Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect staff to keep this day free, even if not contracted to work?

983 replies

Newyeargrinch · 19/02/2024 08:47

Senior manager in a small business that has just paid out a considerable amount of money to sponsor a local event towards the end of the year (think Xmas fair). This could potentially bring in a lot of good publicity and business for us. The success of the event depends on having plenty of staff present to represent us. The event is on a Saturday. Some staff work Saturday anyway, some alternate Saturdays. Others are weekday only, some full time, others part time. I know full well that if we asked for volunteers or left until nearer the time, certain staff would come up with reasons why they couldn't help. Therefore an email has gone out to all staff, informing them of the date and saying we expect them to keep it free to attend this event (they will get an extra day off in lieu). Several staff replied to say they didn't know their plans that far ahead as yet but, if free, would be happy to help. We've replied that, if they have nothing planned, they can keep the day free and will be expected to help.

It has been fed back that many staff are unhappy and say that we cannot dictate what they do with their spare time.

I think it's a small ask, they've had 10 months notice and it could bring a lot of extra business our way, ultimately benefiting them!

AIBU?

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 19/02/2024 15:18

If you offered me a forced option of ‘work a Saturday in December when you could do something lovely at Christmas with your family but now have to find a whole days childcare and you can have a random Tuesday off’ with no added incentive, I would think you were a really crappy employer.

willWillSmithsmith · 19/02/2024 15:17

ElaineMBenes · 19/02/2024 14:29

Benefit them how exactly? Are you planning on offering them a share of any new business that comes in as a bonus?

Maybe the benefit is the company gaining enough new business to stay afloat and therefore people keep their jobs?
I work at university and work at open days and recruitment events which sometimes take place on a weekend or evening. I don't get a cut of the tuition fees for any students we recruit......I do however keep my job if we recruit enough students to stay viable.

And if the day isn’t particularly successful in pulling in new business will the OP’s company have to close/make redundancies? She didn’t allude to it being make or break, just that it would be ‘beneficial’.

caringcarer · 19/02/2024 15:16

I think you're asking too much. You could roster all staff to work on that day and pay them accordingly, if you want them to be there. But to expect volunteers to give up their free time just before Xmas is unfair. Some will have DC to think about or are you providing free childcare so staff can work?

user1487424951 · 19/02/2024 15:14

Does anyone else think @ElaineMBenes is the OP who has changed names? 👀👀

Undisclosedlocation · 19/02/2024 15:11

And this sort of crap is always phrased as ‘we’ need to cover this event 🙄
Errr no mate, ‘you’ need to

Norugratsatall · 19/02/2024 15:04

I've worked for a small family-run business. Absolute nightmare! Really poorly paid, unpaid overtime expected as standard, customer facing role and so often no lunch break either. Brain storming sessions in the evening at local pubs etc (always unpaid). We were expected to be as devoted to the company as its owners who were clueless about what their staff wanted/needed. Got out as soon as I could...

Rachel1509 · 19/02/2024 15:04

I think your approach is unreasonable.
a better approach would’ve been to offer a day in lieu for working at such an important event. Working families would’ve welcomed that so close to Christmas

frequentlyfrazzled · 19/02/2024 15:01

Just joining in with the many posters to say YABVVU.
I dont have kids so no childcare issues to worry about, but I would still not want to commit to working on a Saturday in December even with 10 months notice. In fact I have changed jobs in the last year specifically to get my weekends back (used to do alternate weekends and hated it).

Plus anyone would have to be on another planet not to understand that December is a really busy month for most people and December weekends are particularly busy. Apart from all the shopping and prep, there is often family visiting to arrange and loads of other social stuff to fit in, most of which cannot be organised so far ahead of time.

If the attendance of minimum staff numbers was so crucial to your event, then this should have been properly planned and resourced at the outset before you committed to sponsor it. So having dropped the ball, you really needed to get staff on side, eg by offering staff who don't normally work Saturdays an enhanced hourly rate or a Christmas bonus etc. But instead you have used strong arm tactics, which would have put my back up immediately. Don't be surprised if this backfires on you, and people suddenly remember that they have firm plans to visit Uncle Bob in Brighton that weekend.

