Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what posh Mums cook for dinner…

837 replies

Primrosecottagelover · 19/02/2024 03:15

I have just seen Pippa Middleton’s bikini photos on the DM. Three different bikinis so far, washboard abs & nothing jiggles as she chases three kids. She could easily pass as a fibreglass mannequin. I’m wondering why it is that the Middleton women and affluent women (even middle class at my child’s school), always seem to be so impossibly slim. I struggle with my weight and I would love to see the groceries, fridge contents, packed lunchboxes and dinner plans of the other half. Obviously I know what healthy eating and cooking is but, the bodies of Mothers these days is next level. Why am I struggling to keep my tummy from flopping out while women in their 40’s pull off wearing linen mini shorts (not in UK) and high waisted jeans.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Comedycook · 19/02/2024 14:42

Pippa’s figure is clearly a very athletic figure and no doubt she does have a home gym/personal trainer etc. But some of the comments on this thread are suggesting its impossible to be slim and eat normally - its really not with an active lifestyle and not eating complete rubbish

Of course being slim in not impossible...but there's a range of sizes that can be regarded as slim. To achieve PM levels of slim is clearly hard work. That's not achieved by just a healthy diet and occasional gym session. Like pps said, she's an athlete really.

PoliteTurtle · 19/02/2024 14:33

I have always been in the slimmer side, and I’m certainly not posh and I definitely don’t intentionally exercise. Each time I had my kids I’d snap back really easily (I realise this sounds like a humble brag but I actually wish I could put on weight as I lack massively in the boob region) … it could just be their genetics?

Isitautumnyet23 · 19/02/2024 14:31

boymamaof2 · 19/02/2024 12:04

As an ITU nurse, in my experience this is accurate. In general, the more overweight ones survive than the ultra skinny. One of our consultants is a bit of an extreme athlete (you're taking marathons and cross country cycles) and very skinny, and has commented that his mortality would be higher than a number of our overweight patients. Reassuring for us nurses who are straight to the coffee room for caffeine and biscuits 😂

If you are a nurse on your feet all day, there is no issue with a few coffees and a couple of biscuits to get you through your shift. I imagine you will be getting at least the recommended amount of steps in per day, if not alot more.

The problem is when an office worker drives their kids to school, drives to works, sits at a desk all day, eats a shop bought (high calorie) lunch and drives home. Modern life isn’t ideal for keeping active so its up to us to make sure we do keep as active as possible when we can (weekends, walking if possible whenever time allows, a walk in a lunch hour etc, an evening exercise class if you can fit it in).

Pippa’s figure is clearly a very athletic figure and no doubt she does have a home gym/personal trainer etc. But some of the comments on this thread are suggesting its impossible to be slim and eat normally - its really not with an active lifestyle and not eating complete rubbish.

Brawcolli · 19/02/2024 14:30

godlikeAI · 19/02/2024 13:32

Not insulting or dickish - it’s a genuine question as to whether people have lost sight of what is attractive. Especially when having a physique like that is the result of quite deliberate effort. I’m all for eating right, exercising etc - but killing yourself to look arguably not great? Seems a very peculiar thing to aspire to

‘She looks like a boobless, bumless little weight lifting man.’

There is nothing about this sentence that isn’t insulting or dickish.

Different people find different body types attractive. Again, just because you don’t find this particular body type attractive doesn’t mean it’s ’bad.’ Also, just because she’s toned and slim doesn’t mean she’s killing herself.

LastRites · 19/02/2024 14:25

I don’t think anyone slim eats ‘what they want’ if I’m honest. I mean I’d love to eat Domino’s stuffed crust every night and drink half a bottle of wine followed by chocolate, but I know I’d feel terrible for it, so my version of eating what I want includes all those things but moderately; I’ll have a takeaway but not every week; I’ll eat biscuits with my tea but only two and if I want cake, I’ll save calories to accommodate it. My husband’s birthday is coming up and we’ll go for brunch and to the pub and get fish & chips on the way home, but this is by no means a normal day and we’ll play tennis in between and go for a long walk.

Ultimately for me eating all the things I’m tempted by would lead to poor mental health as I’d feel guilty constantly. I really like healthy food and the added bonus is it is guilt free, and means I can enjoy treats occasionally without feeling bad about it.

