Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that car insurance has gotten to be a scam

185 replies

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 20:42

Tell me in what world is it reasonable that I’ve just paid £4500 for my (very sensible) DD’s first year of insurance, whilst DM’s 80 year old best friend is still tootling around with severe eyesight issues and dementia, having a near miss on a daily basis yet paying next to nothing insurance wise! Absolutely scandalous that the government are sitting back and allowing the horrendous price gouging currently going on with car insurance in the UK.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Ginandjuice57884 · 18/02/2024 22:37

They should just use their parents' car for the first year. After that the premium will go down.

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 22:36

VeniVidiWeeWee · 18/02/2024 22:33

Then why bother starting a misinformed thread about insurance costs when you choose not to mitigate that cost?

Because it’s a ridiculous price for all young people, not just DD! I don’t know a single one of her friends who would be able to afford and insure a car (no matter how much of a run around it is) with the way things are at the minute, parents helping out are the only reason that they are able to but not everyone is this fortunate

OP posts:
EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 18/02/2024 22:35

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 22:21

DD wanted a Mini and we are fortunate enough to be able to afford it. The same can’t be said for every teenager

You purchased your daughter a fancy car you’ve struggled to afford the insurance premiums on. If you’d checked out the insurance groups first you could have purchased a car with cheaper insurance and you’d never have needed to have started this thread.

Densol57 · 18/02/2024 22:34

Car insurance for all, not just young people is an absolute disgusting disgrace! I agree with you OP - its a total scam.

I drive a new Range Rover. Im 58, have 25+ years no claims, no convictions, passed at 17 and without a black box the cheapest was £1,700 !!

So I drive around like Miss Daisy with a black box fitted for £562 pa. I drive a few cars so thats for 4,000 miles a year.

Total joke 🤣

VeniVidiWeeWee · 18/02/2024 22:33

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 22:21

DD wanted a Mini and we are fortunate enough to be able to afford it. The same can’t be said for every teenager

Then why bother starting a misinformed thread about insurance costs when you choose not to mitigate that cost?

FrangipaniBlue · 18/02/2024 22:25

DS is 16 but I've just done a quote online with his DoB as 17 to get a rough idea how much it would cos to add him onto my mine (1.6 diesel caddy van so nothing sporty).

Put my premium up by £3,000.

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 22:21

VeniVidiWeeWee · 18/02/2024 22:13

A very quick Google shows most minis as being in insurance group 11 or 12.

Why not get a car in a much lower group?

DD wanted a Mini and we are fortunate enough to be able to afford it. The same can’t be said for every teenager

OP posts:
GasPanic · 18/02/2024 22:15

Well the premium has to reflect the risk.

If insurance companies were overcharging (over estimating the risk) they would make enormous profits. If they were undercharging they would go bust.

Since neither is actually happening that indicates that they have the risk about right.

Maybe there is some argument that they are estimating the risk correctly, but apportioning it inappropriately across their portfolios. If that were the case you would hope that the market would intervene to correct that (one insurer would be able to offer substantially lower premiums by apportioning risk correctly and only targeting that particular market).

I think there are also a number of technical reasons why insurance is going up, for example car repair prices becoming hugely expensive and cars that have been in accidents more likely to be written off completely rather than be considered repairable.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 18/02/2024 22:13

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 22:02

‘It isn’t compulsory to own a car so if you/they can’t afford the insurance premiums then don’t buy one.’ is an incredibly short sighted and tone deaf statement. We live in a country with awful public transport, if DD didn’t have a car she wouldn’t be able to work to help fund her studies or get to her NHS placement, without which she wouldn’t be able to graduate and become a HCP. She’s far from the only one in this situation and to be frank I don’t know what she would do if I couldn’t afford to help her out.

A very quick Google shows most minis as being in insurance group 11 or 12.

Why not get a car in a much lower group?

jm9138 · 18/02/2024 22:08

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 21:51

But statistically speaking it is true? That’s not discrimination, that’s fact

The statistics are also true that ethnicity, disability and perhaps even sexuality might make you more likely to have an accident. Should we have different premiums for these characteristics as well? Overall cancer risk is higher in white people than other ethnicities, should critical illness premiums be higher for white people?

Interestingly there is a study that shows women and gay men are the worse drivers. I think it is better if we just use time driving, vehicle, location, points on licence and no claims bonus to determine premiums because I don’t think we end up in a good place if we go down a road looking at things people can do nothing about.

https://www.4autoinsurancequote.com/gay-men-are-bad-drivers-and-therefore-pay-more-for-auto-insurance/

Do gay men pay more for auto insurance? | 4AutoInsuranceQuote.com

According to a number of studies, gay males and females score poorly when it comes to driving safety. The brains of these two groups seem to be wired similarly in some aspects as both groups score poorly on navigation tests and other tasks that require...

https://www.4autoinsurancequote.com/gay-men-are-bad-drivers-and-therefore-pay-more-for-auto-insurance/

Samlewis96 · 18/02/2024 22:06

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 21:13

Ok - if you can insure a 19 year old newly qualified driver for £1400 in the year 2024 then be my guest. It’s the exact same issue among all of DD’s peers.

