Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Payrise and maintenance

341 replies

Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 07:05

Keen to hear people's opinions about this.

Two DC, father is married with more children. Mother is single.

Father is not on a great wage however his wife has received several payrises in the years they've been together and works in a professional career which means as a whole their household is quite well off and can afford quite a lot of luxuries.

Maintenance is paid by the father based on his low wage. Mother is struggling a little as also on a lower wage.

Mother argues that they should pay more as a household instead due to wife's higher pay, obviously not officially through CMS as they don't take new partners into account, but morally. Wife disagrees and says what she earns is nothing to do with the mother and is for her household/children/ stepchildren when there, not at their mums.

Father stuck in the middle a bit.

Random poll options

YABU - wife should subsidise higher maintenance.

YANBU - Mother and father should care for their children on their own respective wages and what wife earns is nothing to do with the mother.

OP posts:
JacksonLambsEatIvy · 20/02/2024 23:41

Vonesk · 20/02/2024 23:05

In the UK, The Second Wife is partially responsible and is accessed for financial arrangements for her husbands first family. Dont SHOOT the messenger.
So that a Man cannot do a runner and beget more sprogs to eliminate himself from financial liability.

  1. The same laws don’t apply across the UK, so your assertion fails in the first clause.
  2. Why have you capitalised Second Wife like it’s a title?
  3. In England a new partner (or wife) is only relevant if there has not yet been a financial settlement. No one should consider a relationship with someone divorced who does not have the finances sorted (on a clean break basis).
  4. If the new partner is taken into consideration as part of agreeing a financial settlement, it is only in relation to the divorcing partner’s reduced needs (because they no longer need to be solely responsible for paying their housing and living costs). But it is much better to not live with someone who hasn’t sorted their divorce out yet in pretty much all cases.

Your final sentence is weird and seems intended to dehumanise the younger children in a so-called second family.

So, yeah, we will shoot the messenger. Because the messenger is up to no good.

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 20/02/2024 23:34

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 20/02/2024 22:25

What strikes me reading the first half of this thread (not read it all) is how many people seem to think that it’s ok for step parents to not treat or value their step children as much as their own children. I can’t imagine seeing my step children as anything less than my own children.

Oh stop with the moralising.

MississippiAF · 20/02/2024 23:12

Vonesk · 20/02/2024 23:05

In the UK, The Second Wife is partially responsible and is accessed for financial arrangements for her husbands first family. Dont SHOOT the messenger.
So that a Man cannot do a runner and beget more sprogs to eliminate himself from financial liability.

Nope.

AnneLovesGilbert · 20/02/2024 23:06

Vonesk · 20/02/2024 23:05

In the UK, The Second Wife is partially responsible and is accessed for financial arrangements for her husbands first family. Dont SHOOT the messenger.
So that a Man cannot do a runner and beget more sprogs to eliminate himself from financial liability.

Stop lying.

Vonesk · 20/02/2024 23:05

In the UK, The Second Wife is partially responsible and is accessed for financial arrangements for her husbands first family. Dont SHOOT the messenger.
So that a Man cannot do a runner and beget more sprogs to eliminate himself from financial liability.

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 20/02/2024 22:25

What strikes me reading the first half of this thread (not read it all) is how many people seem to think that it’s ok for step parents to not treat or value their step children as much as their own children. I can’t imagine seeing my step children as anything less than my own children.

whynotwhatknot · 20/02/2024 14:31

people clearly dont rtft op as stated her dh pays more tan the cms minumum has not reduced it since having more chhildren and has also offered to hhave them more which thhe ex has has refused

op hhhas nothing to do with providing for their children

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 20/02/2024 12:46

BadLad · 20/02/2024 09:50

Men could choose not to get into a relationship with a more affluent woman.

I’ve surely heard it all now.

Well if they object to that woman and her children having a better lifestyle than he or his ex provide… yeah.

if the optics and equal provision matter to him, he should just pick someone whose lifestyle won’t make his kids feel bad.

Or everyone could be bloody grateful for what the woman actually enables and provides and stop trying to get her to provide even more because she chose a man with children.

Goldbar · 20/02/2024 11:18

I didn't think YABU to start off with, OP, because it's not your job to pay for their children, however much the mum might be struggling.

However, now that you've clarified that all 'struggling' and 'feeling the pinch' means in this situation is that the ex is having to cut down on luxuries like holidays and meals out (which the kids won't be missing out on anyway because they can have them when they're at your house), then I also agree that your DH is not unreasonable either. So long as the kids have everything they need in life to thrive and do well, their mum's lifestyle beyond that is clearly not his responsibility.

PinkEasterbunny · 20/02/2024 11:17

Lillo7 · 20/02/2024 10:13

The children have everything they need, they do hobbies each, have uniforms, clothes, nice shoes, go on school trips. DH pays half of all this as well as maintenance. He also pays for their phones too.

We pay bills in proportion to our respective salaries, and I also end up covering more of things like holidays understandably. But I won't be taking on even more bills so that he can pay more than he already does to his ex. I don't see how that's any different than me just paying her myself.

From what I can tell, to her feeling the pinch or struggling is not being able to have many luxuries. The children are still clothed, fed, cared for etc..

My comment about her finding a partner was ridiculous yes. It was intended to be. Because her being single is absolutely not my problem and I won't feel guilty because she doesn't have a partner and I do. Her relationship status is nothing to do with me or my money.

