Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect staff to keep this day free, even if not contracted to work?

983 replies

Newyeargrinch · 19/02/2024 08:47

Senior manager in a small business that has just paid out a considerable amount of money to sponsor a local event towards the end of the year (think Xmas fair). This could potentially bring in a lot of good publicity and business for us. The success of the event depends on having plenty of staff present to represent us. The event is on a Saturday. Some staff work Saturday anyway, some alternate Saturdays. Others are weekday only, some full time, others part time. I know full well that if we asked for volunteers or left until nearer the time, certain staff would come up with reasons why they couldn't help. Therefore an email has gone out to all staff, informing them of the date and saying we expect them to keep it free to attend this event (they will get an extra day off in lieu). Several staff replied to say they didn't know their plans that far ahead as yet but, if free, would be happy to help. We've replied that, if they have nothing planned, they can keep the day free and will be expected to help.

It has been fed back that many staff are unhappy and say that we cannot dictate what they do with their spare time.

I think it's a small ask, they've had 10 months notice and it could bring a lot of extra business our way, ultimately benefiting them!

AIBU?

OP posts:
BreakingAndBroke · 21/02/2024 13:21

Are you offering overtime pay (1.5x or 2x salary for example) to work on a non-working day? You can ask, but you can't demand people work.

Most people have a life outside of work including hobbies, friends, children and caring responsibilities. December is a time when lots of people travel further afield to see friends and family and they aren't going to give that up easily.

VoiceOfCommonSense · 21/02/2024 13:14

Newyeargrinch · 19/02/2024 08:47

Senior manager in a small business that has just paid out a considerable amount of money to sponsor a local event towards the end of the year (think Xmas fair). This could potentially bring in a lot of good publicity and business for us. The success of the event depends on having plenty of staff present to represent us. The event is on a Saturday. Some staff work Saturday anyway, some alternate Saturdays. Others are weekday only, some full time, others part time. I know full well that if we asked for volunteers or left until nearer the time, certain staff would come up with reasons why they couldn't help. Therefore an email has gone out to all staff, informing them of the date and saying we expect them to keep it free to attend this event (they will get an extra day off in lieu). Several staff replied to say they didn't know their plans that far ahead as yet but, if free, would be happy to help. We've replied that, if they have nothing planned, they can keep the day free and will be expected to help.

It has been fed back that many staff are unhappy and say that we cannot dictate what they do with their spare time.

I think it's a small ask, they've had 10 months notice and it could bring a lot of extra business our way, ultimately benefiting them!

AIBU?

I think if you are the type of boss to do something like this his knows what else you have probably done that you think is fine. You employ them you don’t own them. They don’t care about generating extra business, it’s just a job to them. You should have just asked for volunteers to be rostered or paid people more. It’s unreasonable to ask people to be on standby no matter how much notice you give..

wronginalltherightways · 21/02/2024 11:53

Talkamongstyourselves · 20/02/2024 14:18

I turned down a promotion just last month. I enjoy the job I do, it's (mostly), stress-free and when I leave at the end of my shift I can forget about it until I clock on the next day. I'm at an age now where I couldn't give a fat rat's crack about "bettering myself" or "moving up the career ladder". As long as I have enough to pay my bills and a bit left over (which I have), I'm happy in my calm, stress-free life.

I have been a team-leader/supervisor in the past and have no wish to do it again.

Many, many teachers fell the same way. If they don't leave the profession entirely, they step back from anything beyond 'just' classroom teaching, or quit and do 'supply teaching' or become HLTAs so they can just do their contracted hours and go home. I think people would be surprised at the number of HLTAs and 'regular' TAs who are qualified teachers because they're no longer willing to kill themselves for a job and other people's children whilst neglecting their own.

Shinyandnew1 · 21/02/2024 11:12

When you say an extra day off in lieu, do you mean in addition to getting overtime, or just that the day off in lieu is expected to be a fair swap? If it’s the latter then you have to realise that that’s just not feasible for many people. Swapping work on one day to work on another day doesn’t recognise that people have plans and commitments. For example parents who work full time and only get to spend a decent amount of time with their children at the weekends won’t get that time back just because youve given them another day off because the kids will still have to go to school

Exary this. A forced ‘Right, staff-have a random Wednesday off in December rather than a Saturday when you could have a lovely Christmassy day out with your family’ is not a generous offer!

threatmatrix · 21/02/2024 11:05

Maybe offer extra money. But as a business owner myself I would never consider dictating what my staff can or cannot do on their designated free time. Mind you my staff would willing commit to anything for me as we are like family. I would also be guving them extra money and a day In lieu. If I received an email like you sent out I’d be inclined to tell you to F off.

Fitrix29 · 21/02/2024 11:00

When you say an extra day off in lieu, do you mean in addition to getting overtime, or just that the day off in lieu is expected to be a fair swap? If it’s the latter then you have to realise that that’s just not feasible for many people. Swapping work on one day to work on another day doesn’t recognise that people have plans and commitments. For example parents who work full time and only get to spend a decent amount of time with their children at the weekends won’t get that time back just because youve given them another day off because the kids will still have to go to school etc on the day you give in lieu. Some might not actually have another parent available that day to look after them so it might actually cost them money in childcare to attend the event. Others might not have ‘plans’ but attend regular things on that day (gym class, church etc) so you’re still inconveniencing them.

Yes, it is reasonable notice, but you still can’t EXPECT people to rearrange their lives and potentially incur additional costs just because you’ve asked them to well in advance. You need to actually make it worth their while. A day off in lieu doesn’t do this, all this means is that they’re still being paid for the number of days they work. If you want to put them out then you need to make it worth their while; you need to give the day off in lieu AND something else, ideally cold hard cash. If it’s important to the business then it needs to put its money where its mouth is rather than just demanding the goodwill of its employees and going in the huff if they don’t oblige.

