Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that car insurance has gotten to be a scam

185 replies

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 20:42

Tell me in what world is it reasonable that I’ve just paid £4500 for my (very sensible) DD’s first year of insurance, whilst DM’s 80 year old best friend is still tootling around with severe eyesight issues and dementia, having a near miss on a daily basis yet paying next to nothing insurance wise! Absolutely scandalous that the government are sitting back and allowing the horrendous price gouging currently going on with car insurance in the UK.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Floofydawg · 19/02/2024 09:20

Chersfrozenface · 19/02/2024 09:06

Direct Line, Vitality and RSA have pulled out of car insurance altogether, because they were making a loss on it.

For smaller firms it is becoming an uneconomical business.

For larger ones, it's a loss leader they hope will attract customers to take out their other products. Admiral Multicover car + home insurance is an example.

Direct Line haven't pulled out of car insurance.

MaloneMeadow · 19/02/2024 09:19

RatatouillePie · 19/02/2024 09:16

And yet STILL no action has been taken to prevent the most likely of accidents - male under 25 drivers with 3+ people in the car.

Under 25s make up 25% of drink driving deaths.

Of the fatalities for under 25 drivers, 75% are male.

Most serious accidents happen at night.

It's about time that they introduced a rule about no more than two under 25s in a car after 10pm!

Or perhaps we change the way we teach driving. In some countries, drivers have to complete 2000 hours of driving with a parent before sitting a test (or so many hours with a professional instructor).

AND...

Don't forget all those EV cars on the roads that are increasing insurance premiums due to the cost of repair!

Fully agree with this

OP posts:
Tracker1234 · 19/02/2024 09:18

100% agree. My FIl has many scrapes on his car which he doesnt fix and in the next year or so he will probably give up but in the meantime he is on the road paying little in the way of premimums compared to some as he hasnt made any claims.

I have children in their mid 20's and despite NO accidents their insurance keeps going up and up. No feasible reason given although one current isnurance company did say there is a rising number of people driving without insurance.

RatatouillePie · 19/02/2024 09:16

And yet STILL no action has been taken to prevent the most likely of accidents - male under 25 drivers with 3+ people in the car.

Under 25s make up 25% of drink driving deaths.

Of the fatalities for under 25 drivers, 75% are male.

Most serious accidents happen at night.

It's about time that they introduced a rule about no more than two under 25s in a car after 10pm!

Or perhaps we change the way we teach driving. In some countries, drivers have to complete 2000 hours of driving with a parent before sitting a test (or so many hours with a professional instructor).

AND...

Don't forget all those EV cars on the roads that are increasing insurance premiums due to the cost of repair!

Chersfrozenface · 19/02/2024 09:06

Direct Line, Vitality and RSA have pulled out of car insurance altogether, because they were making a loss on it.

For smaller firms it is becoming an uneconomical business.

For larger ones, it's a loss leader they hope will attract customers to take out their other products. Admiral Multicover car + home insurance is an example.

KnittedCardi · 19/02/2024 09:03

I change insurers every year. I go online. Recently, multi-car seems to be more cost effective. We added DDs car last year, she was 20, and the price was roughly £1,500. We got discounts put through onto our two other cars though! DH and I are on all cars, DD obviously only on hers. No black box. Seems to spread the risk. DD's also got a refund when she switched to Uni address, that was a surprise. She has a Fist 500 1.2l. With LV so mainstream.

Slightly dreading this year now.......

Carnewb · 19/02/2024 08:50

I'm a new driver as the UN suggests, 44 when I bought and insured the car September last year, 1.2 petrol and 11 years old. I don't have anywhere to park except on the road and use it for commuting and leisure and it's £1660 for the year. That does include the fees for the credit arrangement as well.
I had companies refused to even quote me, household name ones. I think my postcode is probably part of it as well and as obviously I'm unproven so they don't really know what risk I pose apart from statistics.
It's a lot of money every month, almost as much as paying for the car itself, but the loan for the car was a one off, I need fully comp as if it gets written off I can't afford to replace it.
I had a last ditch attempt at going for my licence because public transport had deteriorated to the point that staying employed was getting tricky.
All in all for lessons, tests, car and everything else it's set me back around £7k in 12 months, £4k of that is a loan and credit for the car itself & insurance and then things like repairs, tax and tyres.
I'd have happily stayed with public transport had it been an option!
I don't have anyone that I could use as a named driver or someone willing to put me on theirs for a while either, so I assume it's more expensive due to that as well. But ultimately if I want to keep my job then I have to keep finding the money, I've got no option.

jasflowers · 19/02/2024 08:38

Floofydawg · 19/02/2024 08:21

This. Insurance companies are not charities. They have to recover their costs.

Yet making more profit than ever before!

Bit like energy prices, we are told that Ukraine etc caused prices to rocket, yet the suppliers (not the exploration companies) are making more than ever, BG profits went up 10 fold to £772million.

Same with Supermarkets, all making massive profits.

Car parts haven't shot up in price and neither has the mechanics wages, in fact, having serviced our cars ourselves for many years, car parts have fallen back in price, my partner just ordered a full set of disc's and pads for our Skoda Octavia, from a named brand for £129, the car recently had 3 glow plugs fitted for £36, same with our DD's Citroen, parts cheap and readily available.

Insurance has just cottoned on to the fact we have to have it, therefore, like food, they can charge whatever they like, if they all wrack up the prices, where is the competition?

