Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what posh Mums cook for dinner…

837 replies

Primrosecottagelover · 19/02/2024 03:15

I have just seen Pippa Middleton’s bikini photos on the DM. Three different bikinis so far, washboard abs & nothing jiggles as she chases three kids. She could easily pass as a fibreglass mannequin. I’m wondering why it is that the Middleton women and affluent women (even middle class at my child’s school), always seem to be so impossibly slim. I struggle with my weight and I would love to see the groceries, fridge contents, packed lunchboxes and dinner plans of the other half. Obviously I know what healthy eating and cooking is but, the bodies of Mothers these days is next level. Why am I struggling to keep my tummy from flopping out while women in their 40’s pull off wearing linen mini shorts (not in UK) and high waisted jeans.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
runningpram · 19/02/2024 09:34

I’m reasonably slim - although not PMid like. I eat very few processed carbs, run do a bit of yoga and try to do a Caroline Girvan workout once a week. I also cycle and walk a lot.
I don’t have time to do loads of exercise (or as much as I’d like) and my diet is not perfect. Im extremely average looks wise and am a bit of a scruffer. But If I had time, money for a fantastic gym, enough sleep and could afford all organic, plus a stylist I reckon I could easily look like PMid. I think most reasonably slim women, who like to eat healthy and work out could- with only a few months of work and a bit of help.

horseyhorsey17 · 19/02/2024 09:33

Dentistlakes · 19/02/2024 09:26

This.

Pippa’s physique isn’t thin. She has a high muscle mass and low body fat percentage. She is naturally this way, but you don’t maintain it as you get older without work. I would bet she lifts heavy probably 4-5 times per week with some cardio, eats a high protein diet and limits or eliminates HPF and alcohol.

She is wealthy and has time which is a huge advantage, but it’s not impossible to do if you put in a consistent effort. Go to any gym and you’ll find women like her, usually working out at 5am before work. I’m in the gym 6 days a week and work full time. Granted my children are now teenagers, so I don’t have young children to deal with. It’s largely about priorities. Although my physique is now very good, aesthetics is not why I do it. I’m 53 and want to stay healthy and functional as I age. I don’t want to struggle to get out of A chair in my 70’s or become pre diabetic. If I had carried on the way I was (5.5 stone heavier than I am now), I would be heading for a pretty uncomfortable old age.

Hmmmm no she is thin. I've just looked at the pics and she doesn't look to me like someone who lifts heavy 4-5 times a week. She hasn't got enough defined muscle for that. She looks like she's got a naturally slim and athletic build.

I'd say it's more likely she has a private chef, small portions, personal trainer and loads of expensive treatments - and as others have said, the luxury of time and no stress from having to, you know, work. It's easy to be skinny when you're that rich.

Barrenfieldoffucks · 19/02/2024 09:31

PeridotSparkle · 19/02/2024 09:19

Hmm by all accounts there's a reason Kate's had surgery. That relates to not eating.

She had a hemicolectomy due to Crohns.

ChilliPB · 19/02/2024 09:31

Primrosecottagelover · 19/02/2024 08:38

I’m very curious, please don’t take this the wrong way, it’s just a question and not an assumption…. Would you look down on someone that didn’t do that exercise or befriend them ?

@Primrosecottagelover no certainly wouldn’t look down on them. It’s just a choice of lifestyle. We’re active/outdoorsy. Others might be into something completely different and spend their weekends on hobbies, art/culture etc.

But would we be friends? Maybe not - just because we might not have loads in common/might not want to do the same things at the weekends.

This weekend, it was lovely weather so I met a friend for a walk with our dogs on Saturday in the Pentlands (3 hours walk). On Sunday, a group of about ten of us plus kids met at the beach and went swimming/for a walk/coffee and cake. Most of us cycled there as it’s easier to get to by bike than car (4 mile cycle for me each way). I also did a short 30 minute home gym session on Saturday, and took the dog for a short 30 minute run on Sunday morning to tire her out as I didn’t take her to the beach. So I would say I had an active weekend, if you counted calories I’d guess I burnt quite a lot - but probably more through the social weekend plans than the formal exercise of run and gym session. My point is a healthy/active lifestyle can count for more - and for many people is much more enjoyable - than more formal exercise.

