Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that car insurance has gotten to be a scam

185 replies

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 20:42

Tell me in what world is it reasonable that I’ve just paid £4500 for my (very sensible) DD’s first year of insurance, whilst DM’s 80 year old best friend is still tootling around with severe eyesight issues and dementia, having a near miss on a daily basis yet paying next to nothing insurance wise! Absolutely scandalous that the government are sitting back and allowing the horrendous price gouging currently going on with car insurance in the UK.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
ComtesseDeSpair · 19/02/2024 17:04

KnittedCardi · 19/02/2024 16:26

I never understood this, as insurance is based on a complex risk matrix. Did they take sex out of it completely?? How ridiculous and unfair.

Including sex in the matrix became difficult to defend when considered in the context of other protected characteristics. Should insurers be able to ask customers about their race, sexuality or any health condition in case this makes a difference to level of risk? It may be that e.g. Asian people, bisexual people and people diagnosed with anxiety are more likely to have accidents - we just don’t know because that data isn’t collected, but I doubt anyone would want to argue that it should be.

Pricing data shows that women as a group still pay lower premiums than men as a group: female drivers generally drive fewer miles, are less likely to drive for business, have lower value cars, have fewer major accidents on the road and make fewer high value claims, so are automatically rewarded with lower premiums regardless.

KnittedCardi · 19/02/2024 16:26

EsmaCannonball · 19/02/2024 15:33

Inspired by something written by Caroline Criado-Perez a while ago, I read a RoSPA report on road traffic incidents in the UK. 95% of serious accidents were caused by men behaving dangerously or carelessly, usually due to over-confidence in their own abilities. The old situation, where women had cheaper car insurance than men, was not based upon discrimination but upon hard data. Women are being discriminated against now and not rewarded for their safer driving.

I never understood this, as insurance is based on a complex risk matrix. Did they take sex out of it completely?? How ridiculous and unfair.

ComtesseDeSpair · 19/02/2024 15:57

I find it really hard to believe that insurance companies are not making profits. Why would they exist if they’re not making a profit.

Many providers nowadays are, essentially, investment businesses with insurance sidelines. They remain in business through a fine balancing act of divestment of risk and class in their portfolios, keeping their solvency capital requirements as low as possible by endlessly reviewing actuarial models for reserving on their liabilities, and on profits from investment of premium. They don’t make money from selling car insurance.

Stricter regulation, particularly in the Lloyd’s market, when it comes to solvency capital, capital ratios, and assessment of operational resilience is one of the many reasons for increase in premium, as providers can no longer operate under the lean capital structures many used to - and the government has no appetite to deregulate the industry, quite rightly.

Chersfrozenface · 19/02/2024 15:54

I find it really hard to believe that insurance companies are not making profits. Why would they exist if they’re not making a profit.

They don't make a profit on it, by and large. Those that still offer car insurance do so because drivers have to have insurance by law. The companies use it as a way to acquire customers and then market other, optional, forms of insurance to them. It's a loss leader.

This is from Forbes, the financial website.

"Despite the size of the market, most insurers make a loss on their motor insurance underwriting operations. Instead, they make profit in other areas by offering their policyholders additional services such as home, travel or pet cover, says trade organisation, the Association of British Insurers (ABI). "

https://www.forbes.com/uk/advisor/car-insurance/car-insurance-statistics/#:~:text=Despite%20the%20size%20of%20the,of%20British%20Insurers%20(ABI).

UK Car Insurance Statistics 2024

A car insurance policy offers financial protection against the risks to which a driver is exposed, namely being involved in an accident with another vehicl

https://www.forbes.com/uk/advisor/car-insurance/car-insurance-statistics#:~:text=Despite%20the%20size%20of%20the,of%20British%20Insurers%20(ABI).

CagneyAndLazy · 19/02/2024 15:51

@inabubble3

I find it really hard to believe that insurance companies are not making profits. Why would they exist if they’re not making a profit.

