Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what posh Mums cook for dinner…

837 replies

Primrosecottagelover · 19/02/2024 03:15

I have just seen Pippa Middleton’s bikini photos on the DM. Three different bikinis so far, washboard abs & nothing jiggles as she chases three kids. She could easily pass as a fibreglass mannequin. I’m wondering why it is that the Middleton women and affluent women (even middle class at my child’s school), always seem to be so impossibly slim. I struggle with my weight and I would love to see the groceries, fridge contents, packed lunchboxes and dinner plans of the other half. Obviously I know what healthy eating and cooking is but, the bodies of Mothers these days is next level. Why am I struggling to keep my tummy from flopping out while women in their 40’s pull off wearing linen mini shorts (not in UK) and high waisted jeans.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Comedycook · 19/02/2024 13:40

AmethystSparkles · 19/02/2024 13:32

I’m a size 8 and aged 51. I have chronic fatigue/migraines/digestive issues but I always walk the dogs and when I’m well I do Ashtanga yoga. I’m in bed a lot of the time though.

I really don’t think women like PM eat as little as you think….no one can survive on fish and veg. I’ve just had cod steamed for two mins in the microwave and microwave brown rice (about 3/4 of the packet) with chilli sauce. I’ve also had half a big tub of coconut yoghurt, a Trek protein bar and 40g of 70 percent chocolate.

The only time my BMI was in the healthy range and top end ...was when I was at university in my late teens. Honestly I really didn't eat much..one meal a day. I was always hungry. It was a struggle.

LetusandLoveit · 19/02/2024 13:40

For most women, to achieve Pippa Middleton's extreme lack of body fat will require unhealthy disordered eating. Her body fat % is unlikely to be in the healthy range. We do require some body fat and this extreme lack of body fat is unusual without severe food restriction along with a lot of exercise.

@pokebowls I am thinking that PM knows one heck of a lot more than you do about nutrition and health. She's recently completed a Masters in Physical Education.

To accuse her of having an eating disorder is just making yourself appear stupid.

blankittyblank · 19/02/2024 13:38

4YellowDaffodils · 19/02/2024 07:40

PM clearly does loads of exercise- her shoulder muscles shows that. She looks very strong.

But genetics are a factor. All my family (including the men) are under 5 ft 6 and apple shaped. My mother helpfully calls us hobbits. My father equally helpfully calls us a family of 'fat bastards'. We all seem to have eating disorders as well as there is an awful lot of fat shaming going on in my family. I'm 5 ft 1 and even when I was 8 stone I looked squat. DH is long and lean and the Dcs are long and lean and DH has never dieted in his life - nor has either of his sisters who are equally long and lean (if what they tell me is the case).

I'd love to have a different body shape though- that's for certain.

Agree - genetics play a huge part. Especially if you have a naturally muscular physique. I was always small but muscular as a kid. These days, if i do any exercsie for just a few weeks, I tone up really fast. Because I naturally have muscle tone and muscle memory. My sons have different body shapes - my youngest is more like me and you can see his muscles. My eldest is more like his Dad, and even though they do the same activities, he has no muscle tone!

Pippa has good muscle tone, quite athletic. She obviously works hard for it, but I bet it's way easier for her to look like that than other people on the same diet and exercise plans.

GingerIsBest · 19/02/2024 13:37

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 19/02/2024 13:29

Pippa Middleton is a runner and has completed ultra marathons. Comparing her body shape to Hollywood actresses is daft- you’d be better off comparing her to female athletes. Jessica Ennis Hill and Paula Radcliffe don’t look much like Halle Berry either.

I couldn't say what her body fat is but she is not excessively skinny. I agree with @ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm - rather compare her to athletes, not actresses.

When DS was overweight in primary school and being teased and we had to work hard to get him on track - through a combination of better food choices and activity - he was stressed for a long time that he was still overweight (and at school he was still being bulled/teased). At one point, I took photos of his body for him, then found some genuinely overweight children of his age online and then I removed the heads and showed him all the pics. I was horrified that he was convinced that HE was the person who was the most overweight.

I think the same is happening in reverse with the Middleton sisters. They're constantly accused of being too thin, borderline bulimic/anorexic etc. But I think if their bodies were just shown without their faces next to a whole lot of other celebrities they'd just be normal within that framework (less so compared to us mere mortals! Grin )

godlikeAI · 19/02/2024 13:37

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 19/02/2024 13:34

@godlikeAI I agree.

Thank you! I’m not saying she can’t look however she wants, of course she should, as should anyone. I just can’t believe hundreds of people would sit around wondering how to look the same - that’s the strange part

spriots · 19/02/2024 13:35

There's some pretty offensive generalisations being made about overweight people in this thread too. I am overweight - I have never eaten a whole packet of biscuits. I don't eat biscuits at all actually or cake or UPFs in general.

LetusandLoveit · 19/02/2024 13:35

godlikeAI · 19/02/2024 13:32

Not insulting or dickish - it’s a genuine question as to whether people have lost sight of what is attractive. Especially when having a physique like that is the result of quite deliberate effort. I’m all for eating right, exercising etc - but killing yourself to look arguably not great? Seems a very peculiar thing to aspire to

What exactly do you think is wrong with her body shape? @godlikeAI

She has a rectangle figure. Straight up and down.
She's slim and fit.

People really have lost sight of what is attractive.
They seem to to think pumped up boobs, enhanced pumped up bums etc are the way to go.

She's a normal size with a muscly body. She isn't showing skin and bone collar bones, or ribs. She's slim with good muscly legs.

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 19/02/2024 13:34

@godlikeAI I agree.

AmethystSparkles · 19/02/2024 13:32

I’m a size 8 and aged 51. I have chronic fatigue/migraines/digestive issues but I always walk the dogs and when I’m well I do Ashtanga yoga. I’m in bed a lot of the time though.

I really don’t think women like PM eat as little as you think….no one can survive on fish and veg. I’ve just had cod steamed for two mins in the microwave and microwave brown rice (about 3/4 of the packet) with chilli sauce. I’ve also had half a big tub of coconut yoghurt, a Trek protein bar and 40g of 70 percent chocolate.

godlikeAI · 19/02/2024 13:32

Brawcolli · 19/02/2024 10:42

Ah don’t be a dick, just because you don’t personally find her body shape attractive doesn’t mean you have to insult her, that’s really childish.

Not insulting or dickish - it’s a genuine question as to whether people have lost sight of what is attractive. Especially when having a physique like that is the result of quite deliberate effort. I’m all for eating right, exercising etc - but killing yourself to look arguably not great? Seems a very peculiar thing to aspire to

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 19/02/2024 13:29

pokebowls · 19/02/2024 12:28

For most women, to achieve Pippa Middleton's extreme lack of body fat will require unhealthy disordered eating. Her body fat % is unlikely to be in the healthy range. We do require some body fat and this extreme lack of body fat is unusual without severe food restriction along with a lot of exercise.

Images of healthy levels of body fat on fit women with muscle and core strength compared to PM

Pippa Middleton is a runner and has completed ultra marathons. Comparing her body shape to Hollywood actresses is daft- you’d be better off comparing her to female athletes. Jessica Ennis Hill and Paula Radcliffe don’t look much like Halle Berry either.

Missamyp · 19/02/2024 13:24

It is currently reported that 7 out of 10 people are overweight or obese. This is a significant increase from the 1 in 10 people who were overweight or obese in the 60s and 70s. Having no money does not necessarily play a role in weight gain. People may consume a full pack of chocolate biscuits, or bags of crisps or constantly nibble on dense UPFs, these can be expensive.

Interestingly, when compared to the supermarket snack equivalents, homemade treats like Grandma's flapjacks and buns did not have the same effect on weight gain. It is worth noting that 40-50 years ago, being slim was considered the societal norm.

Lifeomars · 19/02/2024 13:22

Time and money, no sifting through the yellow stickered goods in the reduced section, no freezer diving at the end of month trying to cobble a meal out of various odd unrecognisable things that you forgot to label. I have always menu planned but this was due to being skint rather than in pursuit of a slender frame and my weight has been up and down over the years as I so many other things to be busy with like earning enough to pay the bills

Perkatory · 19/02/2024 13:20

The posher people I know who are slim all eat the Michael Pollan way: eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants. Everything is high quality, so they eat chocolate but it's premium and/or organic with a high cocoa percentage. They drink wine, and maybe the occasional Gin and tonic, but no other alcohol and no soft drinks. Drinks are water, and green tea or black coffee (or maybe with a dash of plant milk). They don't eat UHPFs as a rule. 50% of every meal or more is green in colour. Carbs are the wholegrain variety. Down time is spent exercising or socialising (or both), but never watching Tv.

boymamaof2 · 19/02/2024 13:18

@Comedycook it just gives you some reserve. As @Coatsoff42 says if you can't eat for a while and are on nutritional feed (that gives most people very loose stools!) it helps. Get knocked by one serious infection, which is very common, and you've got literally nothing to fall back on. Of course these are all sweeping generalisations and all are different but of all the patients I've treated who have very slim chances of survival, it's only ever been the slightly or quite overweight ones who make it in experience. This is obviously an ITU standpoint, I'm sure my cardiac colleagues will have a different experience but it's always nice to have some balance

SumthingAndNuthing · 19/02/2024 13:15

Ramalangadingdong · 19/02/2024 13:12

I wish I hadn't read this thread. It should have a trigger warning for people with Eating disorders. I wasn't expecting it to be about body image and pining after the bodies of people like KM and PM.

I think a trigger warning would be OTT, you could have stopped reading at any point.

Ramalangadingdong · 19/02/2024 13:12

I wish I hadn't read this thread. It should have a trigger warning for people with Eating disorders. I wasn't expecting it to be about body image and pining after the bodies of people like KM and PM.

Rivendeluge · 19/02/2024 13:10

@Naillig222 in my house, pudding is hot and dessert is cold. Or something posh. Or served in a restaurant.

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 19/02/2024 13:10

dandeliondandy · 19/02/2024 13:02

Yes, wasn't she living on barely more than prawns and a dish of peas with balsamic vinegar at one point?

i know she had to change her diet recently as her her mercury levels were high due to the amount of fish she ate.

kidyounot2 · 19/02/2024 13:09

@Naillig222 Yes, pudding usually used to describe a dessert...

Naillig222 · 19/02/2024 13:08

Slightly off topic but when you all talk about pudding.. Is that the word you use for dessert? Or do you eat a rice pudding after dinner?

JustJessi · 19/02/2024 13:08

Nots456 · 19/02/2024 05:11

I'm 40 next year and my physique is similar to PM. It hasn't actually changed since I was 16: Size 6 and weight 7.5 stone, flat stomach, toned.

I've never been on a diet and I eat whatever I want. However I have a naturally small-ish appetite, I'm vegetarian and I dislike sugary 'treats', sugary drinks, chocolate bars or anything artificial or highly processed. I do eat good homemade cake now and then, a quality croissant or some plain dark chocolate. I don't drink alcohol, only occasionally. No smoking.

I don't have a car so I walk and cycle everywhere. I don't want to lose weight so I'm focussing on building strength and flexibility through yoga.

I have siblings who are overweight and the biggest difference between us is that they are happy to eat ultra processed foods and I am not. I think this is the secret really.
I eat whatever I want but none of it is ultra processed.

If there's a choice of a fruit or plain yoghurt I always choose plain as it's less likely to have sweeteners and flavourings in it. I won't eat anything that is an artificial colour. I won't eat cereals as most of them have crap in them. I cook plain organic porridge oats and put fruit on top. All my dinners are cooked from scratch. I'll rarely buy anything ready made (only if desperate and then will opt for something with minimal ingredients and processing). I eat quality organic butter but not margarine which is full of rubbish. I buy quality cheese but won't touch the rubbery supermarket stuff. Organic free range eggs. Lots of vegetables. Quality bread that is just wheat, salt and yeast. Etc etc

I completely agree with all of this. It’s not carbs, oil, and healthy fats that cause overweightness - Italy, France and Luxembourg have the lowest rates of obesity in the world and all love bread and cheese! We should eat healthy, wholesome, nutritious food with very occasional high quality treats, and we will look great for it. Exercise/activity helps!

But also, I think the physiques of PM and KM look as though they have a very low body fat percentage. KM is all over the pro-ana websites as a role model! Women are supposed to have a bit more fat on them than men, so it may not be all that healthy to be noticeably thin with defined abs.

mitogoshi · 19/02/2024 13:04

One of my DD's is that shape and it's due to chronic under eating... I try to get her to eat well but she basically eats too few calories end of, no tricks. My dd doesn't exercise or steam food, she literally eats like a fly. Her sister spends 90 mins plus a day exercising,sports at a high level, non sedentary job yet is a size 12 because she eats healthily but normal portions and drinks (too much). Me? I'm overweight and know exactly why. Our income and background puts us in the semi posh category but we aren't, we like pints down the pub Smile

dandeliondandy · 19/02/2024 13:02

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 19/02/2024 12:59

Look at Victoria Beckham’s daily menu and you’ll get the idea.

Yes, wasn't she living on barely more than prawns and a dish of peas with balsamic vinegar at one point?

EvelynBeatrice · 19/02/2024 13:02

This is all so odd. How many overweight athletes do you see? These ladies are not in the Olympics but they are athletes. There's nothing odd about their body type at all. Gyms are full of slim people!

Swipe left for the next trending thread