Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"A smart child will do well in any school" - not true?

183 replies

TBNT · 17/02/2024 16:12

Inspired to ask this due to another thread.

But it's something that's been said to me countless times over the years when looking at the (pretty awful) schools in our local area.

I have always politely nodded while thinking in my head "I'm pretty sure my very academic, yet nerdy and socially anxious child wouldn't do very well in that school"

And until reading on here today hadn't seen that opinion expressed elsewhere and just felt like I was being unreasonable in my own head.

So just that really - I've heard of kids coming out of rough comps with loads of 9s. But I genuinely feel that a child like my eldest DD would not achieve what she's capable of in a place she felt uncomfortable.

OP posts:
ApplesAndPearsTheFruits · 17/02/2024 17:36

ilovebreadsauce · 17/02/2024 17:32

It's not just a question of knowing and applying the material sadly.well at least it isn't on STEM subjects. You often need to know the exam board and how they like answers wording- certain buzz words and phrases you need to hit.you really need a teacher experienced on the idiosyncrasies of the exam board

I remember this with English as well – there was kind of a formula and a few specific linguistic terms that were drummed into us as being point scorers.

Notmyfirstusername · 17/02/2024 17:35

I went to one of the worst schools in the country at the time I was sitting my GCSEs.
I scraped straight C’s in everything . If I remember correctly, the percentage of pupils getting grade C English and maths was well below 20% at the time. It still hasn’t managed 20% decades later. As soon as I escaped to a half decent sixth form outside the area, I obtained straight A grades at A level and was offered places at Oxford and Cambridge based on my tutor’s recommendation.

I was laughed at in college and university as I couldn’t pronounce many words correctly, as I’d only seen them written in books I borrowed from the local library. My spelling and grammar is still appalling today, as I have no foundation in the basics, it took until my late 20’s to learn how to spell words like biscuit and field reliably.

No matter how bright and motivated the child, if you go to a school like my old one and have no family support, you’ll scrape through at best.

ilovebreadsauce · 17/02/2024 17:32

It's not just a question of knowing and applying the material sadly.well at least it isn't on STEM subjects. You often need to know the exam board and how they like answers wording- certain buzz words and phrases you need to hit.you really need a teacher experienced on the idiosyncrasies of the exam board

ApplesAndPearsTheFruits · 17/02/2024 17:25

I actually feel like comprehensives can be more balanced and relaxed socially than some ‘academic’ schools.

I had experience of both, and while the comprehensive had stuff like playground fights (which was unheard of at the v middle class – although free – grammar), at the comp people had wider and more varied groups of friends. The single-sex grammar school I also went to was by comparison v cliquey and more socially uptight, with little friendship sets that no one ever deviated from – everyone had a small, rigid group. It was weird! And bullying happened but was more likely to be from ’friends’ isolating others in the group rather than the hard kid in the year being mouthy.

I think it’s a mistake to generalise that one type of place will be gentle and nice and another type rough.

monpetitlapin · 17/02/2024 17:24

Also if you send a bright kid to a school where it's frowned upon to do well or be inquisitive, they will not have any friends and will likely be bullied.

I think it only works if the parents have enough money (not below the poverty line, for sure), the right outlook on life and the understanding of the right things to be able to support the child to do better in spite of a shit school, and live somewhere/do activities where the child gets a social life beyond the shit school. Those kind of kids will do well anywhere, because most of their learning isn't taking place in school anyway.

IMO, the ability of the child isn't as important as the ability of the parents to facilitate that (e.g. sign them up to the library so they can borrow books, give them internet access these days, etc)

Tel12 · 17/02/2024 17:24

I think that good schools tend to enable the average child to do better. The super smart tend to do well in most average schools. Just my personal observation.

Goblinmodeactivated · 17/02/2024 17:20

If the school struggles to retain staff, so there’s a constant roster of cover staff who don’t know what they are supposed to be teaching, plus disruptive children who the cover teachers don’t discipline, then it’s much more difficult for that smart kid to excel (albeit not impossible I guess)

Garlicdoughball · 17/02/2024 17:19

My child is quite nerdy, she goes to a “rough” school. She’s been happy and has done well, her (school) friend has an offer for Cambridge.

Paradiddlediddle · 17/02/2024 17:19

DS1 would, I’m fairly sure, do as well as he could do anywhere. Massively self motivated, clever, hard working, resilient when it comes to peers but very motivated by praise/respect from adults. As it happens he ended up in a super selective grammar.
DS2 is only 7 but I can already see he needs someone focussing on him and will coast if allowed. He probably needs a bit more pressure than the local comp will apply.

borntobequiet · 17/02/2024 17:19

SongbirdGarden · 17/02/2024 16:22

A smart child will do even better home educated.

Not the ones I picked up in FE whose education had been horribly patchy. Home education can be inadequate too.

LolaSmiles · 17/02/2024 17:18

I don't think it's true either. In my experience it's something that's trotted out as a way to either have a dig at anyone for their education choices or to avoid acknowledging that quite a lot of children don't reach their potential in the current system.

A bright child who is socially skilled, with a supportive family, especially one with the ability and willingness to top up with tutors and enrichment, will probably do well compared to their peers in most environments, but that's very different to thriving and reaching their potential.

monpetitlapin · 17/02/2024 17:15

YANBU. I was thinking about this the other day. My parents believed this so I was moved from an outstanding high school to an inadequate one that was closer (so no bus fare needed) in Y9. The standards were completely different, the teaching quality wasn't great, pupils were disruptive in lessons and disrespectful to teachers, and in group work there was no one at my level to work with so I ended up carrying every group work project. There was zero stretch and challenge. And careers advice was nonexistent so I made all the wrong GCSE choices and was very limited in what I could do at A-level as I knew nothing about needing, for example, GCSE History to do the A-level.

Bushmillsbabe · 17/02/2024 17:11

It should be amended to 'a smart, very motivated child in any school they are happy in will do well' My secondary was almost closed down at least twice in the time I was there due to failing inspections and the teachers spent more time on crowd control than anything else. But I had really interested teachers who recognised my commitment to my chosen career path (medicine) and gave me extra support and resources to enable me to basically teach myself the curriculum in my own time. I loved my time at school, made lifelong friends but most of what I learnt was self taught. I walked out with highest possible grades in gcse and A levels and a top uni place. My brother, equally smart but not motivated and no clear idea of what he was aiming at came out with much lower grades from a private school, he hated his time there and was bullied as the 'scholarship kid' (I also got a scholarship but decided not to go). Also had he gone to my school I think he would have done even worse from an academic perspective
A school which they are happy and receive a well rounded education is my priority for my girls. It may not be the highest rated by ofsted. There is no 'best school', only the best school for your child.

megletthesecond · 17/02/2024 17:10

Yanbu.
My DD (waiting ASD assessment, originally predicted 7-9 grades but now 1-2) hasn't been able to cope with secondary at all. Too much noise in the corridors and classrooms. She managed the extra curricular classes as it was only the children who wanted to be there and no one mucked around. She was scared of the teachers who raised their voices and the strict rules.

Citrusandginger · 17/02/2024 17:09

Peer pressure is enormous at secondary. And especially for years 9-11 when peers can have more influence than parents.

School that manage to hold onto their reputation for academic achievement tend to attract parents who want their children to do well and I think it makes a big difference if your child's friends parents hold similar values to you. It's no surprise that schools that attract children with high parental expectations continue to get good results. And it's equally true that schools that struggle to attract middle class parents will struggle to get good results. Even if the children are brighter.

The fly in the ointment is bullying. If a school has a reputation for academic success and good behaviour but doesn't do enough to tackle bullying, they will let their children down.

restingrichface · 17/02/2024 17:07

YANBU.

It depends entirely on the personality of the child. If they're not confident and/or a self-starter, they absolutely won't thrive as well in a lesser environment.

AmaryllisChorus · 17/02/2024 17:06

Echobelly · 17/02/2024 16:47

I think a smart child can do well in any school academically, but how gratifying an experience school is for them is another matter.

An intelligent motivated child can probably still get good results at a school where a small number of kids who DGAF are allowed to disrupt lessons constantly, but it'll be a pretty miserable existence especially as this kind of disruption must be incredibly tedious as well.

This is true. And it's not just about passing exams either. It's about feeling like you belong. Like you are in an environment where your enthusiasm for learning isn't sneered out, doesn't make you an outsider, a swot, a teacher's pet, but is as natural to your fellow pupils as it is to you.

I went to a state school where it was deeply uncool to like learning. Even the teachers were bitchy if you were too keen. My DC went to our 'lovely' local primary school in a leafy village and I noticed the same attitude. Staff and pupils seemed to almost disapprove of intelligence, of academic ability. So we looked at local private schools. Found one that wasn't all about status and wealth, but about learning. DC were so happy there.

PuttingDownRoots · 17/02/2024 17:06

I have observed that my DD will strive to be in the top 10-15% of her class. But not necessarily push to be better than that. The better her classmates do, the better she does.

Her sister will just push herself to do the best she can, regardless what's happening around her. She's not as smart book wise as her sister, but has better work ethic and self motivation.

ErrolTheDragon · 17/02/2024 16:58

They may or may not do 'well', but they're more likely to fulfil their potential in a school which suits them.

HelpMebeok · 17/02/2024 16:56

I think it depends what you mean. Lots of people think that private education buys best. But it really depends on the school, your child's personality and outlook, and the culture of the other children within the school. It's a lot more complicated than a bright child will flourish at any school

TooOldForThisNonsense · 17/02/2024 16:53

I think it depends. My eldest son has got the highest possible grades in an OK state school so he could not have done better in a better state school or private. But I guess it may depend on things like class size, level of disruption, and obvs an OK school is still better than a bad one

coxesorangepippin · 17/02/2024 16:53

I was a very bright kid who went to a very rough comp. Really, really rough.

Yes, I passed all my GCSE's with A-C's but can't help but think I'd have had 9 A's had I gone to the grammar school down the road.

Peer pressure and your school environment contribute hugely in the teen years.

Hence why my kids will be going to private school come hell or high water.

aramox1 · 17/02/2024 16:50

A smart motivated well-supported child has a better chance of doing well. But no.

ScarlettSunset · 17/02/2024 16:50

Depends very much on the child and also the support and encouragement given by parents.
Some children can can do amazingly well in a 'bad' school, and likewise, a clever child at a really good school can do badly if the parents aren't interested at all.

Echobelly · 17/02/2024 16:47

I think a smart child can do well in any school academically, but how gratifying an experience school is for them is another matter.

An intelligent motivated child can probably still get good results at a school where a small number of kids who DGAF are allowed to disrupt lessons constantly, but it'll be a pretty miserable existence especially as this kind of disruption must be incredibly tedious as well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread