Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Recent-ish new highway rules that favour the pedestrian - I fear accidents

182 replies

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 18/02/2024 16:14

The stop and give way to a pedestrian crossing a road at a junction. That is what the majority of sensible road users have done anyway

Along with the above comes a new bit "Give way to pedestrians waiting to cross the road at a junction." This IMO will result in more accidents, EG, those that drive to close to the driver in front. The driver in front indicates to turn left like a good driver but at the junction off a main road is a pedestrian waiting to cross. The good driver stops to let the pedestrian cross and bang into the rear of the car goes the driver that was driving up their arse.

We often turn left into our close of a busy, main road and I always fear some seriously ignorant driver going into the rear of one of our cars if we had to suddenly pull up as there was another car shooting towards the main road as turning often has cars parked on one side.

If you are a good driver you should know this but here it goes: You are coming off a main, or road for that matter and hoping to turn left into another road. A pedestrian waiting to cross. You stop and there is a chance on the main/bigger roads the driver behind you is a moron and driving to close to you as you indicate and slow down before that. The rule applies to turning right as well but that is not as risky

AIBU to believe this new law will result in more harm than good, EG more car-to-car accidents when a car driver gives way to a waiting pedestrain/s to cross?
(I always slow down in advance to turn but have noted many times idiots right up th backside of our car and I think, what if I had to stop to allow someone across the road or there is something in the road and this new rule will just cause more accidents as many that have a licence have no idea how to drive safely and within the law)

I always try to keep a good distance as people turn into another road or their drive for that matter etc but I feel this new rule has not been well thought out

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/the-highway-code-8-changes-you-need-to-know-from-29-january-2022

""

The Highway Code: 8 changes you need to know from 29 January 2022

Rules for all types of road users have been updated in The Highway Code to improve the safety of people walking, cycling and riding horses.

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/the-highway-code-8-changes-you-need-to-know-from-29-january-2022

OP posts:
Thisisnotarehearsal · 19/02/2024 10:53

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 18/02/2024 16:17

I got bipped for trying to cross a road at a junction.

Yes me too, and on another occasion a white van sped up towards me as I started crossing at the junction he was heading towards.

If I hadn't leapt back I'd be dead or badly injured.

I did see one lady who got bipped at walk round to the driver door and start yelling at the driver about the new rules. I don't know if people don't know or don't care, but they seem to get ignored a lot

applesandmares · 19/02/2024 10:45

Someone I know died recently in an accident fuelled by this rule change. In my view it's dangerous for all road users for pedestrians to become emboldened to step out into the road at junctions despite the traffic.

Butterdishy · 19/02/2024 10:35

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 10:26

So we are traveling at 40 mph loads of people walking past the crossing, and the possibility of a clown just stepping on the crossing with a sharp turn onto the crossing just as I approach the cross, EG, 5 fee from the crossing - what speeds should drivers pass crossings when there are people walking past it and potneital for a clown to suddenly start crossing without looking just before the crossing as many do.

It's not really difficult to slow down a bit in anticipation of a pedestrian crossing. It's troubling that you think it is.

PandaCwtch · 19/02/2024 10:34

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 10:26

So we are traveling at 40 mph loads of people walking past the crossing, and the possibility of a clown just stepping on the crossing with a sharp turn onto the crossing just as I approach the cross, EG, 5 fee from the crossing - what speeds should drivers pass crossings when there are people walking past it and potneital for a clown to suddenly start crossing without looking just before the crossing as many do.

The design standards for zebra crossings discourage the placement of zebra crossings where the 85th percentile speed approach is more than 30mph, so they shouldn't exist in 40mph zones, unless there is other street furniture that reduces speed before the crossing, so you could suggest to your council that the speed limit here is inappropriate.

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 10:29

DisappearingGirl · 19/02/2024 10:16

Yes I totally agree with you OP. As a driver, if I am turning into a side road, I would always stop for a pedestrian who is already crossing the road (as people have said this has always been the law anyway) and I am always very aware of pedestrians who aren't looking properly and may be about to step out.

However if there is a pedestrian waiting to cross who is clearly checking the oncoming traffic, it seems odd to stop for them, when they are clearly not about to step out otherwise. Yes I worry about being rear-ended by a car on the main road who isn't expecting me to stop, especially as they can probably see that the side road in front of me is clear. And if I do get rear-ended I'd also likely hit the pedestrian.

It also leads to a weird stalemate where the pedestrian wasn't expecting me to stop, and I don't want to wave them over or make eye contact as I can't be sure there's not a car somewhere else that would make it unsafe. So then we're all waiting for each other.

I think reinforcing the existing rules about pedestrians who are already crossing, as well as being more careful about pedestrians and cyclists in general, is a good idea. However I think the new rule of a pedestrian on the pavement having right of way is dangerous and confusing, for the driver and the pedestrian.

Thnak you for a great post - you remind me of myself/family driving - there should be more good drivers like us and more education for pedestrians to make our raods safer for all of us

OP posts:
DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 10:26

Butterdishy · 19/02/2024 10:11

I said prepare to stop. Slow down, check mirrors etc. Of course you don't actually stop every time. If your regularly slamming your brakes at zebra crossings, your not driving safely at all.

