Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Payrise and maintenance

341 replies

Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 07:05

Keen to hear people's opinions about this.

Two DC, father is married with more children. Mother is single.

Father is not on a great wage however his wife has received several payrises in the years they've been together and works in a professional career which means as a whole their household is quite well off and can afford quite a lot of luxuries.

Maintenance is paid by the father based on his low wage. Mother is struggling a little as also on a lower wage.

Mother argues that they should pay more as a household instead due to wife's higher pay, obviously not officially through CMS as they don't take new partners into account, but morally. Wife disagrees and says what she earns is nothing to do with the mother and is for her household/children/ stepchildren when there, not at their mums.

Father stuck in the middle a bit.

Random poll options

YABU - wife should subsidise higher maintenance.

YANBU - Mother and father should care for their children on their own respective wages and what wife earns is nothing to do with the mother.

OP posts:
Hoplolly · 19/02/2024 14:09

Go for the position above, move to a similar but higher paying role at a different company? Upskill.
the normal things that people do to increase their pay.

What a ridiculous idealistic view. We'd all be doing that if we could but it's not quite as simple as you'd like to make out.

As a PP poster has mentioned, it's always so one-sided. The children MUST have the same quality of life as the other children at their dad's house, but should mum meet and marry a billionaire, nobody would be insisting that they should be raising the dad's standard of living.

beAsensible1 · 19/02/2024 14:02

I didn’t say it was easy, you asked how and I gave an example.

PinkEasterbunny · 19/02/2024 14:02

So it’s that easy
anyone can just “earn more” should they wish to

or is it just the men NRPs you think can magically pull more money out of their arse?

Just the men, by the sound of it .....

funinthesun19 · 19/02/2024 14:02

I think it’s really daft/ unrealistic that just because a dad’s partner has a high earning job, the he should just magically get a job with the same amount of earnings just so that the mum’s household has as much as the stepmum brings in.

Do people not realise that sometimes, women are more skilled than men? Have higher qualifications? And therefore they will have more money?

Sometimes the stepmum is better off than both the mum and the dad and that’s absolutely 100% ok!

If the dad is to go and get a higher earning job, then he might have go and do the MN unthinkable and possibly train. We all know how frowned upon it is for a dad to cut down his hours so he can study/ have a career change. So what exactly do you want him to do if you want him to ensure that eventually his children have the same standard of living at their mum’s as they do at their dad’s? And even then, even if he did earn as much as his partner, the ex would only be getting a percentage of that amount whereas the dad’s partner gets to keep ALL of hers for the dad’s household. So it’s never ever going to be equal.

If the mum’s partner was well off, absolutely nobody would be falling over themselves to say the children need the same standard of living at their dad’s house. So this whole thing just screams of nothing more than jealously and the fact that so many people think that only one household matters: the mum’s.

Britpop123 · 19/02/2024 14:00

beAsensible1 · 19/02/2024 13:54

Go for the position above, move to a similar but higher paying role at a different company? Upskill.
the normal things that people do to increase their pay.

no time for that, but always time to make more children when the others are barely managing.

Edited

So it’s that easy
anyone can just “earn more” should they wish to

or is it just the men NRPs you think can magically pull more money out of their arse?

beAsensible1 · 19/02/2024 13:58

PinkEasterbunny · 19/02/2024 13:56

Go for the position above, move to a similar but higher paying role at a different company? Upskill.
the normal thing ma that people do to increase their pay.
no time for that, but always time to make more children when the others are barely managing.

But who's to say he hasn't already done that? The whole point of this thread is that the OP earns good money, there's nothing to say that her husband doesn't, or doesn't want to!!!

OP has said he isn’t on a great wage.

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 19/02/2024 13:58

Goldbar · 19/02/2024 13:51

A good comparison would be the mums who send nappies/clothes/food with young children for contact, because they don't trust their useless exes to provide what is needed. Yes, they don't have to - but they do it because otherwise the kids will go without and their priority is to prevent this, not 'fairness'.

