Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"A smart child will do well in any school" - not true?

183 replies

TBNT · 17/02/2024 16:12

Inspired to ask this due to another thread.

But it's something that's been said to me countless times over the years when looking at the (pretty awful) schools in our local area.

I have always politely nodded while thinking in my head "I'm pretty sure my very academic, yet nerdy and socially anxious child wouldn't do very well in that school"

And until reading on here today hadn't seen that opinion expressed elsewhere and just felt like I was being unreasonable in my own head.

So just that really - I've heard of kids coming out of rough comps with loads of 9s. But I genuinely feel that a child like my eldest DD would not achieve what she's capable of in a place she felt uncomfortable.

OP posts:
Spendonsend · 17/02/2024 18:48

No i dont think so, i've been to governor meetings at 4 secondary schools recently, all looking at attaintment and progress 8. Some schools are doing better with their cohort than others. Some schools really coast with high prior attainers. They still do ok but not as well as they shoukd have done. Other schools are known as 'bad' on attainmeng but actually really bring everyone forward.

Thats before you even get to issues like bulling, motivation and feeling safe or enjoying school, other oportunites etc.

VaccineSticker · 17/02/2024 18:46

strawberriesandsun · 17/02/2024 17:58

So basically. Children who have rich parents have choices that children from poorer or just average backgrounds don't have, so will never do as well. Great world we live in.

Yes and this applies to pretty much everything on this globe on an internationally level. That’s how the world works.
But what we can do as a nation is narrow the gap between the rich and poor by spending more money on education to make sure that the future generation has had the best start in life regardless of their income.
Ultimately, they will be the future tax payers and innovators etc. if we don’t nurture this generation, then the country has no future.

noodlesfortea · 17/02/2024 18:43

I posted on the other thread about my experience - I think school environment and teaching makes a big difference.

I did well at GCSE and degree level, but very poorly at A level (different school to GCSEs). I suspect if I'd stuck at the same school I would have done better.

But if you are stuck with rubbish school, there are other ways you can support like tutors.

izimbra · 17/02/2024 18:42

A lot of secondary school choice is largely about social engineering.

A school in the UK which is predominantly full of children from disadvantaged and working class backgrounds will by and large be considered a 'bad' school on mumsnet, regardless of its progress 8 score, how well it's managed or how committed and hard working its teachers are.

My son went to a massive comprehensive with a mix of kids from a wide range of backgrounds and achieved very highly - but he has ASD, and doesn't give a sh*t about what anyone thinks of him.

Our school system is horrifically socially polarised and it's really damaging to many children. I'm always staggered that people are so blind to it, and accepting of this as it's absolute poison for kids from ordinary families.

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/02/2024 18:41

Thepeopleversuswork · 17/02/2024 18:07

I think it's a bit more nuanced than that. It's certainly true that children who have rich parents have a safety net which isn't available to children from poorer backgrounds, they can afford not to do as well at school and their parents can pay for them to avoid the schools where learning is hardest (and obviously pay to support with extra coaching etc where needed).

But private school isn't a panacea: not all private schools are good (some are worse than many state schools), they don't suit all children from a cultural/social perspective and they are not immune from the problems that affect state schools. Some private schools have terrible bullying problems.

And some kids, from a range of backgrounds, do brilliantly in terrible schools. Children whose parents prioritise education can do surprisingly well in very poor economic circumstances. Its at least as much about the parents' attitude as it is the amount of money spent on the child's education.

But I'd agree with your premise that it's a lottery and its profoundly unfair

Yet not all parents choose to do this despite having the means. I went to one of the worst schools in the country. So bad my friend’s parents wouldn’t send their dcs there and they were a very ordinary family; my friend trained as a hairdresser, her brother a builder.

My mother otoh used to crow at me about her education at a very prestigious grammar. At my school, the teachers missed out swathes of subject matter eg in maths there was no choice between A and B as we hadn’t been taught B. Unsurprisingly I got mediocre passes. Bs and Cs.

None of this stopped my parents from leaving me to rot in this awful school when they had the means to pay for decent education… or even just send me to a better school a few miles down the road.

