Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that car insurance has gotten to be a scam

185 replies

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 20:42

Tell me in what world is it reasonable that I’ve just paid £4500 for my (very sensible) DD’s first year of insurance, whilst DM’s 80 year old best friend is still tootling around with severe eyesight issues and dementia, having a near miss on a daily basis yet paying next to nothing insurance wise! Absolutely scandalous that the government are sitting back and allowing the horrendous price gouging currently going on with car insurance in the UK.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
GasPanic · 18/02/2024 23:06

GetWhatYouWant · 18/02/2024 22:56

I think many posters would really benefit from reading up on how insurance premiums are calculated, the lack of understanding on here is quite astounding.

Don't they all get together somewhere in some big room with massive leather chairs ?

Then they say "we're gonna soak the young uns this year" and rub their hands together like Mr. Burns before throwing the dice and x1000 to see how much they add to the premiums ?

I know someone who works in that business and they say there's a load of computers and stuff, maths and statistics and complicated analysis of risk, but I reckon it's a load of old rot because my insurance went up by £100 this year.

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 23:06

ImRen · 18/02/2024 23:01

It's statistics.

The 80 might have poorer eyesight and reaction times but might be statistically less likely to have an accident. She might only drive in day light, only drive short distance, only drive in areas she knows well and she might well be aware that she needs to drive cautiously. She may well be a very experienced driver.
A younger driver won't have that profile. They are likely to drive faster and more recklessly and won't be experienced.

Considering that whilst driving DM to lunch the other day she physically could not even see a car coming towards her in the street due to having such a blind spot in her vision I really don’t think that this is the case!

OP posts:
Emily1583 · 18/02/2024 23:05

CagneyAndLazy · 18/02/2024 22:43

This thread is mad.

Poster after poster coming on to say "it's a scam!" while understanding absolutely zero about it.

Utter thickos.

We're all ears. Come on then share your wisdom instead of just sticking your two fingers up at everyone and walking off with no advice to the question in hand at all..

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 23:05

Dibbydoos · 18/02/2024 23:02

I agree.

Thankfully my DS is now 21 so I took a fully inclusive lease for him at virtually the same monthly cost as his insurance for a 2015 1.6 TD automatic Golf. A new Cupra Leon automatic hybrid will be delivered on Weds for him and he can sell his golf.

The quote for me with >25yrs ncb was over a grand! I'll switch it temporarily onto my insurance to sell it.

I'll be taking out a fully inclusive lease myself when i need a car.

That sounds like an absolutely fabulous deal, I’d never heard of inclusive leasing (at least where we are)

OP posts:
Dibbydoos · 18/02/2024 23:02

I agree.

Thankfully my DS is now 21 so I took a fully inclusive lease for him at virtually the same monthly cost as his insurance for a 2015 1.6 TD automatic Golf. A new Cupra Leon automatic hybrid will be delivered on Weds for him and he can sell his golf.

The quote for me with >25yrs ncb was over a grand! I'll switch it temporarily onto my insurance to sell it.

I'll be taking out a fully inclusive lease myself when i need a car.

ImRen · 18/02/2024 23:01

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 20:42

Tell me in what world is it reasonable that I’ve just paid £4500 for my (very sensible) DD’s first year of insurance, whilst DM’s 80 year old best friend is still tootling around with severe eyesight issues and dementia, having a near miss on a daily basis yet paying next to nothing insurance wise! Absolutely scandalous that the government are sitting back and allowing the horrendous price gouging currently going on with car insurance in the UK.

It's statistics.

The 80 might have poorer eyesight and reaction times but might be statistically less likely to have an accident. She might only drive in day light, only drive short distance, only drive in areas she knows well and she might well be aware that she needs to drive cautiously. She may well be a very experienced driver.
A younger driver won't have that profile. They are likely to drive faster and more recklessly and won't be experienced.

RainingCatsnd0gs · 18/02/2024 22:57

I also drive an d banger, so insurance is cheap !

GetWhatYouWant · 18/02/2024 22:56

I think many posters would really benefit from reading up on how insurance premiums are calculated, the lack of understanding on here is quite astounding.

CagneyAndLazy · 18/02/2024 22:56

Isleoftights · 18/02/2024 22:50

Thisisnotarehearsal · Today 21:40

It is a total scam

My premium has gone up 50 per cent for no reason.

NO, your premium has gone up 'for a reason'; the reason is, insurance companies (Direct Line, Admiral, Aviva etc.) are MAKING LOSSES on car insurance. Hence their share prices are in the pits, and several CEOs have been sacked.

Indeed.

I posted stats further up the thread on that, but they just ignore it.

In 2022, on average, car insurers paid out ~£114 for every £100 they took in premiums.

And still people come and claim it's all some big scam.

Isleoftights · 18/02/2024 22:53

RainingCatsnd0gs · Today 22:50

I moved & my car insurance decreased by about £50 this year !

