Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I want out of this, what are my options, please help

207 replies

Godifeelsolow · 18/02/2024 20:32

Another awful weekend with Dp, but something has finally snapped in me and I want out, no matter how hard it will be.
Beautiful, sunny day and sat in the car trying not to cry earlier, after Dp called me weird and a narcissist, I’d done nothing wrong, he has simmering aggression and I’m starting to actually hate him.
We’re not married, but have a house in both our names and have a young Dd and dog. The best would be for Dd to stay in her house and for all that to stay the same and for him to leave and us to share custody between us somehow. How do I get him to do this? I’m not sure I could afford the mortgage alone, what can I do in this situation?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AInightingale · 20/02/2024 16:44

Totally agree @Chevybaby . My ex insisted on staying in our home, which was 50-50 jointly owned, He has subsequently filled it with junk and neglected to do any maintenance for years, the agreement was to sell (it was affected by the crash) when it had regained enough value, but he's quite deliberately made it unsellable at a decent price. Valuer says he's seen it before with men living alone after a separation. Those type of men don't give a damn about children or uprooting them. OP has not posted for a while, I hope the thread has not totally depressed her.

Chevybaby · 20/02/2024 11:41

Picklestop · 19/02/2024 09:14

I’m truly baffled as to why you think it is upon the man to leave a jointly owned home when a relationship breaks down.

And it would be fairly bonkers for anyone to move out of their jointly owned home and then carry on paying the mortgage on it for 13 years whilst also having to fund somewhere else to live.

And if OP moved out, no he wouldn’t have to contribute to the cost of her home. He will need to pay child maintenance, unless they share 50:50.

I never said a man should leave a jointly owned home. I said I've known of a surprising amount of men whove refused to leave a shared home when they should've. In my case it was a home that I had personally owned for many years before he'd moved in and towards which he had never paid a penny of the mortgage. I've seen so many different versions of this, always men and never women. I suspect it's something to do with fear of isolation whereas women are largely better at forging networks/maintaining close friendshipsso maybe being alone is less daunting? But really i have no idea.

"The cost of her home"
Eh no. If the mother has primary custody then it's the cost of the children's home...🙈

Honestly, splitting up is so so hard on children, everyone should do everything they possible can to keep that damage to a minimum. For example, Maintaining the joint mortgage on the home the child already knows might be cheaper than privately renting something smaller, less secure and much farther away. Why further traumatize your children just to make sure that life is sufficiently difficult for your ex?

Obviously loads of potential variables here and also different options. But all im saying is OPs hope is not bonkers, it might make sense for them.. Even if you don't get on you're going to be raising children together for the next 10/20 years and wherever possible should try to think of looking after them as a team effort.

AInightingale · 19/02/2024 16:49

Unfortunately, a partner who starts to engage in this verbal abuse ('simmering aggression' describes it well) doesn't sound like he would be up for compromise or reasonable solutions. Although OP says that he could afford to rent now from his salary, he will want his share of assets even if it means his daughter spending her childhood in private rentals. Not a great existence in the UK, it may be more secure in other countries.

prh47bridge · 19/02/2024 15:44

Godifeelsolow · 18/02/2024 20:43

@TheSnowyOwl If I was able to keep paying the mortgage alone, would this work. I can’t afford to buy him out, but when it’s sold, he could have his share

You may be able to use TOLATA and Schedule 1 of the Children Act to delay any sale until your daughter is older. Consult a solicitor.

Ratherstandonacliffandsetfiretomyself · 19/02/2024 15:43

My ex and his ex wife had an agreement that when the house they bought together sold she would get her share of the equity. She moved out and rented a property and he stayed in the family home - reasoning being that she didn’t want to uproot the kids in any way. I suspect he got himself into extra debt to keep paying the mortgage. As far as I know he still lives in the house but they weren’t even divorced when I was with him and no idea what’s happened since. I don’t know how it works if you’re not married but maybe worth a conversation with a solicitor

LookItsMeAgain · 19/02/2024 15:32

Hi @Godifeelsolow, I don't think posting to the AIBU part of Mumsnet was in your best interest here as it can get pretty hot under the collar quite quickly. I've been in touch with the MN Admins and made a suggestion that your post be moved either to Chat or Relationships as the information you need right now for your personal situation may be easier found under one of those areas. I've suggested to MN Admins that they reach out to you and I hope you don't think that I was overreaching here. I just read a few of the responses you received and thought that it might be a little less "in your face" (if you will) in one of the other areas on the boards.
I hope you manage to find a solution to your situation.

Chickenkeev · 19/02/2024 15:07

LakieLady · 19/02/2024 14:27

That's how my abusive ex started gaslighting me. I was "weird" for having different opinions from him about stuff, then it very quickly progressed to everyone we knew thinking I was crazy and that he was a saint for putting up with me.

After that, he got more and more emotionally abusive, isolated me from friends, became financially abusive etc. And it all started with me being "weird". Looking back on it now, I can see it was "boiling frog" syndrome.

You have just described to a tee my mother's experience 😔

Iwasafool · 19/02/2024 15:07

LakieLady · 19/02/2024 14:12

They have a huge amount of discretion in how long the disregard can be applied. Providing that the claimant can show they're making a genuine effort to sell or otherwise dispose of a property, the DWP are usually fine with it.

One client of mine had the equity in the house disregarded for well over 3 years, because it involved protracted legal proceedings following a relationship breakdown and she had to get a court order to force her ex to sell it. Anecdotally, I've heard of the disregard being applied for 10 years or more, if that's how long it takes.

I'd say unless someone can guarantee that for 10 years plus the move will be more damaging than doing it now. That's my experience of kids.

Iwasafool · 19/02/2024 15:04

Crumpleton · 19/02/2024 13:30

Meanwhile he lives in a tent on common ground not being able to have his DC stay over night as he's got no pennies left in order to rent a place of his own to live in.

Edited

This is why I immediately agreed to selling and splitting 50/50. I think the damage to my children of seeing their father living a very different life to them would have done so much harm.

Picklestop · 19/02/2024 14:54

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 19/02/2024 12:35

Relationship breakdown is very different to repeated verbal abuse.

Why are people being so obtuse on this thread? It’s clearly not just an ‘I want to leave’ it’s a case of ‘I’m sick of being abused by my partner’ - the advice for dealing with an abusive situation is a whole world away from advice if you are just deciding you don’t love them anymore. Jeez.

The reason for the relationship breakdown is completely irrelevant to the legalities of the housing situation and it is you who is being a bit stupid if you think it does.

terfinthewild · 19/02/2024 14:42

I'm sorry you are going through this. Try your best to keep things as amicable as possible with him for the sake of your little one. The more you can work with him the better the chance this will be over with quickly.
I do think you need to sell, it seems to be the only thing you can do realistically.
I'm not sure why so many comments are labelling this man as 'abusive' because he called you names and seems frustrated and angry. By that definition 90% of Mumsnetters are 'abusive' too.

PrueRamsay · 19/02/2024 14:37

sandyhappypeople · 19/02/2024 14:05

What is the real benefit of this though?

Surely if he can't afford to pay the mortgage AND rent/buy somewhere else, he can refuse to contribute and she will be left paying the mortgage for the next 13 years on her own THEN be forced to give him half the equity that she's been solely paying for?

Unless there's more to it, or maybe it works if the kids are older, but it seems like a pretty shit deal to me? Surely selling the house and having a fresh start would be better all round?

It was far better for me when in this situation.

I paid the mortgage, he didn’t (he did pay standard CM) and if I hadn’t had the order, I would have had to sell the family home but not had enough money to buy anything for myself and the DC. I would have spent my share of the equity on rent whilst XH had a great time living in OW house and splashing his share around.

I was able to give the DC security for ten years and when we finally sold, I had gone back to uni to increase my earning potential and could afford to buy a small property of my own.

It really depends on individual circumstances but if OP is married and can afford the repayments she might want to consider it as an option.

LakieLady · 19/02/2024 14:27

Chickenkeev · 19/02/2024 02:28

Calling her weird and a narcissist is pretty nasty. Maybe he's god's gift but somehow I doubt it.

That's how my abusive ex started gaslighting me. I was "weird" for having different opinions from him about stuff, then it very quickly progressed to everyone we knew thinking I was crazy and that he was a saint for putting up with me.

After that, he got more and more emotionally abusive, isolated me from friends, became financially abusive etc. And it all started with me being "weird". Looking back on it now, I can see it was "boiling frog" syndrome.

LakieLady · 19/02/2024 14:12

AInightingale · 19/02/2024 08:58

Sorry yes I know about the six month rule, but I meant that the house does have to be sold eventually, I don't know how long they are prepared to give extensions for. The UC system is a lot stricter than the old Tas Credit one, where the former family home (with a former partner living there) was not regarded as capital. I think the only exceptions are that a person under 18/ over 60/ disabled lives there. Although if OP has only a tiny amount of equity it will be disregarded in any case. Depends what she stands to make from a sale, I suppose.

They have a huge amount of discretion in how long the disregard can be applied. Providing that the claimant can show they're making a genuine effort to sell or otherwise dispose of a property, the DWP are usually fine with it.

One client of mine had the equity in the house disregarded for well over 3 years, because it involved protracted legal proceedings following a relationship breakdown and she had to get a court order to force her ex to sell it. Anecdotally, I've heard of the disregard being applied for 10 years or more, if that's how long it takes.

sandyhappypeople · 19/02/2024 14:05

PrueRamsay · 19/02/2024 13:48

You have referred to him as both DP and DH. Which is it?

If DH, you may be able to get a Mesher order which would enable you to stay in house and sell when DD is 18.

If DP, you will probably have to sell now.

What is the real benefit of this though?

Surely if he can't afford to pay the mortgage AND rent/buy somewhere else, he can refuse to contribute and she will be left paying the mortgage for the next 13 years on her own THEN be forced to give him half the equity that she's been solely paying for?

Unless there's more to it, or maybe it works if the kids are older, but it seems like a pretty shit deal to me? Surely selling the house and having a fresh start would be better all round?

Blahblah34 · 19/02/2024 14:02

Far better for her to grow up in a smaller house/ flat with a happy mother than stay where she is with an unhappy one.

NotAgainWilson · 19/02/2024 13:53

PutMyFootIn · 19/02/2024 11:59

they're not married

And? That only means she is not protected when it comes to financial assets but the child interests still are protected by the courts whether they are married or not, or what? Do you think that just because they are not married the court would see the kids as bastards with no rights?

The Arrangements for the care of Children information would help the op see how the courts will try to ensure the child is protected and how to go if there is a battle for child residence (There is no such thing as custody in the UK)

NeedToChangeName · 19/02/2024 13:49

Godifeelsolow · 18/02/2024 23:19

@AInightingale He could afford to move out and rent, that’s why I was wondering *If I could afford to pay the mortgage and he agreed when the house was sold, to split the proceeds equally at that point, then Dd is older at least.

@Godifeelsolow if you were him, would you agree to this? I wouldn't, in his shoes

You'll be fine in the end. Hold on to that thought. Brighter days ahead

LittleBrenda · 19/02/2024 13:49

*Relationship breakdown is very different to repeated verbal abuse.

Why are people being so obtuse on this thread? It’s clearly not just an ‘I want to leave’ it’s a case of ‘I’m sick of being abused by my partner’ - the advice for dealing with an abusive situation is a whole world away from advice if you are just deciding you don’t love them anymore. Jeez.*

I understand that even less then.

How likely is it that an abusive man is going to agree to move out?

I completely understand why the OP would like to stay in the house, I also see why she needs to get out of this relationship.

But I don't think she should be advised to try and get the house to live in and that her partner should rent and then they should sell it when their five year old is eighteen. I don't think it's realistic and I'm not shocked that when people leave their partners, for whatever reason, that some of those partners do not wish to leave the house.

PrueRamsay · 19/02/2024 13:48

You have referred to him as both DP and DH. Which is it?

If DH, you may be able to get a Mesher order which would enable you to stay in house and sell when DD is 18.

If DP, you will probably have to sell now.

sandyhappypeople · 19/02/2024 13:43

Barney60 · 19/02/2024 13:11

ButterBastardBeans · Today 00:27

Godifeelsolow · Yesterday 22:48

@ButterBastardBeans In what way will
it make things easier?
Because the police will make him stay away from you and give you advice on how to make this happen - court orders and the like.

The police wont for VERBAL abuse , only if hes physically marked you.

Without knowing the full story I don't think the police is the way to go here, unless there's more to it then OP is saying, they just need to separate, but I think telling people not to go to the police unless someone has physically marked them is slightly misguided, there are all different levels of abuse and there are parts of the law that are now specifically designed to protect against abuse that is non physical.

Domestic abuse can involve physical violence, where an abuser harms someone leaving visible marks and scars. But it can also be psychological – something that is referred to as coercive and controlling behaviour.

The police don't have to rely on the whole 'well if he's not actually done anything to you, our hands are tied' bullshit that has been the party line for a long time, it's well known now that abusive behaviour can and will escalate, and can even lead to murder of a spouse or ex spouse if left unchecked, of which the police are always investigated as to why they didn't do more with the information they had. That's why more and more people are being prosecuted for non violent abuse, such as stalking, harassment and coercive and controlling behaviour, if you think you are a victim of any of those thing you SHOULD go to the police, not wait for it to escalate to violent abuse.

Crumpleton · 19/02/2024 13:30

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 18/02/2024 22:55

Oh and also according to some on here he needs to pay the ops mortgage and bills as well then maintenance on top!

Meanwhile he lives in a tent on common ground not being able to have his DC stay over night as he's got no pennies left in order to rent a place of his own to live in.

AlohaOptima · 19/02/2024 13:16

Firstly - get a sense of how much equity is in the house and explore wether you can remortgage to pay him his share and extend the term so that you can afford the payments

If Not - can he afford to buy you out? Then your daughter gets to spend half her time still in the family home. You can use your half of the equity to buy somewhere new.

If neither of those work, sadly the house will have to be sold and you will both have to move out.

Good luck OP, this bit is scary but in a year or two you will look back and be glad you did it.

Barney60 · 19/02/2024 13:11

ButterBastardBeans · Today 00:27

Godifeelsolow · Yesterday 22:48

@ButterBastardBeans In what way will
it make things easier?
Because the police will make him stay away from you and give you advice on how to make this happen - court orders and the like.

The police wont for VERBAL abuse , only if hes physically marked you.

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 19/02/2024 12:35

LittleBrenda · 19/02/2024 09:21

I’m truly baffled as to why you think it is upon the man to leave a jointly owned home when a relationship breaks down.
Me too. Why would anyone be 'shocked' by either parent 'outright refusing' to move out of the family home?

Relationship breakdown is very different to repeated verbal abuse.

Why are people being so obtuse on this thread? It’s clearly not just an ‘I want to leave’ it’s a case of ‘I’m sick of being abused by my partner’ - the advice for dealing with an abusive situation is a whole world away from advice if you are just deciding you don’t love them anymore. Jeez.