Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone ever got rid of a dog and then regretted it?

181 replies

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 17:45

PLEASE BE KIND.

I know these threads can bring out the worst in people so please don’t kick me when I’m down.

I have a 2 year old dog, had him since a pup. He was honestly the most well behaved puppy ever - crate trained from day one, no accidents inside unless unwell, never chewed or destroyed anything etc. However he has now regressed during his ‘teenage’ stage and is honestly a nightmare.

He doesn’t listen to a word you say, he is running out the front door into the road (he has a gate across the kitchen but has now started jumping this so pretty useless), he is lunging at every dog we see on walks to the point where I don’t want to walk him anymore, jumping all over the furniture, walls and guests whenever someone comes over.

He is a cross bread and a bit of a nightmare to train as of late because nothing motivates him anymore to actually listen to the command you’re giving him.

I’ve honestly got to the point where I’ve given up on him - I dread waking up to him every morning and it’s honestly the biggest shame because I used to absolutely adore that dog before this all started happening but he just triggers the entire household and it’s pushing me to breaking point, I feel mentally and physically unwell and drained.

Has anyone ever got rid of a dog and then later on regretted it?

I really am starting to consider it as one of my options because of the toll it’s taking not only on me but the whole house but my biggest worry is once everything has settled down it would be the biggest mistake of my life getting rid of him…

OP posts:
mydogisthebest · 17/02/2024 19:28

bingoringo4 · 17/02/2024 19:10

Honestly the hysteria on threads like this is bonkers. "Family" comparing it to a child. It's a dog, just a dog. Humanising dogs is mental. She's not taking it outside and shooting it ffs. Get a grip

Yet another idiot spouting "it's a dog". No one who thinks "it's just a dog" should ever get one.

She may not be going to shoot it but trying to rehome a dog when there are so many other selfish idiots trying to do the same is likely to condemn it to being killed anyway

YeahIsaidit · 17/02/2024 19:26

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 18:00

@Mairzydotes I looked into it last year and the vet wouldn’t do it because he had really bad anxiety when I first got him, we finally got to a good place behaviour wise for it to happen but now his separation anxiety is through the roof so I don’t know if the vet would recommend it or not

Neutering should calm him down. Without being neutered, he's more at risk of testicular cancer as he ages and isn't being used for breeding

JustAnotherDayWorkingAtHome · 17/02/2024 19:25

We have a cockapoo with separation anxiety and tried chemical castration before having him neutered as we didn't want to make him more anxious.

Our boy is 3 and a bit now and I was at breaking point with him around 18 months.

I love him to bits and he's wonderful but not perfect but I'm so glad I persevered. I agree about cockapoo comments though on results of crossing the two breeds. Good luck OP with what you decide.

sonjadog · 17/02/2024 19:23

Your dog is at the worst age, and in six months may well be calming down and become less challenging. I know a lot of people who have considered rehoming their dog around this age, and a couple of years later they are all wondering why they could ever have thought such a thing. I would try consistent training, neutering and lots of lots of patience.

I have rehomed a dog. I had two dogs and they were just too much for me on my own and I had stopped enjoying being a dog owner. Both were great dogs in different ways. One had a rather overpowering personality and completely dominated the more timid one. When I decided to rehome, I wasn't sure and I started off just seeing who might be interested, and a wonderful family turned up who gave my dog all the love and attention that he deserved. I had more energy and enjoyed dog ownership again, and my remaining dog got to take the huge space his personality required! So, it doesn't have to be a negative thing to rehome, but take the responsibility yourself to find him a good home, don't just dump him in a rehoming centre. Your dog deserves better than that.