UnaPeacock · 17/02/2024 18:41

@PrimitivePerson are you me?? :) I was exactly the same at my grammar school. Hated every second and switched off from my learning, just plodded on until the end of 6th form. In hindsight, I think I would have done better at my local comp. My eldest is in year 7 at our local comp and he is thriving and loving school and the extra curricular stuff. Not all schools suit all children.

Futb0l · 17/02/2024 18:41

I was really academic & nerdy and not great socially.

I came out of my poor comprehensive school with top grades and went to a great university, on to a high regarded grad scheme and now in a very well paid job.

The only real downside was I didn't have a great time friendship wise. I was bullied to a minor degree, mainly in the sense of being rather deliberately excluded at times. I drifted - not often totally alone but often on the edge of a group and looking back? They tolerated me, they didn't like me. I didn't "fit" with that mainly unaspiring crowd. I didn't really stay in touch with people from school for more than a couple of years afterwards.

As an adult? I'm really happy, great job, loads of lovely friends, met my wonderful husband at uni, and it really doesn't matter a jot that I don't have a clutch of school friends.

Parenting makes a bigger difference. FWIW DH sister went to a top, in demand private and came away from it with wprse grades than mine, anorexia, and not particularly great friendships.

Magatha · 17/02/2024 18:40

Blakessevenrideagain · 17/02/2024 16:22

Bright does not equal self motivated. Bright but easily led
Bright but lazy
Bright but lacking in confidence
Bright but lacking social skills
Bright but developing MH issues
Bright but masking intelligence to fit in

none of those will achieve without resources, support, and belief from adults around them.

I often read 'Bright will do well anywhere' and think 'what rot!'

Absolutely this.

Very few bright children will be self motivated enough to ignore their environment and reach their full potential.

I've been amazed at my DCs school and the support and encouragement they provide - children want to do well. At my shit comprehensive there were no expectations and it wasn't cool to try - we were encouraged to think of jobs like lab assistants, admin workers. I can't recall anyone aiming for professions like medicine or law. We weren't even taught the curriculum beyond A grade, no ambitions to get us to A* level.

Naptrappedmummy · 17/02/2024 18:40

Mangledrake · 17/02/2024 16:19

Like you, I doubt this very much.

A smart, confident, extroverted, neurotypical child without disabilities, ideally sporty, not of a race / religion likely to attract bullies wherever they live, is pretty likely to do well at any school.

A smart child can succeed academically without good teaching, with some initiative and family encouragement. But other aspects of life, especially school life can undermine their academic progress very easily.

But there’s well and ‘well’. They might do well at the comp (and there is a MASSIVE range of quality when it comes to comps, so no assuming they’re like the ones in a leafy area of Surrey/Bath/York please!), as in they might pass an acceptable number of exams and go on to a good career, but those sorts of children could’ve really shone had they gone to a grammar or private (or one of the top comprehensives).

It isn’t rocket science or controversial to realise small class sizes, invested parents and excellent facilities will usually push average students to good, and good to excellent.

TwoWithCurls · 17/02/2024 18:36

I went to an all girls' selective grammar. If I'd been in a mixed comp I wouldn't have done any work at all, because I was a bit of a wild child who just wanted to socialise and make people laugh.

Chairwoman · 17/02/2024 18:33

I was a bright child in primary, went to a rough secondary school and pissed around for 3 years getting kicked out of classes, detention, etc. I was honestly such a shit.
Moved schools and area's in Y9 and became the geeky kid that didn’t fit in, so concentrated more on my studies and got some As/Bs. I know if I would have stayed in my old school it wouldn’t have gone as well, I was far too influenced by my peers and fitting in with the cool crowd.
The move affected my MH but I genuinely don’t believe a bright child will do well at any school. Disagree completely.

Timeturnerplease · 17/02/2024 18:31

C4tintherug · 17/02/2024 16:22

Not true. I’m a teacher and in classes with constant disruption and poor behaviour we just don’t get the content covered like I do in classes with excellent behaviour. 1 or 2 “characters” can be enough to destroy the whole class learning environment.
I don’t have many classes like that but I do teach in a naice area but the impact of this on outcomes is undeniable. Especially on girls in my opinion, they don’t get a voice in a classroom that is full of boisterous boys.

