Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Recent-ish new highway rules that favour the pedestrian - I fear accidents

182 replies

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 18/02/2024 16:14

The stop and give way to a pedestrian crossing a road at a junction. That is what the majority of sensible road users have done anyway

Along with the above comes a new bit "Give way to pedestrians waiting to cross the road at a junction." This IMO will result in more accidents, EG, those that drive to close to the driver in front. The driver in front indicates to turn left like a good driver but at the junction off a main road is a pedestrian waiting to cross. The good driver stops to let the pedestrian cross and bang into the rear of the car goes the driver that was driving up their arse.

We often turn left into our close of a busy, main road and I always fear some seriously ignorant driver going into the rear of one of our cars if we had to suddenly pull up as there was another car shooting towards the main road as turning often has cars parked on one side.

If you are a good driver you should know this but here it goes: You are coming off a main, or road for that matter and hoping to turn left into another road. A pedestrian waiting to cross. You stop and there is a chance on the main/bigger roads the driver behind you is a moron and driving to close to you as you indicate and slow down before that. The rule applies to turning right as well but that is not as risky

AIBU to believe this new law will result in more harm than good, EG more car-to-car accidents when a car driver gives way to a waiting pedestrain/s to cross?
(I always slow down in advance to turn but have noted many times idiots right up th backside of our car and I think, what if I had to stop to allow someone across the road or there is something in the road and this new rule will just cause more accidents as many that have a licence have no idea how to drive safely and within the law)

I always try to keep a good distance as people turn into another road or their drive for that matter etc but I feel this new rule has not been well thought out

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/the-highway-code-8-changes-you-need-to-know-from-29-january-2022

""

The Highway Code: 8 changes you need to know from 29 January 2022

Rules for all types of road users have been updated in The Highway Code to improve the safety of people walking, cycling and riding horses.

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/the-highway-code-8-changes-you-need-to-know-from-29-january-2022

OP posts:
Bourbon75 · 19/02/2024 14:09

I don't let pedestrians cross if I think the car behind will bump into me. It happens alot near me. Busy roundabout and whether going left, straight on or right if there's someone waiting UNLESS i'm virtually stationary anyway i keep going as i'm not risking damage to my car or my children being injured. Imo the pedestrians need to wait until it is safe to cross, not expect cars to brake unexpectedly.

ConsistentlyElectrifiedElves · 19/02/2024 14:02

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 18/02/2024 16:17

I got bipped for trying to cross a road at a junction.

There was an incident outside our office a little while ago.

Pedestrian crossing the road, in line with the new rules, car driver hooted at him, so the pedestrian just stood in the road and wouldn't let the car past!

Cue the driver going totally apeshit at the pedestrian, who was shouting back about the new Highway Code! This went on for about 10 minutes!

Think the pedestrian finally got bored and went on his way.

I know the new rules, but both as a pedestrian and a driver I take extra care. Someone let me cross earlier today and it caught me by surprise as it is a rule that seems to have passed many people by.

Ginmonkeyagain · 19/02/2024 13:34

I live in London - I assume everyone is a shit awful driver and approach crossing the road on that basis.

StrawberrySquash · 19/02/2024 13:32

MintsPi · 18/02/2024 23:47

Since the law was clarified only one driver has given way to me as they turn into a side road. I walk the school run every day to give some perspective. Just today I saw a pedestrian being beeped at for not giving way to a car that he had priority over.

These rules have changed nothing.

Same.

And as a pedestrian I don't trust drivers to stop. 90% don't even seem to know it's my priority. So I stand at the side of the road and wait. But I can honestly see why a lot don't, given other road users. If all pedestrians just started taking the space I suspect it would cause problems and not a few pedestrian -car collisions.

The rule about giving way to a pedestrian waiting to cross doesn't make sense to me. It's likely to cause a driver to clog up the main road. If you have a stream of pedestrians they could be stuck there for ages. Especially bad if the driver is turning right.