Spotnessmonster · 17/02/2024 19:20

Op go easy on yourself and don't pay too much mind to all the unhelpful, negative posts.
If you exhaust all options and decide to re-home, go through a rescue. As much as people up thread are saying they are overwhelmed, that's what they are there for. And it's more beneficial for the dog to be rehomed to someone who's been vetted and up for the challenge.
I think if you've tried everything and the dog is having a negative effect on the family and their mental health then there won't be regret, probably just relief.

stomachamelon · 17/02/2024 19:16

@ThisSpunkyBird that's really sad. Try not to blame yourself it sounds like you thought you were doing the right thing.
Big hug

Neriah · 17/02/2024 19:15

Just to add, for posterity... People keep getting Cockerpoos because they are cute looking and "easy". Cute, possibly. But they are hybrids of the second smartest / intelligent dog in the world crossed with another really smart breed. You are either smarter than them, or they are smarter than you! They need far more careful consideration than most people think about.

romdowa · 17/02/2024 19:11

Neriah · 17/02/2024 19:08

Sorry, you lost me at "get rid". This is a living creature, not a worn out rug. If you must rehome him, do it responsibly for his sake. And don't get a dog again. Ever. I'd also suggest no children... not because I think dogs are people, but if you think a teenage dog is hard work, you really don't want to try out teenage humans.

🤣🤣🤣

bingoringo4 · 17/02/2024 19:10

Honestly the hysteria on threads like this is bonkers. "Family" comparing it to a child. It's a dog, just a dog. Humanising dogs is mental. She's not taking it outside and shooting it ffs. Get a grip

Neriah · 17/02/2024 19:08

Sorry, you lost me at "get rid". This is a living creature, not a worn out rug. If you must rehome him, do it responsibly for his sake. And don't get a dog again. Ever. I'd also suggest no children... not because I think dogs are people, but if you think a teenage dog is hard work, you really don't want to try out teenage humans.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 17/02/2024 19:07

My cockapoo is a mentalist. She is a Velcro dog and doesn’t like being away from me. She was a terror during teenage years-also did the bolting out the front door, pretending to be deaf, constantly digging under the fence and escaping and generally being a knob. She drove me to distraction. She is also timid and has to be picked up to walk past other dogs larger than herself after being jumped on by a visla.

She has been spayed. To counter the escaping I bought an extra long lead, which was kept on all the time so I could encourage her back and then give her cheese, which is her all time favourite. We then spent hours and hours training with treats. Am happy to say she is now 3.5 and has calmed down considerably. She will
pop out the front door if open but she doesn’t run off, she just has a sniff around and easily comes back. She still is anxious at times but is a complete love and very sorted. Patience is key.

puzzledout · 17/02/2024 19:06

I don't envy your decision!

WhyWhyY · 17/02/2024 19:05

Sounds like you need a break to make this decision when you’re not frazzled.

can you afford a dog walker? I am a firm believer in a well exercised dog is a content one and it takes the pressure off you. Many dog walkers will actually help with the issue if you explain it first.

also if you do have to re home him and you can do so responsibly I am sure you won’t regret it, it will be a decision made for everyone’s best interests so don’t beat yourself up.

billybear · 17/02/2024 19:04

what breed of dog /big or small.ive heard good things about a little treat use daily,by NUTRIPAW,i use the tummy friendly ones for my dog ,you can get nervous dog and ichy dog, my dogs tummy is much better since he started these by on line i use 1 a day a tub has 120 in so lasts 4 months,are they bored mine is getting older but still likes me to roll a ball in the hall if its too wet for out side,good luck

Xtraincome · 17/02/2024 19:04

If you re-home this dog, I won't judge. If you then, at any point, get another dog, I will judge you massively!

People get dogs they can't handle ALL THE TIME! We chose a lazy British Bulldog and he is turning 3 in October. He is going through training, then being fixed as it ends. He will then attend doggy day care to socialise and get himself in a pecking order with others and then will be out the other side of his hyper phase - which is actually calming massively anyway. It takes time, patience and money to own pets. If you don't have these now, you never will, so just make the decision quickly and be done with dogs if that's what you choose to do. Also, why people get breeds with a working dog trait yet do not have the time or resources to support their development I'll never know.