This. I teach primary, but I’ve very much noticed the same; no one learnt as much as they could have done last year, when we were all constantly interrupted by disruptive children in that class.

Hatty65 · 17/02/2024 18:31

A smart and motivated child will probably do well in any school.

Unfortunately, I've got a smart, idle dickhead who pissed about through his entire school career (in excellent schools, with excellent teaching) and has achieved very little academically.

Tomatojuiceandvodka · 17/02/2024 18:29

buttercupcake · 17/02/2024 18:23

My child achieved all 9’s at GCSE & 4 A*’s at A level at the local comp. It can be done with the right focus and home support.

It can be done but social injustice often carries on well beyond exam results.

from a horrific comp I managed all as and a at gcse and 4 as at a level (back in the olden days before a levels had as)went to a top uni and completed my course with a close friend who had been through eton. Despite our equal qualifications, our lifestyles remain a world apart.

Edit to say I’ve accidentally made this bold by typing asterisks!

DelilahBucket · 17/02/2024 18:29

I don't think it's true. My school failed me in so many ways and despite being very bright I came aways with B's, C's a D and an E in my GCSEs. I only got those grades because I was bright. I should have been all A's and A*'s.
DS didn't go to his feeder secondary. I don't think he would be predicted 7-9's if he had gone to that school. The one we got him into encourages him to his potential. That's not to say that he isn't surrounded by kids who either aren't academic, or have no interest in being there, that's no different to any other comp, but how the pupils are treated is very different. Those who would happily muddle through in the middle are given extra lessons and pushed a bit further to maximise their capabilities.

VaccineSticker · 17/02/2024 18:29

TBNT · 17/02/2024 16:12

Inspired to ask this due to another thread.

But it's something that's been said to me countless times over the years when looking at the (pretty awful) schools in our local area.

I have always politely nodded while thinking in my head "I'm pretty sure my very academic, yet nerdy and socially anxious child wouldn't do very well in that school"

And until reading on here today hadn't seen that opinion expressed elsewhere and just felt like I was being unreasonable in my own head.

So just that really - I've heard of kids coming out of rough comps with loads of 9s. But I genuinely feel that a child like my eldest DD would not achieve what she's capable of in a place she felt uncomfortable.

At university level- yes.
but not at school level, absolutely no way.

Tomatojuiceandvodka · 17/02/2024 18:27

I hate this expression. It’s partly true but it’s mainly bandied around by tory voters and governments who fail children in state education to remove the blame from themselves when kids fail in crap schools. After all, if they were bright they’d have done well. Easy for you to say, toffy mctofferson when you pay for your kids’ education.

bright children will tend to do well but you’re not telling me the quality of their education and the type of friends they make at school don’t influence it.

i do not believe private schools or grammar schools have better teachers, but I do believe that teachers in those schools have easier jobs.

buttercupcake · 17/02/2024 18:23

My child achieved all 9’s at GCSE & 4 A*’s at A level at the local comp. It can be done with the right focus and home support.

wronginalltherightways · 17/02/2024 18:21

I've heard that expression, too. My husband even spouted it once years ago, but soon realised it had no basis in reality for most children. All our bright children were moved from a particular school because there was no way they would do well without better school leadership and higher expectations for them.

TBNT · 17/02/2024 18:19

strawberriesandsun · 17/02/2024 17:58

So basically. Children who have rich parents have choices that children from poorer or just average backgrounds don't have, so will never do as well. Great world we live in.

It certainly can feel that way.

I'm thanking my lucky stars that DD got a scholarship and bursary and is able to be in an environment with children who want to learn and behave well and has staff who have the time to treat her as an individual.

We don't live near grammar schools and couldn't afford private school on our income.

It's horrendously unfair that so many children like DD1 can't escape the life she was stuck in at her state primary school.

