Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I want out of this, what are my options, please help

207 replies

Godifeelsolow · 18/02/2024 20:32

Another awful weekend with Dp, but something has finally snapped in me and I want out, no matter how hard it will be.
Beautiful, sunny day and sat in the car trying not to cry earlier, after Dp called me weird and a narcissist, I’d done nothing wrong, he has simmering aggression and I’m starting to actually hate him.
We’re not married, but have a house in both our names and have a young Dd and dog. The best would be for Dd to stay in her house and for all that to stay the same and for him to leave and us to share custody between us somehow. How do I get him to do this? I’m not sure I could afford the mortgage alone, what can I do in this situation?

OP posts:
Illstartexercisingtomorrow · 19/02/2024 10:07

Gosh some really harsh replies on. What is wrong with people???

Sorry you are going through this OP. Honestly the material benefits of staying in a house that your dd is used to with school nearby and friends nearby, will be outweighed by having a happy mum who isn’t emotionally or verbally abused.

I think you need to stop looking at this as what dd would lose, but actually what she would gain from you moving. Fwiw - I am the product of a mum who stayed (no choice back then), and I often resented her for it and was angry with her for a long time. I feel like I would have loved the freedom of a happy home and a joyful mum.

Thisisnotarehearsal · 19/02/2024 09:54

LemonTT · 18/02/2024 21:33

You are wrong. Both in terms of this being something the OP would be entitled to if she was married and the primary carer and that her child has no rights in this scenario.

Even if the OP was married she wouldn’t automatically get to stay in the house without releasing his share of the equity. Most divorces are needs cases and in the housing needs of parents is always the same. Doesn’t matter what the co parenting share is. Only where there isn’t enough capital and income to fund needs would the court order a deferred sale or release of equity. This is something that should be used in a last resort if there isn’t enough equity to ensure the child is housed. Lots of reasons for this but it generally doesn’t benefit either party to do this unless it is necessary.

Not being married the OP wouldn’t be able to use divorce laws to stay in the home. However the childrens act has provision for this scenario and if there wasn’t enough capital or income to house the child then the court can delay the sale until it is affordable. Both parties retain their share. So even if the OP pays the mortgage for another decade her ex still gets 50%.

A suitable home for both parents is a 1-2 bed property rented or mortgaged. Married or not and in both cases income needs to be maximised.

Stability is about relationships with parents and then close family. At 5 friendships and school matter but it isn’t as important as when a child is 15 and sitting exams.

No need to be so rude @LemonTT. That's why I said 'I think' and to seek advice legal advice from a professional.

Plus I know two divorced women, one with two daughters, one with a son who have the right to remain in their home until the children are grown. Both fathers are every other weekend.

Not that it is relevant as they were both married.

zingally · 19/02/2024 09:41

Best for DD is two parents who are happy, stable and mentally well.

Everything else is honestly just wallpapering.

Your "D"P doesn't go after your DD because she's young. But what happens when she starts to become a stroppy, argumentative teen? You think she won't get the same treatment you get now? Of course she will.

15 years from now, she'll barely remember the house, the dog, and the kid a few doors down. She'll remember the steps you took to safeguard her from from an aggressive man.

Checkeringin · 19/02/2024 09:39

Could he afford to buy you out OP? That way DD gets to keep her family home and you will have some money to get set up again. I know it's really scary, but with one 5 year old DD you are doing the right thing if you are unhappy.

BlondiesHaveMoreFun · 19/02/2024 09:39

AcrossthePond55 · 19/02/2024 00:25

But why should he? What if he were to say to you "Well, you can move out, I'll stay here and DD can split the time between us 50/50. That way she'll still be in 'her' home, etc, etc half the time. Then later on when I decide to sell the house, you'll get your share". Would you go for that? After all, if it's your 1st priority to keep DD in her home, it shouldn't matter which parent is living in said home and which parent is renting, all things being equal.

