Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"A smart child will do well in any school" - not true?

183 replies

TBNT · 17/02/2024 16:12

Inspired to ask this due to another thread.

But it's something that's been said to me countless times over the years when looking at the (pretty awful) schools in our local area.

I have always politely nodded while thinking in my head "I'm pretty sure my very academic, yet nerdy and socially anxious child wouldn't do very well in that school"

And until reading on here today hadn't seen that opinion expressed elsewhere and just felt like I was being unreasonable in my own head.

So just that really - I've heard of kids coming out of rough comps with loads of 9s. But I genuinely feel that a child like my eldest DD would not achieve what she's capable of in a place she felt uncomfortable.

OP posts:
pastypirate · 17/02/2024 21:23

It's nonsense and we all know it.
However my v resilient dd1 probably would have been ok at the comp as she's v focused but I wouldn't risk it and I'm v happy with her grammar.

YukoandHiro · 17/02/2024 21:11

Hatty65 · 17/02/2024 18:31

A smart and motivated child will probably do well in any school.

Unfortunately, I've got a smart, idle dickhead who pissed about through his entire school career (in excellent schools, with excellent teaching) and has achieved very little academically.

How old is he now and how have things panned out?

In my experience smart idle dickheads still end up with extremely lucrative careers. Irritated me though it does.

Academic prowess isn't everything. In fact strong success under age 21 is zero prediction of career/earnings success? Often the skills you need for that end up failing you in work. Being conscientious doesn't make you stand out in the workplace

Citrusandginger · 17/02/2024 21:07

Bright children will do well anywhere is often said as a sop to those who didn't get their first choice of secondary. It polite and well meaning. Unfortunately it's not necessary true.

It's also arguably easier to get a higher P8 score in a stable school. DD's school is 5.9 and well above average. It's a well regarded, over subscribed girls school where teachers want to work and has a high level of parental support.

I also know schools that are below and well below average. They struggle to recruit and retain staff and serve demographics with multi-generational disinterest in education. It is hard to see how they will turn around their P8 or how bright children will do well in such environments.

Leonarda89 · 17/02/2024 21:01

YANBU.
I work with young people. I have worked with many, many extremely bright young people who have struggled and not done well in a variety of schools, for many different reasons. School can throw so many things in the way of academic success and being intelligent alone doesn't determine how well a young person does.

PaperDoIIs · 17/02/2024 20:54

Depends what you mean by well.

Emotionally and socially? Tbf that's not a guarantee in any school.

Academically? Again .. what do you mean by well? Excel and fully achieve their potential?Probably not. Be average/slightly above average? Yes, definitely.

BlueMediterranean · 17/02/2024 20:35

C4tintherug · 17/02/2024 16:22

Not true. I’m a teacher and in classes with constant disruption and poor behaviour we just don’t get the content covered like I do in classes with excellent behaviour. 1 or 2 “characters” can be enough to destroy the whole class learning environment.
I don’t have many classes like that but I do teach in a naice area but the impact of this on outcomes is undeniable. Especially on girls in my opinion, they don’t get a voice in a classroom that is full of boisterous boys.

I'm also a teacher and I agree 100% with you.

Meadowfinch · 17/02/2024 20:33

Not true at all.

My bright ds started at primary school, a cheerful little soul, enthusiastic and boisterous. It was fine until yr 4, then he outgrew them and they held him back, tried to bully him into sitting still & shutting up.

By year 6 he was angry, frustrated, bored, being turned off school.

I moved him to a school that wanted him to extend himself. Now he's happy, confident, engaged, back on track. Different schools suit different children.

MargaretThursday · 17/02/2024 20:26

There's does okay in comparison to others in the school
Done well
And done the best they can.

For my 3 dc, I can see they'd all have benefitted from a smaller private school with lots of opportunities. I wish we could have but we couldn't afford it for one let alone three.

But my dc ideally would have benefitted from different schools to each other too. They all went to the same comprehensive.
Dd1 had a perfectionist streak, always worked hard at all times even if she didn't like the subject. She was always striving to get the best. She would have been better at a school that did fewer GCSEs (she did 16 GCSEs and got mostly A/A*s) so she could concentrate more on the ones she did, as she spent far too long working and trying to achieve perfect results and with a good range of extra curricular things that she could be part of, which would have benefitted her socially. She'd also have benefitted from competition in her better subjects at times.

Dd2 did well on extra curriculars where she was because they suited her and she got into a couple of niche ones, at least partially by the stint of them being traditionally male ones; she was normally one of two girls amount 20-40 boys, so she got opportunities there.
However what she needed was a school that didn't just fall for the wide blue eyes and tell her she was doing well enough. She needed to have teachers that pushed her, and would say to her that just doing it wasn't good enough, or fall for the excuses why she hadn't done it. She'd also have benefitted from less distractions.

Ds works if he likes the subject. He's also inclined to do enough to keep out of trouble and no more. Again he'd have benefitted from being pushed more and more extra curriculars he could do.

So yes, they're all bright and did okay. Yes, they could have all achieved greater results. But more, I think they'd have been happier in a school that suited them better, especially dd1.

Ponderingwindow · 17/02/2024 20:09

Getting good grades is not the same as actively learning. It is not the same as being their best self.

students that are allowed to coast, don’t actually learn how to study and learn. They think everything will come easy and then one day eventually it doesn’t, but they lack the toolset to meet the challenge. That day might not even come until they are adults, but part of the purpose of school is to learn to face a challenging problem and assimilate the information to understand and solve it. Every child deserves to learn that skill, even if they are bright or gifted.

CloudPop · 17/02/2024 20:03

t's horrendously unfair that so many children like DD1 can't escape the life she was stuck in at her state primary school.

@TBNT yes it is. It's a disgrace.

TodayForTomorrow · 17/02/2024 19:43

I'm a firm believer that you can't really tell whether a school will suit your child based on results or an ofsted judgement. I think it comes down to the culture of the school and whether they make good friends. Things like staff turnover are important as well.

Cantrushart · 17/02/2024 19:25

The peer group is one of the biggest motivators to a teenager. Bright friends with ambition set a higher bar.

Yorkshireknitter · 17/02/2024 19:20

It depends what doing “well” means and if we value wellbeing as much or more as academic results. I hope we do.

If academic results are the only focus then they may well get very good results in a rough school. That depends on the child and their teachers; I got excellent GCSE results in a rough school in a very deprived area. I also was miserable and bullied over multiple periods during the time I was there, but often by the other children from middle-class backgrounds.

On the other hand when I arrived at university I was really shocked by the stories of wide spread eating disorders, huge drug use and as well as even worse bullying from girls who had attending posh boarding schools or selective grammars. Teenagers with money and/or supportive parents can still be absolutely vicious to anyone they perceive as weaker. Academic results at their schools of course were outstanding.

If we think about the long term affect on people’s mental health, then exposure to a high pressure environment (perhaps particularly for girls in single sex schools) in an academically well-regarded school doesn’t necessarily breed happy well-adjusted 18-year-olds with a healthy relationship with food.

School is preparing us for life, not just for work, it depends on the individual child what the best environment will be for that. It’s not just rough school v academically good school.

arlequin · 17/02/2024 19:16

It's not just about grades though. It's about being able to go beyond the syllabus and really enjoy learning. Do extra-curriculars. Really learn to speak a language properly. Good schools offer so much more than 9s

Ecnerual · 17/02/2024 19:08

"As soon as I escaped to a half decent sixth form outside the area, I obtained straight A grades at A level and was offered places at Oxford and Cambridge based on my tutor’s recommendation."

@Notmyfirstusername I thought you could only apply to one or the other? 🤔

PrimitivePerson · 17/02/2024 19:06

@UnaPeacock Haha, I'm glad it's not just me. It's taken me a long time to recover from what happened to me, and I wouldn't wish it on anyone else.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 17/02/2024 19:03

School only really works for a minority of children, we could only really say otherwise if we had a higher proportion of kids achieving 5 good passes at 4-5+.

Having seen the difference moving my young child from a crap school to a good school, I am firmly in the "kids can't learn anywhere" camp. Happy children learn, a child who feels unsafe, who's needs are not considered, who is not encouraged or inspired by the adults around them, a child who is ignored, bullied, or unsupported will not be able to learn.

Ratherstandonacliffandsetfiretomyself · 17/02/2024 18:59

I left secondary school 22 years ago with 7 A*s and 3 As at GCSE. The school was an absolute sinkhole, more like a zoo than a school at times, kids in my year left with 24% 5 A-Cs - the worst they'd ever had apparently.

But my school life was hell - absolutely bullied constantly - found out I'm autistic aged 35 but back then you didn't have a choice but to put up and shut up so I did. My home life was awful too so there was no point telling anyone - in fact my own mum never knew the extent of it until about 2 years ago!