Totally agree

Missamyp · 20/02/2024 10:49

I'm sorry, but it may be worth suggesting to the ex-wife to review her income and explore ways to improve it. It's important to remember that after a divorce, each party is responsible for their own financial situation.
While it may be tempting to compare lifestyles, it's not ethical or legal for one party to demand the same standard of living as the other.

Dollyparton3 · 20/02/2024 10:40

Agree with you OP. In our case the ex pleaded poverty whilst sitting on a part time wage, with a new kitchen, new car whilst telling the kids that they couldn't have nice things because of their dad.

The year that maintenance ended she went back to work full time.

Chocolatebuttonns · 20/02/2024 10:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Hoplolly · 20/02/2024 10:16

Couldn't agree with you more @Lillo7

Lillo7 · 20/02/2024 10:13

The children have everything they need, they do hobbies each, have uniforms, clothes, nice shoes, go on school trips. DH pays half of all this as well as maintenance. He also pays for their phones too.

We pay bills in proportion to our respective salaries, and I also end up covering more of things like holidays understandably. But I won't be taking on even more bills so that he can pay more than he already does to his ex. I don't see how that's any different than me just paying her myself.

From what I can tell, to her feeling the pinch or struggling is not being able to have many luxuries. The children are still clothed, fed, cared for etc..

My comment about her finding a partner was ridiculous yes. It was intended to be. Because her being single is absolutely not my problem and I won't feel guilty because she doesn't have a partner and I do. Her relationship status is nothing to do with me or my money.

OP posts:
funinthesun19 · 20/02/2024 09:56

GN637 · 20/02/2024 07:06

Priorities indeed. ExH pays around £800 a month for his swanky electric lease car as a salary sacrifice so that there's less income on paper for the CMS to take into consideration. He pays less than £150 a month for Dd. He's updating his car next month but dropping the maintenance. Dd knows where his priorities lie and it's not with her and her self esteem takes a battering on a daily basis due to him. He can't afford her pocket money this month to make things worse. He gives the child he lives with (her sister) about £100 a week to spend as she pleases. Men like him as scum and their children know it.

That’s a different scenario to OP’s. Your ex is knowingly and sneakily depriving his DD money from HIM. That’s scummy behaviour and I agree with you that paying £800 on a car via a salary sacrifice is beyond repulsive. He sounds like he will constantly try to find ways to reduce the money he gives to her from his money.

With OP situation though, I don’t see the father in quite the same light as your DD’s father. OP’s husband sounds like he’s paying maintenance for his DD without using any loopholes to try and reduce it. The fact that he has a wife with a high earning job doesn’t automatically equal bad father if he’s doing everything he can for his DD with his OWN money.

CassandraWebb · 20/02/2024 09:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

And I wasn't 🤷‍♀️

Chocolatebuttonns · 20/02/2024 09:50

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

BadLad · 20/02/2024 09:50

Men could choose not to get into a relationship with a more affluent woman.

I’ve surely heard it all now.

CassandraWebb · 20/02/2024 09:49

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

My children aren't his.

We both contribute the same. We each have the same number of children. We each earn essentially the same (varies a little depending on bonuses/ overtime etc)

I don't see how I am subsidising him

Dweetfidilove · 20/02/2024 09:49

caringcarer · 19/02/2024 14:34

I know DH says exh is round the twist. The sad thing is when exh and I were together he seemed very normal and reasonable. He cheated on me and I found out and divorced him. I don't think he thought I ever would because I really loved him. The divorce was horrendous. He made everything so much harder by refusing to just go 50/50 on everything. He was abusive to me and tried to threaten DH when I was dating him. He came to my house the first Valentine's day after we had divorced and made my son let him in. I wasn't there. He smashed a glass vase with some lilies I'd been given. I came home to glass everywhere. He threatened to turn up at our wedding and spoil it. Then after all that shit he put DH and me through for several years he thinks we should let him use our holiday home. He's jealous because the DC and DGC come on holiday with me and DH sometimes and not him. If he'd been nicer to them who knows. I think he's on his own and instead of getting on with his life he sits and stews on stuff. Our kids think he has MH issues. He's definitely obsessive about the bloody pension.

I’m not even slightly surprised he’s awful all round.
Your husband is right, and it will never occur to him that he’s the issue.
Well done on escaping him (for the most part).

Chocolatebuttonns · 20/02/2024 09:46

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Chocolatebuttonns · 20/02/2024 09:45

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

CassandraWebb · 20/02/2024 09:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

In what way is my husband living off me? H has 2 kids. I have 2 kids. We both have very similar (decent) salaries.

Brotherlove · 20/02/2024 09:39

Propertynightmare24573 · 20/02/2024 08:01

Imagine you're the child. You desperately want to go to football club or dance classes or brownies or whatever but your mum can't afford it. You know she can't because 3 weeks in 4 you eat reasonably ok but the 4th week for some inexplicable reason you get plain pasta and mum doesn't seem to eat as much. Your trainers are from Asda and a bit worn and tatty.

Meanwhile dad and his new family and your new half siblings are out at riding lessons, wearing the latest fashions in high end brands. They go on the school residential trips, and their snapchat stories are full of Starbucks.

Ok it's a bit extreme but it's not unheard of. How would you feel if you were that child?

Sadly we are in this situation but the other way around.
RP provides everything for kids, they do not need anything.
NRP pleads poverty, food is sparce, no new clothes, shoes etc
Child told 'ask RP to send new xyz'.
No CMS required by RP.
At NRP there's always money for takeaways with the gf, booze in fridge and fags hidden in the car.....and they still somehow think RP giving £ to NRP would be appropriate.
How on earth is this resolved?