Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we need new laws relating to social media and the posting of minors?

39 replies

FoxBoxSox · 18/02/2024 12:20

I have a guilty habit of mindlessly scrolling social media videos when bored. I am becoming increasingly more appalled at the level of private information parents share about their DC under the guise of ‘raising awareness’.

Multiple ‘content creators’ share so much information that from their various posts alone, anyone can work out where their DC go to school, what their disabilities are and the extent of these. Private medical information such as how their tween DC wets themselves when distressed or is violent in meltdown , alongside detailed descriptions of their child’s personal worries and conversations had with parents. All plastered for other people to see. The DC themselves are often posted on their ‘stories’ so all of this medical information openly identifies them.

Photos and videos of DC in their most vulnerable moments (in comas , on life support etc). Older DC incapacitated and in nappies, on life support. I completely understand why parents may take these photos for themselves, but posting them to social media is too much. The DC can not consent.

Do these parents not realise that their DC’s peers will see this stuff? It’s such an invasion of privacy and I feel terrible for the DC.

Is it time we had laws to prevent DC being exposed in this way?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TizerorFizz · 18/02/2024 23:02

Maybe reporting to social services would be a better course of action?

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 18/02/2024 17:42

FoxBoxSox · 18/02/2024 17:21

It’s also easy to forget what goes in to these videos. If a child is being filmed whilst in hospital for example, it’s easy to forget whilst seeing the final cut, that someone is actually standing there, phone in hand, filming their child this way.

The same with parents who vlog outings to the supermarket with their children; they’re following them around the whole store with a camera watching their every move to catch content. It’s alien to me.

Cross posted, but that's how I feel about the parent involved in the situation I mentioned.

Instead of worrying about her daughter's safety or comforting her, her first instinct was to ensure she got photos for instagram, and then to film her daughter whilst getting first aid and then again in A & E. In some of the video her daughter is clearly distressed and in pain.

I also think how much must get filmed that we don't see in these situations. If the child says they don't want to be filmed, we'd never see it.

Banning the filming of children in hospitals would be relatively easy.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 18/02/2024 17:40

I agree with you- and children with SEN may never be able to speak out or make their wishes known.

I follow some adult equestrian influencers on social media, so occasionally get recommended videos featuring children. There's one very famous child influencer who's mum posted video of her having broken her arm to youtube. She also made her child get back on the pony for prize giving (and photos) rather than taking her to get first aid straight away. Surely any normal mum would want to comfort their distressed child, not film them.

They obviously make a lot of money on social media, and I'm sure the child involved gets a lot of benefit out of the situation BUT equally I do wonder if any money is being put aside for her as an adult, and also about the hours she is "working" and the pressure she is under.

There's another one I've posts from on Facebook who talks very openly about her daughter's struggles with school etc. This is a 5yo child, who can't really consent to this sort of information being shared. She might not want people to know those sorts of details about her!

Regardless of how hard it might be to enforce I do think there needs to be rules around safeguarding children "working" as influencers and the children of influencers, both in terms of what is shared about them, but also in terms of making sure some of the money they earn is put in trust for them. I also think that some of these children probably have to "work" long hours etc to produce content- so there should also be rules around working hours etc.

I accept it would be difficult to enforce, but if laws were in place at least it would make it easier to force companies to take down inappropriate photos and videos etc.

FoxBoxSox · 18/02/2024 17:21

It’s also easy to forget what goes in to these videos. If a child is being filmed whilst in hospital for example, it’s easy to forget whilst seeing the final cut, that someone is actually standing there, phone in hand, filming their child this way.

The same with parents who vlog outings to the supermarket with their children; they’re following them around the whole store with a camera watching their every move to catch content. It’s alien to me.

OP posts:
Gophering · 18/02/2024 17:17

So many people (mainly mums) on Instagram in our local area who spend their entire life getting free trips everywhere for meals and days out and haircuts etc in return for a write up and they show videos and photos of their kids daily doing all these free things and apart from the risk of the kids appearing on a public Instagram page every day i also feel sorry for them never seeming to have a normal week of hanging out at home watching tv etc.

StopTheBusINeedAWeeWeeAWeeWeeBagOChips · 18/02/2024 17:13

I agree, can you imagine going for a job in future, and your future employer can find everything from the time you wet yourself on Santa's knee, to your first heartbreak, to how you got detention for cheating in a test.