I really don’t agree with the tone of a lot of this thread that women who are slim have this miserable lifestyle eating lettuce and doing hours of exercise 😂 It definitely helps that where I live - Edinburgh - we have access to mountains, the sea, lovely countryside etc. We moved here specifically for this.

If I had friends that weren’t into the cycle/walk/swim in the sea it’s not that I’d look down on them at all, but we probably wouldn’t see each other loads as a good chunk of my social life is around being outdoors/being active.

queenofarles · 19/02/2024 09:31

Pippa etc will spend at least a couple of hours a day exercising and will eat next to nothing.

please don’t post stuff like this , you are feeding the notion that the only way is to starve and over work the body.
im 40 too i have someone who cooks our meals and a PT 4 days a week , I also went for a lengthy period of time with just sticking to workout programs on YT and preparing fresh meals myself.

I never over do it, maximum of an hour per session.I Never just eat smoothies for breakfast and steamed fish and Spinach for lunch but I also don’t eat whatever I want all day , there is a middle ground.

crostini · 19/02/2024 09:29

What country are you in? Most Europeans eat higher quality food and do more home cooking than British people.

Missamyp · 19/02/2024 09:29

The main issue is that the average size of people has changed over the years. Previously, most people were of a similar size, but now being slim is considered unusual. The trend has shifted towards accepting and normalizing different body types.
The toned and athletic look of some individuals is due to their athletic involvement. It is important to note that being introduced to exercise has little to do with social class. In my case and DP's, we grew up in working-class families where exercise was considered important.

pontipinemum · 19/02/2024 09:28

I read the article, she does a huge amount of exercise! My BIL is a whippet but eats like a horse, I mostly see him eat the nicer things in life cake/ big meals because I see him eat at parties where he eats a lo. But I am guessing he sticks to healthier stuff at home. But he exercises a LOT, he loves running, doing crazy dark trail things, etc.

Pippa probably eats mainly healthy and enjoys some treats. But the huge amount of exercise will keep her slim

LapinR0se · 19/02/2024 09:27

I am 5’5” and weigh 55kg which is 8 stone 9lb (just did the conversion). I eat and drink what I want.
I did have an eating disorder when I was younger and then a long period where my eating was quite restricted. I basically ate enough to have periods. Then I was 49kg which is 7 stone 10lb. I reckon a lot of famous and very slim women eat as I did then - low carb, no dairy, gluten free, all dressed up as healthy eating.

Dentistlakes · 19/02/2024 09:26

FrustatedAgain · 19/02/2024 09:00

Pippa isn’t skinny, she’s muscular and slim and clearly works for that physique. As others have said before exercise as has always been a feature in the Middletown’s lives. She will eat a diet a very healthy one of non ultra processed foods, but plenty of calories to sustain the exercise she does.

This.

Pippa’s physique isn’t thin. She has a high muscle mass and low body fat percentage. She is naturally this way, but you don’t maintain it as you get older without work. I would bet she lifts heavy probably 4-5 times per week with some cardio, eats a high protein diet and limits or eliminates HPF and alcohol.

She is wealthy and has time which is a huge advantage, but it’s not impossible to do if you put in a consistent effort. Go to any gym and you’ll find women like her, usually working out at 5am before work. I’m in the gym 6 days a week and work full time. Granted my children are now teenagers, so I don’t have young children to deal with. It’s largely about priorities. Although my physique is now very good, aesthetics is not why I do it. I’m 53 and want to stay healthy and functional as I age. I don’t want to struggle to get out of A chair in my 70’s or become pre diabetic. If I had carried on the way I was (5.5 stone heavier than I am now), I would be heading for a pretty uncomfortable old age.

4YellowDaffodils · 19/02/2024 09:25

Well- if anything this thread has made me vow to continue enjoying good homemade meals - to walk as much as I can (I like the pp idea of never driving anywhere under 5 minutes away) - and to cut out alcohol. I'm going to stop worrying about my 2 stone overweight figure and implement those changes only and see where it gets me. I don't have a sweet tooth so never eat puddings but I'm not going to cut out carbs or eat poached fish all day every day.

Re active lifestyles- I was not brought up in this way at all. Our family downtime was sitting reading or watching tv and cooking and eating enormous meals. I swim with the Dcs once a week but again that's all i do with them. I think I'm going to consciously change this- for me and for the DCs.

