Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone ever got rid of a dog and then regretted it?

181 replies

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 17:45

PLEASE BE KIND.

I know these threads can bring out the worst in people so please don’t kick me when I’m down.

I have a 2 year old dog, had him since a pup. He was honestly the most well behaved puppy ever - crate trained from day one, no accidents inside unless unwell, never chewed or destroyed anything etc. However he has now regressed during his ‘teenage’ stage and is honestly a nightmare.

He doesn’t listen to a word you say, he is running out the front door into the road (he has a gate across the kitchen but has now started jumping this so pretty useless), he is lunging at every dog we see on walks to the point where I don’t want to walk him anymore, jumping all over the furniture, walls and guests whenever someone comes over.

He is a cross bread and a bit of a nightmare to train as of late because nothing motivates him anymore to actually listen to the command you’re giving him.

I’ve honestly got to the point where I’ve given up on him - I dread waking up to him every morning and it’s honestly the biggest shame because I used to absolutely adore that dog before this all started happening but he just triggers the entire household and it’s pushing me to breaking point, I feel mentally and physically unwell and drained.

Has anyone ever got rid of a dog and then later on regretted it?

I really am starting to consider it as one of my options because of the toll it’s taking not only on me but the whole house but my biggest worry is once everything has settled down it would be the biggest mistake of my life getting rid of him…

OP posts:
BuddhaAtSea · 17/02/2024 20:37

@mydogisthebest are you quite alright? Your comments sound psychotic, did you mean to come across this way?

mydogisthebest · 17/02/2024 20:26

BarbaricPeach · 17/02/2024 20:21

We rehomed our dog.

The breaking point was when he snapped at my son (10 months old) without provocation so obviously the situation is a bit different in that on a practical level we needed to get him out the house and I can't regret that.

But to be honest, even up to that point we had been struggling with him. He was a very well trained boy, lovely to everyone. But when the baby arrived, we just couldn't give him the attention he needed. We still did everything we needed to regarding walking, feeding, playing etc. But we just couldn't do the extra bits. Where he'd once had both of us WFH all day to play and snuggle him, now I had PPD and was out most of the day with the baby and my husband was struggling to balance work and sleepless nights so didn't have the spare energy for the dog. So we'd already been considering if rehoming him would be kinder, and then the snap sealed his fate.

To be honest, I don't miss him that much. I was gutted when he left. He went to live with a friend who is a dog walker and I get pangs when I see him on her social media, or old photos on my phone. I know he's having a nicer life with her than us (or pretty much any dog owner I know) which helps. But the pressure that lifted off our shoulders when he was gone was immense. I wish we could have kept him, but I don't regret not keeping him at all.

Why get a dog when you intend having children? So many idiots get dogs and then get rid because they have a baby

BarbaricPeach · 17/02/2024 20:21

We rehomed our dog.

The breaking point was when he snapped at my son (10 months old) without provocation so obviously the situation is a bit different in that on a practical level we needed to get him out the house and I can't regret that.

But to be honest, even up to that point we had been struggling with him. He was a very well trained boy, lovely to everyone. But when the baby arrived, we just couldn't give him the attention he needed. We still did everything we needed to regarding walking, feeding, playing etc. But we just couldn't do the extra bits. Where he'd once had both of us WFH all day to play and snuggle him, now I had PPD and was out most of the day with the baby and my husband was struggling to balance work and sleepless nights so didn't have the spare energy for the dog. So we'd already been considering if rehoming him would be kinder, and then the snap sealed his fate.

To be honest, I don't miss him that much. I was gutted when he left. He went to live with a friend who is a dog walker and I get pangs when I see him on her social media, or old photos on my phone. I know he's having a nicer life with her than us (or pretty much any dog owner I know) which helps. But the pressure that lifted off our shoulders when he was gone was immense. I wish we could have kept him, but I don't regret not keeping him at all.

Neriah · 17/02/2024 20:12

GreekDogRescue · 17/02/2024 19:44

We need to spay and neuter as there is a tsunami of stray dogs in many countries in the world, also this country is facing an unprecedented dumping of lockdown dogs as per the OP’s.
The last thing we need is to bring anymore unwanted dogs into this world.
OP wanted to breed from this dog, hence not having him neutered and claiming it would make his anxiety ‘worse’.

I am not discussing tsunamis of dogs. I am pointing out that the "health benefits" of neutering are dubious at best, and can make their behaviour and health worse. Which was the point I responded to. The excess of dogs is not due to lack of neutering - it is due to irresponsible ownership, irresponsible breeding, and profiteering. Like any other "commodity", if people demand it there will be a supply. During the worst periods of covid drug dealers are finding puppy farming mode lucrative than heroin.

Shannith · 17/02/2024 20:06

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 17/02/2024 19:52

I really don't understand how people are supported here when any human relationship breaks down - divorce, going NC with family members (I'm sure the reasons are excellent and it is necessary for safety or mental health or whatever) but the moment anyone has reached the end of their tether with a dog or cat they are expected to work on it, to get training, take responsibility. Sadly relationships break down. And that can include relationships with animals as well. It's never happened to me with a dog but I have two rescue dogs who found themselves rehomed as older puppies (different breeds/families) through no fault of their own with zero training. I'm so glad their previous owners weren't guilt tripped into keeping them and they are a much loved part of our family.

Because the other person in the relationship doesn't die/end up locked in a kennel for years because you fall out of love with them.

Flottie · 17/02/2024 20:05

Not the point of the thread… but you can get special dog stair gates which are higher. We had to get one as our dog learnt to jump a normal height one we had in our kitchen.

Personally though I’d persevere and just focus solidly on training for a period of time. And get a behaviourist. Invest time and money. If that still fails then it would be in the dogs best interest to rehome (not get rid of…).

But I’m a strong believer in if you get a dog you are making them a promise to give them a forever home. We have a difficult rescue and she has taken a lot of training and time and she still has her issues but can’t imagine life without her.

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/02/2024 20:05

I can see you’re taking the comments on board op. Just so you know, mental stimulation is as tiring and important as physical stimulation. I have a highly strung cockapoo with a decent sized garden and another dog to keep him company… not that I’m suggesting you get a second dog. My cockapoo likes to experiment / make things move / make noises eg lift the lid on the small bin in the loo up and down, thwack the rack on the ironing board etc. I also have indestructible tennis balls in the house and plenty of toys.

MerryMaidens · 17/02/2024 20:03

bingoringo4 · 17/02/2024 19:56

This 👆🏼

Yes double this. But I think it's because a lot of posters like dogs more than people.

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 19:59

@GreekDogRescue if you did actually have any knowledge about dogs rather than just what you believe in your own head you would know that it’s the hormones that helps give the dog confidence and taking that away in the form of neutering in dogs that have anxiety can make that even worse - even sometimes causing them to become fearful aggressive.

i’m pretty sure my experienced and qualified well recommended vet knows more than you on the subject so please feel free to take your neutering lecturing to another post.

OP posts:
sageandrosemary · 17/02/2024 19:58

We rehomed privately to a home that she's far, far happier in.

My mental health was so bad, I don't regret it at all.

We stay in touch. She's having a blast, and I'm not on the brink of a breakdown anymore.

Do what's right for you all OP. Best of luck.

bingoringo4 · 17/02/2024 19:56

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 17/02/2024 19:52

I really don't understand how people are supported here when any human relationship breaks down - divorce, going NC with family members (I'm sure the reasons are excellent and it is necessary for safety or mental health or whatever) but the moment anyone has reached the end of their tether with a dog or cat they are expected to work on it, to get training, take responsibility. Sadly relationships break down. And that can include relationships with animals as well. It's never happened to me with a dog but I have two rescue dogs who found themselves rehomed as older puppies (different breeds/families) through no fault of their own with zero training. I'm so glad their previous owners weren't guilt tripped into keeping them and they are a much loved part of our family.

This 👆🏼

Shannith · 17/02/2024 19:54

Neriah · 17/02/2024 19:15

Just to add, for posterity... People keep getting Cockerpoos because they are cute looking and "easy". Cute, possibly. But they are hybrids of the second smartest / intelligent dog in the world crossed with another really smart breed. You are either smarter than them, or they are smarter than you! They need far more careful consideration than most people think about.

Although this, ai do actually agree with 100%

Missingmyusername · 17/02/2024 19:53

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 17:52

I have done my absolute best by the dog but now it’s impacting my mental health to the point where everyday is a real struggle - he wasn’t a lockdown dog either before that’s a suggestion.

I absolutely adored the dog but his behaviour is just out of control - I’ve consulted with multiple dog trainers and he actually goes to a daycare with a trainer there once a week and he is even causing issues there now too.

At what point does the humans in the household take priority?

Wow at the final paragraph. You don’t need permission from mn to rehome the dog op.

Clearly you take priority. Let the dog go to someone who will love him, just rehome responsibly.

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 19:53

GreekDogRescue · 17/02/2024 19:44

We need to spay and neuter as there is a tsunami of stray dogs in many countries in the world, also this country is facing an unprecedented dumping of lockdown dogs as per the OP’s.
The last thing we need is to bring anymore unwanted dogs into this world.
OP wanted to breed from this dog, hence not having him neutered and claiming it would make his anxiety ‘worse’.

I don’t want to breed him - I don’t want the hassle and I don’t need the money - so stop acting like you know something that isn’t true, get a grip.

OP posts:
IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 17/02/2024 19:52

I really don't understand how people are supported here when any human relationship breaks down - divorce, going NC with family members (I'm sure the reasons are excellent and it is necessary for safety or mental health or whatever) but the moment anyone has reached the end of their tether with a dog or cat they are expected to work on it, to get training, take responsibility. Sadly relationships break down. And that can include relationships with animals as well. It's never happened to me with a dog but I have two rescue dogs who found themselves rehomed as older puppies (different breeds/families) through no fault of their own with zero training. I'm so glad their previous owners weren't guilt tripped into keeping them and they are a much loved part of our family.

Shannith · 17/02/2024 19:51

@Neriah that's the best logic I've ever heard. If neutering were beneficial for the health of dogs, we do it to humans.

Yep. I mean I dunno why I thought otherwise. I stand chastened.

MerryMaidens · 17/02/2024 19:50

Sure, but you don't have to rehome through a shelter. You could do it directly. Maybe give SpanielAid a call?

fleurneige · 17/02/2024 19:49

Ignorant post? I'd say a post talking about 'getting rid' of a dog, is über ignorant. But yes, re-home asap, poor dog. None of this is his fault, he deserves better.

Shannith · 17/02/2024 19:47

Ok - if you do choose to rehome the dog you owe it to him to do it properly.

And that means finding him a proper rescue space.

What do I mean by a proper rescue space?

The dogs are kept well- even better if they go into foster where their behaviour can be accessed, basic retaining done and matched with the right home.

The rescue provides full rescue back up - this means that if whoever your dog is adopted by can't keep them for any reason - the take the dog back

The rescue homechecks and has a rigorous process for vetting adopters.

They take a full history of the dog, with full disclosure about all its behaviours and issues and make sure potential adopters know this

Unfortunately not all rescues are really rescues. It's unregulated and there are a lot of unscrupulous people who claim to be rescues but will just take a dog and sell it to the next person that walks through the door.

Real rescues are full to bursting at the momen - because they do things properly.

Guess what they are full of? Teenage dogs, brought in lockdown that are now branded tearways. A hell of a lot of cockerpoos. It makes me... let's go with sad.

Finding your dog a good rescue space will take time, commitment and patience. Not as much as training the dog but still quite a lot. Please do that for him.

I wish, wish, wish that the "breed" had never been invented (as so does the person that invented it) because they look cute and it spawned a tsunami of evil breeders who sold them to people who had no idea what type of dog they are getting - just look cute and sound fancy.

But it's too late for that.

You might some luck with spaniel breed rescues. Spaniel Aid and UK spaniel rescue.

Please please for the love of god do not post on Facebook, gumtree or the like. You will have no way of vetting people. The unscrupulous "rescues" also trawl Facebook for free dogs, offer to rescue and them, keep the dogs in squalor or worse until they can sell them on.