That’s not a good comparison.

A comparison would be a SM having to buy the child nappies in both houses because neither parent cares that their child is going without.

But there’s no reason to assume the parents don’t care. It sounds like the ex here is just thinking about how much she can get and not thinking ‘oh it’s great the kids get so much because @Lillo7 earns a decent salary’.

PinkEasterbunny · 19/02/2024 13:56

Go for the position above, move to a similar but higher paying role at a different company? Upskill.
the normal thing ma that people do to increase their pay.
no time for that, but always time to make more children when the others are barely managing.

But who's to say he hasn't already done that? The whole point of this thread is that the OP earns good money, there's nothing to say that her husband doesn't, or doesn't want to!!!

beAsensible1 · 19/02/2024 13:54

GrumpyPanda · 19/02/2024 13:26

RTFT. He's working FT in a professional job as is the ex. How exactly do you propose he "maximize his income"?

Go for the position above, move to a similar but higher paying role at a different company? Upskill.
the normal things that people do to increase their pay.

no time for that, but always time to make more children when the others are barely managing.

Britpop123 · 19/02/2024 13:52

Brotherlove · 19/02/2024 13:47

Do you think ex - who child does not live with - should receive money from the RP because they have more?

I’m just challenging those that say, without considering context, that it’s all about an equal standard of living and (usually the man) should pay to ensure that happens.

Goldbar · 19/02/2024 13:51

A good comparison would be the mums who send nappies/clothes/food with young children for contact, because they don't trust their useless exes to provide what is needed. Yes, they don't have to - but they do it because otherwise the kids will go without and their priority is to prevent this, not 'fairness'.

Toooldtoworry · 19/02/2024 13:50

allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 19/02/2024 09:35

@Toooldtoworry wow!! Bad enough my DHs ex expects me to leave my house solely to their son when we have 5 children between us (none together). cannot believe the cheek of him!!! your house to leave to your children, not even to him if you can avoid it!!

I mean it is jointly owned so poor word use and DSS will get a share from DHs half but I am fuming about that comment.

Goldbar · 19/02/2024 13:49

Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 13:27

They aren't living in poverty far as I know, just feeling the pinch a little at the min.

It really depends on what 'feeling the pinch' means.

The way I see it, both parents are (at least morally) 'joint and severally liable' to provide their children with a decent standard of living - for the whole time, not just 50% or less of the time. This means that if one parent is unable to or welches out, the other parent is still wholly responsible, not just 50% responsible.

For example, single parents can't say "well, I'm only 50% responsible for my child, aren't I?" and demand that social services sort something out for the other 50% of the time.

So your DH has a responsibility to make sure his DC have a decent standard of living 100% of the time, not just the 50% they are with him. Likewise, his ex has a responsibility to ensure that the DC have a decent standard of living 100% of the time. If overall the DC aren't properly provided for, both parents are at fault regardless of in whose house it occurs.

But 'properly provided for' doesn't mean 'equal standard of living'. So it does come down to the specifics of what you mean by 'feeling the pinch'. If there's not enough food or any money to replace outgrown shoes or clothes, if your SDC are living in a freezing house, if there's no money for school trips (and I don't mean the skiing holidays) and if basic extracurriculars (again, not Pony Club!) are being cut, then I do think your DH has to take more responsibility here to ensure his kids have a decent life. And driving around in a new car would just seem singularly tactless and inappropriate in those circumstances, regardless of whoever paid for it. But if it's simply that they'll have to go camping this summer rather than a holiday abroad, then that's clearly a different thing.

Brotherlove · 19/02/2024 13:47

Britpop123 · 19/02/2024 13:42

Clearly mumsnet will not approve of “levelling things up” here

Do you think ex - who child does not live with - should receive money from the RP because they have more?

PinkEasterbunny · 19/02/2024 13:43

He needs to step up and start maximising his income. He’s should feel very rubbish that there’s such a disparity in his children’s quality of life.

