Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Payrise and maintenance

341 replies

Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 07:05

Keen to hear people's opinions about this.

Two DC, father is married with more children. Mother is single.

Father is not on a great wage however his wife has received several payrises in the years they've been together and works in a professional career which means as a whole their household is quite well off and can afford quite a lot of luxuries.

Maintenance is paid by the father based on his low wage. Mother is struggling a little as also on a lower wage.

Mother argues that they should pay more as a household instead due to wife's higher pay, obviously not officially through CMS as they don't take new partners into account, but morally. Wife disagrees and says what she earns is nothing to do with the mother and is for her household/children/ stepchildren when there, not at their mums.

Father stuck in the middle a bit.

Random poll options

YABU - wife should subsidise higher maintenance.

YANBU - Mother and father should care for their children on their own respective wages and what wife earns is nothing to do with the mother.

OP posts:
MississippiAF · 21/02/2024 08:28

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 21/02/2024 07:44

No, they’re not legally responsible for any kind of financial support for HIS children. I just don’t see any solution that would provide a “fair” system that works well for kids in the event that parents separate.

Well you’ve hit the nail on the head. Somewhere along the line, people started to think everything must always be equal and ‘fair’ in any household a DC is part of, with anyone at all involved (ie stepparents) needing to contribute to ensure this magical fairness is ensured at all times.

It doesn’t.

I work really hard, DH’s does fuck all. Their DC are never going to have the life with her that I can give mine. I’ll be damned if I’m giving money to their household to allow their mother to look good in front of them and hide her fecklessness.

Valtine2 · 21/02/2024 08:18

Absolutely not. How much money your DH pay? How often does he have his child? This is key also so mum can work more hours?

BIossomtoes · 21/02/2024 08:17

My bloke’s ex took the same stance. It’s ridiculous.

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 21/02/2024 08:12

You said “providing you don’t get involved with anyone who has kids, or adopt any”.

The thread has NOTHING to do with adoption. You brought adoption into the discussion of how (you think) stepparents should feel about stepchildren. You are the one that aligned the two situations.

But, I think you are purposefully being disingenuous to have a fight online. So I’m not going to engage any further.

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 21/02/2024 08:02

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 21/02/2024 07:58

YOU did. Read your own post and stop being disingenuous. Why would you even bring adoption into anything?

’You sound bitter’ is clearly your way of pretending that this isn’t the very clear pattern of argument that recurs on stepparenting discussions all the time. Less bitter than fed up with this nonsense being thrown at women in these situations.

No I didn’t equate being a step parent to adopting 😂
I equated adopting to a statement saying that it was impossible to love a child that you hadn’t carried and birthed, the same way that you love one that you had. That is literally saying that an adoptive parent can’t love their adopted child as much as one they’ve birthed and carried, and many people feel that way, and there’s nothing wrong with feeling that way just don’t adopt, or get involved with someone who has kids. It’s not rocket science

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 21/02/2024 08:00

Toooldtoworry · 21/02/2024 07:50

But you are expecting the step parent to provide a similar life for their step child if the parents don't earn enough to support that.

And…?

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 21/02/2024 07:58

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 21/02/2024 07:49

Did someone equate becoming a step parent and adopting a child? 🤔
The latter part of your post sounds quite bitter.

Edited

YOU did. Read your own post and stop being disingenuous. Why would you even bring adoption into anything?

’You sound bitter’ is clearly your way of pretending that this isn’t the very clear pattern of argument that recurs on stepparenting discussions all the time. Less bitter than fed up with this nonsense being thrown at women in these situations.

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 21/02/2024 07:54

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 21/02/2024 07:46

A new partners income isn’t taken into account in England either. Certainly not standard practice.

It can be taken into account in limited ways and under certain circumstances in determining a financial settlement. But it’s not a ‘what can she contribute to the pot to be shared?’ question. It’s only about determining the divorcing party’s needs. So his needs for housing costs will be reduced because he doesn’t need to pay 100% of his rent and bills.

If there was no marriage or the divorce was concluded with a clean break financial settlement before any new cohabiting occurred, then the new partner’s income is entirely irrelevant to the ex.