But seriously, your choices are; he buys you out, you buy him out, or the house gets sold and equity split. There is no other option unless he agrees to one, and I highly doubt he will. He isn't going to want to rent when his share of the equity may qualify him to buy a house or a flat.

See a solicitor by all means, it's always best to get your questions answered by the experts. It allows you to set aside impractical ideas and move forward with realistic expectations.

As far as what do you do once the house goes on the market if you have to live together til it's sold? You tell him that you are effectively 'separated'. That you will no longer be responsible for his 'upkeep'. No more cooking for him, cleaning for him, etc. And that you will separate finances (if they're joint now) and pay your pro rata share of the household expenses. You set up a 'child arrangements' schedule in which you set days for each of you to be the 'primary parent'. And you move into the spare room, the sofa, or start bunking in with DD. And you ignore him after that. You form your own 'new' life, go out with friends, visit relatives, do as you please.

I believe you can apply for certain benefits once you have separated, even if living in the same house. I'm not sure if the same applies to CMS since he'd be living in the same house as DD.

Agree with this. These are your realistic options.

A 5 year old child will adapt very easily to moving home. Simple "bribes" like letting her choose how her new bedroom is decorated.

My children are adults now, but when they were children they moved house 5 times. Each time was made exciting and there were no problems. And yes, one move was me leaving their Dad and setting up alone. She's only 5 years old - no big deal.

You definitely need legal advice. Your proposal for him leaving and letting you stay and pay the mortgage, would be littered with difficulties. Let's say you pay the mortgage on your own, for the next 13 years, and then sell at £100k more than the house is worth today? Does he get any of that profit? He hasn't paid the mortgage BUT his money has been invested in the asset. Money that he could have invested into another property and seen the investment grow. Quite messy, I would think.

NotAgainWilson · 19/02/2024 09:22

Op, so many stupid judgemental answers from people who have no idea of what the breaking process involves.

You need legal advice but also to use your personal financial resources wisely to ensure you can afford to fight this battle. Things I wish someone had told me at the start:

  1. You need to leave, but leave when it is convenient to you and DD. Finishing a long term relationship is like a getting married. You need to save, plan and prepare to have a good start to your new life. You leave when it works for you, unless he is violent of course, then you leave immediately.

  2. Go to entitled.co.uk and use their calculator to see how much financial support you will get raising your child on your own.

  3. Then go to the child maintenance service (CMS) website and calculate how much you or he will need to pay. This is calculated by night spend with each parent not days. One important thing to consider is that if you have a 50/50 split on the nights, no one pays or gets child maintenance. The one who has the child for more nights (even if it is just one night above 50/50) is the one who becomes the resident parent and the one who gets paid child maintenance and gets the universal credit.

  4. Go to the library or order a book on divorce (The Which Guide to Divorce was excellent but I am not sure they are still doing it or updating it). Since you are not married, you need to focus on the parts of the “Arrangements for the Care of Children” you will have a lot of your questions answered about how courts go about the subject and a lot unanswered about your particular case, that’s when you contact a solicitor for your 30 minutes free appointment. Don’t waste money on solicitor fees asking them to explain you the very basics, they charge per block of 6 minutes, so use your time wisely!

  5. You will need support during the split but never pour your heart out to your solicitor, they are not trained for that and even if sympathetic and reassuring they charge far far more than counselors so use the right professional for the problem and remember, you don’t need to convince them who is right or that your ex is a bastard, you are paying them to protect your interests and they will do even if it is you who is the bastard and you are not right, so keep your sessions concise, straight to the point and short.

  6. You can get a Mesher Order that allows for your child and resident parent to stay in the house until the child is 18 BUT… they are only put in place if the non resident parent is LOADED and able to house himself at an equal level without having access to the equity of the house. If not, the house will be sold and proceeds split.

  7. Don’t fight for child maintenance in court, you can get more money BUT after a calendar year, either of you can contact the CMS to have it reduced to CMS calculation. The moment CMS takes over, anything agreed in court about this is irrelevant.

