Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone ever got rid of a dog and then regretted it?

181 replies

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 17:45

PLEASE BE KIND.

I know these threads can bring out the worst in people so please don’t kick me when I’m down.

I have a 2 year old dog, had him since a pup. He was honestly the most well behaved puppy ever - crate trained from day one, no accidents inside unless unwell, never chewed or destroyed anything etc. However he has now regressed during his ‘teenage’ stage and is honestly a nightmare.

He doesn’t listen to a word you say, he is running out the front door into the road (he has a gate across the kitchen but has now started jumping this so pretty useless), he is lunging at every dog we see on walks to the point where I don’t want to walk him anymore, jumping all over the furniture, walls and guests whenever someone comes over.

He is a cross bread and a bit of a nightmare to train as of late because nothing motivates him anymore to actually listen to the command you’re giving him.

I’ve honestly got to the point where I’ve given up on him - I dread waking up to him every morning and it’s honestly the biggest shame because I used to absolutely adore that dog before this all started happening but he just triggers the entire household and it’s pushing me to breaking point, I feel mentally and physically unwell and drained.

Has anyone ever got rid of a dog and then later on regretted it?

I really am starting to consider it as one of my options because of the toll it’s taking not only on me but the whole house but my biggest worry is once everything has settled down it would be the biggest mistake of my life getting rid of him…

OP posts:
Herdinggoats · 17/02/2024 18:53

I think the phrase “getting rid” of a dog is right here. Rehoming is a bit of a euphemism and helps with the idea that the dog is going to find a loving new home, whereas the reality for most is that they end up in kennels for months or possibly years-particularly a dog with behaviour problems like this one.

the reality for this poor dog, being a cross with behaviour problems is that finding a new home will not be easy. This dog is not being “rehomed”. It is being turfed out.

Onlyvisiting · 17/02/2024 18:53

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 17:45

PLEASE BE KIND.

I know these threads can bring out the worst in people so please don’t kick me when I’m down.

I have a 2 year old dog, had him since a pup. He was honestly the most well behaved puppy ever - crate trained from day one, no accidents inside unless unwell, never chewed or destroyed anything etc. However he has now regressed during his ‘teenage’ stage and is honestly a nightmare.

He doesn’t listen to a word you say, he is running out the front door into the road (he has a gate across the kitchen but has now started jumping this so pretty useless), he is lunging at every dog we see on walks to the point where I don’t want to walk him anymore, jumping all over the furniture, walls and guests whenever someone comes over.

He is a cross bread and a bit of a nightmare to train as of late because nothing motivates him anymore to actually listen to the command you’re giving him.

I’ve honestly got to the point where I’ve given up on him - I dread waking up to him every morning and it’s honestly the biggest shame because I used to absolutely adore that dog before this all started happening but he just triggers the entire household and it’s pushing me to breaking point, I feel mentally and physically unwell and drained.

Has anyone ever got rid of a dog and then later on regretted it?

I really am starting to consider it as one of my options because of the toll it’s taking not only on me but the whole house but my biggest worry is once everything has settled down it would be the biggest mistake of my life getting rid of him…

The trouble is people act like rehome is simple. Whilst a different home may well be a good thing for this dog the reality is that there is no guarantee you will find one.
The rescue centers are full to bursting and lots are unable to take any others. There are a limited number of experienced homes available for an untrained dog with separation anxiety and behavioural issues. The risk of private rehome is he could end up anywhere, unneutered dogs offered free to good home are in danger of being taken for further breeding (by unscrupulous puppy Farmers) or bait for dog fighting, or even just bounced through well meaning but overwhelmed homes that can't cope and add to his problems.
Please if you decide to go down this route then at least enlist the help of a reputable rescue for home checking etc, even if they can't physically take him for you.

mydogisthebest · 17/02/2024 18:52

Woodstocks · 17/02/2024 17:49

We did. We rehomed him with a family member and nobody misses him at all. The kids were fine about it literally didn’t blink.

i think a lot of people take on way too much feeling of responsibility and treat a dog like a child and giving a dog up is seen as abandoning him, worst thing you can do, part of the family etc but let’s be real- it is only an animal at the end of the day and if you do right by the dog and he comes to a good new home where he is wanted you have done enough. You don’t have to slog on for the next ten years waiting for him to die!

Disgusting attitude.

Nobody misses him and your kids were fine! I bet he doesn't miss any of you.

Your words "only an animal" says it all. YOU chose to take on that animal and he looked to you for his welfare.

What would you do if you had a problem child? You don't even have the option of slogging on for 10 years waiting for them to die do you? You do what you should do which is love them, look after them. That is what you should be doing for any pet YOU decide to get.

Please please please please do not get another dog ever.

fishfingersandtoes · 17/02/2024 18:51

When I was a kid my parents got rid of our dog (gave her away to a different owner) mainly because we couldn't afford her but probably partly because they didn't really want the hassle of having a dog. We kids were actually completely fine about it. We were mildly upset when we were told, but got some chips from the chip shop as a treat and didn't really think much more about it. Our parents never regretted it either.
It's not a bad thing to do if you re-home her.