Backtolife45 · 19/02/2024 09:21

Nots456 · 19/02/2024 05:11

I'm 40 next year and my physique is similar to PM. It hasn't actually changed since I was 16: Size 6 and weight 7.5 stone, flat stomach, toned.

I've never been on a diet and I eat whatever I want. However I have a naturally small-ish appetite, I'm vegetarian and I dislike sugary 'treats', sugary drinks, chocolate bars or anything artificial or highly processed. I do eat good homemade cake now and then, a quality croissant or some plain dark chocolate. I don't drink alcohol, only occasionally. No smoking.

I don't have a car so I walk and cycle everywhere. I don't want to lose weight so I'm focussing on building strength and flexibility through yoga.

I have siblings who are overweight and the biggest difference between us is that they are happy to eat ultra processed foods and I am not. I think this is the secret really.
I eat whatever I want but none of it is ultra processed.

If there's a choice of a fruit or plain yoghurt I always choose plain as it's less likely to have sweeteners and flavourings in it. I won't eat anything that is an artificial colour. I won't eat cereals as most of them have crap in them. I cook plain organic porridge oats and put fruit on top. All my dinners are cooked from scratch. I'll rarely buy anything ready made (only if desperate and then will opt for something with minimal ingredients and processing). I eat quality organic butter but not margarine which is full of rubbish. I buy quality cheese but won't touch the rubbery supermarket stuff. Organic free range eggs. Lots of vegetables. Quality bread that is just wheat, salt and yeast. Etc etc

Sorry, @Nots456 that sounds a horrible way to live.

sawnotseen · 19/02/2024 09:20

And to the pp saying that all men prefer curves- BS - I have only been single for a year in my life, since teenage and that was through choice, recovering following separation from my husband of 21 years. Never been short of male attention! I have the same measurements as Kylie M and am two years younger.

PeridotSparkle · 19/02/2024 09:19

Hmm by all accounts there's a reason Kate's had surgery. That relates to not eating.

Downwarddog2 · 19/02/2024 09:17

Follow Yoanna Hanbury on Instagram, she often does a what I eat in a day.. She's married to the british polo player Charlie Hanbury they have three gorgeous daughters & I follow her page for pure escapism

Barrenfieldoffucks · 19/02/2024 09:17

I’m quite posh, but I’m also quite fat. 😂 I don’t eat too badly funnily enough, but I do have adhd which in me partly manifests itself as zero impulse control or willpower. I can’t get in an exercise routine, and can go days eating really well, then eat 5 packs of crisps on the trot because the crunch or whatever is so satisfying.

I should add that I cook well and all my kids are a lovely healthy size and weight.

OOBetty · 19/02/2024 09:17

I think we all know what’s healthy to eat and that exercise is also important.
Dont we.? I don’t put it down to being posh as I’m not keen on the word, makes me cringe a little like the word terf.

Perhaps a photo of your food cupboard and fridge and a basic rundown of your weekly menu / food and how much exercise you do would be more helpful and maybe others can then see the issue as you’re struggling.

Can you send a picture or list OP

NeverHadHaveHas · 19/02/2024 09:16

Mirabai · 19/02/2024 09:02

Pippa is superich, not just averagely wealthy, and never has to work again. She probably spends a significant about of time every day working out. She certainly seems to have developed rugby player shoulders - I would change her trainer if I were her.

Wow. Why do you think it’s ok to body shame her in that way?

Rivendeluge · 19/02/2024 09:16

I enjoy life and refuse to believe we "should" aspire to remove all the joy from eating!
See, I don't get this. What's joyful about eating? You eat because you need fuel for your body. It's something you do to stay healthy and have energy to live and do whatever activities you want, stop being hungry. It's like washing yourself or learning for a test. Something you have to do to get on with life. Cooking, and deciding what to eat is tedious and a chore. Then you have to clean up. Why is that joyful?

Allfur · 19/02/2024 09:15

Cotton wool dipped in orange juice was not 'a thing'!

