Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Recent-ish new highway rules that favour the pedestrian - I fear accidents

182 replies

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 18/02/2024 16:14

The stop and give way to a pedestrian crossing a road at a junction. That is what the majority of sensible road users have done anyway

Along with the above comes a new bit "Give way to pedestrians waiting to cross the road at a junction." This IMO will result in more accidents, EG, those that drive to close to the driver in front. The driver in front indicates to turn left like a good driver but at the junction off a main road is a pedestrian waiting to cross. The good driver stops to let the pedestrian cross and bang into the rear of the car goes the driver that was driving up their arse.

We often turn left into our close of a busy, main road and I always fear some seriously ignorant driver going into the rear of one of our cars if we had to suddenly pull up as there was another car shooting towards the main road as turning often has cars parked on one side.

If you are a good driver you should know this but here it goes: You are coming off a main, or road for that matter and hoping to turn left into another road. A pedestrian waiting to cross. You stop and there is a chance on the main/bigger roads the driver behind you is a moron and driving to close to you as you indicate and slow down before that. The rule applies to turning right as well but that is not as risky

AIBU to believe this new law will result in more harm than good, EG more car-to-car accidents when a car driver gives way to a waiting pedestrain/s to cross?
(I always slow down in advance to turn but have noted many times idiots right up th backside of our car and I think, what if I had to stop to allow someone across the road or there is something in the road and this new rule will just cause more accidents as many that have a licence have no idea how to drive safely and within the law)

I always try to keep a good distance as people turn into another road or their drive for that matter etc but I feel this new rule has not been well thought out

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/the-highway-code-8-changes-you-need-to-know-from-29-january-2022

""

The Highway Code: 8 changes you need to know from 29 January 2022

Rules for all types of road users have been updated in The Highway Code to improve the safety of people walking, cycling and riding horses.

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/the-highway-code-8-changes-you-need-to-know-from-29-january-2022

OP posts:
Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 19/02/2024 20:37

OP: please don't just quote selectively from the Highway Code. You've just told us that when you saw pedestrians about to cross the minor road you "often did a slight pap of the horn just to make them aware"? That is not what your horn is for! And sounds quite an intimidating thing to do to someone who has the right of way, over you in your car.

@sleepyscientist do you really think pedestrians are safer if they travel some way down the minor road before crossing it? why should they make a detour, at the same time reducing their visibility, and their own ability to see traffic approaching the junction? This is contrary to all road safety advice, which is about maximising visibility and sight lines! (and expecting drivers to look where they're going and stop rather than mowing down more vulnerable road users/ crashing into other vehicles whether moving or stopped)

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 20:36

DdraigGoch · 19/02/2024 17:06

AIBU to believe this new law will result in more harm than good, EG more car-to-car accidents when a car driver gives way to a waiting pedestrain/s to cross?

Why is a car-on-car shunt more harm than car-on-pedestrian? One of those will result in a serious injury, the other is fixable and claimable on insurance.

FGS read the posts again, no one but no one is suggesting that.

What I have noted and tried to fix in a later post is to remind those pedestrians who think they have a right of way on every road and step onto the roads without stopping and looking read my post about pedestrian rules when they cross the road/s.

OP posts:
DistingusedSocialCommentator · 19/02/2024 20:32

zaffa · 19/02/2024 18:33

But @DistingusedSocialCommentator in the circumstances that not everyone takes responsibility, then the most vulnerable must be protected. Pedestrians are the most vulnerable. So even if they are irresponsible, they must have the most protection.

@zaffa

You are not clear, please try again as I'm confused about "the most vulnerable must be protected.." - are you saying driver will knock over a fool who stepped into the road without looking, following the highway code, knock over the person in order to avoid being hit in the rear of your car?

Sorry If I have completely misunderstood you

OP posts:
PawsisShady · 19/02/2024 20:27

There's a junction in our town centre that worked perfectly well. It had traffic lights and a crossing
They removed those

So now turning from the high street into the side road to get out of town can take 10-15 mins as there's a constant flow of pedestrians across the side road who you have to give way to. Being a city centre it's busy!
Then when you try and turn they dart in front of you and you're waiting again

Why they removed the traffic lights and crossing I have no idea

tiger2691 · 19/02/2024 20:19

AhBiscuits · 18/02/2024 16:19

A minor rear end bump is pretty inconsequential in the grand scheme of things.