So we are traveling at 40 mph loads of people walking past the crossing, and the possibility of a clown just stepping on the crossing with a sharp turn onto the crossing just as I approach the cross, EG, 5 fee from the crossing - what speeds should drivers pass crossings when there are people walking past it and potneital for a clown to suddenly start crossing without looking just before the crossing as many do.

OP posts:
DisappearingGirl · 19/02/2024 10:16

Yes I totally agree with you OP. As a driver, if I am turning into a side road, I would always stop for a pedestrian who is already crossing the road (as people have said this has always been the law anyway) and I am always very aware of pedestrians who aren't looking properly and may be about to step out.

However if there is a pedestrian waiting to cross who is clearly checking the oncoming traffic, it seems odd to stop for them, when they are clearly not about to step out otherwise. Yes I worry about being rear-ended by a car on the main road who isn't expecting me to stop, especially as they can probably see that the side road in front of me is clear. And if I do get rear-ended I'd also likely hit the pedestrian.

It also leads to a weird stalemate where the pedestrian wasn't expecting me to stop, and I don't want to wave them over or make eye contact as I can't be sure there's not a car somewhere else that would make it unsafe. So then we're all waiting for each other.

I think reinforcing the existing rules about pedestrians who are already crossing, as well as being more careful about pedestrians and cyclists in general, is a good idea. However I think the new rule of a pedestrian on the pavement having right of way is dangerous and confusing, for the driver and the pedestrian.

TinkyPo · 19/02/2024 10:15

OceanicBoundlessness · 19/02/2024 10:08

I think things have pretty much continued as they always did. Pedestrians tend to wait because of their sense of self preservation. Families do no want to teach their children to just cross indiscriminately.

Common sense has to come in. Eg if I want to turn right and have a queue of traffic behind who are going straight on and there's someone waiting to cross on the road I'm turning into, it's often quicker to just turn right so that the traffic can continue to flow rather than stop, wait for the person to realise I've stopped so they can cross etc.

I think this is half the point though. It’s about making streets more pedestrian focused and less car focused. Easier and quicker for pedestrians to get about and harder and slower for motorists. It’s starting to shift the balance away from the current situation where the car rules supreme. If the cars behind you have to wait I think that is a good thing. We are only going to move towards a greener, more child-friendly world if the reign of the car is curtailed.

Butterdishy · 19/02/2024 10:11

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 09:55

So a driver stops for every pedestrian that is near a crossing and then niote they are not crossing, then waits again for the next people to walk past?

I said prepare to stop. Slow down, check mirrors etc. Of course you don't actually stop every time. If your regularly slamming your brakes at zebra crossings, your not driving safely at all.

peachgreen · 19/02/2024 10:10

I don't drive, so I'm always Team Pedestrian, and I think this is a stupid rule. It's way safer for me to just wait than it is for the car to have to stop.

OceanicBoundlessness · 19/02/2024 10:08

I think things have pretty much continued as they always did. Pedestrians tend to wait because of their sense of self preservation. Families do no want to teach their children to just cross indiscriminately.

Common sense has to come in. Eg if I want to turn right and have a queue of traffic behind who are going straight on and there's someone waiting to cross on the road I'm turning into, it's often quicker to just turn right so that the traffic can continue to flow rather than stop, wait for the person to realise I've stopped so they can cross etc.

greengreengrass25 · 19/02/2024 10:08

I think pedestrians shouldn't be distracted by their mobile phones whilst they are trying to cross and pay attention

I always stop to let people cross road anyway but take your point about drivers behind

TinkyPo · 19/02/2024 10:05

I am predominantly a cyclist and pedestrian, but also an occasional car driver, in a city. I have noticed a slight increase in car drivers giving way to pedestrians waiting to cross the road but it is by no means universal. I like to believe that it is just that some car drivers are ignorant of the current legislation, and not that they purposely break the law, but there is probably a bit of both. I think more publicity of the new requirements is required and examples of exactly what it means in practice need to go in the media.

As a cyclist I do, when turning into a road, give way to pedestrians but I feel really vulnerable doing this sometimes, especially when turning right from a major to a minor road if I end up waiting at the mouth of the road, rather than my starting point on the main road.

I often find that pedestrians are surprised that I have stopped. I do not wave them across, as to do so could put them at risk of crossing without considering other traffic, but at times there has been a bit of a stand off where we are both waiting for the other one to go. I also often get pedestrians encouraging me to keep cycling through a zebra crossing that they are waiting at and I am approaching, which is sweet.

CasperGutman · 19/02/2024 10:03

The situation I'm more concerned about is turning right across traffic into a side road. There may have been no pedestrian around when you approached, but then you've waited some time for a gap in oncoming traffic. When a gap that's just about big enough finally arises, you may very well forget to check behind you, most likely in your blind spot, and miss a pedestrian starting to cross the side road. Even if you spot them, your only option may be to stop in the path of oncoming traffic, risking a serious accident if they don't stop in time.

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 09:55

Butterdishy · 19/02/2024 09:50

Yes. If they're near enough to step out in front of you, they are near enough that you should be prepared to stop for them.

