Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what posh Mums cook for dinner…

837 replies

Primrosecottagelover · 19/02/2024 03:15

I have just seen Pippa Middleton’s bikini photos on the DM. Three different bikinis so far, washboard abs & nothing jiggles as she chases three kids. She could easily pass as a fibreglass mannequin. I’m wondering why it is that the Middleton women and affluent women (even middle class at my child’s school), always seem to be so impossibly slim. I struggle with my weight and I would love to see the groceries, fridge contents, packed lunchboxes and dinner plans of the other half. Obviously I know what healthy eating and cooking is but, the bodies of Mothers these days is next level. Why am I struggling to keep my tummy from flopping out while women in their 40’s pull off wearing linen mini shorts (not in UK) and high waisted jeans.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
SkiSkii · 19/02/2024 08:08

Two separate women I lived with during the course of my life who were as skinny as this both had undiagnosed eating disorders. One was bulimic and the other would starve herself for days, then eat nothing but cakes, crisps, chocolates - non stop cycles of this.

Both needed extensive dental work, and both had really foul tempers and issues with their menstrual cycle.

Incidentally, both from European countries that are known for particularly slim women. Neither smoked.

I believe it can be done healthily, but I have yet to witness it personally in a woman over 40.

My sister maintains a very healthy weight over 40, but doesn’t have a six pack, doesn’t attend a gym. She eats only twice a day and eats hardly any carbs, and only ever snacks on fruits. She doesn’t eat a chocolate or a biscuit for months at a time.

atomicnotsoblonde · 19/02/2024 08:06

JonnyTheDogFacedBoy · 19/02/2024 07:56

Just looked at the photos. You'll probably find she can eat quite substantially with that amount of muscle.

I battled with my weight from teens onward. Was very focused on being as skinny as possible and ate very restrictively but could never maintain any loss, yoyoed for years. The thing that changed everything, and that has given me the best body of my life in my 40s, is building muscle. I now have to make sure I eat enough calories to maintain my weight, or I lose weight very easily. I'm now bmi of 19.5 with 19% body fat. I eat healthy, with a focus on getting enough protein and fibre, most of the time. The difference now is I can go for a night out, or on an all inclusive holiday, or have an indulgent Christmas and not gain weight. My lifestyle before I built muscle meant that any deviation from my restrictive diet would result in instant weight gain. It was so depressing. Honestly - anyone feeling like they have to starve to be slim - work on building lean muscle. Life is so much more enjoyable now.

What is your routine? I need to do exactly this!

Justkeepswimmingswimming · 19/02/2024 08:05

I thought she was rumoured to follow the Louise Parker method. At least before W and C wedding.

EverybodyStoryEyed · 19/02/2024 08:05

MC children tend be whippet thin, I think their portions are very small and loads of sports.

LadyRoughDiamond · 19/02/2024 08:05

Remember, really posh people feed their children early, then eat an adult ‘supper’ later. Those hearty ‘family meals’ only happen occasionally.

muddyford · 19/02/2024 08:01

Most independent schools prioritise sport, so it's a habit formed early. State schools used to, but I don't think they do now. I used to do three afternoons PE a week.

3WildOnes · 19/02/2024 08:01

She most likely exercises and eats a normal healthy diet. I doubt she is depriving herself. She probably can eat 2000 calories a day as she is active.
I am as slim as PM. I eat normal food. I try to limit UPF as much as possible but I don't deprive myself. I don't eat massive portions.

Hobbitfeet32 · 19/02/2024 08:00

I’m early 40s bmi 21.5. I do anywhere between about 4-6 hours of exercise per week. Eat what I want which is mainly a balanced diet but I don’t deliberately restrict anything. Stomach is flat but don’t have abs. Partly genetic but mostly because of the combination of exercise and a healthy diet. Work a very busy stressful job as does DH. I also don’t attach any emotion to food so if I do eat something higher in calories I don’t spend the next week feeling guilty. I’ll enjoy it just continue with my generally healthy diet.

Createausername1970 · 19/02/2024 07:56

Lampslights · 19/02/2024 07:08

Pippa doesn’t starve herself, I do think some folks are just resentful seeing a slim woman. She is clearly muscled and toned, and you don’t achieve that from starving yourself, being anorexic, or eating crumbs, as some folks are making out.

she’s a runner, and serious runners are often slim and built like her, I’m also fairly sure she lifts for strength. I understand she has always been sporty though, and a key part of her life. On top of this she will eat a healthy diet, enough to give her the energy for her exercise and I am going to guess drinks limited alcohol. Like she’s not sitting getting tanked up on a sat night, but will have a couple of glasses of wine on occasion.

And on top of all of this - she is the future queen's sister and she is going to have a lifetime of being photographed, some with permission, some without.

I could do to lose a few pounds, but the incentive isn't always there. But I am bloody sure if I was regularly going to end up in glossy magazines, and know that my looks and physique were going to be the topic of numerous threads on numerous forums, I think that would be the daily incentive to ensure I always looked as good as I could.

JonnyTheDogFacedBoy · 19/02/2024 07:56

Just looked at the photos. You'll probably find she can eat quite substantially with that amount of muscle.

I battled with my weight from teens onward. Was very focused on being as skinny as possible and ate very restrictively but could never maintain any loss, yoyoed for years. The thing that changed everything, and that has given me the best body of my life in my 40s, is building muscle. I now have to make sure I eat enough calories to maintain my weight, or I lose weight very easily. I'm now bmi of 19.5 with 19% body fat. I eat healthy, with a focus on getting enough protein and fibre, most of the time. The difference now is I can go for a night out, or on an all inclusive holiday, or have an indulgent Christmas and not gain weight. My lifestyle before I built muscle meant that any deviation from my restrictive diet would result in instant weight gain. It was so depressing. Honestly - anyone feeling like they have to starve to be slim - work on building lean muscle. Life is so much more enjoyable now.

SpongeBob2022 · 19/02/2024 07:56

PM is an athlete. I believe she has taken part in both triathlons and marathons so it's hardly surprising she has the body that she has. I imagine she does eat healthily but you can't participate in things like that whilst eating nothing. I think she looks great and some of the comments on here are spiteful and unwarranted.

I can't comment on the OP really as I don't know any posh people. But my body shape is slim like hers, just not nearly as toned. For me and anyone else I know similar to me I would say the starting point is the genes we have.

SarahAndGoose · 19/02/2024 07:55

pandp · 19/02/2024 07:29

I'm 74, a slim size 6, weigh around 41kg, exercise daily and try to walk 12 - 14,000 steps daily. I have 2 children, one born when I was 23 and second at 33 . I was an overweight teenager, dieted when I was 21 and have remained slim ever since. I very rarely eat any ultraprocessed food, always cook from scratch using fresh ingredients and include plenty of fruit and veg in my diet. I always use butter, never margarine,. I don't regard myself as being on a diet, I'm not excessive, love a piece of homemade cake or scone, an occasional glass of wine. I guess it's just a way of life now.

How tall you are you? 41kg really is tiny - like Olympic gymnast size.

spriots · 19/02/2024 07:55

The thing that hasn't been said yet which I think is a big factor is that it is a lot easier to maintain a slim figure than to lose weight.

She has always had time to exercise and money to eat well because she has never had a job . I think what happens to many of us is that we go through a difficult patch - e.g. having a child or a stressful patch at work and exercise and healthy eating becomes harder for a bit, gain weight and then it's really hard to shift.

Whereas someone like her just hasn't really experienced that. She has had children of course but she hasn't had the things that go alongside that for most women - limited childcare in the early months, having very little sleep etc - because she will have had nannies, probably including a night nanny.

hopsalong · 19/02/2024 07:55

I think it's likely to be nothing as complicated or extreme as you imagine.

We only know who Pippa is because she's Kate's sister. William, who more or less had his pick of widely body type, chose to get married to someone tall, athletic and thin. (Like his mother, but that's a separate point.)

Pippa probably does a lot of exercise but I doubt she eats only steamed fish and spinach. If she didn't exercise she wouldn't be so muscular but I imagine she would still be thin. She's a thin person.

I'm mid-40s with kids and look worse in a bikini (more cellulite!) but not honestly that different. Yesterday I had a big Sunday lunch (no pudding because I was too full) and sausages and mash for dinner with a mini magnum and some raspberries for pudding. For breakfast I had a bowl of sultana bran and a banana. Pretty standard stuff I think. Before I had kids I was actually more curvy.

Fizbosshoes · 19/02/2024 07:53

4YellowDaffodils · 19/02/2024 07:40

PM clearly does loads of exercise- her shoulder muscles shows that. She looks very strong.

But genetics are a factor. All my family (including the men) are under 5 ft 6 and apple shaped. My mother helpfully calls us hobbits. My father equally helpfully calls us a family of 'fat bastards'. We all seem to have eating disorders as well as there is an awful lot of fat shaming going on in my family. I'm 5 ft 1 and even when I was 8 stone I looked squat. DH is long and lean and the Dcs are long and lean and DH has never dieted in his life - nor has either of his sisters who are equally long and lean (if what they tell me is the case).

I'd love to have a different body shape though- that's for certain.

I agree genetics help as does being tall.
I'm less than 5ft and size 8 but I do not look lean.

Obviously she works out and who knows what she eats

CuttingMeOpenthenHealingMeFine · 19/02/2024 07:50

I am 40 and slim (and not posh). I’m pescatarian , don’t drink alcohol and work out three times a week using You Tube videos.

To be honest most women I know are overweight and it isn’t because they don’t have money, it’s because they down ridiculous amounts of wine and takeaways all through the week. One complains about not being able to lose weight and complains she is just big boned but one look at her instagram shows cakes and milkshakes every day from the local cafe at lunch time, I also love the cakes from this place but once a week is enough, if I had them every day I would be the size of a house. I think a lot of women just lack a bit of common sense and then tell themselves that anyone who is slim lives on salad to make themselves feel better.