OP posts:
xsquared · 17/02/2024 18:17

I don't think you can generalise, as it depends on the personality of the child, how resilient they are and their work ethic as some factors off the top of my head.

dh went to a school that was so bad that it was knocked down a few years after he uad left, but he still managed to get all A/A*s at GCSE and 5As at A Level, where he taught himself further maths as he was the only one taking it, and got a top 1st at Cambridge in Natural Sciences. He now works in an academic job at the local university.

dd is at a local comprehensive, and although we think she would probably love the opportunities at the private school in town, she is heading for grade 9s. That is because she is determined, self motivated and generally interested in the subjects she studies. She has a strong work ethic and is one of those students who would finished their homework before they get home.

ds on the other hand, although bright is a lazy so and so, and paid the price for thinking he could coast through the exams with last minute revision. In his mind, school work remains at school, and he is the type of person who wanted to get quick results with minimal effort. He is a little bit older and wiser hopefully, and although he didn't get in to the uni course he wanted, he does seem to be working harder than he did.

GreatGateauxsby · 17/02/2024 18:17

Load of old crap.

i was bright but liked to fart about and did the minimum expected.
i still like to “be the best” but also to coast. 😬

in a bog standard school I’d have hung out with the naughty girls and got a few As with Bs and maybe some Cs instead of close to what I was actually capable of.
I did SOME revision and got mix of As and A which was considered quite middling / unremarkable vs my straight A peers but was enough to set me up for a decent degree course

Thepeopleversuswork · 17/02/2024 18:07

strawberriesandsun · 17/02/2024 17:58

So basically. Children who have rich parents have choices that children from poorer or just average backgrounds don't have, so will never do as well. Great world we live in.

I think it's a bit more nuanced than that. It's certainly true that children who have rich parents have a safety net which isn't available to children from poorer backgrounds, they can afford not to do as well at school and their parents can pay for them to avoid the schools where learning is hardest (and obviously pay to support with extra coaching etc where needed).

But private school isn't a panacea: not all private schools are good (some are worse than many state schools), they don't suit all children from a cultural/social perspective and they are not immune from the problems that affect state schools. Some private schools have terrible bullying problems.

And some kids, from a range of backgrounds, do brilliantly in terrible schools. Children whose parents prioritise education can do surprisingly well in very poor economic circumstances. Its at least as much about the parents' attitude as it is the amount of money spent on the child's education.

But I'd agree with your premise that it's a lottery and its profoundly unfair

strawberriesandsun · 17/02/2024 17:58

So basically. Children who have rich parents have choices that children from poorer or just average backgrounds don't have, so will never do as well. Great world we live in.

Thepeopleversuswork · 17/02/2024 17:42

This is a grotesque oversimplification and I agree with a PP that sometimes parents tell themselves this to salve their own conscience about not having prioritised their own child's learning (or sometimes when they have put political considerations ahead of meeting their child's needs as in the case of people who disagree with private school... but this is a whole other thread).

There are so many variables which influence a child's progress at school. Simply being "smart" is by no means enough. So many ways a "smart" child (and how do we define smart anyway?) can be failed by school:

  • Being picked on at a rough school for being academic and wanting to do well
  • Failing to be supported emotionally by the wider school environment because they don't fit in socially (as was the case for me at my "good" (but very snobbish) private school)
  • Being insufficiently challenged by the school academically and not achieving to their potential
  • Coming from a home environment where education is not prioritised and the school having insufficient skills at identification or resources to work with this (as was the case for my partner who was seriously good at maths but whose parents didn't want him to go to university so he stopped education after going to a grammar)
  • Going to a school where lack of resource and a high concentration of children from deprived backgrounds or with SEN means the teachers are basically acting like social workers and are unable to teach
  • Being unmotivated to learn and not having sufficient encouragement

I could go on. Nor is the solution as simple as just making sure they go to an independent or grammar school: sometimes that is a life-saver, sometimes it's a worse solution than the local state school. Sometimes home ed is the solution but it's clearly only available to a small minority and won't suit all children. And some children actually thrive on doing well in a challenging environment. The equation of calculating a child's odds at getting the best out of school is so difficult that it's basically unique.

The truth is you have to know your own child and strive to help them find their path but simply relying on their "smartness" and coasting on this is more or less asking for trouble.