Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone ever got rid of a dog and then regretted it?

181 replies

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 17:45

PLEASE BE KIND.

I know these threads can bring out the worst in people so please don’t kick me when I’m down.

I have a 2 year old dog, had him since a pup. He was honestly the most well behaved puppy ever - crate trained from day one, no accidents inside unless unwell, never chewed or destroyed anything etc. However he has now regressed during his ‘teenage’ stage and is honestly a nightmare.

He doesn’t listen to a word you say, he is running out the front door into the road (he has a gate across the kitchen but has now started jumping this so pretty useless), he is lunging at every dog we see on walks to the point where I don’t want to walk him anymore, jumping all over the furniture, walls and guests whenever someone comes over.

He is a cross bread and a bit of a nightmare to train as of late because nothing motivates him anymore to actually listen to the command you’re giving him.

I’ve honestly got to the point where I’ve given up on him - I dread waking up to him every morning and it’s honestly the biggest shame because I used to absolutely adore that dog before this all started happening but he just triggers the entire household and it’s pushing me to breaking point, I feel mentally and physically unwell and drained.

Has anyone ever got rid of a dog and then later on regretted it?

I really am starting to consider it as one of my options because of the toll it’s taking not only on me but the whole house but my biggest worry is once everything has settled down it would be the biggest mistake of my life getting rid of him…

OP posts:
AutismMum21 · 18/02/2024 17:33

Thank you for all the advice - I spent all yesterday researching some options that stemmed from what people had recommended on here.

I think I have a plan in place however the big issue is I genuinely think I need a couple of days away from the dog to be in the right place mentally to be able to start it - I feel so dysregulated at the moment because it’s been so constant that I’m completely burning out and nothing productive is going to come out of that.

I don’t think any family could take him because one household works all day and the other household has other animals that doesn’t mix well with dogs.

He does have a dog walker but I don’t know if she boards and I don’t know if anyone else would take him in boarding with all the issues that he has…

Has anyone got any ideas of how to work around this please?

OP posts:
GlassCaseOfEmotions · 18/02/2024 14:45

Professionalnot · 18/02/2024 14:27

Hi op,
Could he be suffering from something called red cocker syndrom I believe it was, has that been checked? The bad breeder you say he came from, perhaps they didn't care about prevention, genetic problems etc.

Cocker rage (or rage syndrome) is very rare, very obvious and very dangerous. Nothing OP has said indicates that this dog has it.

It also can't be tested for. By its nature, it's sudden and unpredictable and by the time you got to a vet, the dog would have snapped out of the episode (usually lasts for seconds).

GlassCaseOfEmotions · 18/02/2024 14:38

I have a Sproodle (working springer x poodle). The entire litter are utterly bonkers (breeder is a friend of mine and majority of pups went to people we know). I also have another working line breed.

The problem with this cross is that you're breeding 2 high energy, anxious, working dogs together. If you don't give them the right outlet, they become feral.

Mental stimulation and work is far more important than physical exercise. If you give too much physical exercise, especially unstructured, you create an adrenalin junkie that just won't let up.

  • change your walking route. Dogs, especially entire males, get so much enrichment from different walks each day. Can just be changing direction when you leave your house, walk a street that you wouldn't normally. Let him use his nose and sniff until he moves on from that place. This helps to knacker their brain out
  • patience is key. They are clowns! Make sure the dog is leashed and ask for A command. Stay neutral and wait until the dog gives the behaviour you're asking for. Then calmly praise (treat ideally without saying anything. They feed off the usual 'training pitch' voice)
  • give your dog a long lasting natural chew in the house (different ones each time to keep it interesting) in a place they can relax (no chaos, limited foot traffic etc)
  • get him 'working'. Lots of sniff games (a handful of treats thrown in grass is quick and easy) and a 'find it' command. Hide treats in cardboard boxes with ripped up paper. Use small bits of treats so they're not easy to find
  • crate train if you've not done so already. It's a safe and comforting space for your dog to unwind
  • have a routine and stick to it (meal times, walk time, bed time etc). Like kids, they thrive off routine
  • no unstructured off lead time. Don't just let your dog off to run wild or constantly be throwing a ball. Have a long line if they're likely to bugger off when the lead comes off. Practice recall/ heel/ sit/ down etc and use the long line to reinforce the command. Only when calm and listening should you be letting off the lead, if at all

The teen years are the hardest for any dog. My first had me in tears daily and is dog reactive on lead, my 2nd (the Sproodle) was an angel from day 1 and then went off the rails at just over a year old. They're now nearly 4 and 2.5 and are the loveliest dogs, as long as I'm providing them with the right outlet for the situation.

A gundog trainer is your best bet when it comes to a professional. They understand both breeds and the different drives they have. Your bog standard trainer can teach the very basics, but a gundog trainer will be able to help with breed specifics.

Dogs aren't shaped overnight, it takes a long time to see the rewards of your training. It's taken me nearly 2 years to see small positive changes in my first dog with his reactivity, it will always be a work in progress! Once you've tried all the above and a suitable trainer for 6 months to a year, then consider rehoming if things aren't any better.

You may not be the right household for this dog. Busy families don't tend to mix well with this cross breed unless there's already very well established training and the dog is out of their teens before the environment becomes overstimulating with noise/ kids etc

Professionalnot · 18/02/2024 14:27

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 18:07

@twistyizzy he comes from a really complicated background therefore the first year was spent just building his confidence more than anything.

@needastrongoneagain the highest value treats to him are chicken and cheese but the minute he knows he has to work for them he isn’t bothered - he doesn’t have the best attention span I don’t think!

Hi op,
Could he be suffering from something called red cocker syndrom I believe it was, has that been checked? The bad breeder you say he came from, perhaps they didn't care about prevention, genetic problems etc.

AnnieSnap · 18/02/2024 13:55

@HeadsShouldersTitsandArse You sound caring and sensible (notwithstanding the initial ‘aw puppy’). You clearly thought about what was best for your dog.

HeadsShouldersTitsandArse · 18/02/2024 11:10

I stupidly brought a puppy without properly thinking it through, I didn’t think about the commitment at all. I have to be honest I just thought “aw puppies” and brought one.

He was really well trained for a couple of years, then when DD was born he became jealous and naughty. He would go outside to the toilet, have a wee.. scratch to come back in, then poo on the floor and eat it. After a few months we still couldn’t stop him eating his poo, even when he did it outside he would immediately eat it. Vet gave us a different food to try to it didn’t help. DD started crawling and moving more and the dog started taking more interest in her, but it meant he was always trying to lick her hands and face and I couldn’t cope with that at that point. I was too scared she would catch something nasty or go blind.

DH suggested shutting the dog away while DD was on the floor but that’s seemed like the dog was being shut away for more time than he was out and it wasn’t fair on him at all.

So we rehomed him to a family member who doesn’t have children and had two other dogs of the same breed. He loves life there and we definitely made the right decision for us as a family.

It does mean however, that we have put a complete ban on pets in our home. I don’t feel like I am responsible enough to own a pet and give them a permanent loving home. I would hate myself if we allowed ourselves to have a pet and rehome it again at no fault of its own. So we’re a no pet household.

samsam123 · 18/02/2024 10:57

No a dog is for life

AnnieSnap · 18/02/2024 10:24

Shiningout · 18/02/2024 09:39

I knew it would be something like a cockapoo, they look like a little teddy bear so people go running out to buy them and are then shocked that it grows into a ridiculously high energy dog.

My thoughts exactly. Both my vet and recently retired groomer of some 40-years say they have many more issues than any other dogs. When people want something cute and woolly, that doesn’t shed, why not get an actual Poodle. They come in 3 sizes 🤷‍♀️

Psychoticbreak · 18/02/2024 10:01

Rehome the dog cos you clearly do not want it. Poor baby :(

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 18/02/2024 10:01

@Shannith Because the other person in the relationship doesn't die/end up locked in a kennel for years because you fall out of love with them.

Sadly that happens far too often when the dog is not rehomed - partly, I think, because of the judgement people experience when they want to rehome.

Shiningout · 18/02/2024 09:39

I knew it would be something like a cockapoo, they look like a little teddy bear so people go running out to buy them and are then shocked that it grows into a ridiculously high energy dog.

fruitypancake · 18/02/2024 09:05

He will grow out of the puppy stage !