Grayson1965 · 21/02/2024 10:42

I don't think your being unreasonable as asking for people to help . But you can't expect them or make them do it . Ask for volunteers and them without children see how you go and there is a nice way of asking without getting stroppy and you can only ask can't you

Londongirlx · 21/02/2024 10:32

I can see the stick but no carrot....

echt · 21/02/2024 10:26

Like far too many MN threads, I imagine that the main reason the OP has not returned is because of the foul language and ridicule to which she has been subjected

If the OP is a manager or even, like, real they'd have encountered strong language before now.

Also, if you can't take ridicule, don't post on AIBU, ya nong.

TheCompactPussycat · 21/02/2024 10:22

echt · 21/02/2024 01:49

I'd like the thread to hit 1000 telling the OP what an entitled fecking eejit she is.

The real question is who are the 11% of respondents who think the OP isn't being unreasonable??

StockpotSoup · 21/02/2024 10:17

whyhere · 21/02/2024 07:37

Like far too many MN threads, I imagine that the main reason the OP has not returned is because of the foul language and ridicule to which she has been subjected.

Oh come on - dial it down a touch. The type of person who’s thick-skinned enough to tell their staff to keep a Saturday just before Christmas free because she needs bodies at an event and then get in a strop when they don’t fancy it isn’t going to clutch their pearls over “foul language”.

There are two possible reasons why she hasn’t come back. 1) The whole thing is fiction intended to wind people up. 2) It’s real and she’s in a strop that hardly anyone has sided with her.

Willitwork999 · 21/02/2024 10:07

I think the wording of your email is quite harsh. You expect!!!

A more friendly approach may have received a more favourable reaction.
As has been mentioned, a request for volunteers initially with a bonus option may have been a better carrot.

IncognitoIsMyFavouriteWord · 21/02/2024 08:11

Lol, OP, is this a reverse?

If not, you're taking the Michael.

Jack80 · 21/02/2024 08:04

If an incentive was put to staff then that maybe help. Maybe a day off in lieu if worked the Saturday.

whyhere · 21/02/2024 07:37

Like far too many MN threads, I imagine that the main reason the OP has not returned is because of the foul language and ridicule to which she has been subjected.

ElaineMBenes · 21/02/2024 07:36

I think, in essence, I think it means ‘suck it up, peasant, your opinion matters not’

Ha! Indeed.

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 21/02/2024 07:33

Ilovecleaning · 21/02/2024 05:14

YOO-HOO, Newyeargrinch! Where aaaaare you!

Enjoying all the frothing on her thread I think 😃

TellMeWhoTheVillainsAre · 21/02/2024 07:32

How many staff do you employ? it sounds like you have plenty. And how many staff do you need? Some will be happy to make themselves available. Some won't.
You can ask for volunteers. You should get enough interest. If you show goodwill and give people the option you're likely to get a more positive response.

stichguru · 21/02/2024 07:28

Does their contract say that occasional Saturday/weekend work can be expected? If so, then what you've said is fine. If not, then the company has already said they don't need to work Saturdays. This would mean that you can ask them, but you need to make it very clear that they don't NEED to work, because legally they don't, and there will be no consequences for them not working, because it's fine they don't work. You can't change the expectations for the job without warning and expect your employees to be ok with it. You're on rocky ground if this is what you have done - go back on it before you have a team who hate you and a legal mess.

puzzledout · 21/02/2024 07:04

Ilovecleaning · 21/02/2024 05:14

YOO-HOO, Newyeargrinch! Where aaaaare you!

GrinGrinGrinGrinGrin

5YearsLeft · 21/02/2024 06:54

echt · 21/02/2024 01:49

I'd like the thread to hit 1000 telling the OP what an entitled fecking eejit she is.

Ha. Well, I can respect that. Though I don’t think OP’s ever coming back. Although, it would be great if she comes back at comment 990 and says, “Thanks. This was a reverse” and that’s it (I always suspected because why would the boss call themselves “Newyeargrinch.”) Oh god, the rage, and only 10 comments to express it in.

Hiddenmnetter · 21/02/2024 05:55

OP you are having a laugh. My Rest Days are MINE. You cannot compel me to work them. If you want me to work, incentivise me. Pay me overtime, and if it suits me, I will take you up on it. Guarantee a specific high value day off in lieu, whatever it is. Working a Saturday is not the same as a Monday-Friday especially if you have children.

YOU have 10 months to prepare. Request volunteers on TOIL basis if you want, but first thing I would be offering is overtime at a 25%-50% uplift, or 1.25-1.5 TOIL. See what people do. Surely you know your workers and who would be interested?

I appreciate that you need a commitment from people, but you then have to incentivise them to provide that commitment, not just “I’ll give you another random day off instead”- no, <my friends go out on Saturday > <i play hockey > <my children need looking after > whatever it is. Weekends are high value days. You want people to work weekends, pay to reflect the value.

Ilovecleaning · 21/02/2024 05:14

YOO-HOO, Newyeargrinch! Where aaaaare you!

12daysofchristmas12 · 21/02/2024 04:55

My old job used to make me do this. Hence why it is my old job.

LouHey · 21/02/2024 04:47

SofiaAmes · 21/02/2024 00:16

Is this legal? I live in California and you can't require staff to do unpaid volunteer work and can actually be fined quite heavily for it. I thought England had much stricter employee protection laws than here!
And frankly, if your employees are not profit sharing, then why would you expect them to want to do something beneficial for the company in their free time? Especially in these times of a worker shortage in many industries.

It's not OK here, either. I don't think a company can be fined for asking, but the employee doesn't need to agree to the extra hours.

Swipe left for the next trending thread