Just to be clear, you don't have the right to dictate what staff do with their free time, unless it is agreed in their contracts. If you want staff to go above and beyond then you need to value and respect them, and reward them appropriately when asking them to go beyond their normal duties or hours of work. And then understand that they can still refuse, which does not make them unsupportive or bad employees, but just normal people with busy lives outside of work.

The employment relationship is a mutual one, and respect and goodwill go both ways.

Abeona · 19/02/2024 15:01

ElaineMBenes · 19/02/2024 14:08

Or just forget to turn up because there is, as various people in management have pointed out, no incentive for them to give up a Saturday just before Christmas.

This is worse that just saying no in the first place!
As a manager who has been responsible for staffing weekend events it is an absolute nightmare if someone just doesn't turn up as you have planned workload and job roles.
I had a member of staff who despite it being part of her contract to work occasional evenings and weekends, would regularly not turn up or there would always be an emergency. It caused the rest of us more stress and work.

There you go again! You are a manager who is probably already, unknowingly, exploiting the goodwill of your staff because they need to keep their job to pay their bills. You're seeing it entirely from your own pov (as a manager) because (as before) you can't/ won't/ don't choose to imagine what it might be like for them.

Itwasafterallallaboutme · 19/02/2024 14:58

I have read all of your one OP on this thread @Newyeargrinch, but only some of the responses you have had - there have been quite a lot of them - and I agree with almost all of them.

I have - unfortunately - always been a "yes" person, as I have always loved helping people. I have also hated being confrontational. But even I would have given you a resounding "no" as I cannot stand bullying and/or blackmailing, and it is the one of the few things I will stand up against.

How about sending all of your employees a letter apologising profusely, and saying your previous posts had been unacceptable, and were not meant as presented at the time. I would then be asking them (if my CFery) was strong enough, if they could just make a note of the requested date in their calendar or diary, saying that if they are available on that date, would they mind coming to the event on a normal days wage, but with two other paid days off - except for bank holidays, and any other days the office is officially closed.

You could also start canvassing your own family and friends asking them to help out on the day, and telling them that free refreshments will be provided for them throughout the day, with a meal provided all together after the event. If you really are a small company, then you might like to consider asking any employees that can make that date, to ask their families if they would like to help out - of course under the same conditions your own family has been offered. You would then need to limit how many volunteers you would actually need to use (plus two in case of last minute cancellations), or your expenses could become ridiculous!

Mine are probably very silly suggestions, as the only office type of employment
I have ever experienced was in my "works experience" fortnight when I was 16, about 50 years ago, and I was only filing or making teas and coffees then. However, I have run my own home and family without too many major mishaps, so maybe that counts for something?

newlaptop12 · 19/02/2024 14:49

I get time off in lieu for something that happens once a year on a Saturday. It's at approx time and a half (I come in for 2-3 hours and get a half day off) and it's voluntary - I tell them if I can do it or not, about 6w before the event.

you need to replace the hours at time and a half or double time (as it's a weekend), and realise that people won't be able to commit so far ahead.

TheDowagerDoughnut · 19/02/2024 14:48

The only way I see this working is to ask for people to volunteer to commit now to that day - and commit to them being rota'd in return - so both parties know now that it is a firm agreement.

Help smooth the way for those volunteers by offering a good incentive, by way of salary for the day. Double rate, for example.

For many people that still won't be enough to give up a pre Xmas Saturday, but others may prefer the money at that time of year.

If you are ONLY offering a day in lieu, it'd be a No from me too. And if you'd just sent an email saying you expected it (as you seem to have done), it'd be a hard, principled No.

Otterock · 19/02/2024 14:46

Massive no from me. Ask for volunteers first with a sweetener if they do. Apart from that no, unless there’s a clause in their contract. I’d have ignored your request and carried on with my life if I wasn’t scheduled to work that day or on weekends.

BusyMummy001 · 19/02/2024 14:44

I think it would have been better to put a call out for people to sign up and offer to pay time and a half for those that commit by X-date as it’s something out of the ordinary in terms of their day to day jobs.

Then you have commitment from them to turn up and confirmed numbers as to who will be working on the day.