If you're on a motorbike it's not, we don't have a cage around us.

zaffa · 19/02/2024 18:33

But @DistingusedSocialCommentator in the circumstances that not everyone takes responsibility, then the most vulnerable must be protected. Pedestrians are the most vulnerable. So even if they are irresponsible, they must have the most protection.

fauconberg · 19/02/2024 18:25

Hugely dangerous. As the vulnerable road user pedestrians should never assume the right of way, and I say that as one predominantly. When going overseas few counties adopt have this policy and our younger people assume cars will stop, ditto foreign drivers here who will be unaware of this rule

DdraigGoch · 19/02/2024 18:18

professorcunning · 19/02/2024 17:56

So we should let cars drive on the pavement?

After all the pedestrians have a greater responsibility.

They already do drive on the pavement.

deragod · 19/02/2024 18:17

Pedestrians are responsible because we do not have a choice.
Car brained people who have legs purely for decorative purposes are not.
They do not care if someone will be killed because they parked on the pavement, because they speed, or someone might need the space more (for example someone who is disabled) etc.
They do not think how mother with a pram or a person on wheelchair is supposed to use pavement when cars are parked there.
Losers (for example 8 years old going to school) are supposed to understand that the bigger and safer, who had to demonstrated that understands road code are the priority.

I am surrounded by lots of stupid people. Men who park their cars on the lawn opposite my house, teenagers swimming in the Thames etc.
Can I stab them? Is capital punishment really the standard we aspire to?
Or is it only the privilege of drivers?

Butterdishy · 19/02/2024 18:06

You should be traveling at a speed where you can observe your surroundings and come to a stop in decent time. If you're slamming your breaks on, risking the car behind hitting you, it's because you're going too fast and reacting too late.

Butterdishy · 19/02/2024 18:02

Frankly, it's terrifying that so many drivers seem to view the highway code as optional when pedestrians are involved.

professorcunning · 19/02/2024 17:56

Hereyoume · 19/02/2024 09:35

So we should pedestrians walk down the motorway?

After all the drivers have a greater responsibility.

So we should let cars drive on the pavement?

After all the pedestrians have a greater responsibility.

DdraigGoch · 19/02/2024 17:23

Hereyoume · 19/02/2024 09:35

So we should pedestrians walk down the motorway?

After all the drivers have a greater responsibility.

Don't be ridiculous, motorways are dedicated to motor vehicles, the clue is in the name. Streets are shared between all users and the ones in heavy metal boxes need to drive appropriately.

The Dutch have "auto te gast" on their signs. Making it clear that on residential streets, cars are guests and must give way to pedestrians and bicycles.

SinnerBoy · 19/02/2024 17:15

OK, own up! Which one of you was driving a dark orange Range rover 10 minutes ago? When I turned onto the roundabout and waited for Darby and Joan to cross from the pedestrian island?

Come on. enquiring minds want to know!

DdraigGoch · 19/02/2024 17:12

sleepyscientist · 19/02/2024 07:20

It's who they hit you are protecting as they are taking the force of the collision. The legal side of it is covered by insurance anyway. If the pedestrian was banned from crossing at a junction and had to walk say 10-15m into the side road to cross no one would get injured as people would have chance to stop once into the side road if a hazard was already in the road.

Why the hell should the pedestrian go an extra 30m out of their way because some impatient SUV driver can't wait five seconds for the car in front to have a clear way into the side road? Deal with the guilty party, don't punish the victim.

DdraigGoch · 19/02/2024 17:06

AIBU to believe this new law will result in more harm than good, EG more car-to-car accidents when a car driver gives way to a waiting pedestrain/s to cross?

Why is a car-on-car shunt more harm than car-on-pedestrian? One of those will result in a serious injury, the other is fixable and claimable on insurance.

pokebowls · 19/02/2024 16:53

I'm not sure what your post is wanting. Is it a rant about pedestrians having priority? Is it specifically the situation of pedestrians having priority over crossing roads where you are turning left into that road?

TempestTost · 19/02/2024 16:52

Butterdishy · 19/02/2024 14:29

The law says differently. It shouldn't be "breaking unexpectedly" unless the pedestrian is invisible.

But you need to be able to see them in time in order to break safely at whatever the speed is.

That isn't just about visibility, it is about what else is going on that the driver is paying attention to. Coming out of a roundabout, the driver is also going to be paying attention to other cars coming out of the roundabout, and when a pedestrian appears, the driven still needs to check behind to make sure there is enough distance for the car following to stop too. It's not just academic, it isn't safe to stop if the car behind is too close.

Given where crossings are on a lot of roundabouts it almost seems like they are placed so the drivers won't be able to stop in time!

TempestTost · 19/02/2024 16:45

I don't love pedestrians crossing at any junction, not even when I am a pedestrian.

It works fine in some settings like quiet residential neighbourhoods. Or two lanes with good visibility and traffic isn't too fast.

But where you have extra lanes, the traffic tends to come fast, or it's very busy (or a combination of these often) it seems to me like there are too many things that can go wrong, and the person on the losing end is likely to be the pedestrian.

Yes, ideally cars would drive properly, not follow too closely, and so on. But you can't base complex safety systems on the assumption that everyone will always do the right thing. There will always always be failures and errors.

What I have noticed more recently where I live is intersections and crossings that seem increasingly fraught because of extra bike lanes and weird crossing signals. Next to my mum's house you have to prepare to cross a bike lane, a line of parked cars, and two wide lanes of traffic that is often rather fast and includes busses. Worse, there are these green bike lane markers all along that seem to frig up my sense of how far away the cars are, especially where they curve around corners.

No way I'd cross that street unless in a designated spot, it's too risky. Saying I have the right of way really doesn't change that.

PrincessTeaSet · 19/02/2024 16:22

TheLostOnes · 18/02/2024 16:18

Isn't the point that the aim is to reduce the number of car into pedestrian accidents, which are far more dangerous than car into car accidents? Also, this was brought in two years ago - not particularly new. Has it caused loads of accidents so far? Maybe you've heard that it has?

Hardly anyone actually does give way to pedestrians waiting to cross . That will be why there are no more accidents caused by waiting cars, if this is the case. More likely to get beeped at or accelerated at if you try to cross!

phoenixrosehere · 19/02/2024 16:17

StrawberrySquash · 19/02/2024 13:32

Same.

And as a pedestrian I don't trust drivers to stop. 90% don't even seem to know it's my priority. So I stand at the side of the road and wait. But I can honestly see why a lot don't, given other road users. If all pedestrians just started taking the space I suspect it would cause problems and not a few pedestrian -car collisions.

The rule about giving way to a pedestrian waiting to cross doesn't make sense to me. It's likely to cause a driver to clog up the main road. If you have a stream of pedestrians they could be stuck there for ages. Especially bad if the driver is turning right.

Agree. I haven’t noticed a difference either. I still have to wait for a driver to be kind enough to stop for me. Some do on one side but not on the other so at certain junctions I have to wait ages for both sides to stop to let me cross and it’s a residential area so pedestrians should be expected especially near two schools. I wonder how some of these drivers would cope if they couldn’t drive for a short period and had to walk or walk to public transport would they be more considerate afterwards or return to being inconsiderate.

Posters on MN moan about the States, but living here makes me miss the various stop signs in residential areas that made it safe to cross even when there was no pavement to walk on when I lived there.

Bourbon75 · 19/02/2024 16:01

Probably doing about 15 - 20 mph. It's usually when I'm turning right at the roundabout. Cars behind aren't expecting you to stop as you're exiting the roundabout so I think if I decided to stop to let someone go there's a high chance the car behind wouldn't notice and would bump. I know they should but I also know how badly many people drive...

Goldwork · 19/02/2024 14:29

Bourbon75 · 19/02/2024 14:09

I don't let pedestrians cross if I think the car behind will bump into me. It happens alot near me. Busy roundabout and whether going left, straight on or right if there's someone waiting UNLESS i'm virtually stationary anyway i keep going as i'm not risking damage to my car or my children being injured. Imo the pedestrians need to wait until it is safe to cross, not expect cars to brake unexpectedly.

I can't picture how this works in terms of accidence avoidance - if you slow down enough to check for obstructions and turn safely isn't someone going to hit you anyway if they really are driving that unsafely.

Butterdishy · 19/02/2024 14:29

Bourbon75 · 19/02/2024 14:09

I don't let pedestrians cross if I think the car behind will bump into me. It happens alot near me. Busy roundabout and whether going left, straight on or right if there's someone waiting UNLESS i'm virtually stationary anyway i keep going as i'm not risking damage to my car or my children being injured. Imo the pedestrians need to wait until it is safe to cross, not expect cars to brake unexpectedly.

The law says differently. It shouldn't be "breaking unexpectedly" unless the pedestrian is invisible.

greengreengrass25 · 19/02/2024 14:17

Bourbon75 · 19/02/2024 14:09

I don't let pedestrians cross if I think the car behind will bump into me. It happens alot near me. Busy roundabout and whether going left, straight on or right if there's someone waiting UNLESS i'm virtually stationary anyway i keep going as i'm not risking damage to my car or my children being injured. Imo the pedestrians need to wait until it is safe to cross, not expect cars to brake unexpectedly.

I think that is fair enough

Swipe left for the next trending thread