Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a 3rd child?

260 replies

broodybaby85 · 19/02/2024 10:12

I turn 39 this year. I have 2 children already with a large age gap (eldest turns 18 this year and youngest is almost 3). Been with my partner for almost 19 years (he's not the eldest's father).

I know my age will go against me, but I cannot shake the feeling that I want to do it "one last time". However, I also know that with 2 children already and the age gap, there are many cons to adding another.

Please Mumsnet, talk me out of this and help me to just be happy with the two beautiful children I have and get over with my longing for a third?? 😭

Maybe I need to see some of those cons in black and white?! 😂

OP posts:
EndlessTreadmill · 20/02/2024 11:35

broodybaby85 · 20/02/2024 09:33

Yes this is one of my reasons in the pro column I guess. My eldest will be off to uni living her own life in the next few years, possibly even getting married and having her own baby, who knows! So my 3 yo is more likely to grow up as my eldest did - an only child (my eldest was an only child until age 14). It didn't do my eldest any harm obviously- she's a lovely well rounded young lady.

But having that fuller family unit for my youngest is definitely a pull for me. My partner thinks slightly differently and this is where we don't entirely agree - he feels we have a lovely family unit currently and that our youngest completes us, and we can give her all of our attention (and finances) as she grows up, and that adding another to that mix dilutes some of that and potentially "spoils" what we have. Having said that, he's not a 100% no either. 😬

Personally, I think the nicest thing in the world for a child is to have siblings. Everything is more fun when there is someone of a similar age doing it alongside you. My kids favourite moments I think are with their siblings, laughing over nothing in the back of the car, or at the park - and I always feel sorry for only children, with only their parents for company....but that is personal opinion.

BigAnne · 20/02/2024 11:34

I had my 3rd at 41, she's a joy. However I'm now helping with child care to toddlers at 66. It's not easy

Newbie1011 · 20/02/2024 11:32

I understand the going back and forth, looking on forums etc for some sort of decisive experience/ answer! I did this for ages too.
We took the plunge in the end. I am bow about to have my third in a few weeks at age 38 because I couldn’t shake the feeling I wanted it! So can’t yet tell you how it’s turned out - BUT I will say a couple of things -
Even after going back and forth for ages, I was VERY freaked out when I got pregnant - panicked hugely about whether we could really do it, what the impact on existing kids would be, and even wondered if I could really go through with it.
Now, I am excited and so is DH and my two kids, and we have a good setup, but I am still quite nervous - I’m not sure it’s possible to be sure you’ve done ‘the right thing’ - there is no right answer!
ALSO! The car thing has been SO much more of a stress than I thought it would be. When we were considering it everyone went in about the car and I was like OK a new car what’s the big deal. Well actually it IS a big deal - seven seaters are horrible and also cost a fortune especially if you don’t want one that looks like a bus and leaves you feeling like Anne from Motherland! We have realised we are going to have to shell out a good £20k for one I would even countenance driving, even with trading in our current nice SUV! Anyway maybe that’s obviously not a final consideration but just to be aware - it’s definitely a thing!
I actually think you’re in a good position though. It’s not as if you have twin toddlers or anything to make the experience hellish! - I wouldn’t have wanted to do a close age gap again personally as I didn’t enjoy the baby and toddler combo very much!! Having said that it’ll be nice for your younger one to have a closer- in- age buddy!
Good luck and let us know what you decide!

Changed18 · 20/02/2024 11:31

Not too old at all, btw.

Changed18 · 20/02/2024 11:31

My DF did something similar to this - two kids in his 20s, two in his 40s. I suppose it means you always have the cost of maintaining kids, rather over one part of your life (ie you've just finished paying for one child and then you have two more to pay for for the next 18 years) and I suppose that might have an effect on your retirement plans/ability to save for a pension. But that seems to be the main downside. If that's fine...