I am aware I sound judgey but please OP whatever you choose to do, own it and do right by whichever decision you make and move forward with gusto

MrsKnows · 17/02/2024 19:03

I feel your pain! You poor things! It sounds as if he simply needs some professional training!

The longer he runs wild, the longer his bad habits will become entrenched!

When I was a child, our rescue dog became very aggressive at meal times - he was taken back to the shelter and we later found out that the previous owners had abused him around food.

If we had known what the issue was sooner (or realised it was just the food situation) we could have trained him out if it. Yes we regretted it!

Our current dog became a nightmare teen! He’d been attacked a couple of times and became so reactive we were ready to euthanise him! Luckily, we found an intense training course instead!

Nine years later, here he is laying on the sofa, snoring merrily, next to me! We would have bitterly regretted giving him up! But it’s better to give him to the shelter and say you don’t know how to train him than to make him miserable! Poor doggie!

You aren’t doing any of you any favours! Good luck! I hope you get it sorted! ⭐️💝

OrlandointheWilderness · 17/02/2024 19:02

And yes - cockapoos aren't good family pets!

OrlandointheWilderness · 17/02/2024 19:01

You could try chemical castration to see what effect it would have, but I would be reluctant to castrate a dog with any signs of anxiety as it can make it much worse.
Training will see you through here, he sounds like he needs a job to do. He a cross between two intelligent breeds who both need stimulation. Look at Gundog training.

romdowa · 17/02/2024 19:00

Honestly cockerpoos are insane and a nightmare to train. My father took mine in the end as he was destroying our house and after spending a fortune on dog trainers and putting in hours every day, it didn't make a tack of difference. He's happy out now with my father who has plenty space and time.

ThisSpunkyBird · 17/02/2024 19:00

I did, and have regretted it every day of my life since. I was moving from the state of Maine to the state of Florida. This was a Newfoundland dog that had never had to be tied up. We had 100 acres for him to roam. We gave him to a family member who lived on a farm, and the dog loved him as the family member had visited often however, the dog never got over the loss of his entire family moving without him, I still cry when I think about him I miss him so much. But I cannot go back and get him as he had to put the dog down so my baby boy is gone and I can’t do anything about it. You can never replace them as my family does treat our pets as family members.

WhatIsHeThinking · 17/02/2024 18:59

I know a family who emigrated and who rehomed their dog rather than wait out the quarantine period. I’m not a huge dog fan but I found that quite sickening and is a big reason I didn’t keep in touch with them.

JMSA · 17/02/2024 18:56

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 18:00

@Mairzydotes I looked into it last year and the vet wouldn’t do it because he had really bad anxiety when I first got him, we finally got to a good place behaviour wise for it to happen but now his separation anxiety is through the roof so I don’t know if the vet would recommend it or not

It doesn't sound like the dog is happy either.

Morecurlywurly · 17/02/2024 18:56

Woodstocks · 17/02/2024 17:49

We did. We rehomed him with a family member and nobody misses him at all. The kids were fine about it literally didn’t blink.

i think a lot of people take on way too much feeling of responsibility and treat a dog like a child and giving a dog up is seen as abandoning him, worst thing you can do, part of the family etc but let’s be real- it is only an animal at the end of the day and if you do right by the dog and he comes to a good new home where he is wanted you have done enough. You don’t have to slog on for the next ten years waiting for him to die!

Wow, the dog’s well rid of you isn’t he ? You did him a favour ! You saved him from a life sentence.

It’s not “just an animal”but a family member.

JMSA · 17/02/2024 18:55

No. I frigging adore my dog. He has imperfections aplenty but I could never get shot of him.
And even if I could, my kids would never speak to me again Grin

Babyroobs · 17/02/2024 18:55

Has he been neutered ? My working cocker was like this at the same age but much calmer once he had been castrated. I was at the end of what I could cope with but he is wonderful now, couldn't ask for a better dog.