AlwaysGinPlease · 18/02/2024 08:59

Get rid? Waiting to die? Some disgusting attitudes on this thread. Yours included Op. Hiding it as I have no desire to be banned.

Neriah · 18/02/2024 08:45

DoIhavegreeneyes · 18/02/2024 08:09

My reaction is that having got herself as far as describing the situation in a post here amongst all the dog lovers OP has past the point of coping. For the sake of the humans connected with her and the dog she should remove the dog. Rehome or sell or pts.
That dog is not contributing any pleasure or benefit to that household. It is adding to stress and work.

No responsible vets will put a healthy dog down because its existence is an inconvenience to the owner. And rightly so. You take responsibility for the living creature that you have brought into the family. Rehome if you must. But killing it is not an acceptable answer.

DoIhavegreeneyes · 18/02/2024 08:09

My reaction is that having got herself as far as describing the situation in a post here amongst all the dog lovers OP has past the point of coping. For the sake of the humans connected with her and the dog she should remove the dog. Rehome or sell or pts.
That dog is not contributing any pleasure or benefit to that household. It is adding to stress and work.

Slanketblanket · 18/02/2024 07:59

twistyizzy · 18/02/2024 07:46

No to the ball throwing, very bad for joints and can create ball obsession. For spaniels scent work and search/find/retrieve is much more beneficial. Although they do need daily off lead exercise, spaniels were bred to work all day outside so they never "tire" with increased exercise. What they need is breed appropriate training to reduce anxiety and then taught to settle.

Well we used to throw a frisby rather than a ball and lose it in the hedge every time so I guess that's suitable.

My point was if op is just lead walking along a pavement and back then it's not enough.

If there was any reason I couldn't walk my dog, and it would have to be a big reason like she'd just had leg surgery, she'd get so so naughty at home.

twistyizzy · 18/02/2024 07:46

Slanketblanket · 18/02/2024 06:47

How long are your walks? I don't have experience of a cockapoo but I do with spaniels and generally, they need a lot of exercise otherwise they do get naughty. I'd be walking two hour-long off-lead walks with lots of mental stimulation and ball throwing etc. a day.

If you're trudging round the block on a lead for 20 mins it probably isn't cutting it.

No to the ball throwing, very bad for joints and can create ball obsession. For spaniels scent work and search/find/retrieve is much more beneficial. Although they do need daily off lead exercise, spaniels were bred to work all day outside so they never "tire" with increased exercise. What they need is breed appropriate training to reduce anxiety and then taught to settle.

Slanketblanket · 18/02/2024 06:47

How long are your walks? I don't have experience of a cockapoo but I do with spaniels and generally, they need a lot of exercise otherwise they do get naughty. I'd be walking two hour-long off-lead walks with lots of mental stimulation and ball throwing etc. a day.

If you're trudging round the block on a lead for 20 mins it probably isn't cutting it.

Woodstocks · 18/02/2024 06:36

Tinydogssitter · 17/02/2024 22:35

You too, are only an animal @Woodstocks.

I don’t debate that. As I said - we found the dog a good new home with a family member who had a better setup and actively wanted a dog. Whereas our circumstances changed to the point that we had to modify our lives beyond what we deemed reasonable to keep the dog. I don’t feel ashamed as we did our best by the dog. He wasn’t put down or put in kennels.

I know I know - if you don’t completely give up your life for the pet you are a bad person on here. My friend gave up a pet as she would have been homeless otherwise As couldn’t find somewhere that accepted pets in time. I still believe that humans trump animals even though I know that loads of people love animals more than people.

TheDowagerDoughnut · 18/02/2024 05:37

In all honesty I find these threads - this one included - have a kind of double think to them.

The dog is always untrainable and the owners have always tried everything and loads of professional trainers to no avail, so want to rehome to someone who has more time or patience. Rather suggesting they think the dog IS trainable with more time or patience and undermining the claim they have tried everything. Otherwise, if you have genuinely tried everything in the world, what is a new home going to do differently to get a different result?

That said, if you don't want the dog you don't want it and it's a petty shitty life for a dog to be homed with someone who doesn't want it and won't make the time or patience for them that they need. Better rehomed at two years old than at four or six etc.