BodyKeepingScore · 19/02/2024 14:41

Is this a joke. Would have been a hard no from me. Very unreasonable to ask of staff

Universalsnail · 19/02/2024 14:40

Unreasonable. If you want them to 100% keep a date in the long distance free you need to pay them for it. As an employee I'd tell you jog on about this unless you were asking me to definitely work it

Throwawayme · 19/02/2024 14:39

I'm at a loss on how it benefits them to give up their non contracted weekend day. You need to give them an incentive to want to do it!

dimllaishebiaith · 19/02/2024 14:38

ElaineMBenes · 19/02/2024 14:29

Benefit them how exactly? Are you planning on offering them a share of any new business that comes in as a bonus?

Maybe the benefit is the company gaining enough new business to stay afloat and therefore people keep their jobs?
I work at university and work at open days and recruitment events which sometimes take place on a weekend or evening. I don't get a cut of the tuition fees for any students we recruit......I do however keep my job if we recruit enough students to stay viable.

Its not a race to the bottom

Encouraging the erosion of workers rights in order to ensure that business owners and shareholders get plenty of money is not a good way for society to go

Far better to reward your staff fairly and offer incentives for work over and above what they are contracted for

FreebieWallopFridge · 19/02/2024 14:37

This is a carrot not stick situation.

You should have said they’d be paid and get TOIL.

And you certainly have handled this really, really badly.

StockpotSoup · 19/02/2024 14:36

ElaineMBenes · 19/02/2024 14:29

Benefit them how exactly? Are you planning on offering them a share of any new business that comes in as a bonus?

Maybe the benefit is the company gaining enough new business to stay afloat and therefore people keep their jobs?
I work at university and work at open days and recruitment events which sometimes take place on a weekend or evening. I don't get a cut of the tuition fees for any students we recruit......I do however keep my job if we recruit enough students to stay viable.

This event isn’t for ten months. If the company is worried that they don’t have enough new business to stay afloat, sod December - they need to be doing something now.

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 19/02/2024 14:35

ElaineMBenes · 19/02/2024 14:29

Benefit them how exactly? Are you planning on offering them a share of any new business that comes in as a bonus?

Maybe the benefit is the company gaining enough new business to stay afloat and therefore people keep their jobs?
I work at university and work at open days and recruitment events which sometimes take place on a weekend or evening. I don't get a cut of the tuition fees for any students we recruit......I do however keep my job if we recruit enough students to stay viable.

That’s a terrible idea

That could easily be construed as ‘you might lose your job if you don’t do this’. That’s just inviting official complaints and tribunals.

It might be part of your role to help recruit students. But it doesn’t follow that doing anything to bring. New business in is part of everyone’s jobs.

You could use the ‘ah you must do this or the business could under’ and apply it to anything. Working late everyday, shift changes, not getting AL, working your days off and so on’

‘work your usual day off and we will attract more business’ is of no benefit to the employee

LoveAHamSandwhich · 19/02/2024 14:35

Anyway, I'll say it again. I reckon this is a family-owned business. There is no HR dept. And OP is one of the family.

IslayAnn · 19/02/2024 14:35

No sorry you can't dictate what staff do in their spare time, and with kids the run up to Christmas is usually a nightmare with Christmas stuff for school and fitting in seeing family.
I would advise asking for volunteers to commit now to working on that day, then see if you have enough cover. You might have to provide an incentive like extra pay though if staff are not normally contracted to work weekends

Whatsmynameagain9 · 19/02/2024 14:34

You should have offered a perk for volunteers signing up and committing now to help you plan. And offer them a day off in leiu in addition.

Temp staff to make up the shortfall.

LoveAHamSandwhich · 19/02/2024 14:34

ElaineMBenes · 19/02/2024 14:29

Benefit them how exactly? Are you planning on offering them a share of any new business that comes in as a bonus?

Maybe the benefit is the company gaining enough new business to stay afloat and therefore people keep their jobs?
I work at university and work at open days and recruitment events which sometimes take place on a weekend or evening. I don't get a cut of the tuition fees for any students we recruit......I do however keep my job if we recruit enough students to stay viable.

And was it in your contract, that you would be doing that?