My son is 19. His was £1052 for the year on a Peugeot 207

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 22:02

GetWhatYouWant · 18/02/2024 21:55

Exactly this. There are some seriously stupid people on this thread who appear to have no idea how car insurance works. It's been extremely well-publicised recently in newspapers etc that insurance premiums have increased significantly across the board and why that is.
Of course young drivers' insurance is going to cost a fortune. Statically they are at the greatest risk of having an accident and making a claim therefore their premiums will be high. They also haven't been driving so haven't built up any no claims discount.
It isn't compulsory to own a car so if you/they can't afford the insurance premiums then don't buy one.

‘It isn’t compulsory to own a car so if you/they can’t afford the insurance premiums then don’t buy one.’ is an incredibly short sighted and tone deaf statement. We live in a country with awful public transport, if DD didn’t have a car she wouldn’t be able to work to help fund her studies or get to her NHS placement, without which she wouldn’t be able to graduate and become a HCP. She’s far from the only one in this situation and to be frank I don’t know what she would do if I couldn’t afford to help her out.

OP posts:
Taylormiffed · 18/02/2024 22:00

The mini might be the problem here. She needs something dull and sensible.

GetWhatYouWant · 18/02/2024 21:55

ComtesseDeSpair · 18/02/2024 21:15

Car insurance is a loss leader for most providers: on average it costs insurers £1.10 in claims and operating costs for every £1 received in premiums. It really isn’t a “scam”, you’re just paying what it costs to provide cover: parts and labour cost more than they did even a couple of years ago; modern cars are more expensive to repair, even a relatively minor accident can result in a significant repair bill or write off; insurance fraud cases and e.g. whiplash claims have skyrocketed in recent years.

Exactly this. There are some seriously stupid people on this thread who appear to have no idea how car insurance works. It's been extremely well-publicised recently in newspapers etc that insurance premiums have increased significantly across the board and why that is.
Of course young drivers' insurance is going to cost a fortune. Statically they are at the greatest risk of having an accident and making a claim therefore their premiums will be high. They also haven't been driving so haven't built up any no claims discount.
It isn't compulsory to own a car so if you/they can't afford the insurance premiums then don't buy one.

43ontherocksporfavor · 18/02/2024 21:53

@Silverbirchtwo yeah we tried that but Dd wanted a certain car. It’s fine as she’s paying the insurance and most of the car- we helped out a bit.

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 21:51

jm9138 · 18/02/2024 21:48

As a society we decided to discriminate against individuals because of a group characteristic is not fair some time ago.

But statistically speaking it is true? That’s not discrimination, that’s fact

OP posts:
Silverbirchtwo · 18/02/2024 21:51

Shop around and make sure the car they are trying to insure is a sensible one (might not be obvious but you can check insurance bands), go for one that monitors their driving with a black box. Put a parent on as a named driver, counter intuitive but apparently reduces the price.

There was a thread recently where changing the car brought it down by at least 50%.

BobnLen · 18/02/2024 21:50

£700 a year isn't next to nothing, I pay around £200.

Dixiechickonhols · 18/02/2024 21:49

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 21:34

Thanks for this - all really helpful, will do!!

It was earlier this year I was really impressed with police response. I filled form in one evening, policeman called me next day and said he’d visit and suggest a voluntary surrender to the elderly man (he’d cut in front of a bus, driven on wrong side of road, hit my mum (pedestrian) and seemed confused - there were witnesses. He went to see him immediately and man failed basic read a plate sight test so it moved to licence revoked. It was all done and dusted in a couple of days. My mum was badly bruised but otherwise ok and I was glad he was off the road.

43ontherocksporfavor · 18/02/2024 21:49

Also occupation affects premium. When Dd was a barmaid/ studying it was £200 Pa higher than in her current finance role.

jm9138 · 18/02/2024 21:48

Ponoka7 · 18/02/2024 21:00

They are not allowed to discount based on sex. Your DD is paying the price for the shithead under 25 male drivers.

As a society we decided to discriminate against individuals because of a group characteristic is not fair some time ago.

Yogatoga1 · 18/02/2024 21:48

BobnLen · 18/02/2024 21:40

Exactly how much is this next to nothing that the 80yr old pays or are you just guessing

i’d like to know too.

i’ve just reinsured my 19 year old for their 2nd year of driving, cost £1000 as the main driver.

yes it’s a lot, but I wasn’t seeing the huge sums quoted here. You have to play around with additional drivers etc to get the best deal. Our was with both me and dh as named drivers.

Missingmyusername · 18/02/2024 21:47

Yup. My uncle has dementia, still driving. My aunt asking medical staff if it’s ok and they said yes, as long as you are with him (she can’t drive).

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 21:47

BobnLen · 18/02/2024 21:40

Exactly how much is this next to nothing that the 80yr old pays or are you just guessing

According to DM £700/year. I’m going to take a wild guess and say that’s with no medical conditions declared (funnily enough)

OP posts:
Laurama91 · 18/02/2024 21:47

It doesn't surprise me. I passed 13 years ago and I'm sure I paid £1180 on a litre r reg fiesta. My insurance went up by £50 this year. We moved to the next village but changed from parking on road to drive which you think would be cheaper

Swipe left for the next trending thread