I’m also not a lover of sweets and puddings really. My downfall would be beer, wine, pizza & cheese!

queenofarles · 19/02/2024 14:19

Having no money does not necessarily play a role in weight gain. People may consume a full pack of chocolate biscuits, or bags of crisps or constantly nibble on dense UPFs, these can be expensive.
I think it does contribute to a certain extent,
UPFs are always cheap, but good sourdough or bakery seeded country bread costs more than Value white toast for example.

but on the other hand , for almost two decade we were conditioned to believe that
eating three whole fruits throughout the day is bad but taking a "smoothie" made with 1cup blueberries , 1 cup raspberries and half a cup pineapples and an apple all at once is good.

the need for Protein bars and proteins labeled everything when in reality , it’s easily <and cheaper> achievable to get good amount of protein from things like cheese , eggs etc.

skinnycrumpet · 19/02/2024 14:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Moonwatcher1234 · 19/02/2024 14:17

Nots456 · 19/02/2024 05:11

I'm 40 next year and my physique is similar to PM. It hasn't actually changed since I was 16: Size 6 and weight 7.5 stone, flat stomach, toned.

I've never been on a diet and I eat whatever I want. However I have a naturally small-ish appetite, I'm vegetarian and I dislike sugary 'treats', sugary drinks, chocolate bars or anything artificial or highly processed. I do eat good homemade cake now and then, a quality croissant or some plain dark chocolate. I don't drink alcohol, only occasionally. No smoking.

I don't have a car so I walk and cycle everywhere. I don't want to lose weight so I'm focussing on building strength and flexibility through yoga.

I have siblings who are overweight and the biggest difference between us is that they are happy to eat ultra processed foods and I am not. I think this is the secret really.
I eat whatever I want but none of it is ultra processed.

If there's a choice of a fruit or plain yoghurt I always choose plain as it's less likely to have sweeteners and flavourings in it. I won't eat anything that is an artificial colour. I won't eat cereals as most of them have crap in them. I cook plain organic porridge oats and put fruit on top. All my dinners are cooked from scratch. I'll rarely buy anything ready made (only if desperate and then will opt for something with minimal ingredients and processing). I eat quality organic butter but not margarine which is full of rubbish. I buy quality cheese but won't touch the rubbery supermarket stuff. Organic free range eggs. Lots of vegetables. Quality bread that is just wheat, salt and yeast. Etc etc

I suspect our definition of eating whatever you want would differ hugely! Your diet sounds very healthy but isn’t really the epitome of a real, I eat whatever i want and still manage to remain slim diet. Wish I had your self discipline though

Comedycook · 19/02/2024 14:17

skinnycrumpet · 19/02/2024 14:15

Did you read her previous post? No one who’s into working out would say that about another woman’s athletic body. Also why would I be bothered about being called rude? Your opinion about anything is irrelevant to me!

Yes I did read it.

Are you insinuating that anyone who is not shaped like PM is out of shape?

SoTiredNeedHoliday · 19/02/2024 14:17

Newchapterbeckons · 19/02/2024 06:30

Being openly anorexic is acceptable in many circles.

that's ridiculous and a far cry from what anyone would ever want for their child to think.

Have you ever met someone with Anorexia? It's not just looking thin..... It's a whole lot worse than that

I think the comment is insensitive and just plain wrong.

skinnycrumpet · 19/02/2024 14:15

Comedycook · 19/02/2024 14:10

You're not the thread police.. I'll comment on what I want.

But I see you can't answer my question.

Imagine calling someone out of shape...that's rude enough....then imagine calling someone out of shape when you can't even see them?!

Issues

Did you read her previous post? No one who’s into working out would say that about another woman’s athletic body. Also why would I be bothered about being called rude? Your opinion about anything is irrelevant to me!

TeaPotPetPig · 19/02/2024 14:13

Getting photographed a lot, standing next to skinny socialites and celebrities would be enough to spur me on to binning the bourbons.

Comedycook · 19/02/2024 14:10

skinnycrumpet · 19/02/2024 14:06

I wasn’t talking to you 🤗

You're not the thread police.. I'll comment on what I want.

But I see you can't answer my question.

Imagine calling someone out of shape...that's rude enough....then imagine calling someone out of shape when you can't even see them?!

Issues

skinnycrumpet · 19/02/2024 14:06

Comedycook · 19/02/2024 13:59

So rude and unnecessary.

How does the pp you quoted "sound" out of shape?