That’s what happens in England. But, as I said, no sensible person should move in with a person who hasn’t sorted out their financial settlement as part of their divorce first.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 21/02/2024 07:50

Vonesk · 20/02/2024 23:05

In the UK, The Second Wife is partially responsible and is accessed for financial arrangements for her husbands first family. Dont SHOOT the messenger.
So that a Man cannot do a runner and beget more sprogs to eliminate himself from financial liability.

Hahahaha you are so wrong it is laughable, stop spouting this shit.

Toooldtoworry · 21/02/2024 07:50

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 21/02/2024 07:42

No one is expected anyone to “give anyone half their wage” 🙄
but an awful lot of people are prepared to see their step kids go without and live a “lesser life” than their own children, which I find quite a repugnant attitude.

But you are expecting the step parent to provide a similar life for their step child if the parents don't earn enough to support that.

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 21/02/2024 07:49

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 21/02/2024 07:48

it is really offensive to many adoptive families to make statements comparing becoming a stepmother to adopting a child.

It’s a completely different situation and the child has two parents who retain parental responsibility. Financially supporting the parent you’re not in a relationship is not a requirement.

For all this you must love and treat them as your own stuff, it very quickly becomes apparent that this only extends to paying for the SC. It doesn’t extend to decision-making or disciplining. It’s more of a treat them as your own when it suits their parents (so you can pay for stuff and do the childcare and housework - must do it with a smile on your face no matter what) but stay in your lane if you expect anything else.

Moralising to try to insist that the OP has some kind of obligation to make up for the children’s mother’s career and lifestyle choices is ridiculous.

Did someone equate becoming a step parent and adopting a child? 🤔
The latter part of your post sounds quite bitter.

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 21/02/2024 07:48

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 21/02/2024 07:40

There’s nothing wrong with that, providing you don’t get involved with anyone who has kids, or adopt any.

it is really offensive to many adoptive families to make statements comparing becoming a stepmother to adopting a child.

It’s a completely different situation and the child has two parents who retain parental responsibility. Financially supporting the parent you’re not in a relationship is not a requirement.

For all this you must love and treat them as your own stuff, it very quickly becomes apparent that this only extends to paying for the SC. It doesn’t extend to decision-making or disciplining. It’s more of a treat them as your own when it suits their parents (so you can pay for stuff and do the childcare and housework - must do it with a smile on your face no matter what) but stay in your lane if you expect anything else.

Moralising to try to insist that the OP has some kind of obligation to make up for the children’s mother’s career and lifestyle choices is ridiculous.

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 21/02/2024 07:46

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 20/02/2024 23:41

  1. The same laws don’t apply across the UK, so your assertion fails in the first clause.
  2. Why have you capitalised Second Wife like it’s a title?
  3. In England a new partner (or wife) is only relevant if there has not yet been a financial settlement. No one should consider a relationship with someone divorced who does not have the finances sorted (on a clean break basis).
  4. If the new partner is taken into consideration as part of agreeing a financial settlement, it is only in relation to the divorcing partner’s reduced needs (because they no longer need to be solely responsible for paying their housing and living costs). But it is much better to not live with someone who hasn’t sorted their divorce out yet in pretty much all cases.

Your final sentence is weird and seems intended to dehumanise the younger children in a so-called second family.

So, yeah, we will shoot the messenger. Because the messenger is up to no good.

A new partners income isn’t taken into account in England either. Certainly not standard practice.

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 21/02/2024 07:44

Vonesk · 20/02/2024 23:05

In the UK, The Second Wife is partially responsible and is accessed for financial arrangements for her husbands first family. Dont SHOOT the messenger.
So that a Man cannot do a runner and beget more sprogs to eliminate himself from financial liability.

No, they’re not legally responsible for any kind of financial support for HIS children. I just don’t see any solution that would provide a “fair” system that works well for kids in the event that parents separate.

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 21/02/2024 07:42

Toooldtoworry · 21/02/2024 06:04

Would you give them half your wage at the detriment to your own home to 'equalise' if the RP did not earn the same?

No one is expected anyone to “give anyone half their wage” 🙄
but an awful lot of people are prepared to see their step kids go without and live a “lesser life” than their own children, which I find quite a repugnant attitude.

