Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"A smart child will do well in any school" - not true?

183 replies

TBNT · 17/02/2024 16:12

Inspired to ask this due to another thread.

But it's something that's been said to me countless times over the years when looking at the (pretty awful) schools in our local area.

I have always politely nodded while thinking in my head "I'm pretty sure my very academic, yet nerdy and socially anxious child wouldn't do very well in that school"

And until reading on here today hadn't seen that opinion expressed elsewhere and just felt like I was being unreasonable in my own head.

So just that really - I've heard of kids coming out of rough comps with loads of 9s. But I genuinely feel that a child like my eldest DD would not achieve what she's capable of in a place she felt uncomfortable.

OP posts:
TheBeesKnee · 17/02/2024 16:29

I went to the worst school in the borough because I switched the first and last school preference around on my application. 10 year old me was desperate to stay with my best friend, who was going to the school closest to her house.

It was hell. I was bullied for various things and although my friend and I stayed close she made new friends and I kind of didn't really. I was lovely and lessons were disruptive. My mental health was wrecked, I was self harming, and when I admitted to my mum what I'd done with the application she was furious but didn't move me because I'd made my bed, as it were.

I was very motivated to do well and go to college and uni and escape and that kind of kept me going. So technically yes I did well despite everything, but Jesus Christ at what price?

missmollygreen · 17/02/2024 16:29

Not true.
But it is also not true to say that a smart child will do well in a good school.

Cowboybuilderwoes · 17/02/2024 16:29

It’s true statistically based on the evidence, apparently. The rest is all anecdotal.

Alcyoneus · 17/02/2024 16:29

Not true at all. Put a smart kid in a class full of feral ones, what kind of education will they get? Unless they can telepathically extract information out a teacher’s head.

The problem is always other freak kids and their feckless parents.

TBNT · 17/02/2024 16:28

Mangledrake · 17/02/2024 16:22

I wish we had more emphasis on keeping all children safe at school than on their academic achievement. Given the choice I'd prioritise the first for any child of any ability.

100%

Equally I'd rather kids didn't learn (for example) languages at all if it meant that time could be spent working on social skills for all.

(And I love languages! But feel like most schools aren't able to devote the time to their emotional wellbeing when trying to fit all the curriculum in)

OP posts:
seascape124 · 17/02/2024 16:28

Quitelikeit · 17/02/2024 16:16

When you say she would feel
uncomfortable do you assume that the other pupils will be hissing at her all day long or something?

If she is bright then she will succeed and get good grades.

At my daughter's school a girl thinks she's a dog and barks at pupils. She apparently calls herself a furry? I don't quite understand it. So not quite hissing 😕

EarthlyNightshade · 17/02/2024 16:28

Not true, however, I do believe that home environment, having interested parents, a space to work, the tools to work, etc. does help a lot.
My DS is bright and coasting in his comp - if he was at the grammar, he might be working harder and doing better (or he might be deflated and struggling, we'll never know)

YukoandHiro · 17/02/2024 16:28

"I assume, like at her primary school, that she'd be sniffed out like an easy target and be picked on for sport."

Yeah but @TBNT that's literally every school. Even (especially?) the posh private school ones.

What matters is if they find their gang. Likeminded people to protect from external buffeting. I was very lucky in my deeply average school in the sense and made lifelong close friends.

The problem is you can't tell how that's going to go for a couple of years. Go for the school you want, make sure you've got a backup that you'll actually get into, and hope for the best.

I wouldn't hesitate to move schools for social reasons, even if they were excelling academically

RoomOfRequirement · 17/02/2024 16:28

They probably 'do well' in comparison to the national average because they're already smart.

But they might not 'do well' compared to their potential, depending on other factors like their personality and how much they are self motivated vs needing a push.

Silverbirchtwo · 17/02/2024 16:27

Smart children will get an education in any school, but they are failed in most schools because the emphasis tends to be on those that are behind. The smart ones are always ahead of where the class is. I guess a lot depends on the streaming and if there are enough smart kids to be a stream with appropriate teaching. It's really difficult to teach mixed ability groups particularly with large classes. A large comp should have a good top stream which is likely to have pupils with a different attitude to the ones where the children would rather not be there at all.

I agree that quiet, nerdy, socially anxious children won't thrive in a rough bullying environment, but that applies to smart and not so smart children.

finallyme2018 · 17/02/2024 16:27

it is completely false that a clever child learns anywhere. my child is ridiculously clever. I didn’t even know how clever he was though I did know he was cleverer than what he was showing in school. Yet he consistently failed exams and was in the bottom sets at school. I now home educate him and he has a tutor for his lessons who adapts the teaching to the way my child understands and he suddenly acing every tests etc put in front of him. He doesn’t learn the way school teach, he gets anxious and cannot concentrate in noisy classrooms, being subjected to bullying every day and having teachers who do not understand his additional needs just added to his failing mental health. He now has different groups of friends he sees weekly where he had literally 1 friend at school and is about to start a 14-16 college course. Best thing I ever did for him was take him out of the failing educational system in the uk.

taxguru · 17/02/2024 16:27

It's utter bullshit. I started secondary as a straight A pupil and left after five years without a single GCSE "pass". That was because I was bullied daily, not just verbally, but physical assaults and property damage. I started to hide during breaks and lunchtimes to avoid them. Teachers were utterly useless and just did the usual victim blaming of "fight back". The two worse were either side of me in the alphabet so when lazy teachers set seating plans or groups by alphabet I was always put on the same table or in the same group as them. No one, however "bright" will do well in that kind of environment! I pleaded to change forms, change groups, etc., but teachers wouldn't have any of it. My parents tried their best but were of the era where they trusted teachers, and so they started blaming me for not being tough enough too! I ended up truanting to avoid them. It's not as if the school and teachers were any good - it was a failing crap comp where lessons were more crowd control than teaching. Of course, some got a string of As - they were the bullies!!!

Once I left, I did evening classes at the local college to get my GCSE and A levels and then went on to study for Chartered Accountancy exams. So definitely not a lack of ability or work ethic.

Poudretteite · 17/02/2024 16:26

Not true. At my local school, the teachers treated the kids like prisoners, and we were at odds. Teachers wanted to control us, kids wanted to rebel (so it felt). There was no motivation to do well, and it wasn't cool to do well.

A scholarship to a private school was another world and suddenly I was enjoying the competition and getting A*s.

Valeriekat · 17/02/2024 16:26

Quitelikeit · 17/02/2024 16:16

When you say she would feel
uncomfortable do you assume that the other pupils will be hissing at her all day long or something?

If she is bright then she will succeed and get good grades.

Only if they have setting for all subjects.

PrimitivePerson · 17/02/2024 16:25

I went to a grammar school with a brilliant reputation and great results and hated every minute of it. I did OK, but probably could have done better.

I made a point of sending my kids to a comprehensive. They all thrived and had a much more diverse and enriching education than I did.

TBNT · 17/02/2024 16:25

Blakessevenrideagain · 17/02/2024 16:22

Bright does not equal self motivated. Bright but easily led
Bright but lazy
Bright but lacking in confidence
Bright but lacking social skills
Bright but developing MH issues
Bright but masking intelligence to fit in

none of those will achieve without resources, support, and belief from adults around them.

I often read 'Bright will do well anywhere' and think 'what rot!'

I feel like every 'bright but' that you listed describes DD1.

It's a hard world for her to traverse.

OP posts:
WhatNoRaisins · 17/02/2024 16:24

Just anecdata but I couldn't help but notice that this is more true for girls at least academic wise.

I also agree that not having your mental health wrecked by the experience is also important.

whiteboardking · 17/02/2024 16:23

@TBNT you'll prob find there's clubs in school for kids with similar interests. Ours has loads lunch clubs & she'd find similar kids

Blakessevenrideagain · 17/02/2024 16:22

Bright does not equal self motivated. Bright but easily led
Bright but lazy
Bright but lacking in confidence
Bright but lacking social skills
Bright but developing MH issues
Bright but masking intelligence to fit in

none of those will achieve without resources, support, and belief from adults around them.

I often read 'Bright will do well anywhere' and think 'what rot!'

Mangledrake · 17/02/2024 16:22

I wish we had more emphasis on keeping all children safe at school than on their academic achievement. Given the choice I'd prioritise the first for any child of any ability.

TBNT · 17/02/2024 16:22

Also to me - good grades would mean nothing if she ended up hating herself.

So 'doing well' in school to me doesn't mean just getting a load of good GCSEs.

OP posts:
C4tintherug · 17/02/2024 16:22

Not true. I’m a teacher and in classes with constant disruption and poor behaviour we just don’t get the content covered like I do in classes with excellent behaviour. 1 or 2 “characters” can be enough to destroy the whole class learning environment.
I don’t have many classes like that but I do teach in a naice area but the impact of this on outcomes is undeniable. Especially on girls in my opinion, they don’t get a voice in a classroom that is full of boisterous boys.

SongbirdGarden · 17/02/2024 16:22

A smart child will do even better home educated.

whiteboardking · 17/02/2024 16:21

People over exaggerate all extremes.
Kids do well if pushed by parents and study hard. So yes can do well even if school isn't the best. But a child won't do well if bullied. But bullying often over exaggerated by people who don't even go to these schools.
All the big city comps I know have high academic kids that stick together and middle road ones that stick together and kids who aren't interested. They tend to stick in own tribe

MacaroonMacaron · 17/02/2024 16:21

No it's bollocks.

There are probably a few kids out there who are laser-focused, very driven and who basically teach themselves the syllabus and pass exams with not much teacher input. They would do well in any school.

Most kids are not like that. Most kids would find it really hard to learn in an environment where they are bullied and picked on for doing their homework, answering in class and being a swot. Most would find it hard to get any work done at all when their classmates are swearing at the teacher and chucking chairs about. Or when the school can't recruit permanent teachers and the kids are having to make do with a procession of able and well-qualified teachers, but who up and leave for a permanent position as soon as it comes up. Or in a school where academic achievement is low, and the school doesn't offer more than one or two A-levels/Advanced Highers because there isn't the demand. Or where the general attitude is that school is for mugs, you're there to have fun with your mates rather than learn anything, and messing about is just what you do.

It's a trite phrase which some parents trot out to make themselves feel better about their own situation.