So a driver stops for every pedestrian that is near a crossing and then niote they are not crossing, then waits again for the next people to walk past?

OP posts:
Waffleson · 19/02/2024 09:54

I've no issue with giving way to a pedestrian when I'm turning from a major to a minor road. But I frequently use a crossroads with poor visibility where I am going straightover, from a minor road crossing the major road to continue on the minor road. I've got a job to keep track of the traffic in three directions. The other day I got huffed at by a driver on the opposite side who had stopped and waived a pedestrian across in front of me. In that situation I think I have right of way, though I may be wrong. The thing is, my brain can't cope with having to look in all those directions AND anticipate a pedestrian stepping out in front of me while I'm part way across a dangerous junction.

I tend to use the rule of thumb that I always let pedestrians cross unless by doing so I'm significantly increasing the chance of an accident.

OceanicBoundlessness · 19/02/2024 09:53

Anyone driving needs to be aware that the car in front might not turn immediately for all manner of reasons.
Often vans are parked illegally so a car needs to wait for an oncoming car to exit the junction so that there's space for them to turn, for example.

Butterdishy · 19/02/2024 09:50

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 09:47

@Butterdishy
"If a pedestrian is anywhere near a zebra crossing, as a driver you should be prepared to stop. It is your responsibility to drive according to your surroundings"

Define "anywhere near"??

Does that include those walking double speed on pavement close to edge and cut across the road onto the crossing?

Does that include those that stand at the foot of a zebra crossing nattering on their mobile or another person/s?

Yes. If they're near enough to step out in front of you, they are near enough that you should be prepared to stop for them.

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 09:48

OLDbutnotforgotten · 19/02/2024 09:39

It sounds like a great idea, but I remember reading a quote that said ‘ the graveyard is full of people who had the right of way’

Too many drivers pay no consideration to pedestrians, and I’d never risk stepping out onto road when a car was coming.

Exactly that.

IMO, often good drivers are good pedestrians.

OP posts:
DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 09:47

@Butterdishy
"If a pedestrian is anywhere near a zebra crossing, as a driver you should be prepared to stop. It is your responsibility to drive according to your surroundings"

Define "anywhere near"??

Does that include those walking double speed on pavement close to edge and cut across the road onto the crossing?

Does that include those that stand at the foot of a zebra crossing nattering on their mobile or another person/s?

OP posts:
OLDbutnotforgotten · 19/02/2024 09:39

It sounds like a great idea, but I remember reading a quote that said ‘ the graveyard is full of people who had the right of way’

Too many drivers pay no consideration to pedestrians, and I’d never risk stepping out onto road when a car was coming.

Butterdishy · 19/02/2024 09:37

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 09:23

At junctions only theese new rules apply - lets not get confused.

As I said, I've always given way when a pedestrian is in the road. My fear now is driving up a main road, the idiot behind driving too closely, you slow down a decent distance from the left turn, indicate in advance and then note a pedestrian appears from behind a tall suv/van ect and you stop to give way but the clown behind you that expected you to turn left is driving to close not paying attention crases into your car causing all sort of problems.

Pedestrians need to take care as well. As well as beig a good driver I'm a pedestrain as well so look out for both groups when walking or driving

At zebra crossings, the ignorant pedestrian and there are a few that are walking along at speed straight on then before reaching the crossing step in front of your car near, a few feet from a crossing are a nightmare - often these types are on their smart phone

Everyone needed to take responsibility and this is why idiots, proper idiots that don't indicate wind me up - its against the law not to indicate appropriately and not only aids other drivers driving but also aids pedestrians to a good degree. Yes, I never take it for granted that someone indicating will actually turn at the next turning or pull over but often the problem is with the fools that dont indicate when they are supposed to.

You also have the bicycle ridders to contend with along with the mass of scooter riders that are trying to make a livivng

If a pedestrian is anywhere near a zebra crossing, as a driver you should be prepared to stop. It is your responsibility to drive according to your surroundings.

Hereyoume · 19/02/2024 09:35

professorcunning · 19/02/2024 08:49

I'm a driver and I agree with them. You're all for personal responsibility until you're the one expected to show it! The car driver is the one in control of the dangerous vehicle so they are the one with the greater level of personal responsibility. I see it similar to owning a gun. If you own something with the potential to harm others, it is your responsibility to ensure that harm does not occur. Whether that be locking up your guns or driving carefully, the onus is on you, the license owner, to follow the rules and keep others safe.

So we should pedestrians walk down the motorway?

After all the drivers have a greater responsibility.

NotTerfNorCis · 19/02/2024 09:28

I nearly got run over crossing a side road on foot a few weeks ago. I hadn't been paying attention and neither had the driver, who took a fast right turn into the road. The weird thing was that I remember being in the road and thinking, he'll see me, he'll slow, but he actually sped up! I had to dive out the way.

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 09:24

Didoreththeterf · 19/02/2024 09:21

I am a driver, but I am responsible driver who cares about the safety of more vulnerable road users, and not an entitled twat.

Great post, please apply to pedestrians as well that step out into a road without looking

OP posts: