posts:
Busby88 · 20/02/2024 09:20

I posted a similar thread recently, although my two are younger. What is really putting me off is the idea it could be twins (risk increases with age!) or of something happening physically to either me or a new baby which would then impact on how well I am able to care for my existing two children. Holidays, cars, finances, rooms etc can all be managed I think, for me it’s whether I want to risk upsetting what we have now.

broodybaby85 · 20/02/2024 09:19

@Dogdo
Ahh seems we are in a similar dilemma! We also have the nursery fee reduction coming up this year so we'd back to paying astronomical fees again with a third🤦🏼‍♀️ Definitely something to think about isn't it. But like you, I cannot be logical about it, it's purely an emotional longing, if that makes sense? 😭

OP posts:
Balloonhearts · 20/02/2024 09:17

Shiv861 · 19/02/2024 10:32

I literally HATE it when people say abortion just wasn't an option for me! if you are religious fine but dont you think it will make people feel bad for making that decision.

They may mean it literally. Either through finding out too late or live in a US state where its not allowed.

broodybaby85 · 20/02/2024 09:17

ShakeNvacStevens · 20/02/2024 09:01

OP do you think your eldest might feel pushed out by having two siblings who are so much younger than her, at the moment she’s just a big sister to one, but if there’s two younger ones it might feel more like it’s its own new family unit if that makes sense?

Yes it makes sense and it's certainly something to consider, as I'd never want her to feel that way. She's a fantastic elder sister to her younger sibling, and has never expressed feeling pushed out of the family unit (she's obviously very much a part of that unit!!), but she is more naturally more independent due to her age so she comes and goes to college / work / her boyfriends, and I suspect she'd have been doing that regardless of a new sibling as it's something that comes with age? But when she is here it's clear she dotes on her little sister. But you're right. I'm not sure how a 2nd little sibling would feel to her.

OP posts:
broodybaby85 · 20/02/2024 09:14

Is the abortion debate still going on on this thread? 🙄

OP posts:
Gollygumdropz · 20/02/2024 09:11

Shiv861 · 19/02/2024 10:32

I literally HATE it when people say abortion just wasn't an option for me! if you are religious fine but dont you think it will make people feel bad for making that decision.

Talk about being triggered over absolutely nothing. She fell pregnant unexpectedly and didn’t want a termination end of. She didn’t say it was due to a religious conviction, who cares if it was or wasn’t, she didn’t want one end of