Dialledin · 20/02/2024 11:25

I had one at 40 and a second at 42 and many women have babies in their early 40s. Your risk of pregnancy loss is a bit higher but you might not experience that all being well. I would spend a few months on a healthy diet and taking a good quality pre natal. The book ‘It Starts with an Egg’ is good. Whatever your lifestyle is like now will affect egg quality in three months time that’s why it’s wise to prepare. I wish I’d understood this as I went through multiple losses before finally sorting my lifestyle out. Not that it was that unhealthy and I can’t prove it was the problem but improve it did lead to a viable pregnancy. A Mediterranean diet is good for fertility and egg quality. Good luck!

Treeinthesky · 20/02/2024 11:24

Get a dog, change ya job or hair colour. Work on you!!! DO you want a baby ad your bored? My god a 3rd would be hard work. They may have additional needs etc you never know what may happen. However if you want a 3rd just have one :)

Namechangenamechange321 · 20/02/2024 11:22

broodybaby85 · 19/02/2024 10:20

Thanks for your opinions, you're actually swaying me the opposite way to what I intended with the thread - I'm being talked into it rather than out of it 😂

What about my age though? 39 in a few months. Am I too old? 😭

Don’t let your age put you off. I had my second at 40. Felt no different to having my first at 36

LocalHobo · 20/02/2024 11:16

@G535600 Sorry you are facing this but I think you are making the correct decision. It's an ongoing situation, and to ensure you can fully embrace your DC growing up, right up to uni visits, and even grandchildren, you don't want to be constantly pulled in every direction. Flowers

Blueskies3 · 20/02/2024 11:11

Why don’t you try? See what happens? It sounds like you really want another child

Lauz841 · 20/02/2024 11:07

AngeloMysterioso · 19/02/2024 10:41

Not necessarily… I have a fiesta and we’ve managed to fit the whole family in it. DS1 and 2 in Axkid Minikid 4s in the back seat, DS3 in baby carrier in passenger seat (with air bag turned off) DH in the middle in the back. Is a tight squeeze mind you!

I had DS3 aged 38 last year, DS1 is 4, DS2 is 2. We’re only a few months in but so far it’s been great- but I am knackered!

This is what we have to do, kind of. We have a tiny 9 year old who still needs a car seat, and a 2 year old who is still rear facing. I don't drive so husband is in the drivers seat, and we have an 18 year old who is 6ft2 so I have to sit between the seats in the back. Its a squeeze but doable. X

Bluetrews25 · 20/02/2024 11:05

This is just your hormones

Sit tight, if history repeats itself you could be a granny in 3 years and get your fill of newborn cuddles then.

If DD leaves home at 18, then you produce a new sibling, she will never have as close a relationship with the younger due to not living in the same house at the same time. There is the possibility of the younger ones being more of a gang, and the older one not being in it.

Siblings often do not get along as children. Don't assume younger will be best buddies with middle one. You are already used to socialising a singleton, doing playdates etc. Let that continue.

The time when we need our siblings most is when dealing with death of the parents. (Sorry to bring this up) It will not matter that there is such an age gap in MANY DECADES when this happens.

What if you have a terrible pregnancy and birth again?

You will be older and more tired so sleepless nights will be harder to deal with.

You (hopefully) enjoy your current standard of living and like the things you are able to do as a family. There will be less cash available for the family to spend the more people there are in it. Would you need to drop your hours? Even mat leave has an impact.

What if you get PND?

What if youngest has additional needs that take over all your time and funds?
Sorry, shit happens.

And lets not forget world population explosion, food shortages globally, housing shortages locally......and all of your DCs going on to have 2-3 of their own.

HTH

TwoGirlsAndOneDog · 20/02/2024 10:48

broodybaby85 · 19/02/2024 10:20

Thanks for your opinions, you're actually swaying me the opposite way to what I intended with the thread - I'm being talked into it rather than out of it 😂