Sure it's a dog not a human, but when you got the dog you took on responsibility for it.'s not the dogs fault.

All teenage dogs are a pain. Cookerpoos are know for being particularly bad. Because it's a mix of 2 working breeds and they need a job. Cockers are bred to go all day flushing out birds. They go stir crazy if they can't express their instincts.

You'd be better off with a gun dog trainer than any of the ones you've used.

I've fostered dogs like yours and there is generally nothing wrong with the dog that consistent, patient training, time, lots of time, enough exercise and mental stimulation won't fix. Plus neutering.

I'm a dog person through and through. I've had 14 fosters over the last 5 years and I've got my own lab and I'm just about really to commit to a working cocker. A dog like that is a lifestyle choice and that choice is serious training for years and years.

Cockerpoos are not for the faint hearted and are a really bad choice for first time family dogs.

But here we are.

If you are in the south east - let me know or DM me - I know a lot of the rescues and might be able to help you find a reputable one with space.

GreekDogRescue · 17/02/2024 19:44

Neriah · 17/02/2024 19:38

This is now considered a myth. Neutered males are actually at greater risk of cancers and other poor health outcomes. Neutering may be an appropriate choice for some behaviours, but that decision should be carefully weighed up against all factors - neutering can actually contribute to some negative behaviours, and create greater physical health risks. If neutering was so advantageous for health outcomes, we'd have it for humans.

We need to spay and neuter as there is a tsunami of stray dogs in many countries in the world, also this country is facing an unprecedented dumping of lockdown dogs as per the OP’s.
The last thing we need is to bring anymore unwanted dogs into this world.
OP wanted to breed from this dog, hence not having him neutered and claiming it would make his anxiety ‘worse’.

Neriah · 17/02/2024 19:41

MerryMaidens · 17/02/2024 19:36

It is a dog though? The OP sounds like she has a lot on her plate and I'd personally put an anxious child over an anxious dog any day of the week. I grew up rurally where dogs were...dogs. No one would have ever compared them to a child.

OP in your shoes I'd explore a couple more options and then it is of course perfectly possible to responsibly rehome. We were expats for a bit and people had to rehome dogs all the time- maybe it was impossible to ship it to the country they were going to; they wouldn't have appropriate accommodation or the dog wouldn't cope in the new climate (huskies to the Gulf etc). Dogs all found new homes, weren't miserable in the wrong kind of set up, all good. You sound thoughtful about this.

That's fine. But rescues and rehoming centres are currently jam packed. There are literally no spaces for more dogs.

Neriah · 17/02/2024 19:38

YeahIsaidit · 17/02/2024 19:26

Neutering should calm him down. Without being neutered, he's more at risk of testicular cancer as he ages and isn't being used for breeding

This is now considered a myth. Neutered males are actually at greater risk of cancers and other poor health outcomes. Neutering may be an appropriate choice for some behaviours, but that decision should be carefully weighed up against all factors - neutering can actually contribute to some negative behaviours, and create greater physical health risks. If neutering was so advantageous for health outcomes, we'd have it for humans.

MerryMaidens · 17/02/2024 19:36

It is a dog though? The OP sounds like she has a lot on her plate and I'd personally put an anxious child over an anxious dog any day of the week. I grew up rurally where dogs were...dogs. No one would have ever compared them to a child.

OP in your shoes I'd explore a couple more options and then it is of course perfectly possible to responsibly rehome. We were expats for a bit and people had to rehome dogs all the time- maybe it was impossible to ship it to the country they were going to; they wouldn't have appropriate accommodation or the dog wouldn't cope in the new climate (huskies to the Gulf etc). Dogs all found new homes, weren't miserable in the wrong kind of set up, all good. You sound thoughtful about this.

bingoringo4 · 17/02/2024 19:35

@mydogisthebest I've got 5. Bite me.

elisec79 · 17/02/2024 19:34

Babyroobs · 17/02/2024 18:55

Has he been neutered ? My working cocker was like this at the same age but much calmer once he had been castrated. I was at the end of what I could cope with but he is wonderful now, couldn't ask for a better dog.

My mini poodle was challenging, just had him neutered age 4, it's made a big difference, he's a lot calmer.