Kinder to let the dog try again now when they are young. Just do it responsibly - ideally back to the breeder (I can guess not) or to a well know rehoming charity such as Dogs Trust.

Neriah · 18/02/2024 05:12

GreekDogRescue · 17/02/2024 20:45

I’m afraid do your view is very niche and alternative.

I’ve never heard of any vet who thought that spaying and neutering were detrimental to a dogs health.

Remember that neutering decreases the chances of developing prostatic disease and hernias, and eliminates the chances of developing testicular cancer. It also reduces problems with territorial and sexual aggression, inappropriate urination (spraying) and other undesirable behaviour.

In Greece we deal with primitive older men who have an atavistic dislike of neutering dogs; they take the castration aspect personally lol.

I can understand that dog owners in wealthy countries can afford a more luxury belief but most countries are not like the Uk and have a big ex stray dog problem. These dogs end up being poisoned or slaughtered so it’s much better they aren't born in the first place.

Obviously if you don’t want to neuter your own dog no problem. But that means a lot of vigilance to ensure no unwanted pregnancies.

I'm afraid that the Greek vets view is rather old fashioned and out of date then - but then, dogs wondering around the streets in a semi-feral state isn't as common for many European countries now. I'm sure that if you just use Google you'll find that the health disbenefits of neutering are clearly listed, and people should make informed choices rather than blindly following outmoded ideas. Making informed choices isn't a "luxury belief", but I do appreciate that in other countries irresponsible dog ownership can lead people to think that dogs are the problem rather than the people. Feral and straying dogs or unwanted pregnancy is a people problem, and the fact that the issue still persists in Greece and other countries proves that. Neutering dogs may be a legitimate choice, but it hasn't solved the problems with dogs.

AnnieSnap · 18/02/2024 00:16

AutismMum21 · 17/02/2024 17:54

@fleurneige on the basis that you know nothing about me or what I have or haven’t done with the dog - I’m going to ignore your ignorant post.

To be fair, we know that you had a well trained puppy that has become a difficult dog. That doesn’t just happen. It’s clearly a training issue. Consulting with a Trainer isn’t the same as working with a Trainer regulary over a period of time. That probably is a way forward for you because, based on what you’ve said, you are not really motivated to take the time and expense to really work through this.

The behaviour you describe sounds a bit hyper. Maybe he’s anxious generally. Doggie Daycare isn’t a positive experience for all dogs. Some enjoy it, but it’s actually unatural for dogs to be in a confined space with strange dogs for many hours and it can make an anxious dog worse.

You are clearly at the end of your tether and feeling very negative about your dog. Given that, you are probably giving him little, or no positive reinforcement and kindness in his good moments. It’s likely in the circumstances you describe that he only gets attention from you when he’s ’misbehaving’. Think about how that would affect a difficult child’s behaviour. Things being as they are though, it’s probably better for your dog for him to be out of this situation. I suggest you contact Blue Cross or Dogs Trust. Perhaps they can find him a good home.

FasterthanaButteredOtter · 17/02/2024 23:55

You'd be better off with a gun dog trainer than any of the ones you've used.

I've fostered dogs like yours and there is generally nothing wrong with the dog that consistent, patient training, time, lots of time, enough exercise and mental stimulation won't fix. Plus neutering.

Totally agree. Your dog sounds bored and frustrated. Have you said how much exercise, both physical and mental, he gets daily?

Highfivemum · 17/02/2024 23:50

Please speak to your vet. A change as radical as what u are saying could be due to your dog in some pain. Even if it isn’t vets are highly qualified to advise. Cockerpoos need stimulation. They are highly intelligent and sensitive and hate being left alone. I do hope you can work at out as most dogs become the greatest companions.

JudesBiggestFan · 17/02/2024 23:47

I rehomed a dog once. Realised after six days I'd made a huge mistake and gave her back to the breeder. The relief in realising she had been immediately rehomed and that I hadn't ruined my life was immense! I'd done loads of research but I just hated everything about the reality of her and I will never even consider a dog again. My cat on the other hand I've had for over 10 years and adore. No guilt from me...better to right the wrong quickly, for all concerned.