What about my age though? 39 in a few months. Am I too old? 😭

I had my eldest at 36 and my youngest at 38 with a 2yr4m age gap. I’m 39 now with a toddler and baby. I do have to admit that I think I’m less able to deal with the lack of sleep than my younger mum friends and there’s also less flexibility my job - being older, I’ve worked my way up to an Exec level role which means I need to be available if and when the shit hits the fan, which could be anytime and doesn’t work very well with baby and toddler bedtimes/wakings etc. BUT I wouldn’t change it for the world, and I honestly think I (personally) am a way better mum now than I could have been when I was younger. As your eldest is practically an adult and your youngest is (hopefully) past the hardest bits of toddlerhood, I would definitely do it if I were you. Sorry I know that’s not the answer you were looking for!! 😂

persisted · 20/02/2024 10:43

My mother got pregnant again when I was 18.
She had a horrible pregnancy and was in and out of hospital. That left me in a position of having to take care of younger siblings, study, and be worried about her. Eventually the baby was born and they were ok, and that then meant studying with a new born baby in the house.

There was no money so no financial support was available at all for me, which inevitably impacted on my choices. There wasn't enough space in the house so I had to move out as soon as I graduated. She could never work again because of disabilities due to the illness. Every time I was home from university I was the default childcare. They were so small when I moved out that there has never been a proper sibling relationship.

This was all many years ago now, I still think that my parents were ridiculous and selfish, the illness could not have been predicted but they certainly could have done the bloody maths. Its not always a good idea just because you want it to be.

Hysteria30 · 20/02/2024 10:40

broodybaby85 · 19/02/2024 10:12

I turn 39 this year. I have 2 children already with a large age gap (eldest turns 18 this year and youngest is almost 3). Been with my partner for almost 19 years (he's not the eldest's father).

I know my age will go against me, but I cannot shake the feeling that I want to do it "one last time". However, I also know that with 2 children already and the age gap, there are many cons to adding another.

Please Mumsnet, talk me out of this and help me to just be happy with the two beautiful children I have and get over with my longing for a third?? 😭

Maybe I need to see some of those cons in black and white?! 😂

I’m 40 this year and I’ve been feeling the same (my 2 are 18 and 11), however I do think it’s the fear of getting older and not being able to have anymore after menopause as I didn’t feel like this a few years ago. Husband had vasectomy years ago though so it’s not even an option for me! X

broodybaby85 · 20/02/2024 10:39

I'm definitely aware that student loans are repayable. I didn't think there was any other type of student loan? I took mine out in 2003 when I started my first degree aged 18. I finished paying it off a couple years ago at age 37 😱

OP posts:
DoIhavegreeneyes · 20/02/2024 10:37

@broodybaby85 Your education/career achievements are impressive, well done. Top 1% I would think.
Two interesting points upthread.

  1. About maternity services; they are probably not as good as when you last used them
  2. Care of older children. As mine became teens I was very busy with them. Much more management than cooking the fish fingers. I happened to like those early teen years more than all the others.
But I did start in my early 20s. So mid 30s I had teenagers. DH only a little older. You will be a tremendous success whatever you choose, Best Wishes.
porridgeisbae · 20/02/2024 10:31

that student loans have to be repaid ( the clue’s in the name)

@N0Tfunny Loans, particularly for Arts degrees, are effectively a grant for a lot of people because they will never earn enough to have to start repaying them. The threshold for having to start repaying is over £27,000 for most of the loans now.

porridgeisbae · 20/02/2024 10:27

bloomtoperish · 20/02/2024 10:09

Yep. It was an option, they didn't choose it.

Some people genuinely feel more strongly about different things. For instance when there was that plane crash in the Andes and people had to eat the remains of others to survive, some people did that and others did not feel able to do that (and died.)

Something can be psychologically an option for one person that isn't for another.

broodybaby85 · 20/02/2024 10:24

@chaosmaker
My life was never in danger but the pregnancy was rough. The labour would have been life threatening if we weren't in a hospital with medical staff on hand to perform and assisted delivery to get DD out as she was badly stuck. The impact of the birth was more emotional than physical, if I'm honest. I was quite traumatised by the experience and struggled to talk about it for the first year or so. I've since had therapy and I'm a lot better now. But it's not something to minimise, I'm aware of that. I did go through a significant trauma bringing my second child into the world.

OP posts:
N0Tfunny · 20/02/2024 10:24

@broodybaby85 i think you should give more thought to the work, time and money involved in supporting your children through the teenage and early adult years.