JustKillingTime · 19/02/2024 07:49

Anybody of any age or sex, who has washboard abs, is putting the effort into an exercise regime that I am not prepared to do. I’m sure a body like hers does not come easily.

Ultimately, it is what you prioritise. She clearly prioritises a slim, toned and lean body. That is not top of my list. I am slim, but certainly not super toned and I probably eat more processed food than I should.

I am sure she has worked hard for her body. Give me all the nannies, cleaners and chefs that you can, I still won’t have that body as I can’t be bothered to spend an hour in the gym every day or miss out on my crisps.

CarrieMoonbeams · 19/02/2024 07:48

Then she will have a chef which means she has perfectly balanced nutritious meals presented to her. She doesn't have to show much self control. I'd find it easy to be slim if I had the money like she does. @Letsgotitans , It must still require massive self control though, because if I had a chef, I'd be like Henry V111. Only difference is I wouldn't be telling them to make me a goose wrapped in a swan, it'd be a bag of tortilla chips covered in cheese!

And @Threewheeler1 , that's exactly what I thought, my teeth squeaked at the cotton wool story!

TheChosenTwo · 19/02/2024 07:48

Haven’t seen the pics, not going looking for them either but I have a friend who runs ultra marathons, she’s about 5ft tall, in her 50’s and eats a lot. Mostly good stuff but also things like a biscuit or a piece of cake. She just fuels her body effectively. She’s a size 6 (I know this because she went swimming before work but had forgotten to pack any knickers and asked me if I could pick her some up from the supermarket on my way in 😂) and you can’t sustain the level of exercise she does without eating well.
If PM is toned and muscular she’s not surviving on lettuce leaves! Building muscles takes calories!!

OriginalFloorboards · 19/02/2024 07:47

I’m 51 and sugar is my downfall. I have three horses and ride 5 times a week (one is my daughter’s pony so I have two). All kept at home and I’m in and out exercising, moving bales etc. I’m size 10-12 (my thighs) and very toned but it’s due to the looking after / riding horses. My stomach's is creeping up and waist and I know it’s the rubbish I eat on the sofa at night because I’m knackered. I reach for the chocolate. I cook from scratch most nights but can’t afford steamed fish etc. It’s not exactly healthy stuff like lasagna, roast chicken dinners (we don’t have that on the weekend as busy with horses). I’ve definitely got to change this sugar thing at night. No idea what to replace it with to give me the ‘sweetness’. I used to be size 8 in my 30s. I do have stage 4 endometriosis and I need to get my diet in order - healthier. Plus with perimenopause my body is changing. At night I do sit down and I’m so exhausted. Watch TV etc. That’s when I eat rubbish. Even after a meal. It’s like I’ve no will power with the chocolate.

Letsgotitans · 19/02/2024 07:47

Westfacing · 19/02/2024 07:40

I'd find it easy to be slim if I had the money like she does.

It would be 'easier' but not easy - some people just have an issue with eating too much, just as some find it easy to eat healthily.

Look at Oprah Winfrey, who's the world's richest self-made woman (or something like that!) for at least 40 years she's been dieting and trying to control her weight. There were numerous programmes featuring her in her home gym, with the personal chef, etc. but she looks as big as ever.

Much of it down to genes and psychological state as we all know.

Yes I appreciate that but I did mean me specifically.

Pacifybull · 19/02/2024 07:47

There’s nothing particularly unusual about the way she looks. I’m in my late 50s and would look similar, as would many of my friends even older than me. I’ve always been slim and have never been on a diet. I eat quite a bit of chocolate. I do exercise, but not every day, but that’s more for strengthening my bones and joints. We are quite a carb heavy family - a lot of pasta, for example. But we are generally plant-based. I don’t drink any alcohol, for health reasons.

AndThatWasNY · 19/02/2024 07:46

I have a few friends with similar figures that I have been on holiday with.
They eat MUCH less than me (I am a size 12/14). They eat a little bit of shite but most meals are high in protein and veg. Not much ultra processed food. They eat like this all the time. So no dieting. It's just how they eat
We do similar amounts of exercise (3 lots of cardio, 2 lots of weights, walk every day). Over the years my daily little slice of cake, glass of wine, extra slice of toast, biscuit, etc that they don't have add up.

SkiSkii · 19/02/2024 07:46

Moonfishstar · 19/02/2024 07:15

@Lampslights

Yes, as we all want the male gaze of approval.

I didn't say we did! Many women - like you presumably - don't, and that's fine. But equally to say that many women don't care at all about how sexually attractive they look, is obviously wrong.

Btw, it doesn't make you a better woman not to care in any way how physically attractive you appear to others.

I think you will find a lot of women here prefer to dress for other women.

Allfur · 19/02/2024 07:43

And you don't have to be posh

Swipe left for the next trending thread