Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Payrise and maintenance

341 replies

Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 07:05

Keen to hear people's opinions about this.

Two DC, father is married with more children. Mother is single.

Father is not on a great wage however his wife has received several payrises in the years they've been together and works in a professional career which means as a whole their household is quite well off and can afford quite a lot of luxuries.

Maintenance is paid by the father based on his low wage. Mother is struggling a little as also on a lower wage.

Mother argues that they should pay more as a household instead due to wife's higher pay, obviously not officially through CMS as they don't take new partners into account, but morally. Wife disagrees and says what she earns is nothing to do with the mother and is for her household/children/ stepchildren when there, not at their mums.

Father stuck in the middle a bit.

Random poll options

YABU - wife should subsidise higher maintenance.

YANBU - Mother and father should care for their children on their own respective wages and what wife earns is nothing to do with the mother.

OP posts:
Brotherlove · 19/02/2024 13:19

Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 08:27

The kids have the same lifestyle when they are with us. I don't think we need to ensure their home with mum also matches. That's her responsibility.

I'm in a wierd situation like this.....i'm the RP - higher earner , lazy workshy ex demands money from me to ensure the child get the 'same standard of living in both homes'.

JacksonLambsEatIvy · 19/02/2024 13:18

NotARealWookiie · 19/02/2024 13:15

Morally OP I’m with you but I have a feeling the courts would take your earnings into account as the fathers household income - it might be worth looking into this.

Realistically the dad should perhaps take on extra work to pay more for his child and the mum will find this very difficult to do if she has the majority of the time with them.

The courts have absolutely no interest in the OP’s income.

The DH is remarried. Presumably his divorce had a financial settlement. He’s not a high earner, so maintenance will be via CMS.

The courts are utterly irrelevant to this.

NotARealWookiie · 19/02/2024 13:15

Morally OP I’m with you but I have a feeling the courts would take your earnings into account as the fathers household income - it might be worth looking into this.

Realistically the dad should perhaps take on extra work to pay more for his child and the mum will find this very difficult to do if she has the majority of the time with them.

mitogoshi · 19/02/2024 13:07

As long as he's working full time and not minimising income to avoid maintenance. He should also be contributing to big ticket items so his older children within reason have a decent standard of living

Goldbar · 19/02/2024 13:06

Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 13:02

The other children in the household are mine and DHs. There are no children living here that are not DHs responsibility.

Regardless he has never reduced maintenance payments and as mentioned already pays more than the calculator suggests. Which is right and fine. I'd never encourage him to lessen it. I just don't intend to top it up myself

That seems fair.

But I still don't understand why your DH had more children when apparently he can't afford to provide a decent lifestyle for the ones he already had.

This isn't about you or the ex imo. You're entirely correct - not your circus, not your monkeys.

It just backs up my view that most relationship problems of this type arise because there is a fairly inadequate man at the centre of two families. In this case, one who had more children than he could comfortably afford.

beAsensible1 · 19/02/2024 13:04

Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 07:23

She doesn't exactly, but she does see them going away a lot, buying nice cars, living in a bigger house etc.. and when questioned is told its wife's income/she's recently received payrise.

Think it's probably fairly obvious I'm the wife.

This all happened because we bought new cars, me and DH, and she questioned it and was told it was me and I'd had a payrise recently (why DH felt the need to mention it I don't know). Since then she's been trying to guilt DH into paying more maintenance because "we" can clearly afford it.

The maintenance DH pays now is based on having DC 2 days a week less than she does and is slightly more than the calculator as it is.

I've said to DH, it's not up to me to subsidise her because she's single and doesn't earn as much.

He needs to step up and start maximising his income. He’s should feel very rubbish that there’s such a disparity in his children’s quality of life.

Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 13:02

The other children in the household are mine and DHs. There are no children living here that are not DHs responsibility.

Regardless he has never reduced maintenance payments and as mentioned already pays more than the calculator suggests. Which is right and fine. I'd never encourage him to lessen it. I just don't intend to top it up myself

OP posts:
Goldbar · 19/02/2024 13:00

SuperGreens · 19/02/2024 12:53

The only quarter I would give on this is if the father is reducing his payments for his children due to their being additional children in his household now I would think that was a bit mean. Other than that, its really not the new partners business and certainly not hers or his responsibility.

Especially if he's not actually financially responsible for the new children in the household and his expenses have decreased on moving in.

This would be a really, really low thing to do. OP, I'm assuming your DH at least didn't do this?

Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 12:59

The thing is, aside from giving her money, how do you equal up lifestyles like that? So I can afford to take my family, inc DSC, on holiday but because DHs ex can't then we shouldn't go? Is that about the DC or his ex then?

OP posts:
Goldbar · 19/02/2024 12:59

Really? So if the ex wife moved in a well earning new husband you'd get the ick? Somehow I don't believe that.

If the kids were living in relative poverty while the ex wife had new cars and nice holidays, then yes I would.

Goldbar · 19/02/2024 12:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

The OP described the mother as 'struggling a little' so I am assuming that objectively, on the OP's own account, things are somewhat tough for them.