Theres a lot of focus on things like car seats and baby equipment. But these are pennies compared with the costs of children.

Lost wages, pension and promotion costs ( almost always to the mum ), physical trauma of pregnancy , labour, birth and breast feeding (mum again)
cost of going part time or paying for childcare (mum again )
all the things you can’t do as a family because of the costs of two young children

But the BIG costs of children are childcare when small and as teenagers. There are almost NO economies of scale with teens - two are at least twice the work and cost of one.

You might be able to persuade two primary children to do the same hobbies/ sports / classes as each other , to get them to hand down clothes and toys and do the same things at weekends etc . Good luck doing that with teenagers.

It’s really not the same as when most of us reading this were teenagers. The expectations of parents of teens are now much higher, in terms of taxiing then around , being involved in their studies and of course supplying expensive clothes and gadgets.

@broodybaby85 i know you are judge at the start of this now, but supporting your children through college / university / into the housing ladder is phenomenally expensive. Every day there are threads here on MN of parents of 18 years olds who have apparently only just realised that

there are no grants now
that student loans have to be repaid ( the clue’s in the name)
that the loan won’t even pay for accommodation in mostly university cities
that most students now expect a much higher standard of living than 20 years ago and more disposable income than many working people
many courses are not the three years you might be planning for - they can be 4, 5 and 6 years

So my advice to you is make sure that you have factored in all these costs. Including your own plans for retirement. Because if you have children late, you will be working a lot longer than many of your friends and family to support your kids.

The other long term issue you need to factor in is divorce. I’m sorry to mention this but it happens to between one third and one half of us. If you have a this child you’d be wise to ensure that you alone can support your children . Because the sad reality is that most dads DONT do this after a divorce. Around one half stop all contact within 2 years and very few pay half the cost of raising their kids.

I know no one wants to think about that, but it’s the reality. No one thinks it will happen to then until it does. I have three kids and I’m going to be working full time until I’m 67 just to support my youngest through university.

However I don’t have elderly parents to care for as well. Some of my friends have had to go part time in their 60s to care for a mum / dad as well as supporting their kids .

No doubt someone will come along and say “ my parents never gave me a penny , I ate dry bread and worked 30 hours a week on night shift to get through uni. “ That’s great for you, but it’s not what I wanted for my children.

So that’s what I’d be factoring into my plans if I were you.

The broodiness you are feeling now is your hormones talking. You need to make this type of decision with your head and not your heart.

LabradorMama · 20/02/2024 10:22

I started trying for a second at 39, having fallen pregnant immediately on trying at 31 I assumed I was pretty fertile. However, I was almost out of eggs and needed two gruelling years of fertility treatment to have my son at 41. If you’re considering it I’d say go and get a full fertility MOT before you potentially waste months trying (like I did) Also, be aware that having a baby ‘later in life’ 🙄 is much harder - I’m bloody knackered! And now perimenopausal to boot.

broodybaby85 · 20/02/2024 10:21

@DoIhavegreeneyes

I spent 15 years studying and working for my career, including completing 3 degrees, including a PhD, as a single mum to my now almost 18 year old. My PhD research was also published a few years ago, before I fell pregnant with my 2nd. So my hard paid off and I'm in a well paid job now, that I'm proud of and I enjoy. But after 15 years of chasing that dream, I'm done with my career ambitions for a while and ready for them to take a backseat ☺️

OP posts:
DoIhavegreeneyes · 20/02/2024 10:15

You are 39, do you not have any ambitions, no adult interests that you want to develop. It might be studying for a career or just for your own sake? No hobbies you wish to develop further. No interest in current affairs or politics?
Do you value yourself in terms of rearing a young child above all else?
As my 2 grew up I had plans for myself, slightly different and separate to the family plans we had together.

bloomtoperish · 20/02/2024 10:09

Shiv861 · 19/02/2024 10:32

I literally HATE it when people say abortion just wasn't an option for me! if you are religious fine but dont you think it will make people feel bad for making that decision.

Yep. It was an option, they didn't choose it.