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 21/02/2024 07:40

Lillo7 · 21/02/2024 07:22

Yep.

There’s nothing wrong with that, providing you don’t get involved with anyone who has kids, or adopt any.

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 21/02/2024 07:39

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 20/02/2024 23:34

Oh stop with the moralising.

Don’t blame me, if you’re prepared to see that kind of behaviour as acceptable.

Lillo7 · 21/02/2024 07:22

Futb0l · 21/02/2024 06:29

What strikes me reading the first half of this thread (not read it all) is how many people seem to think that it’s ok for step parents to not treat or value their step children as much as their own children. I can’t imagine seeing my step children as anything less than my own children.

This amazes me. I can't imagine ever having a love for someone else's kids to match how i love my own. They are my babies, i birthed them, fed them, I'd cut off my arm for them.

I don't think anyone else's children are lesser as people but I could never love them like my own.

Yep.

OP posts:
Hoplolly · 21/02/2024 07:22

Nail on the head @Futb0l

Futb0l · 21/02/2024 06:29

What strikes me reading the first half of this thread (not read it all) is how many people seem to think that it’s ok for step parents to not treat or value their step children as much as their own children. I can’t imagine seeing my step children as anything less than my own children.

This amazes me. I can't imagine ever having a love for someone else's kids to match how i love my own. They are my babies, i birthed them, fed them, I'd cut off my arm for them.

I don't think anyone else's children are lesser as people but I could never love them like my own.

Futb0l · 21/02/2024 06:26

The great pity here is that a man who didn't earn enough to support one child well, went ahead and fathered some more.

I get it OP, you earn enough to support those kids. But there's no way on earth your DH pays nothing towards your shared family life, and what he is paying makes him less able to support the DC he already had.

Regardless OP, you as the wife aren't responsible for subsidising his ex & child.

I think a surprising number of people are always looking to someone else/anyone else to support them financially, whether its an ex, a spouse, the state.

GlitterBall91 · 21/02/2024 06:19

GlitterBall91 · 21/02/2024 06:17

Wife shouldn’t pay for fathers kids !

this reflects my situation actually- I am a single mum with not a great income and I do struggle.
Ex partner is self employed and actually doesn’t pay anything but that’s a story for another day.
His partner is absolutely minted 🫣😂- they both have brand new cars, holidays to Dubai, the Maldives, house with no mortgage etc etc.. I definitely DON’T expect her to pay for mine and my exs DD!!!

I should add that she’s a lovely woman! And does contribute to treats for my DD when she is there with her dad which is so kind!

but I wouldn’t expect her to pay towards my DDs maintenance

GlitterBall91 · 21/02/2024 06:17

Wife shouldn’t pay for fathers kids !

this reflects my situation actually- I am a single mum with not a great income and I do struggle.
Ex partner is self employed and actually doesn’t pay anything but that’s a story for another day.
His partner is absolutely minted 🫣😂- they both have brand new cars, holidays to Dubai, the Maldives, house with no mortgage etc etc.. I definitely DON’T expect her to pay for mine and my exs DD!!!

Toooldtoworry · 21/02/2024 06:04

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 20/02/2024 22:25

What strikes me reading the first half of this thread (not read it all) is how many people seem to think that it’s ok for step parents to not treat or value their step children as much as their own children. I can’t imagine seeing my step children as anything less than my own children.

Would you give them half your wage at the detriment to your own home to 'equalise' if the RP did not earn the same?

MonkeyHarold · 21/02/2024 02:21

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 20/02/2024 22:25

What strikes me reading the first half of this thread (not read it all) is how many people seem to think that it’s ok for step parents to not treat or value their step children as much as their own children. I can’t imagine seeing my step children as anything less than my own children.

It is absolutely okay to not to treat and value stepchildren the same as your own children. It would be different if your stepchildren lived with you and you were bringing them up with your partner. However, in my situation, my stepchildren children were thirteen and eleven when I met them and they came to stay every other weekend. I did not and do not feel the same about them as I did/do about my children. I value my children above anything and anyone and I think that's completely natural.