SgtJuneAckland · 19/02/2024 09:15

Some will be genetics, my cousin is never more than a size 8 and eats like a horse, will have biscuits with her tea, breakfast will be scrambled egg toast with butter, a bacon sandwich with a Starbucks caramel latte etc, lunch sandwich from the deli chocolate and crisps, dinners she has home cooked food, simple stuff like spag bol, chillis, curry etc but eats huge platefuls and I've got a good appetite. I couldn't eat what she does, eats out or takeaway at least once a week. She's 5'2 has 3 DC and works full time, with each baby she has left hospital in her size 8 jeans. She doesn't do any regular gym type exercise, she will go on bike rides with the kids, walks at the weekend etc so she's not sedentary. If I ate like she did I'd be huge. Her mum is the same. She's now 70 and a size 10 rather than 8 , says she got squishy round the middle!
If I generally eat healthily and go to the gym 3 times a week I can maintain a 10-12 but I've been a size 18. I have also been a 6-8 but people started asking me if I was ill, I'm 5'9+ and have quite broad shoulders so I looked boney. I have to make conscious decisions about food and not just eat what I want.

DelilahBucket · 19/02/2024 09:13

If I had the money I would have a personal chef and zero access to a fridge or snack cupboard 🙈. I imagine the people you are referring to are no different. Plus if I had more time I would be partaking in exercise everyday.

sawnotseen · 19/02/2024 09:13

I am size 6 and weigh 7 stone. I've been the same size all of my adult life apart from when I was pregnant when I went up to 8stone and 8stone 5. Back to my normal size within 8 weeks both times with no effort. Babies were both healthy weights. I eat what I like, lots of meat, poultry, fish, carbs, fruit and veg. Loads of cake and chocolate, desserts, biscuits, ice cream and crisps! My mum is slim. My sister is different and puts on weight easily, she's a size 14. My daughter is size 12. I struggle to put on weight. I got ill in India and lost a stone in two weeks. If I don't eat a lot, every day, I lose weight quickly. I eat porridge with fruit or toast for breakfast. Full English one weekend morning. Lunch is a sandwich/wrap or pasta salad, plus a chocolate bar and crisps. Dinner is always protein carbs and veg. One day might be prawn and crab linguine, next might be sausages mash with veg and onion gravy. Plus dessert, every day. Then I have tea and biscuits through the evening. Or wine and chocolate. My mum says I'm a 'throwback' as her dad's sister was the same as me (she didn't have children so no peers to compare with). Who knows, but I also have muscles from doing very little exercise, daily walking, weekly yoga but that's all. My mum said to me when I was 39 - you need to stop eating so much as you will start gaining weight when you hit your 40s. I didn't.
Maybe the Middleton sisters are the same as me. It's just the way I am.

Sleepysleepasap · 19/02/2024 09:12

JustKillingTime · 19/02/2024 07:49

Anybody of any age or sex, who has washboard abs, is putting the effort into an exercise regime that I am not prepared to do. I’m sure a body like hers does not come easily.

Ultimately, it is what you prioritise. She clearly prioritises a slim, toned and lean body. That is not top of my list. I am slim, but certainly not super toned and I probably eat more processed food than I should.

I am sure she has worked hard for her body. Give me all the nannies, cleaners and chefs that you can, I still won’t have that body as I can’t be bothered to spend an hour in the gym every day or miss out on my crisps.

I could have written this 🤦‍♀️

JonnyTheDogFacedBoy · 19/02/2024 09:10

atomicnotsoblonde · 19/02/2024 08:06

What is your routine? I need to do exactly this!

I started off really slowly. Not a set routine as such, i didnt have any idea or belief that i could achieve what i have, so i went in to it blindly. I always went to the gym but had done cardio only. So I started doing one kettle bells class a week. It was so hard and I ached like a bitch for a whole week the first time, but I stuck with it. My strength gradually... very gradually... improved and I went from not even being able to hold a plank for 10 seconds to 2 minute planks while passing a 8kg kettle bell from side to side. I then added in other weight classes, but would never do more than 2-3 per week tbh. I rarely do cardio, unless I need an endorphin boost. I'll walk on the treadmill on a steep incline (15% incline, 3mph, for 20-30 minutes), 1-2 times a week, I also walk my dog for an hour a day. I occasionally do yoga to have a good stretch.

It is really hard work in the beginning, but once you reach a level where you have good muscle tone, it gets easier. Now I'm maintaining rather than building muscle, I have to do less than when I was fatter and unfitter, if that makes sense? When you're at the start of your "journey", you're having to put in maximum effort and I think this is often why people quit, as they probably think it will always be hard. It's honestly just fun for me now. The hardest part was starting.