Surroundedbyfools · 17/02/2024 18:59

Tbh there’s probably some truth in it and some non truth in it. Same as private schools some ppl say you can’t make steak outta mince. If ur child is naturally clever and bright they will likely do ok at school. If they struggle they will struggle more in a rough school. Private schooling you only get in if u pass tests so obvz their results look better

UnaPeacock · 17/02/2024 18:58

@PrimitivePerson I’m just the same! I’m anti-grammar because of my experiences. I was so confident at my primary school and worked hard and enjoyed learning. But grammar school knocked the confidence out of me and all my independence and love of learning. I feel sad looking back and wish things had been different. I love seeing how happy my son is at his school now. The school he attends doesn’t just focus on academia, it encourages the pupils to become well rounded human beings. He’s very bright and enjoys learning and does well. I felt my school sucked all the joy out of learning and even at the start of year 7 it was all about learning just to do well in exams. Because of that, I’ve turned into a very superficial learner.

oldestboy · 17/02/2024 18:57

I’m torn on this.

In a way yes, they will likely do well wherever if they are bright.

However, and this is a personal experience of mine, they will do well despite it and it may harm them in other ways. I went to a rough comprehensive, had friends, was a bit geeky and loved learning but tried so hard to be a ‘ghost’ to keep myself safe in the absolutely wild environment. Think Waterloo road.

This strategy was successful in that I kept under the radar of everyone including teachers. I worked under the own steam and got good results. It was an endurance, not an education. It affected me long term in how I speak up for myself, how uncomfortable I feel in new situations, down to how I choose which seat to sit in so I don’t have ‘bullies’ behind me.

So yes on paper I did well but as an adult it’s taken me a long time to change some of these behaviours and it would always be better to be somewhere where you fit in and can learn in a optimal way.

Differentstarts · 17/02/2024 18:53

I believe a very small amount of children will do well in any school but the majority won't they would need to be very mentally strong and confident which most teenagers are not. I did really well in primary and loved learning but when I went to a 💩 hole of a secondary I lost all interest. As friends and boyfriends where more important and I only cared about fitting in and being popular I left school with zero gcses and a baby.

Ecnerual · 17/02/2024 18:51

I agree OP.

I grew up on an estate in one of the lower deciles for deprivation. I went to a good selective church secondary school and most of my primary school peers went to the not very good local secondary.

A lot of kids from my good school, even the middle of the road ones, went to university. Loads of the smart kids I remember from primary didn't go to uni at all, or if they did it wasn't to the 'prestigious' or RG ones. I know that isn't a measure for success but it does seem like their options were limited by going to that school.

There will always be exceptions. My primary best friend did well despite going to the local school. She got a first from a good uni in a very academic subject and was then handpicked for a PhD which she completed in record time, and then suggested for a job in the civil service. She is smarter than me (or anyone else I know) and talented in multiple ways (also very down to earth!) but despite that I outperformed her in exams at school (she got mostly Bs and I got mostly A stars) and I even got a higher grade at GCSE in the subject she ended up studying at uni. At a better school she would have had straight A stars without a problem.

Edited to add "stars" the * symbols made the text bold instead 😅

PrimitivePerson · 17/02/2024 18:50

UnaPeacock · 17/02/2024 18:41

@PrimitivePerson are you me?? :) I was exactly the same at my grammar school. Hated every second and switched off from my learning, just plodded on until the end of 6th form. In hindsight, I think I would have done better at my local comp. My eldest is in year 7 at our local comp and he is thriving and loving school and the extra curricular stuff. Not all schools suit all children.

There's actually a lot like us out there. Research has suggested that grammar schools only actually benefit a very small number of the pupils that attend them, and for the rest, the additional stress piled on them can make their academic performance worse.

Unfortunately my parents held very conservative views and thought comprehensives were evil hotbeds of liberalism. My sister did very badly at a comp, and my parents blamed the ethos of the school, failing to notice that my sister was actually developing catastrophic mental health problems.

So...they did everything they could to get me into a grammar school that TOTALLY didn't suit me and caused me quite a few problems. I spent my whole time there keeping my head down and trying not to get noticed, by both staff and other pupils.

When people hear I'm anti-grammar schools they think it's because I'm bitter about not getting into one. I'm bitter because I did!!!

Thepeopleversuswork · 17/02/2024 18:49

@izimbra

Our school system is horrifically socially polarised and it's really damaging to many children. I'm always staggered that people are so blind to it, and accepting of this as it's absolute poison for kids from ordinary families.

I agree with you but what do you expect people to do?

It’s true that the schools system fails many children but I don’t accept the logic that putting your children in a failing school when you can afford not to helps this. I wasn’t going to throw my kid under a bus by sending her to a school where I know she would struggle if I could afford not to just to make a point about bucking the inequality in the system.

If the choice is between principles and your child, the child will win hands down every time. As they should. This isn’t going to change until we as a society address the problems in our education system.