Avia General Insurance 1/2 year profits almost 500m

CagneyAndLazy · 19/02/2024 08:35

inabubble3 · 19/02/2024 06:27

Yup disgusting. 800 for 15 years ncb . has been around £300-400 mark

gavinf said that we got a pay out for an insurance write off last year and we got about 5x what I was expecting. The price of cars, repairs etc has shot up.

this is one of many many things that has gone up that the government has sat back and watched.

I'll happily sit and listen to anyone slating this government, but this is bonkers.

Motor insurance is not profitable for the insurance companies.

They pay out more in claims than they are taking in premiums, look back up the thread, the facts have been posted more than once.

So, in fact, if anything, the government has effectively sat back and watched the motor insurance industry going bust.

Simonjt · 19/02/2024 08:34

This is why new drivers need to base the vehicle they choose to buy on the insurance costs, fhe average group 1 car for a 17-19 year old costs £1,200 on average this year.

Car insurance companies are loss makers on premiums v payouts, without wise investment they would go bust very very quickly without significant price hikes for all policy holders.

CagneyAndLazy · 19/02/2024 08:25

@MaloneMeadow

My DD is far less risk than somebody who can barely even see where they’re going...

You should start an insurance company if you can calculate risk as easily and decisively as that. You'd have a real competitive advantage over the big insurers who do silly things like employ expensive actuaries and analysts to calculate risk for them.

Given that those big insurers are actually loss-making when it comes to motor insurance, you'd positively clean up.

43ontherocksporfavor · 19/02/2024 08:23

OP try a few other insurers and play about with named drivers. DH would have put hers up as he has an sp 30 but I brought it down by several hundred. Also recommend the black box. It means she’s driving sensibly as she gets a score on her app so it’s peace of mind for me too.

Floofydawg · 19/02/2024 08:21

RainingCatsnd0gs · 18/02/2024 23:24

Nobody says insurance is a scam, when something happens & they need to use it !

Think
Travel insurance
Life insurance
Property insurance
Car insurance
Pet insurance

This. Insurance companies are not charities. They have to recover their costs.

Alicewinn · 19/02/2024 08:17

Yeah my premium has just doubled with no warning. (Marshmallow). I’ll be changing asap

CagneyAndLazy · 19/02/2024 08:15

Emily1583 · 18/02/2024 23:05

We're all ears. Come on then share your wisdom instead of just sticking your two fingers up at everyone and walking off with no advice to the question in hand at all..

Are you joking? I've posted at least 3 more times prior to your post with graphics, charts and articles with reams of info on motor insurance risk, pricing logic, and profitability.

If you're going to say I'm "sticking 2 fingers up and walking off", at least make some effort to check that.

Edit: see posts at 21:30, 21:36 and 22:56

MaloneMeadow · 19/02/2024 08:14

BobnLen · 19/02/2024 08:10

@MaloneMeadow you also said that the 80 year olds was 'next to nothing' when it was in fact £700 which is hardly next to nothing.

It’s a hell of a lot less than £4.5k! My DD is far less risk than somebody who can barely even see where they’re going and I will die on that hill. If it makes you feel a bit better about her awfully ‘fashionable’ car, the quote we got for a polo (a very traditional first car) wasn’t much better as they’re now seen as ‘high risk’ for insurance due to the amount of 17 year olds driving them

OP posts:
BobnLen · 19/02/2024 08:10

@MaloneMeadow you also said that the 80 year olds was 'next to nothing' when it was in fact £700 which is hardly next to nothing.

BobnLen · 19/02/2024 08:06

MaloneMeadow · 19/02/2024 07:43

It’s an 8 year old 1.2l, hardly extravagant or fast!

It's a higher insurance group than several other cars but they would look less fashionable. You were saying insurance is a scam in your OP without giving the main detail of the type of car, which is a higher insurance one.

hattie43 · 19/02/2024 07:51

You can see why so many people chance not having insurance . Not good for anyone having such ridiculous premiums

MaloneMeadow · 19/02/2024 07:49

QuestionableMouse · 19/02/2024 07:46

What car do you drive?

I had a big Skoda Superb estate when I passed, and was driving a LWB van the week after!

An electric Audi e-tron, no hope of getting a 19 year old covered on that!

OP posts:
QuestionableMouse · 19/02/2024 07:46

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 21:23

She has her own car as she needs it for commuting to placements etc, unfortunately no real option for us to share as my car would be too big for a newly qualified driver anyway

Nope, we’re in quite a ‘good’ and quiet area!

Edited

What car do you drive?

I had a big Skoda Superb estate when I passed, and was driving a LWB van the week after!

MaloneMeadow · 19/02/2024 07:43

BobnLen · 19/02/2024 06:50

The type of car doesn't help, I noticed that had been left out of the OP

It’s an 8 year old 1.2l, hardly extravagant or fast!

OP posts:
43ontherocksporfavor · 19/02/2024 07:37

Just got my renewal through-£263 on a Fiat 500. Full protected NC 9yrs +. An increase of £60 pa. Quite happy with that but will still check comparison websites.

BobnLen · 19/02/2024 06:50

The type of car doesn't help, I noticed that had been left out of the OP

inabubble3 · 19/02/2024 06:29

Skodacool · 19/02/2024 01:35

What are you talking about?

Surely they mean save up and pay in full rather than saving and paying if you have an accident 😂