  8. There are no winners when you split, you both will be poorer and have their own struggles, but you will earn your freedom and a strength you never thought possible and your life can be wonderful even with far less money and in a different house.

  9. I know the question of what happens to the dog is an absolute worry (I would be devastated if I needed to find mine a new home) but never put the dog’s needs over those of your child or your safety, if you need to go into rented accommodation, having someone on call to take care of the dog long or short term will make things much more bearable. If you need to leave suddenly, there is a charity that will find your dog a foster home for a while, I don’t remember the name but a Google search might bring it up.

Best of luck!

LittleBrenda · 19/02/2024 09:21

I’m truly baffled as to why you think it is upon the man to leave a jointly owned home when a relationship breaks down.
Me too. Why would anyone be 'shocked' by either parent 'outright refusing' to move out of the family home?

dottiedodah · 19/02/2024 09:21

Usually the house is sold and money divided up.It used to be that the wife might have stayed in the house and sold when DC was older .However that was a few years ago now and took into account less money earned by wife .Now more equal partners sort of thing

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 19/02/2024 09:19

It’s not a marriage ending. There no legal contract regarding any other finances. They own an asset together. They want to end the relationship the asset will be sold. The cost of legal fees to Op to fight to stay in the house would likely leave her in a worst position and there’s an extremely high chance she wouldn’t win.

Even if he agreed to let op stay and she paid the mortgage out of CMS payments, she would still need to pay for the upkeep of the property. If CMS isn’t payable due to shared responsibility of the child, why would he pay for his own housing for him and his child, not get his equity AND pay towards Ops housing costs?

But as it’s claimed he is abusive, even if he let Op stay, he would use that to continue to abuse her. He could change his mind at any point. It’s still his house so he can go in if he wants and so on.

If this man is abusive, Op should call the police. However, that’s not that simple either. Telling someone they are a narcissist and weird, isn’t always abusive. Plenty of women label their ex those term to the face and to other people. We don’t know the Op. she could be a narcissist. He could be abusive AND so could be a narcissist.

The problem with ‘log it with police’ or ‘call the police’ is that it could end up worse for Op, depending on the situation. Calling the police out saying you are abused when it turns out it was an argument with no threatening behaviour and him saying ‘god you are such a narcissist’ could hugely back fire on Op. especially if she threw some name calling back.

Proving emotional abuse is very difficult and it takes more than ‘he called me names when we argued’. If Op has evidence of long term emotional abuse, that’s one thing. But calling the police out because he called her a name in a mutual argument could be playing into his hands. It would make the case that the house should be sold to reduce how much contact they need. It could give him evidence that she is trying to alienate him as a parent or even maliciously complaining about him to get him out of the home.

Being a victim of abuse really isn’t easy, you have to step carefully. Anyone that is tempted to exaggerate accusations, could easily find it massively backfires, drags the whole thing out AND makes it far more distressing and expensive than it needs to be.

I am not saying op is considering this. But I get the impression some people are giving the ‘just call the police advice aren’t really thinking it through.

pandarific · 19/02/2024 09:14

@MasterShardlake thank you captain obvious

Picklestop · 19/02/2024 09:14

Chevybaby · 19/02/2024 08:42

At 40 I'm shocked by how many women I've known (myself included) whose partners have just outright refused to leave their home after breaking up. Sometimes for YEARS. So I just feel like you should really be prepared for that. If you want to stay in that home, even if he agrees to share the mortgage payments and move out he might take a very very long time to do so. So if you need away from him as a matter of urgency it might be best to find a new place yourself.

But also I disagree with so many commenter here, I think you and him continuing to make mortgage payments on this home after he moves out is not a bonkers set up. Presumably if you moved out and rented a place and had primary custody of dd then he'd have to contribute towards the cost of that so surely it just makes sense to keep her where she is?

I’m truly baffled as to why you think it is upon the man to leave a jointly owned home when a relationship breaks down.

And it would be fairly bonkers for anyone to move out of their jointly owned home and then carry on paying the mortgage on it for 13 years whilst also having to fund somewhere else to live.