Er....ceteris paribus, that's how it works. Cockermouth v Clapham. Same risk ? No !

Sunshineandrainbow · 18/02/2024 22:52

Kinneddar · 18/02/2024 22:43

It can be done. My niece is paying £750 for her car insurance, she's 20 but she's driving a 10 year old car. Its her friends who are buying new or newer cars who are getting the eye watering quotes

I have a 10 year old car and I am paying 200 less then your neice!!
I have been driving 28 years, no accidents.
Kine went up 20 a month this year.
I need to demand a recount.

Yogatoga1 · 18/02/2024 22:52

Ginandjuice57884 · 18/02/2024 22:37

They should just use their parents' car for the first year. After that the premium will go down.

That doesn’t work. Think about it.

we have a relatively new, biggish family car. As do most grown up adults with families.

adding 18 year old dc would have been absolutely astronomical, I did the quotes and calculations.

cheaper and more practical (3 drivers sharing one car doesn’t really work) to buy a cheap run around for a few grand that is only £1k to insure. The car will last a good few years until the premiums on a decent car become affordable. Plus it will also do younger dc, saving money there too

RainingCatsnd0gs · 18/02/2024 22:50

I moved & my car insurance decreased by about £50 this year !

Isleoftights · 18/02/2024 22:50

Thisisnotarehearsal · Today 21:40

It is a total scam

My premium has gone up 50 per cent for no reason.

NO, your premium has gone up 'for a reason'; the reason is, insurance companies (Direct Line, Admiral, Aviva etc.) are MAKING LOSSES on car insurance. Hence their share prices are in the pits, and several CEOs have been sacked.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 18/02/2024 22:49

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 22:45

You sound like an absolutely delightful person!

But accurate.

Redglitter · 18/02/2024 22:47

I think its perfectly fair to say that insurance is expensive, overpriced even but I don't see how it can be called a scam

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 22:45

CagneyAndLazy · 18/02/2024 22:43

This thread is mad.

Poster after poster coming on to say "it's a scam!" while understanding absolutely zero about it.

Utter thickos.

You sound like an absolutely delightful person!

OP posts:
Isleoftights · 18/02/2024 22:44

Most insurance companies are currently making BIG LOSSES on car insurance. For example, 'Direct Line' lost £180 million on car insurance in the half-year to July 2023.

Kinneddar · 18/02/2024 22:43

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 21:13

Ok - if you can insure a 19 year old newly qualified driver for £1400 in the year 2024 then be my guest. It’s the exact same issue among all of DD’s peers.

It can be done. My niece is paying £750 for her car insurance, she's 20 but she's driving a 10 year old car. Its her friends who are buying new or newer cars who are getting the eye watering quotes

CagneyAndLazy · 18/02/2024 22:43

This thread is mad.

Poster after poster coming on to say "it's a scam!" while understanding absolutely zero about it.

Utter thickos.

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 18/02/2024 22:42

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 22:38

I can afford it perfectly fine - it’s the principle of young people paying astronomical costs no matter who they are or what they drive which bothers me. Of course I checked out insurance groups - a polo, traditionally a common first car comes in around the same price as a Mini these days due to being a popular car among 17 year olds and therefore ‘high risk’. It’s a monopoly and you can’t win

Ah it’s the principle of those poorer than you having to pay through the nose for car insurance. I get you. Those people are probably struggling to even pay for driving lessons to be fair, everyone else is purchasing shitty little cars and keeping the insurance as cheap as possible. Not so fortunate you see.

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 22:40

Ginandjuice57884 · 18/02/2024 22:37

They should just use their parents' car for the first year. After that the premium will go down.

For a lot of people this isn’t an option. DD needs her own as I also work full time and she wouldn’t be able to drive my big SUV insurance wise anyway

OP posts:
MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 22:38

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 18/02/2024 22:35

You purchased your daughter a fancy car you’ve struggled to afford the insurance premiums on. If you’d checked out the insurance groups first you could have purchased a car with cheaper insurance and you’d never have needed to have started this thread.

I can afford it perfectly fine - it’s the principle of young people paying astronomical costs no matter who they are or what they drive which bothers me. Of course I checked out insurance groups - a polo, traditionally a common first car comes in around the same price as a Mini these days due to being a popular car among 17 year olds and therefore ‘high risk’. It’s a monopoly and you can’t win

OP posts:
Redglitter · 18/02/2024 22:38

MindHowYouGoes · 18/02/2024 21:13

Those new business discounts were loss leaders to get people on the books of the insurance company. Now insurers are charging what the insurance costs instead of artificially low first year premiums.

I was under the impression though the companies were supposed to be offering the same rate to new or existing customers

You're still getting the new customer deals though, It just means changing company every year. So they're only getting your business for one year

Swipe left for the next trending thread