Of course, if the kids are having five holidays a year, do countless clubs and sports, get £££ pocket money and the ex is kicking off because she can't afford a pony for them, then that's a different story 😂.

Chocolatebuttonns · 19/02/2024 12:56

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Goldbar · 19/02/2024 12:55

Do you think the same of women too?

Absolutely. Both parents are responsible for financially, emotionally and practically supporting their children. It's up to them how they divide these responsibilities.

But when you get one parent funding 70% of the kids' expenses and having them 70% of the time, or any other sort of unfair split, while the other parent pays minimum CMS and has them 30% of the time, then it's clear who's doing the heavy lifting. I'm not saying this is the OP's husband's split, but it sounds like it comes close.

Chocolatebuttonns · 19/02/2024 12:53

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

SuperGreens · 19/02/2024 12:53

The only quarter I would give on this is if the father is reducing his payments for his children due to their being additional children in his household now I would think that was a bit mean. Other than that, its really not the new partners business and certainly not hers or his responsibility.

Goldbar · 19/02/2024 12:52

Gillypie23 · 19/02/2024 12:50

The mother of kids should get a better paid job.

They should both get better paid jobs. And until then try to maximise their income by doing overtime/finding a second job if they can when the kids aren't with them.

Chocolatebuttonns · 19/02/2024 12:51

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 12:50

Start job-hunting for a higher paid job, get a second job

But not her I assume?

OP posts:
Gillypie23 · 19/02/2024 12:50

The mother of kids should get a better paid job.

Goldbar · 19/02/2024 12:44

PinkEasterbunny · 19/02/2024 12:21

Not your problem, but CM is a minimum and I'm afraid I would judge a dad living a significantly better lifestyle than his children for most of the time, especially if they're mostly being cared for by their mum (who therefore can't work extra due to childcare commitments).

@Goldbar so should the second wife minimise her earnings, so that the disparity doesn't exist?

I'm sorry, this is just how I feel. I couldn't respect someone having a good standard of living 'living off' someone else's earnings, conveniently not taken into account by the CMS, while their children struggle. It would completely give me the ick.

This doesn't mean that I in any way think that the new partner is responsible for financing the kids. I agree 100% that it's entirely the parents' responsibility.

But if you choose to have children, you should strive to give them the best start in life that you possibly can. They don't stop becoming entitled to this just because you separate from their other parent. And driving a new car around if your ex is struggling to afford some of the basic things most parents would hope to give their children during childhood (days out, extracurricular activities, for example) - for me, that just leaves a nasty taste. Start job-hunting for a higher paid job, get a second job, do what you need to give your kids a decent childhood. Too much 'out of sight, out of mind' with some NRPs.

Dweetfidilove · 19/02/2024 12:43

Zanatdy · 19/02/2024 12:30

I morally it depends what amount he’s paying (how low) and the difference in lifestyle. Obviously legally not your issue but I guess the DC’s father isn’t going to push himself to earn more whilst someone else is buying cars and earning a lot. Again nothing can be done but I can see her point being a bit upset for her children if they have completely different standards of living and that’s what maintenance is there but when it’s the new parents money not much can be done. I mean it wouldn’t hurt to add £50, when was it last reviewed? Cost of living is a killer and on one salary it is hard. I don’t think the answer is 50-50 as then she loses maintenance but has almost the same costs bar a reduction in food. That’s going to make it harder not better

I think the idea around 50/50 is she will have more time to work, upskill, spend less on food / energy… Ideally that improves her financial situation 🤷🏽‍♀️.

Dweetfidilove · 19/02/2024 12:40

@caringcarer Your exh should be allowed to holiday with his children in your property. Afterall, you ‘stole’ his pension.🤣🤣🤣.

You honestly couldn’t make some of this shit up - the shameless twat 🤦🏾‍♀️.

Zanatdy · 19/02/2024 12:30

I morally it depends what amount he’s paying (how low) and the difference in lifestyle. Obviously legally not your issue but I guess the DC’s father isn’t going to push himself to earn more whilst someone else is buying cars and earning a lot. Again nothing can be done but I can see her point being a bit upset for her children if they have completely different standards of living and that’s what maintenance is there but when it’s the new parents money not much can be done. I mean it wouldn’t hurt to add £50, when was it last reviewed? Cost of living is a killer and on one salary it is hard. I don’t think the answer is 50-50 as then she loses maintenance but has almost the same costs bar a reduction in food. That’s going to make it harder not better

PinkEasterbunny · 19/02/2024 12:21

Not your problem, but CM is a minimum and I'm afraid I would judge a dad living a significantly better lifestyle than his children for most of the time, especially if they're mostly being cared for by their mum (who therefore can't work extra due to childcare commitments).

@Goldbar so should the second wife minimise her earnings, so that the disparity doesn't exist?

Lillo7 · 19/02/2024 12:20

We've offered plenty of times to have DC more. Her response is to ask if he's calling her a bad mum 🙄

He'd have them half the time. I've said before he should make it happen via court then if he wants but he's constantly made to feel guilty about anything that doesn't go his exes way. And tbf the DC are a little older now so that ship has probably sailed anyway as they are practically old enough to decide for themselves.

OP posts: