Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"A smart child will do well in any school" - not true?

183 replies

TBNT · 17/02/2024 16:12

Inspired to ask this due to another thread.

But it's something that's been said to me countless times over the years when looking at the (pretty awful) schools in our local area.

I have always politely nodded while thinking in my head "I'm pretty sure my very academic, yet nerdy and socially anxious child wouldn't do very well in that school"

And until reading on here today hadn't seen that opinion expressed elsewhere and just felt like I was being unreasonable in my own head.

So just that really - I've heard of kids coming out of rough comps with loads of 9s. But I genuinely feel that a child like my eldest DD would not achieve what she's capable of in a place she felt uncomfortable.

OP posts:
Fionaville · 17/02/2024 16:47

Not true. Which is why I choose to home educate.
I've seen too many bright and curious children, failed in schools. It's the dog eat dog environment that is the problem. An unhappy child can't thrive or learn well.

MidnightsLover · 17/02/2024 16:46

Only you know your child. My DS is incredibly bright but was constantly told by teachers he was underperforming. Started homeschooling and included plenty of time outdoors, physical activities, as well as the basic maths/english everyday and he started learning SO MUCH FASTER. Last week he told me e=mc^2 and quantum physics- that is university level and he is only 13!

MereDintofPandiculation · 17/02/2024 16:46

Blakessevenrideagain · 17/02/2024 16:22

Bright does not equal self motivated. Bright but easily led
Bright but lazy
Bright but lacking in confidence
Bright but lacking social skills
Bright but developing MH issues
Bright but masking intelligence to fit in

none of those will achieve without resources, support, and belief from adults around them.

I often read 'Bright will do well anywhere' and think 'what rot!'

The same applies across the board

Moderate ability but easily led
Moderate ability but lazy
Moderate ability but lacking in confidence
Moderate ability but lacking social skills
Moderate ability but developing MH issues
Moderate ability but masking intelligence to fit in

  • none of those will do well

No matter what the intelligence level of the child, you need to find the school which is the least worst fit to their personality.

And bright won't necessarily do better home-schooled. They'll have the attention to follow their academic pursuits but may struggle with interpersonal skills.

FatPrincess · 17/02/2024 16:45

Hmm, I feel like it might be harder for some kids to fit in at some rougher schools. I work at a plant in a pretty rough working class area and most of the lads went to the local schools. Plenty of XL bully owners and cocaine use amongst them compared to people I know from more privileged backgrounds.

TheSnowyOwl · 17/02/2024 16:42

Doing well is subjective. I would say that in general a smart child will do well academically in any school but they could do much better in certain schools than they do in others. Will they do well mentally and socially though? There will also always be some exceptions and perhaps some children who don’t do well mentally and/socially which impacts them academically.

Mangledrake · 17/02/2024 16:39

Alcyoneus · 17/02/2024 16:29

What are parents for? Should schools teach your kids how to wipe their arse too?

It's a balance. Schools have always had a socialising aim as well as (or as part of) an educational mission.

Some countries spend more time than the UK, especially in early years, working on soft skills like sharing, team work, speaking up, assessing risk etc.

Overwhelming schools with targets while squeezing resources isn't conducive to a good learning environment.

Octavia64 · 17/02/2024 16:38

They are doing a lot of work at the moment looking at why pupil premium kids (basically free school meals kids) who have achieved well in the end of primary tests do so badly at GCSEs.

So bright but poor kids tend to do worse at secondary (overall in the U.K.).

So it's certainly the case that these clever kids aren't doing well.

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5f564f07d3bf7f4d75de7000/Researchtoounderstandsuccessfullapproachestoosupportingtheemostacademicallyyabledisadvantageddpupils.pdf

CurlyhairedAssassin · 17/02/2024 16:37

Depends on the personality of the child. My very quiet and bright eldest DS would have hated the rowdiness and poor behaviour of the boys' only comp that I worked at for many years. I used to feel so sorry for the boys with similar personalities and ability in my old school who struggled to manage simple things like walking down the corridor or the yard at lunchtime. My DS went to a grammar instead and it suited his personality really well - lots of quiet nerds who wanted to behave, and his friend group had v similar personalities to him. He could not have done any better academically and is thriving at a top uni now. His school was the right place for him, without a doubt.

However my neice is at a similar comp to the one i worked at, where behaviour can be an issue. She's a different personality to DS. She's very bright, but she's also very confident and has always held her own, not scared to voice her opinions. Doesn't follow the crowd and isn't easily led. Rolls her eyes in class at the poorly-behaved kids, does her best to focus on lessons and ignore the poor behaviour, is a total self-starter doing lots of extra work and reading in her own time, very ambitious, got a good group of friends who are similar to her. It's early days as she's only doing GCSEs this year but the signs are that she will do brilliantly. The school doesn't have a 6th form so she'll go elsewhere to college and I'm sure will apply herself there too. I have no doubt that attending her "rough" school has not made any difference to her outcomes, and in some ways has made her less sheltered and more robust.

So it all comes down to whether an academic child's personality is robust enough to cope with the chaos that a "rough" school can bring, so that they can be tenacious enough not to develop a "if you can't beat 'em, join 'em" when there's poor behaviour going on around them.

I don't think it's particularly about the quality of teachers as in the rough school I worked in there were some outstanding teachers. I think it's probably easier them to teach in a school where behaviour is good though.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 17/02/2024 16:37

I was on track to leave with no qualifications, as soon as legally possible. Had been written off as stupid. School was alternately terrifyingly bullying and boring. Thankfully we moved to a small town, school was very different, ended up with A levels and a place at a really good uni.

TBNT · 17/02/2024 16:37

@Alcyoneus TBNT
100%

Equally I'd rather kids didn't learn (for example) languages at all if it meant that time could be spent working on social skills for all.

(And I love languages! But feel like most schools aren't able to devote the time to their emotional wellbeing when trying to fit all the curriculum in)

"What are parents for? Should schools teach your kids how to wipe their arse too?"

Well my point exactly - some parents aren't raising kids who are kind, tolerant, or socially mature. So I'd sooner schools bloody did.

OP posts:
NoTouch · 17/02/2024 16:36

Ds came out with straight As in his poor performing schoolv(only 3-4 pupils got all A each year out of 250+).

But he had good friends in the early years. they unfortunately went of the rails a bit in exams years (drinking, police etc) so he switched close friendship groups to avoid the drama, but stayed friendly with all.

yes, a child can get the grades but they need to have confidence, be resilient, self motivated and want to avoid trouble which is rife in their school.

they do still miss out though, teachers are so busy dealing with behaviour issues or supporting those who really need it, so those that are doing ok are generally left to get on with it and not stretched or given other opportunities. more than one teacher said as much at parents evenings.

ds’s school sent out letters a couple of times saying some pupils were identified as doing very well and it was planned they would get various opportunities - mentoring, clubs etc, not one thing materialised.

Mangledrake · 17/02/2024 16:36

Cowboybuilderwoes · 17/02/2024 16:29

It’s true statistically based on the evidence, apparently. The rest is all anecdotal.

It's true if you look at averages. On average, children with high IQs do better even if not at selective schools.

This really doesn't mean a bright child will do well (never mind as well as they could) anywhere.

Easipeelerie · 17/02/2024 16:35

Smart has to mean enormous work ethic, self-motivated, spends hours watching YouTube videos on how to approach different question types. Not many kids are like this.

AmaryllisChorus · 17/02/2024 16:35

Of course it's not true. No child would do well in any school. They need to be at the right school.

Some children will fit well in many schools. Lots won't, especially the smart children are also neurodiverse – they certainly don't thrive in any school.

Bright children who are lonely and isolated or bullied aren't thriving and may fail to do well in adulthood, in the work place and socially - however good their exams results might be. Bright children at schools where it is uncool to be curious, to use critical thinking, to be keen on hard work, may fall in with the crowd just to be socially accepted. That's not thriving.

I often think that phrase is trotted out by people whose children did fine at the local school and so assume all children would. On here, I've noticed it's often used by people who disapprove of private schools.

ICanSeeMyHouseFromHere · 17/02/2024 16:34

A bright kid will probably do OK in most schools, but, my (geeky, young for his age) boy would be eaten alive at some of the schools I went to, so I chose carefully.

Also, opportunities are different - for example, at the comp I did my GCSEs at, I could only do double award science, there was very little choice in other subjects, let alone something exotic, or any way to do something like Maths early and move onto something more advanced - same for A-levels. vs one of the other schools I went to where they had the interest and facilities for separate sciences, every child did a General Studies A-level (which, yes, I know isn't much, but coming out with 4 A-levels rather than 3 is nice), there were multiple options when it came to further maths etc.

PrimitivePerson · 17/02/2024 16:32

missmollygreen · 17/02/2024 16:29

Not true.
But it is also not true to say that a smart child will do well in a good school.

Yeah, I certainly didn't. I went to a school that people are absolutely desperate to get their kids into, and the place was an absolutely brutal over-competitive hellhole with sadistic thugs for teachers.

DeathMetalMum · 17/02/2024 16:32

Not true.

Whilst I didn't get amazing results I benefited from going to a school across town, where in the class I was in my peers actually did their homework and worked hard. I passed all GCSE's, though I could have done better. My parents expected me to revise/do homework but didnt actually check or make sure I did it.

I was bright but lazy/not self motivated as a teenager.

Other children that lived nearby went to the local school - I probably would have not attended school regularly, and I doubt I would have passed many exams.

Blaggingit123 · 17/02/2024 16:32

There’s more to life than school and exam results. I am academically bright and went to a lower than average school. Didn’t get (any) top grades at GCSE (I imagine we weren’t taught the higher end of the syllabus) though in top 3 for the school, better at A Level (well top of my school, 300 points, probably due to the smaller classes), 2.1 at university, onto a prestigious graduate scheme and I’m succeeding now after having kids. High school and GCSEs are a platform but it doesn’t end there, and yes a bright child who wants to succeed will be able to get enough of a platform to do so at any school, I think, though it may limit the opportunities available it won’t stop them.

Social needs are something different though I think. To succeed in life you’ll need to be resilient to this sort of thing anyway I think so going to a school where it’s easier isn’t necessarily a positive and might not prepare you best for reality!

MacaroonMacaron · 17/02/2024 16:31

missmollygreen · 17/02/2024 16:29

Not true.
But it is also not true to say that a smart child will do well in a good school.

Agree, but you are swinging the odds in their favour. A bright child is more likely to do better when they are surrounded by other people like them, who are motivated to learn and who behave and respect the teachers, and whose parents are encouraging and supportive.

AncientQuercus · 17/02/2024 16:31

I've never agreed with that stupid expression.

I was a bright child who could have done well at school had it not been turned into a comprehensive. I needed to keep off the radar of the bullies so did nothing to bring attention to myself. My brother was bright but extremely lazy and did the bare minimum. School responded by just putting him into lower and lower sets.

My eldest was bright but very easily led. Once at a high-performing school she pushed herself to keep up with her friends and try to beat the best in class.

My second, autistic and not at all influenced by popular trends BUT looked out for by friends from primary thrived at a school that would have totally failed his sister. He was single minded enough to tread his own path and take no notice of anyone else.

Both did really well, but neither would have done as well in a different school.

taxguru · 17/02/2024 16:30

SongbirdGarden · 17/02/2024 16:22

A smart child will do even better home educated.

I agree, or they could even self-teach if bright and motivated with a hunger to learn. After my awful years at a crap comp, I vowed to take our son out of school and home school him at the first sign of bullying or disruption at his school - luckily it worked well for him because the school was red hot on discipline and had zero tolerance of disruption, bullying, etc., so he did ok. But I really would have removed him in a heartbeat after what I suffered.

Boomer55 · 17/02/2024 16:30

I think some children can do well, even in a poor school. But, it would depend on family support and a host of other things.🙂

Octavia64 · 17/02/2024 16:30

Absolutely not true for a whole raft of reasons.

Most teens will adapt their behaviour to the kids around them partially just from peer pressure but also teens can really bully others very badly.

In a bad school this means not sticking out, not being too keen, and not working too hard.

In a good school this means doing your homework, taking part in extra curriculars and working hard in lessons.

It makes a massive massive difference.

Bananasandtoast · 17/02/2024 16:30

My DH is a very intelligent man and has/is doing well in his career and earning well.
He'd be doing alot better if he hadn't gone to one of the roughest schools in the country where he didn't feel safe to wear his glasses.
So he struggled through secondary school days barely able to make out the board and getting in trouble for missing things because of this. All preferable to being beaten up.

Alcyoneus · 17/02/2024 16:29

TBNT · 17/02/2024 16:28

100%

Equally I'd rather kids didn't learn (for example) languages at all if it meant that time could be spent working on social skills for all.

(And I love languages! But feel like most schools aren't able to devote the time to their emotional wellbeing when trying to fit all the curriculum in)

What are parents for? Should schools teach your kids how to wipe their arse too?

Swipe left for the next trending thread