I wasn’t talking to you 🤗

NeedToChangeName · 19/02/2024 14:06

wibdib · 19/02/2024 11:43

I used to be super skinny with no effort. Then I met DH and we went from spending a little time together to a lot, and I ended up doing most of the cooking as he wasn’t very good at it (he would do all the washing up which was great for me as I’d much prefer to cook than to do the washing up - there was no dishwasher!).
However my dad died unexpectedly after a few years and I realised I had nothing smart that fitted to go to his funeral - and my weight has crept up and up and up ever since :(
I also realised that I used to make whatever I fancied to eat - wasn’t ever big into potatoes but would occasionally buy a bag of baby anew Jersey Royals as a treat. And I’d often do a big stir fry out chicken with a nice creamy sauce. And some veg. But turns out that although dh (as he now is) says he eats everything, which he does, he also loves potatoes (especially roast or chips) and more traditional meals of meat and veg and potatoes. And me being young and in love tried to make things he liked as I was a good cook, even thought they weren’t the sort of things I’d usually make for me, and he wasn’t keen on my random ‘see what I fancy from the supermarket’ approach to cooking, instead wanting to be organised with a ‘proper’ meal, so over the years I stopped making ‘my’ meals and made many more of ‘his’ type of meals- and my weight had ballooned as a consequence.
And then the dc came along and it turned out they weren’t so into eating the ‘odd’ stuff I liked and dh didn’t, so I’ve just made more and more of the ‘normal’ —bland— stuff…

@wibdib similar in my family

I still cook my choice of food, but in smaller containers and freeze it

I usually eat with DP and DS, but sometimes, they have their food and I have mine

Comedycook · 19/02/2024 13:59

skinnycrumpet · 19/02/2024 13:57

You sound out of shape

So rude and unnecessary.

How does the pp you quoted "sound" out of shape?

skinnycrumpet · 19/02/2024 13:57

godlikeAI · 19/02/2024 13:32

Not insulting or dickish - it’s a genuine question as to whether people have lost sight of what is attractive. Especially when having a physique like that is the result of quite deliberate effort. I’m all for eating right, exercising etc - but killing yourself to look arguably not great? Seems a very peculiar thing to aspire to

You sound out of shape

Strokethefurrywall · 19/02/2024 13:55

LetusandLoveit · 19/02/2024 13:40

For most women, to achieve Pippa Middleton's extreme lack of body fat will require unhealthy disordered eating. Her body fat % is unlikely to be in the healthy range. We do require some body fat and this extreme lack of body fat is unusual without severe food restriction along with a lot of exercise.

@pokebowls I am thinking that PM knows one heck of a lot more than you do about nutrition and health. She's recently completed a Masters in Physical Education.

To accuse her of having an eating disorder is just making yourself appear stupid.

This. She's an athlete, and clearly eats to support her training.
It isn't possible to look like this and run ultramarathons if you're starving yourself 🙄

I know a number of women who look like this, all eat a huge amount of the right food and train regularly.

Charlize43 · 19/02/2024 13:52

Pippa will have only eaten an almond and three cress in the last two weeks, while you, my lovely, will have indulged in a whole feast of culinary treats...

Now, who's the lucky one?

Also you don't have to deal with people clamouring to get behind you to see your arse and then passing judgement on it...

You are blessed!

Catsfrontbum · 19/02/2024 13:51

Pippa has a very athletic body which looks like she takes her food and exercise very seriously. Her neck and shoulders are well defined- clearly she lifts.

I exercise 3/4 times a week. Weightlifting and circuits mainly. I eat well, watch what I eat, not too much UPF.

I look nothing like PM, I am size 8/10 and weight about 57kg, but looking like that is a very specific high protein diet counting all the macros. Who has the time?!

shearwater2 · 19/02/2024 13:51

PM looks amazing in the most recent bikini photos, like a really fit athlete.

Applesonthelawn · 19/02/2024 13:45

I've just googled her and think she looks about as slim and defined as me although I have a different shape. I have a BMI of 22 and I keep it deliberately there because I am over 60 - lower is not really recommended if you are my age. I doubt hers is any lower than mine, so she is really not dangerously skinny, she is fine and healthy and is probably just disciplined.

iwafs · 19/02/2024 13:43

I’d love to look like pippa or kate
sadly I love my food more!

I expect the majority of their diet is veg

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 19/02/2024 13:43

godlikeAI · 19/02/2024 13:32

Not insulting or dickish - it’s a genuine question as to whether people have lost sight of what is attractive. Especially when having a physique like that is the result of quite deliberate effort. I’m all for eating right, exercising etc - but killing yourself to look arguably not great? Seems a very peculiar thing to aspire to

God this is depressing. She looks fit and strong to me. Perhaps she exercises and eats well because she wants to live a long and healthy life?

Cheesehound · 19/02/2024 13:42

I feel for women in the public eye. It must be exhausting being hyper focused on your appearance - or maybe PM isn’t and is just blessed with good fortune in the figure department (and a personal chef, home gym, PT, and loads of spare time to exercise).

@Nots456 I eat very much like you but sadly my downfall is always treats!

Swipe left for the next trending thread