But from what I've read, he's already got a respectable job/income, its just that the OP is doing pretty well too, so between them they are comfortable. Why do both households have to be equal? Its unrealistic.

Britpop123 · 19/02/2024 13:42

Brotherlove · 19/02/2024 13:19

I'm in a wierd situation like this.....i'm the RP - higher earner , lazy workshy ex demands money from me to ensure the child get the 'same standard of living in both homes'.

Clearly mumsnet will not approve of “levelling things up” here

Britpop123 · 19/02/2024 13:39

Goldbar · 19/02/2024 12:44

I'm sorry, this is just how I feel. I couldn't respect someone having a good standard of living 'living off' someone else's earnings, conveniently not taken into account by the CMS, while their children struggle. It would completely give me the ick.

This doesn't mean that I in any way think that the new partner is responsible for financing the kids. I agree 100% that it's entirely the parents' responsibility.

But if you choose to have children, you should strive to give them the best start in life that you possibly can. They don't stop becoming entitled to this just because you separate from their other parent. And driving a new car around if your ex is struggling to afford some of the basic things most parents would hope to give their children during childhood (days out, extracurricular activities, for example) - for me, that just leaves a nasty taste. Start job-hunting for a higher paid job, get a second job, do what you need to give your kids a decent childhood. Too much 'out of sight, out of mind' with some NRPs.

Does all of that apply both ways round
if the RP is doing well and the NRP isn’t should she subsidise him? Should she help make sure the kids have the same standard of living?

I don’t think I’ve ever seen that said on here…

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 19/02/2024 13:31

Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 13:27

Dh and ex were never married so there was no divorce settlement.

As far as I understand it legally my income has nothing to do with maintenance, his DC or his ex.

In fact it's a reason I'd be even more reluctant to start contributing so it could never be argued if anything happened between me and DH, that I financially supported DSC and should continue to do so. No thank you!

You are absolutely right that your salary has absolutely nothing to do with his liability for child maintenance payments.

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 19/02/2024 13:30

NotARealWookiie · 19/02/2024 13:24

Based on your presumption of a financial order… it’s worth being certain.

The financial settlement wouldn’t cover child maintenance regardless.

Just distribution of the ‘marital assets’.

Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 13:27

They aren't living in poverty far as I know, just feeling the pinch a little at the min.

OP posts:
Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 13:27

Dh and ex were never married so there was no divorce settlement.

As far as I understand it legally my income has nothing to do with maintenance, his DC or his ex.

In fact it's a reason I'd be even more reluctant to start contributing so it could never be argued if anything happened between me and DH, that I financially supported DSC and should continue to do so. No thank you!

OP posts:
Chocolatebuttonns · 19/02/2024 13:26

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

GrumpyPanda · 19/02/2024 13:26

beAsensible1 · 19/02/2024 13:04

He needs to step up and start maximising his income. He’s should feel very rubbish that there’s such a disparity in his children’s quality of life.

RTFT. He's working FT in a professional job as is the ex. How exactly do you propose he "maximize his income"?

NotARealWookiie · 19/02/2024 13:24

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 19/02/2024 13:18

The courts have absolutely no interest in the OP’s income.

The DH is remarried. Presumably his divorce had a financial settlement. He’s not a high earner, so maintenance will be via CMS.

The courts are utterly irrelevant to this.

Based on your presumption of a financial order… it’s worth being certain.

Dollyparton3 · 19/02/2024 13:24

I've got this t shirt OP, except I don't have any kids of my own and before DH and the even moved in together the ex asked for maintenance to be relocated to take into account my salary (I KID YOU NOT)

He's always paid maintenance +++ and she was working part time with two mid teens kids who got themselves to and from school so no excuses.

Step kids are now adults but benefitted hugely from our bigger home, nice holidays, days out all paid for by me and whenever any extras needed paying for the extra told the kids "ask Dolly, I can't afford anything on the pittance your dad gives me.

Some ex's just have an axe to grind forever I'm afraid, she sounds like one of them. Ignore her