Its abhorrent how some people can monetise from their own kids lives, and deliberately targeting content at pedophiles as well.

One of the worst I saw was a family who had daughters and a son, but the son, allegedly, like wearing dresses, every video was about it, him going to school in dresses etc, and the daughters absolutely left out, it pissed me off so much I blocked them ages ago, but predicted that this poor kid was going to 'come out' as trans at some point (because he was being groomed into it imo) I saw someone talking about it maybe a year later and I was right. Every bit of it has been documented, that kid will never escape it.

TizerorFizz · 18/02/2024 17:02

Here we want to go after the media giants. It’s the parents in my view. They have responsibilities.

iloveeverykindofcat · 18/02/2024 16:31

Its started already - in some US states, children can retrospectively sue their parents for exploiting them for content. Granted the cases I've heard of were pretty egregious examples ("mommy vlogging" mostly) but it sets a precedent.

pastypirate · 18/02/2024 16:24

Yanbu I can't bear it. I think this generation as adults will have something to say though

oatmilksaga · 18/02/2024 16:21

YankSplaining · 18/02/2024 15:04

I generally agree with this. The only pictures of my kids on social media are on my Friends Only Facebook posts, and all my Facebook friends are people I know IRL.

I don’t understand one thing, though - why pictures of kids in nappies/diapers is supposed to be so especially egregious. There are shirtless, bare-legged babies and toddlers in advertising, on beaches, other places in public. (Were Anne Geddes photographs of babies popular in the UK in the 1990s, like they were in the US?) I can see why it might be embarrassing for a child’s peers to see the picture when the child is older. But I don’t understand the argument that “oh, you shouldn’t post that, because it might arouse pedophiles.”

Pedophiles and other people with sexual fetishes that lead to criminal behavior can be aroused by all kinds of innocent things. If we never photographed anything that might arouse a pedophile, we’d probably have no pictures of children.

I see the argument for not posting pictures or video of kids, especially if someone has a big social media following. But I don’t get, “not only did she post pictures of her children - she posted them wearing just nappies!” I mean, go Google “baby in diaper” or “toddler in diaper.” You’ll find thousands of stock images, many of which are used in mainstream media. This isn’t culturally unusual or risqué.

I think the possibility of children attracting stalkers through social media is more harrowing than the possibility that a pedophile might find images of them sexually arousing.

Dignity.

FoxBoxSox · 18/02/2024 15:38

I agree it will be very difficult to police and it’s unlikely we will see any laws anytime soon. I do think we will see more law suits in the futures as these DC become adults and become aware of just how much personal information their parents posted.

OP posts:
FoxBoxSox · 18/02/2024 15:36

@YankSplaining a good point about the abundance of stock images of toddlers and babies in nappies.

The posts I am referring to are around the dignity of older children who may have disabilities that require nappies or posts of older children who are medically incapacitated and are put in to nappies to help with bodily functions whilst on life support. These things are private and by parents posting them on social media, they are not affording their DC dignity.

OP posts:
Punk4ssBookJockey · 18/02/2024 15:09

I think for any law on this to be effective, it also has to becone very socially unacceptable to post certain identifying details, invading a child's right to privacy or private medical information along with pictures. For example, a way for parents to have to acknowledge they accept the risks to children's mental health, physical safety and loss of the child's right to privacy before setting up an account which posts public content featuring / mentioning children above a certain percentage of the time. Adverts which appear alongside these videos for NSPCC etc. Posters / reminders in places parents go with children (schools, Dr offices, play centres etc). It would be very difficult to police or ban child related content completely because it is impossible to identify a precise tipping point where fun / awareness raising becomes dangerous to the child whilst also allowing freedom of expression and for families and friends to keep in touch over long distances.

YankSplaining · 18/02/2024 15:04

I generally agree with this. The only pictures of my kids on social media are on my Friends Only Facebook posts, and all my Facebook friends are people I know IRL.

I don’t understand one thing, though - why pictures of kids in nappies/diapers is supposed to be so especially egregious. There are shirtless, bare-legged babies and toddlers in advertising, on beaches, other places in public. (Were Anne Geddes photographs of babies popular in the UK in the 1990s, like they were in the US?) I can see why it might be embarrassing for a child’s peers to see the picture when the child is older. But I don’t understand the argument that “oh, you shouldn’t post that, because it might arouse pedophiles.”