BogRollBOGOF · 19/02/2024 13:23

The most useful aspect of the rule change was clarifying assertive cycling positions to give better safety to cyclists.

As a pedestrian, I still look carefully and only cross when safe. As a driver I still approach junctions and crossings with caution and give way if safe. If it's safe behind me to pull up, I'd rather get a dithery pedestrian safely out of the way. I can't change the behaviour of someone else tailgating me, particularly when I'm already clearly indicating and going slowly ready to respond to any hazards around a corner. Stopping and causing a rear end shunt is not safe driving particularly if you're aware the the driver following is impatient/ not being attentive.

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 13:21

zaffa · 19/02/2024 13:13

But surely this is the case in all circs - if the driver behind is too close they will hit you if they don't slow down and you do?
I can't decide not to slow down because of an idiot behind me, especially if there is a risk that I will hit something in front of me if I don't slow down.
My expectation is that driver A wishes to turn (left or right) so in good time, they indicate and slow down. If necessary, they stop (perhaps poor visibility, perhaps pedestrian, perhaps other car in road manoeuvring). If idiot drives B behind doesn't respond to signal and decreased speed, then yes, they will hit driver A, but driver A is unlikely to hit anything else as a result.
If the car behind you was going too exceptionally fast, they'd hit you as soon as you slowed to turn - regardless of pedestrian.
If you get hit by the car behind, it's likely that you and car behind will have damaged bumpers etc. unless car behind is a lunatic, one assumes they will at least attempt to stop.
If you hit a pedestrian, the results are far more catastrophic than car behind you not stopping and rear ending you (unless they are lunatic, then everyone is going to be injured very badly, but again probably more so the pedestrian).

So to sum up my thoughts - I'd rather some idiot rear ended me than I hit a child or pedestrian or cyclist. Perhaps next time they won't drive so fast and will leave stopping time.

This thread is about just that. Nowhere does it state the driver in front would rather hit a pedestrian. This is why I advocate good driving that all drivers indicate, slow down, read the roads better and as per rules, pedestrians take some responsibility like many do but a lot dont like the examples I have give.

When another driver is driving dangerously behind you and hits you in the rear of your vehicle at at times speed off, it is better to anticipate the situation like I do but an equally ignorant of the rules pedestrains/s do not help

I refer you to my previous post here post and link to the responsibilities a pedestrian has.

I'll let you have the last word as my posts are clear about everyone taking responsibility.

OP posts:
zaffa · 19/02/2024 13:13

But surely this is the case in all circs - if the driver behind is too close they will hit you if they don't slow down and you do?
I can't decide not to slow down because of an idiot behind me, especially if there is a risk that I will hit something in front of me if I don't slow down.
My expectation is that driver A wishes to turn (left or right) so in good time, they indicate and slow down. If necessary, they stop (perhaps poor visibility, perhaps pedestrian, perhaps other car in road manoeuvring). If idiot drives B behind doesn't respond to signal and decreased speed, then yes, they will hit driver A, but driver A is unlikely to hit anything else as a result.
If the car behind you was going too exceptionally fast, they'd hit you as soon as you slowed to turn - regardless of pedestrian.
If you get hit by the car behind, it's likely that you and car behind will have damaged bumpers etc. unless car behind is a lunatic, one assumes they will at least attempt to stop.
If you hit a pedestrian, the results are far more catastrophic than car behind you not stopping and rear ending you (unless they are lunatic, then everyone is going to be injured very badly, but again probably more so the pedestrian).

So to sum up my thoughts - I'd rather some idiot rear ended me than I hit a child or pedestrian or cyclist. Perhaps next time they won't drive so fast and will leave stopping time.

Butterdishy · 19/02/2024 13:04

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 13:00

Are you saying there are no rules for pedestrians and its ok for them to step into the road without looking and walk into the road before a crossing and not pay attention along with loitering at a crossing - these are my points and they are written in law that a pedestrian also have a responsibility.