And if OP moved out, no he wouldn’t have to contribute to the cost of her home. He will need to pay child maintenance, unless they share 50:50.

Manopadmanaban · 19/02/2024 09:02

GuinnessBird · 18/02/2024 22:48

So you expect DP to just fuck off, let you stay in the house until whenever you decide to sell it so he can get his part of the money back?

Meanwhile in the real world...

Sounds like a good idea if he's abusive and OP is deeply unhappy. Why should he have a good life?

AInightingale · 19/02/2024 08:58

LakieLady · 19/02/2024 08:39

This is very misinformed.

UC (and other means-tested benefits) will disregard the equity OP has in her home when she explains that she is going through the process of selling or getting her DP to buy her out. The regs specify a fixed period (can't recall if it's 6 months or a year), but this can be extended as long as the claimant is taking all reasonable steps to sell. I've never known an extension to be refused in cases of relationship breakdown in 17 years of working in welfare rights.

OP, I can understand your reservations about uprooting your DP from her home but it will be far less damaging for her than living in an environment where her father is regularly verbally and emotionally abusive to her mother. It will be far better for her if you leave and start again somewhere else.

Sorry yes I know about the six month rule, but I meant that the house does have to be sold eventually, I don't know how long they are prepared to give extensions for. The UC system is a lot stricter than the old Tas Credit one, where the former family home (with a former partner living there) was not regarded as capital. I think the only exceptions are that a person under 18/ over 60/ disabled lives there. Although if OP has only a tiny amount of equity it will be disregarded in any case. Depends what she stands to make from a sale, I suppose.

MasterShardlake · 19/02/2024 08:52

pandarific · 19/02/2024 08:45

@Godifeelsolow get him to leave and rent a room to a female mature student or similar.

How would you get him to leave if he doesn't want to go?

Seagrassbasket · 19/02/2024 08:49

In all honesty lovely the best gift you can give your daughter is getting out, whatever that looks like. Otherwise you are giving her the blueprint for how she should be treated by intimate partners for potentially the rest of her life.

Ohnoooooooo · 19/02/2024 08:48

I know its very hard when you have helped your child build a life they are happy with - but at 5 she will barely remember the house you are in now. We moved our childre at 4 and then again at 5 - they can't really remember those houses. It's better you move now and settle her into somewhere you know she will stay for her primary years / possible high school years.

LakieLady · 19/02/2024 08:47

How is he an abuser??? Calling someone a narcissist and weird isn’t being abusive. She didn’t say that he hit her. Many of you probably say way worse things to your partners than that.

Repeatedly insulting a partner, shouting etc is emotional abuse. A relationship doesn't have to involve physical violence to be abusive.

pandarific · 19/02/2024 08:45

@Godifeelsolow get him to leave and rent a room to a female mature student or similar.

NoraBattysCurlers · 19/02/2024 08:44

Cantalever · 18/02/2024 20:50

I am well out of the loop on this, but can it really be the case that if parents separate, and it is best for their child to stay in the home with the mother (even if shared custody), that the father does not continue to pay something to keep his child's roof over her head? Surely he has some responsibility towards housing his child? Does he not pay anything towards the mortgage just because he is not living there? That would seem too much like changing the goalposts after parenthood had been embarked on. Getting ready to be shot down if this is really out of touch with reality.

The OP has already stated that she expects that they will share custody.

The OP is responsible for her DD when she stays with her. She cannot afford to pay the mortgage and buy her StbxDP out.

The XP will be responsible for housing his DD when she stays with him. It could be the case that the he can afford buy OP out and he and his DD could continue to live in the family home when he has custody.

mydogisthebest · 19/02/2024 08:42

AgathaAllAlong · 19/02/2024 00:19

Oh OP - why on earth did you have DC with this man? I am sorry you are in this situation but it is soul destroying to read posts like this where a woman has stayed with an abusive man and gone on to have children.

I'm sorry but this is a really stupid comment. Many men only turn abusive once a woman is "trapped" with children, how can you spend even 5 seconds on MN and not know that?

OP: No one benefits from living with parents who hate each other. You probably will have to sell and split, but you're gifting her a childhood without hate and name calling.

The OP has said that he was abusive BEFORE they had a child. Why on earth would you have a child with an abusive man?

Chevybaby · 19/02/2024 08:42

At 40 I'm shocked by how many women I've known (myself included) whose partners have just outright refused to leave their home after breaking up. Sometimes for YEARS. So I just feel like you should really be prepared for that. If you want to stay in that home, even if he agrees to share the mortgage payments and move out he might take a very very long time to do so. So if you need away from him as a matter of urgency it might be best to find a new place yourself.

But also I disagree with so many commenter here, I think you and him continuing to make mortgage payments on this home after he moves out is not a bonkers set up. Presumably if you moved out and rented a place and had primary custody of dd then he'd have to contribute towards the cost of that so surely it just makes sense to keep her where she is?

Iwasafool · 19/02/2024 08:41

Godifeelsolow · 18/02/2024 20:43

@TheSnowyOwl If I was able to keep paying the mortgage alone, would this work. I can’t afford to buy him out, but when it’s sold, he could have his share

How generous of you to allow him to have his share. What is he supposed to do in the mean time? Are you as a family well off enough that he can go and buy somewhere equivalent?

Families move house all the time for all sorts of reasons. Is there any reason your DD would be less able to cope with that than other children?

You have to make it a positive for her and yes I've been there. My solicitor tried to persuade me to go for the house, years ago so that was more possible then. My reply was that I didn't want my children spending their time with him in some grotty place and I didn't want me kids coming home upset that they were leaving dad in that grotty place. So I moved to a house a five minute walk away and so did he. It wasn't the lovely big 4 bed, it was a small 3 bed semi for both of us but the kids lived in happy homes going between mum and dad as they chose.

When you need to set up two homes it is rare that there isn't a drop in size/location/standard. That is the price you pay.

LakieLady · 19/02/2024 08:39

AInightingale · 18/02/2024 23:39

If he takes an 'I'm going nowhere' attitude, then remind him that your mortgage company made an agreement with both of you. It would be helpful to speak to a solicitor about this - he may be either forced to buy you out or to agree to a sale. i would also warn you that if you leave, it is impossible to access universal credit (for top ups to your earnings, help with rent etc) if your name is on a house which you don't live in - they regard it as capital.

This is very misinformed.

UC (and other means-tested benefits) will disregard the equity OP has in her home when she explains that she is going through the process of selling or getting her DP to buy her out. The regs specify a fixed period (can't recall if it's 6 months or a year), but this can be extended as long as the claimant is taking all reasonable steps to sell. I've never known an extension to be refused in cases of relationship breakdown in 17 years of working in welfare rights.

OP, I can understand your reservations about uprooting your DP from her home but it will be far less damaging for her than living in an environment where her father is regularly verbally and emotionally abusive to her mother. It will be far better for her if you leave and start again somewhere else.

MikeRafone · 19/02/2024 08:38

Godifeelsolow · 18/02/2024 20:43

@TheSnowyOwl If I was able to keep paying the mortgage alone, would this work. I can’t afford to buy him out, but when it’s sold, he could have his share

that's what you need to seek legal advice concerning.

Book yourself to see a solicitor to find out all the queries you have and whether you can stay in the house until dd is 18

AInightingale · 19/02/2024 08:37

Is the house 'worth' selling OP? How long have you had your mortgage, have you had it valued and what equity is in it? Did you both contribute equally to the deposit? And what age are you both? It would be foolish for your both to jump off the housing ladder now for the sake of a few thousand pounds each. Private renting is insecure - social tenancies are quite another thing, but nearly impossible to come by. It really depends upon how reasonable your partner is prepared to be about it - dog in manger attitudes will result in you both losing out in the long term.