Pedophiles and other people with sexual fetishes that lead to criminal behavior can be aroused by all kinds of innocent things. If we never photographed anything that might arouse a pedophile, we’d probably have no pictures of children.

I see the argument for not posting pictures or video of kids, especially if someone has a big social media following. But I don’t get, “not only did she post pictures of her children - she posted them wearing just nappies!” I mean, go Google “baby in diaper” or “toddler in diaper.” You’ll find thousands of stock images, many of which are used in mainstream media. This isn’t culturally unusual or risqué.

I think the possibility of children attracting stalkers through social media is more harrowing than the possibility that a pedophile might find images of them sexually arousing.

Sobbingteen · 18/02/2024 14:34

I agree. I think it may change when we start getting influencer's children growing up and speaking out.

It seems madness to me that kids are taught to be careful about what they put on social media and to be mindful of their digital footprint and yet we have influencers sharing information about their kids' schools, their medical conditions, their teenage fuck ups. And all basically to make money.

FoxBoxSox · 18/02/2024 14:21

@MyGodMyThighs Because as a parent of DC with disabilities myself, I am incredulous at the lack of privacy parents are affording their DC, under the guise of raising awareness of a particular disability.

OP posts:
MyGodMyThighs · 18/02/2024 14:12

Many parents could do with some basic lessons in internet safety.

Not sure why the OP has singled out parents of children with disabilities though.

Mumma2024 · 18/02/2024 14:03

I recently had concerns about a set of siblings through a Facebook group. Mum was freely posting re abuse and significant MH issues. I was able to go through her posting history and establish school, birthdays, full lists of medical diagnoses for each child and mum, key adults in their lives etc all to make a report to their local safeguarding hub. Mum inevitably posted about it and assumed it was a family friend due to knowing so much detail. She had and still has no concept that all of that information was obtained through her posts on social media. I used it for the right reasons, but God forbid I had had malicious intentions, there was so much information available I could have done serious harm with it all.

It should be regulated, heavily.

iloveeverykindofcat · 18/02/2024 13:52

I agree completely. And not because I'm paranoid that every other person is a paedophile (though there certainly are some out there trawling for such "content") but fundamentally because young children cannot consent to this, or understand the implications. Its not a public service, its pure self indulgence on the parents behalf.

AnnieBuddyHere · 18/02/2024 13:46

So many of the parents who see no harm in it, would go absolutely fucking mental if someone posted photos of them online without their permission.

Totally hypocritical.

ducksinarow123 · 18/02/2024 13:44

I have no problems with picture being shared on private SM accounts to friends and family but yes I completely agree that posting of minors on public accounts should be banned. Some of it is appalling and embarrassing to the children. Parents are literally handing bullies all the ammunition they need it's disgraceful

TizerorFizz · 18/02/2024 13:42

You cannot legislate for everything! Who will police this? What will the penalty be? We now have no smart phones suggested for under 16s. The parents who want this did allow their dc to have the phones! Again, who on earth will police it? It’s unenforceable. So we have to accept laws won’t solve the issues of social media or stupid parents.

Luckydog7 · 18/02/2024 13:32

I believe there is a law in the USA that if a child is being used to create content then parents must reserve 10% of the created income specifically for the child. I don't know if there is similar policy here. It's exploitation if nothing else otherwise. I think 10% is too low myself.

My oh works in IT security. And we have a blanket no photos online partially because he is more aware of the dangers then most. The school can't take them either. It's not that hard. I do think a blanket ban would be appropriate but it would collapse a whole industry so I doubt it's likely.

My kids like watching kids on you tube and you can see that some of the older children are into it but then some of the younger siblings don't know wtf is going on.

HelloCiao · 18/02/2024 13:26

Oh I agree with you 100%. I'm in a dress group on Facebook, 52,000 members, and one woman posts daily about her son. I and thousands of others know what school he goes to, his birthday, his medical conditions, the medicine he takes. So dangerous.

GrazingSheep · 18/02/2024 13:19

There are posters on MN who have no problem with their young children having social media, TikTok etc.
It’s the other side of the same coin.

Swipe left for the next trending thread