I've responded many times to your posts but your "attitude" knowledge is severely lacking about pedestrians and the responsibility they need to take when crossing the road.

I'll let you have the last word as I've more than covered the good aspects of driving and the responsibilities of both the drivers and pedestrians but it seems to shoot past over your head.

from Gov site - yes, really there are rules for pedestrians

Rule 18At all crossings. When using any type of crossing you should

  • always check that the traffic has stopped before you start to cross or push a pram onto a crossing
  • always cross between the studs or over the zebra markings. Do not cross at the side of the crossing or on the zig-zag lines, as it can be dangerous.
You MUST NOT loiter on any type of crossing.

Rule 19Zebra crossings. Give traffic plenty of time to see you and to stop before you start to cross. Vehicles will need more time when the road is slippery. Wait until traffic has stopped from both directions or the road is clear before crossing. Remember that traffic does not have to stop until someone has moved onto the crossing. Drivers and riders should give way to pedestrians waiting to cross and MUST give way to pedestrians on a zebra crossing (see Rule H2). Keep looking both ways, and listening, in case a driver or rider has not seen you and attempts to overtake a vehicle that has stopped.

I'm not saying that at all. Your responsibility to drive safely is not dependent upon other people following the law. A pedestrian should not step into the road without looking, but you should be driving in such a way that you would not hit them if they did.

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 13:00

Butterdishy · 19/02/2024 12:45

Your attitude is terrible. At the end of the day, whether driver or pedestrian, we can only control our own actions. You are responsible for how you drive, if a pedestrian does something you consider stupid, like cross at a pedestrian crossing, it is your responsibility to ensure you don't run them over. It's really that simple.

Are you saying there are no rules for pedestrians and its ok for them to step into the road without looking and walk into the road before a crossing and not pay attention along with loitering at a crossing - these are my points and they are written in law that a pedestrian also have a responsibility.

I've responded many times to your posts but your "attitude" knowledge is severely lacking about pedestrians and the responsibility they need to take when crossing the road.

I'll let you have the last word as I've more than covered the good aspects of driving and the responsibilities of both the drivers and pedestrians but it seems to shoot past over your head.

from Gov site - yes, really there are rules for pedestrians

Rule 18At all crossings. When using any type of crossing you should

  • always check that the traffic has stopped before you start to cross or push a pram onto a crossing
  • always cross between the studs or over the zebra markings. Do not cross at the side of the crossing or on the zig-zag lines, as it can be dangerous.
You MUST NOT loiter on any type of crossing.

Rule 19Zebra crossings. Give traffic plenty of time to see you and to stop before you start to cross. Vehicles will need more time when the road is slippery. Wait until traffic has stopped from both directions or the road is clear before crossing. Remember that traffic does not have to stop until someone has moved onto the crossing. Drivers and riders should give way to pedestrians waiting to cross and MUST give way to pedestrians on a zebra crossing (see Rule H2). Keep looking both ways, and listening, in case a driver or rider has not seen you and attempts to overtake a vehicle that has stopped.

The Highway Code - Introduction - Guidance - GOV.UK

Who The Highway Code is for, how it's worded, the consequences of not following the rules, self-driving vehicles, and the hierarchy of road users (Rules H1 to H3).

https://www.gov.uk/guidance/the-highway-code/introduction#ruleh2

OP posts:
SiriAlexa · 19/02/2024 12:53

I think the new rules can be a little risky for pedestrians. But I notice a lot of pedestrians just step out without looking anyway, so regardless of the rules it's safest always to slow down and check for pedestrians that are about to cross.

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 12:46

greengreengrass25 · 19/02/2024 11:39

I think as a pedestrian I would definitely still stop and wait or wait till car had gone

We do that bue even when a driver gives way, we continue to look and listen as far as possible for those that overtake, undertake or those on push bikes and illegal e-scooters etc.

OP posts:
Butterdishy · 19/02/2024 12:45

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 12:41

It's not really difficult for a pedestrian to approach a crossing and only cross at the crossing (where there is a crossing) and take responsibility as well by looking - it is really as easy as that. It's also in the rules for people not to loiter at crossing like the ones I mentioned and they have a responsibility as well and that is not just my judgement but the rules as well - look them up.

No one is entitled and drivers working together following the rules makes the roads safer.

Many thanks

Your attitude is terrible. At the end of the day, whether driver or pedestrian, we can only control our own actions. You are responsible for how you drive, if a pedestrian does something you consider stupid, like cross at a pedestrian crossing, it is your responsibility to ensure you don't run them over. It's really that simple.

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 12:44

pokebowls · 19/02/2024 12:15

@DistingusedSocialCommentator

Thnak you for a great post - you remind me of myself/family driving - there should be more good drivers like us and more education for pedestrians to make our raods safer for all of us

I'm not sure you should be self labelling yourself as a good driver when you have already admitted to struggling with the concept of

"If a pedestrian is anywhere near a zebra crossing, as a driver you should be prepared to stop. It is your responsibility to drive according to your surroundings"

And you have stated you only stop when someone is already walking on the road when it has been the case for as long as I can remember that drivers should stop when they see someone waiting at a zebra crossing and now at any road crossing.

Hello

I dod label myself as a good driver and many have said that as well as to my OH. They often comment if sat in the car. Any good driver can find it challenging just like I have posted and I drive defensively, IE considers all other drivers and pedestrians as ill-informed and unaware of the rules and so far, that has helped us.

Many years ago I took an advanced driver course and passed it with flying colours - I did this to be even safer on the roads for all that use them and potentially lower our car insurance premiums

OP posts:
DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 12:41

Butterdishy · 19/02/2024 10:35

It's not really difficult to slow down a bit in anticipation of a pedestrian crossing. It's troubling that you think it is.

It's not really difficult for a pedestrian to approach a crossing and only cross at the crossing (where there is a crossing) and take responsibility as well by looking - it is really as easy as that. It's also in the rules for people not to loiter at crossing like the ones I mentioned and they have a responsibility as well and that is not just my judgement but the rules as well - look them up.

No one is entitled and drivers working together following the rules makes the roads safer.

Many thanks

OP posts:
pokebowls · 19/02/2024 12:15

@DistingusedSocialCommentator

Thnak you for a great post - you remind me of myself/family driving - there should be more good drivers like us and more education for pedestrians to make our raods safer for all of us

I'm not sure you should be self labelling yourself as a good driver when you have already admitted to struggling with the concept of

"If a pedestrian is anywhere near a zebra crossing, as a driver you should be prepared to stop. It is your responsibility to drive according to your surroundings"

And you have stated you only stop when someone is already walking on the road when it has been the case for as long as I can remember that drivers should stop when they see someone waiting at a zebra crossing and now at any road crossing.

pokebowls · 19/02/2024 12:09

@DistingusedSocialCommentator

So we are traveling at 40 mph loads of people walking past the crossing, and the possibility of a clown just stepping on the crossing with a sharp turn onto the crossing just as I approach the cross, EG, 5 fee from the crossing - what speeds should drivers pass crossings when there are people walking past it and potneital for a clown to suddenly start crossing without looking just before the crossing as many do.

Well duh. Yeah. Of course you are on constant vigilance at crossings. Whatever the law was and is say you aren't telling us you just plough through them with no care or awareness of potential pedestrians crossing

SinnerBoy · 19/02/2024 11:51

I cross cautiously, I try to make eye contact with the driver and will wait, if they aren't going to stop. Many do so now, perhaps because we don't live in a very overcrowded city.

I was out cycling yesterday and it was gridlocked with people going to the coast and I had couple of comments from evidently frustrated drivers and some who moved left, to stop me progressing on the inside.

That's pretty unusual.

Isitovernow123 · 19/02/2024 11:42

I deliberately step out on the minor road - cars do wait. The idiots are the ones who flash to let cars turning right across their lane into the minor road as they don’t look for pedestrians.

greengreengrass25 · 19/02/2024 11:39

I think as a pedestrian I would definitely still stop and wait or wait till car had gone

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 19/02/2024 11:34

As a pedestrian I hated it when this new rule came in. Not knowing if the car driver would stop or not I paused to check, some would shoot by as they always had done, others would stop then look irritated at me because I wasn't moving quick enough for them. I found myself marooned in the middle of a side road squeezed between two moving vehicles on more than one occasion.
Thankfully most people seem to have reverted back to the original behaviour of pedestrians looking and waiting until the road is clear before stepping out. I think this is much safer, its the pedestrian who is the vulnerable one and I would rather be the one making the decision as to when its safe to cross than be reliant on a driver being observant or not. Knowing I was the one who was in the right is not going to be much comfort for my grieving loved ones when I've been knocked down.

Bearbookagainandagain · 19/02/2024 11:27

Hereyoume · 19/02/2024 08:36

Why?

It's easier and safer for pedestrians to just open their eyes and wait.

Easier according to who? Drivers?

It's very easy to stop a car. Open your eyes, see pedestrians crossing, apply break.

deragod · 19/02/2024 11:15

Oh, I can see we have got some cases of car brain, it is such an awful disease.

Pedestrians did not passed the test to gain a privilege, they do not have to prove they are sane. Is killing a child, a drunk, a person having psychotic episode a just price for 'being right'?
With privilege comes responsibility. Driving a car is a privilege.

Half of Europe has laws that absolutely favour pedestrians. Even when it is a pedestrian that changes directions. And it is forbidden by law to park on pavements....och, how it is possible :O.

Seriously, some compassion for more vulnerable in the society won't kill you. We all should want live among caring people, with strong social cohesion instead of a darwinian jungle it is now

SinnerBoy · 19/02/2024 11:08

DistingusedSocialCommentator · Today 09:47

Define "anywhere near"??

Isn't it within the zigzag line area? I always slow down if people are near, if it takes a few seconds to realise that they aren't going to cross, it's no big deal. Us drivers need to drive to the conditions and if that means at least than the speed limit, so be it.

I don't care if White Van Man is blaring the horn behind me, I'm not going to run someone over.

PansyOatZebra · 19/02/2024 10:57

Crackwillow · 18/02/2024 23:59

The onus is on pooer drivers, not pedestrians. Bumping another car won't kill, but knocking a pedestrian down might. The car has been king for far too long. More rights for pedestrians can only be a good thing.

This.

I walk far more than I drive and I very much welcome the pedestrian related changes because car drivers have for too long shown complete lack of consideration to pedestrians.

My walk into town includes three zebra crossings and it’s shocking the number of people who don’t stop but simply put there hand up thinking that’s acceptable…

I also have one junction to cross where I am on the main road and have right of way and I always make sure the cars stop to let me go.

Car driver attitudes need to change and I completely agree with your statement that cars have been “king” far too long.

Didoreththeterf · 19/02/2024 10:54

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 10:26

So we are traveling at 40 mph loads of people walking past the crossing, and the possibility of a clown just stepping on the crossing with a sharp turn onto the crossing just as I approach the cross, EG, 5 fee from the crossing - what speeds should drivers pass crossings when there are people walking past it and potneital for a clown to suddenly start crossing without looking just before the crossing as many do.

If you are approaching zebra crossings at 40mph when there are pedestrians near you are a dangerous driver.
I drive across zebra crossings in my local town on an almost daily basis - if there are pedestrians on the pavement adjacent I slow to 10mph or less, as I am anticipating the potential hazard.

Swipe left for the next trending thread