You could have just looked at the - independent - links posted earlier in the thread regarding the unprofitable motor insurance sector.

inabubble3 · 19/02/2024 15:44

CagneyAndLazy · 19/02/2024 08:35

I'll happily sit and listen to anyone slating this government, but this is bonkers.

Motor insurance is not profitable for the insurance companies.

They pay out more in claims than they are taking in premiums, look back up the thread, the facts have been posted more than once.

So, in fact, if anything, the government has effectively sat back and watched the motor insurance industry going bust.

I find it really hard to believe that insurance companies are not making profits. Why would they exist if they’re not making a profit.

Unfortunately I’m guessing so many people that are tied into having a car to get to their jobs, children’s schools etc.

See also utility companies, food shopping etc etc etc

I am guessing if they wanted to the government could intervene re. Cost of living…..

If they can make such schemes as ‘eat out to help out’ anything is possible isn’t it :)

EsmaCannonball · 19/02/2024 15:33

Inspired by something written by Caroline Criado-Perez a while ago, I read a RoSPA report on road traffic incidents in the UK. 95% of serious accidents were caused by men behaving dangerously or carelessly, usually due to over-confidence in their own abilities. The old situation, where women had cheaper car insurance than men, was not based upon discrimination but upon hard data. Women are being discriminated against now and not rewarded for their safer driving.

shoppingshamed · 19/02/2024 15:17

jasflowers · 19/02/2024 14:01

Feistas and other small hatchbacks have always been driven by inexperienced drivers and are sometimes stolen too, no surprise with 1.5m of them on the roads, yet just 5000 were stolen last year.

You seem perfectly happy to pay super high insurance premiums & doubtless everything else too, without ever questioning why.

Not sure where you're getting that conclusion from, are you mixing me up with another poster?

I never pay any insurance without making sure I'm getting the best value for money but as I have no influence over other drivers, the cost of car repairs, medical payout scams or any other factors that dictate insurer algorithms I have to accept that premiums are increasing

Google tells me that according to What Car Fiestas were the most stolen car in 2023, just under 6000, I've no reason to doubt their research but happy to reconsider if your figures are from a more reliable source

Even at 5000 it's more than the next two added together

Redglitter · 19/02/2024 14:56

shoppingshamed · 19/02/2024 13:30

That's not a surprise as I believe Fiestas are one of the most stolen cars and driven by the most inexperienced drivers

My nieces both drive Fiestas although ones learning. The older one has a Fiesta that's 10 years old & the insurance has gone up this year to £720 - she's 19

jasflowers · 19/02/2024 14:01

shoppingshamed · 19/02/2024 13:30

That's not a surprise as I believe Fiestas are one of the most stolen cars and driven by the most inexperienced drivers

Feistas and other small hatchbacks have always been driven by inexperienced drivers and are sometimes stolen too, no surprise with 1.5m of them on the roads, yet just 5000 were stolen last year.

You seem perfectly happy to pay super high insurance premiums & doubtless everything else too, without ever questioning why.

EssexMan55 · 19/02/2024 13:50

ComtesseDeSpair · 18/02/2024 21:15

Car insurance is a loss leader for most providers: on average it costs insurers £1.10 in claims and operating costs for every £1 received in premiums. It really isn’t a “scam”, you’re just paying what it costs to provide cover: parts and labour cost more than they did even a couple of years ago; modern cars are more expensive to repair, even a relatively minor accident can result in a significant repair bill or write off; insurance fraud cases and e.g. whiplash claims have skyrocketed in recent years.

Read an interesting article in MoneyWeek explaining that most car insurers make money by investing your premium in stocks etc. Just insuring people loses money.

shoppingshamed · 19/02/2024 13:30

marshyrun · 19/02/2024 11:25

It's ridiculous, my cousin (male, 18 yrs old), passed a few months ago - he's got a 2017 1ltr ford fiesta and he's had to pay £2800 (with a black box). Without the black box the cheapest he could get was £3970! I even found with mine last year my renewal shot up, managed to get it for the same price as the previous years luckily.

Edited

That's not a surprise as I believe Fiestas are one of the most stolen cars and driven by the most inexperienced drivers

shoppingshamed · 19/02/2024 13:28

jasflowers · 19/02/2024 08:38

Yet making more profit than ever before!

Bit like energy prices, we are told that Ukraine etc caused prices to rocket, yet the suppliers (not the exploration companies) are making more than ever, BG profits went up 10 fold to £772million.

Same with Supermarkets, all making massive profits.

Car parts haven't shot up in price and neither has the mechanics wages, in fact, having serviced our cars ourselves for many years, car parts have fallen back in price, my partner just ordered a full set of disc's and pads for our Skoda Octavia, from a named brand for £129, the car recently had 3 glow plugs fitted for £36, same with our DD's Citroen, parts cheap and readily available.

Insurance has just cottoned on to the fact we have to have it, therefore, like food, they can charge whatever they like, if they all wrack up the prices, where is the competition?

Avia General Insurance 1/2 year profits almost 500m

Edited

You really think that motor insurers have only just become aware that motor insurance is compulsory and so have increased premiums, don't be daft

How much did motor contribute to the Avia figure you've quoted?

Poblano · 19/02/2024 12:38

MaloneMeadow · 18/02/2024 22:21

DD wanted a Mini and we are fortunate enough to be able to afford it. The same can’t be said for every teenager

I think this is essentially the problem.

My DC quite likely wanted a fancier car, but they accounted for the insurance cost in their decisions around what they could afford.

DS1 (21) has his own small car, its 1.0 litre so a cheap insurance group. It also only costs £20 per year in road tax.

DS2 (19) and DD (17) have been added to the insurance for my small, 1.2 litre car as they aren't/won't be taking a car to university. I deliberately have a small car for this reason, they also learnt to drive in it. We have a bigger family car too, which DH drives day to day but I can also drive if one of the DC need mine.

Yes, insurance is expensive and has become more so recently. But there are choices that you can make to reduce the cost to some extent.

marshyrun · 19/02/2024 11:25

It's ridiculous, my cousin (male, 18 yrs old), passed a few months ago - he's got a 2017 1ltr ford fiesta and he's had to pay £2800 (with a black box). Without the black box the cheapest he could get was £3970! I even found with mine last year my renewal shot up, managed to get it for the same price as the previous years luckily.

jasflowers · 19/02/2024 11:14

Chersfrozenface · 19/02/2024 09:31

You sre quite right. I was thinking if More Than (RSA).

Zurich are also pulling out of personal lines car insurance, to concentrate on high net worth. Another minor player, but still another company exiting.

Yet the AA is making profit and saw revenues & profits rise, following increases in premiums.

AXA doubled my insurance premium, AA pretty much charged me what i was paying previously.

How can this be if repair costs have risen so much??? AA don't do loss leaders and i'm not a AA member.

The issues with young drivers etc have always been there, nothing new.

GasPanic · 19/02/2024 10:58

RatatouillePie · 19/02/2024 09:16

And yet STILL no action has been taken to prevent the most likely of accidents - male under 25 drivers with 3+ people in the car.

Under 25s make up 25% of drink driving deaths.

Of the fatalities for under 25 drivers, 75% are male.

Most serious accidents happen at night.

It's about time that they introduced a rule about no more than two under 25s in a car after 10pm!

Or perhaps we change the way we teach driving. In some countries, drivers have to complete 2000 hours of driving with a parent before sitting a test (or so many hours with a professional instructor).

AND...

Don't forget all those EV cars on the roads that are increasing insurance premiums due to the cost of repair!

Definitely something needs doing.

I would say maybe an advanced driving course mandatory within 2 years of passing the actual test. Most people really benefit from being on a skid pan for example so that the experience is not new to them if it happens. Also stuff like what to do in an aquaplane situation.

Maybe people who have passed their test are not allowed to carry passengers for 2 years after.

There are loads of things you could come up with that would help.

MaloneMeadow · 19/02/2024 10:53

Atichen · 19/02/2024 10:48

I past my test 20 years ago so don't really know much about young peoples insurance now ....
But is a (cheep) polo still popular first car? Surely there are more basic cars out there

A polo was my first car when I passed but (as far as i know) it was the basic smallest car vw produced... modern polo's are now the size of golf's and vw make a smaller car (fox?) Which was the equivalent of the polo then

I now drove a basic 10 y old corsa (less flashy than my polo) I'm sure a mini would cost me more to insure...(as did my beetle when I had it compared to the equivalent corsa) buti loved it as it was worth it for a few years... it's still cheeper for me to put my dad on my insurance (he lives a few hours away and doesn't ever drive it)!

Edited

Polos are still a very popular first car, at least where we are but they’re not cheap at all to insure anymore as insurance companies see them as ‘high risk’ due to the amount of new teen drivers who have them.

The VW Fox isn’t in production anymore and hasn’t been for many years. The smallest most basic car they make now is the Up

OP posts:
Atichen · 19/02/2024 10:48

I past my test 20 years ago so don't really know much about young peoples insurance now ....
But is a (cheep) polo still popular first car? Surely there are more basic cars out there

A polo was my first car when I passed but (as far as i know) it was the basic smallest car vw produced... modern polo's are now the size of golf's and vw make a smaller car (fox?) Which was the equivalent of the polo then

I now drove a basic 10 y old corsa (less flashy than my polo) I'm sure a mini would cost me more to insure...(as did my beetle when I had it compared to the equivalent corsa) buti loved it as it was worth it for a few years... it's still cheeper for me to put my dad on my insurance (he lives a few hours away and doesn't ever drive it)!

Squidwardthesnail · 19/02/2024 10:16

The type of car really is the bottom line at the moment. I'm a new ish driver, I've had my lisence 18 months and when I looked at cars after I passed I had a lot of quotes of 2k+. But opted for a not entirely pleasant to look at basic tin can because I managed to get insurance for 700. Came down to 600 on renewal. I have friends all aged 25-35 with bigger or nicer cars who are really struggling this year with their renewals, one or two of them looking at 200+ per month, and that's with no claims discounts. It Is possible to get reasonably affordable insurance at the moment, but you have to be really careful what cars you look at

bluelavender · 19/02/2024 10:12

Your insurance premium is a lot higher than for the young drivers I know. Have you looked into a black box?

MaloneMeadow · 19/02/2024 10:09

WomensRightsRenegade · 19/02/2024 10:08

Was there really nothing cheaper than £4500? We got insurance for my 18yr old daughter a few days after she passed her test last year and it was £1200. Just renewed and it’s £800. She has an old C1 though

For us there wasn’t. I quoted a 10 year old polo before we bought the Mini - £8k for her first year!! Nearly fell off my seat!

OP posts:
WomensRightsRenegade · 19/02/2024 10:08

Was there really nothing cheaper than £4500? We got insurance for my 18yr old daughter a few days after she passed her test last year and it was £1200. Just renewed and it’s £800. She has an old C1 though

Chersfrozenface · 19/02/2024 09:31

Floofydawg · 19/02/2024 09:20

Direct Line haven't pulled out of car insurance.

You sre quite right. I was thinking if More Than (RSA).

Zurich are also pulling out of personal lines car insurance, to concentrate on high net worth. Another minor player, but still another company exiting.

RoroNoa · 19/02/2024 09:21

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/02/2024 20:46

Young people are much more of a risk than older people driving. It's just statistics.

And report the near miss person. That's not OK.

My husband just did his first year of driving.

He's 40 and has paid 3.5k 😑

We have 2 sons that just cnat afford to learn.

I think that's the enf game. More youths using public transport. Price them out of car ownership.