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 18:49

@Aftersunbun thank you so much, I really appreciate that.

yes I have a child with autism and normally she tolerates the dog really well - they just leave each other to get on with it sort of thing but because of his behaviour she’s really struggling with it and she’s become incredibly wary of him and always looking over her shoulder so obviously I don’t want the situation stressing her out either so it’s really tough to know what’s for the best!

OP posts:
Aftersunbun · 17/02/2024 18:46

Only you know what is best for your dog and your family.
Have just spotted your username and wonder if autism is an additional factor/consideration for your family.
it sounds like a very stressful situation and although this will likely set your pup back with his own anxiety and well-being, you should think of your own/your family’s mental health.

No one should judge what they don’t fully know.

Good luck OP

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 18:46

Thank you for all of the helpful responses and advice to follow - I will definitely be taking them all on board!

I will definitely check in with the vet firstly to see if it’s pain or illness making him this way and secondly to see if they suggest any medication or supplements.

@GreekDogRescue it also appears that you haven’t read the whole thread properly or you’d know the reasoning for not having him neutered as of yet

OP posts:
Cora24601 · 17/02/2024 18:45

In the last week my almost 2 year old rescue dog has peed in the house (this morning for the first time ever) rolled in a dead rat... twice (honestly the smell you can't imagine). Managed to find his way into the cats food and eaten packets of treats whole where he's pooped out the packets and has now become barky where he never usually is. He's going through a teenage phase (big dogs mature slower) and I know he will come out of it but I know it's not over and up to me and my family to manage. My 3 year old now perfect girl spent her first 18 months torturing me and my partner to the point we would come to blows over it. Honestly we would have re homed my rescue if we hadn't have had the best trainer (I do believe not all trainers are created equal) and even sent them messages basically saying 'we are worried we will have to rehome him, we can't take it anymore' so I completely understand being where you are. Only you can make the decision on when you are at your limit and how much is too much but I'm so glad we didn't rehome him. My advice would be stick to certain rules and don't keep chopping and changing, dogs thrive on knowing what is expected. Our rescue dog kept jumping his pen so we made it so he couldn't, get inventive. If he barks ignore it or use distraction techniques, dogs really are a long game thing and will change as they age. You do have my sympathies though, it's not easy.

GreekDogRescue · 17/02/2024 18:44

Also it appears you haven’t bothered to neuter him.

Were you hoping to breed him?

GreekDogRescue · 17/02/2024 18:43

You say he isn’t a lockdown dog OP yet you bought him from this abusive breeder in 2021, height of lockdowns.
I hope you don’t buy anymore dogs.
If you really don’t want him why not ask your friends, family or neighbours. I hope you don’t dump him on a rescue as they are overwhelmed.

Balloonhearts · 17/02/2024 18:40

It's his adolescent phase. They all have it and it's very very trying. Separating him from his cherries should sort the aggression but the rest he will grow out of. By the time they hit 4 they've usually turned back into a well behaved citizen.

Riverlee · 17/02/2024 18:35

Not sure whether it was on mn or elsewhere, but I read about a dog recently whose personality changed. Turned out he had arthritis and that was causing the problems. Once he started medicines, the situation improved.

Have you taken him to the vet and got him checked out?

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 17/02/2024 18:32

Have you considered chemical castration? You can see how he responds and if it doesn't help or makes him worse, it's not permanent like a full neuter.

But ultimately I don't think there's anything wrong with re-homing if you're both miserable. Much better than keeping the dog in a home that's not suiting him. Don't let people make you feel guilty.

bingoringo4 · 17/02/2024 18:32

I rehomed a dog once and never regretted it.

Wizzadorra70 · 17/02/2024 18:27

Book an appointment with your vet. There is no reason for a dog to be anxious these days - I've got a very highly sensitive sprocker. Our vet was great and recommended a great behaviourist who we had 3 sessions with, mainly on how to manage her anxiety at home and when out. She's on a mix of natural calming tablets with pro-biotics and these work well but for holidays/long trips, we get meds from the Vet so we avoid her reaching danger levels. She's on a low protein food, and we walk avoiding other dogs as much as we can with her on a long line which for some reason helps her feel secure. It's not a personal attack on you OP but whatever idiot thought of mixing cockers and poodles should have been shot - they may look cute and not shed hair, but the ones I've met have been madder than boxes of frogs. And get him neutered - hormones won't be helping the adolescence.

I would try absolutely everything before you reach that decision.

Shannith · 17/02/2024 18:24

twistyizzy · 17/02/2024 18:08

@AutismMum21 cockers are high energy working dogs prone to resource guarding and anxiety. Poodles are high energy dogs prone to anxiety. You are crossing 2 high energy, anxious breeds and expecting to get a low energy dog?
What training have you done around scentwork/retrieval/gundog training?

This absolutely. I'm sorry but I see so many 2 year old cockerpoos in rescue.

It's a cross of 2 working breeds, not a teddy bear. Would you have got a working cocker?

Well you got one.

^^that was grumpy I know but I'm so tired of people being surprised when cockerpoos turn out like this. They are kind of bred to be like this.

I will come back with some useful advice. I am a foster for a rescue and can proa sly help you decide what to do to make sure he can find a good home.

noctilucentcloud · 17/02/2024 18:20

OhmygodDont · 17/02/2024 17:55

A response good pet owner knows when they are in over their head and when to admit they are not the best home for the dog/pet.

Clinging on to a oh well we took them on so till they die while giving them say a poor life doesn’t make one person a better owner than one who owns up admits their limits/mistakes and rehomes.

Knowing what’s best for the animal makes the best owner even if you have to admit your not the best owner or home
for them.

I agree with this having volunteered at a rehoming centre and having a rehomed/rescue dog. Everyone should think very very carefully before getting a pet (not saying you didn't OP), but sometimes circumstances change. It is far better that an animal is given up to a responsible rehoming charity than leads a miserable life where its needs are not met. Please don't think I'm saying pets are disposable, they're not and it does make me angry that some people don't really think through getting a pet (again not saying this is you OP) but I think sometimes rehoming is unavoidable and I take a pragmatic approach that sometimes it really is in the animals best interests.

21ZIGGY · 17/02/2024 18:19

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 17:54

@fleurneige on the basis that you know nothing about me or what I have or haven’t done with the dog - I’m going to ignore your ignorant post.

I think you should say what training youve done to get better advice.

But generally i do wonder when people rehome difficult dogs why they think someone else could or should take on a dog that the first owner failed?

needastrongoneagain · 17/02/2024 18:17

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 18:15

@Aftersunbun so he came from an awful breeder (that’s just a whole story within itself) and I suspect he was abused by that breeder, that’s why I took him in when I found him in the condition he was in. His anxiety was mainly around being left and if he saw any man he would literally wee and poo out of fear, scared of his toys etc. really awful stuff.

His confidence now is completely different in the sense that he is no longer scared of those things and he was getting better at being left alone etc.

He is still really confident in a lot of ways but he has started really acting up when being left alone again which did improve for a period of time before.

Hope I’ve explained that okay!

It sounds like you have done a lot more good than you give yourself credit for!

needastrongoneagain · 17/02/2024 18:16

But sounds like his first year wasn't easy, and that's tough for a dog. Sorry OP, maybe more of a reason to give it a try if you can? 😊

twistyizzy · 17/02/2024 18:16

@AutismMum21 you need to look at the breeds that have made your dog and treat accordingly. Anxiety can be due to boredom, correct scehtwork/retrieval work will help calm the dog as it allows them to do what they were made to do.
If the household is stressed then this will impact on the behaviour of the dog. As I said previously you have a mongrel which has been bred from 2 high energy breeds prone to anxiety
I wish cockapoos would stop being sold as being good family pets.

twistyizzy · 17/02/2024 18:16

@AutismMum21 you need to look at the breeds that have made your dog and treat accordingly. Anxiety can be due to boredom, correct scehtwork/retrieval work will help calm the dog as it allows them to do what they were made to do.
If the household is stressed then this will impact on the behaviour of the dog. As I said previously you have a mongrel which has been bred from 2 high energy breeds prone to anxiety
I wish cockapoos would stop being sold as being good family pets.

Startrekkeruniverse · 17/02/2024 18:16

Woodstocks · 17/02/2024 17:49

We did. We rehomed him with a family member and nobody misses him at all. The kids were fine about it literally didn’t blink.

i think a lot of people take on way too much feeling of responsibility and treat a dog like a child and giving a dog up is seen as abandoning him, worst thing you can do, part of the family etc but let’s be real- it is only an animal at the end of the day and if you do right by the dog and he comes to a good new home where he is wanted you have done enough. You don’t have to slog on for the next ten years waiting for him to die!

“is only an animal at the end of the day”

no-one with this sort of attitude should have a pet.

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 18:15

@Aftersunbun so he came from an awful breeder (that’s just a whole story within itself) and I suspect he was abused by that breeder, that’s why I took him in when I found him in the condition he was in. His anxiety was mainly around being left and if he saw any man he would literally wee and poo out of fear, scared of his toys etc. really awful stuff.

His confidence now is completely different in the sense that he is no longer scared of those things and he was getting better at being left alone etc.

He is still really confident in a lot of ways but he has started really acting up when being left alone again which did improve for a period of time before.

Hope I’ve explained that okay!

OP posts:
needastrongoneagain · 17/02/2024 18:14

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 18:07

@twistyizzy he comes from a really complicated background therefore the first year was spent just building his confidence more than anything.

@needastrongoneagain the highest value treats to him are chicken and cheese but the minute he knows he has to work for them he isn’t bothered - he doesn’t have the best attention span I don’t think!

Then make him work for it!! Hide the chicken, wrap it in a toilet roll, hide it in a bush, big encouragement etc.

I honestly don't get what's wrong with either a springer or a cocker spaniel without adding in a poodle other than looks. And then I think why breed that other than money - sorry OP, not a dig at you but pisses me off!