Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"A smart child will do well in any school" - not true?

183 replies

TBNT · 17/02/2024 16:12

Inspired to ask this due to another thread.

But it's something that's been said to me countless times over the years when looking at the (pretty awful) schools in our local area.

I have always politely nodded while thinking in my head "I'm pretty sure my very academic, yet nerdy and socially anxious child wouldn't do very well in that school"

And until reading on here today hadn't seen that opinion expressed elsewhere and just felt like I was being unreasonable in my own head.

So just that really - I've heard of kids coming out of rough comps with loads of 9s. But I genuinely feel that a child like my eldest DD would not achieve what she's capable of in a place she felt uncomfortable.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hatty65 · 22/02/2024 20:31

@YukoandHiro Sorry, just catching up! My smart, idle dickhead is now 19 - having dropped out of his grammar school without taking his A levels. He repeated Y12 as he had buggered about throughout the first go - and then got to the end of his second attempt, turned 18 and dropped out, deciding he 'couldn't be arsed' to do another year and was way behind as he wasn't doing any work.

He's currently doing a zero hours contract, minimum wage job for about 2 days a week. We keep suggesting apprenticeships but he's not very interested. He seems to think because he is intelligent (which he is) that someone is suddenly going to offer him an easy job starting at about £30,000 a year, despite the fact that he only has his GCSEs.

We're just leaving him to it. You can't argue with some people. He'll pull himself together at some point, hopefully.

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 19/02/2024 19:05

I think the grain of truth.. is that a bright child will likely be out the the top sets where behaviour is better and teachers may be more engaged.

I was mostly top sets in a rough comp. But only middle set for French. So I saw a little of both.

The top sets were almost like a different school. Largely middle class kids, high expectations, sympathetic and encouraging teachers.

Middle set had a palpable feeling of "cant-be arsedness" from both teachers and students.
I took to ignoring the lesson and openly working on my art coursework. No-one even cared until another kid decided to nick my charcoal sharpening knife and ran up and down the corridor with it.

izimbra · 18/02/2024 23:27

Thepeopleversuswork · 17/02/2024 18:49

@izimbra

Our school system is horrifically socially polarised and it's really damaging to many children. I'm always staggered that people are so blind to it, and accepting of this as it's absolute poison for kids from ordinary families.

I agree with you but what do you expect people to do?

It’s true that the schools system fails many children but I don’t accept the logic that putting your children in a failing school when you can afford not to helps this. I wasn’t going to throw my kid under a bus by sending her to a school where I know she would struggle if I could afford not to just to make a point about bucking the inequality in the system.

If the choice is between principles and your child, the child will win hands down every time. As they should. This isn’t going to change until we as a society address the problems in our education system.

When you talk about a 'failing school' do you mean a school where teaching and management is ineffectual, or do you mean a school full of kids from serious disadvantage, which may be well managed, and have great teachers?

Because I wasn't talking about 'failing schools'. I was talking about socially polarised schools.

Orla32 · 18/02/2024 20:07

I haven't read the entire thread but how can this be measured anyway?

Yes a bright kid may do "well" in any school but not as well as they may have done if in a "better" school.

I went to 5 different secondary schools (due to moving around a lot and between parents / other people), I missed 5 out of 6 GSCE school terms and because of that was only put forward for 5 GCSEs. I got decent grades and have done very well despite everything. However, I am sure I did not do as well as I would have being in one good school.

Maray1967 · 18/02/2024 15:27

And a bright enough child might well do much better than a very academic but anxious child. I would prefer confidence and resilience and decent grades to a whole set of 9s and mental health concerns.

Maray1967 · 18/02/2024 15:25

The child has to be bright, confident, self-motivated - and be in a school which sets by academic ability.

PTSDBarbiegirl · 18/02/2024 15:16

2 different things, on one hand you're asking about a 'smart' child doing well in any school on the other hand it's about 'feeling comfortable'. A well adjusted child is likely to be resilient enough to cope in any environment and an academically able yet fragile child is likely not to have the resilience to handle any environment.

Caerulea · 18/02/2024 14:59

A motivated child will do well in any school, nothing to do with smarts.

All 3 of my boys are scary smart, very science & maths. Eldest went into secondary as a 'gold star' gifted - they ignored all his assessments & primary notes on coping mechanisms & he was virtually expelled before his GCSEs (allowed in the exams but not otherwise in school) for relentless low level stuff. He went to the 'better' school, further away, cos they were supposed to be supportive of extra needs...ha..wankers. They broke him (he's okay now!!) but we had to get through drugs, alcohol, two hospital trips for ODs - I really mean they broke him, it was dire.

Middle is crazy smart but a coaster - just very chill, not highly motivated. A teacher who could push him would make the world of difference. Doing 4 A-levels in science & maths. He's very emotionally intelligent, funny af & the most NT person you could meet to the point of being rare. He's now realising how much he coasted & that you can't do that at A-level.

Youngest...about to go thru autism assessments for him but likely no smarter than the other two, same school as middle child & to say he's excelling would be an understatement. He's phenomenally driven (one of the reasons for getting him assessed) & that's the difference. The literal golden boy at school (polar opposite at home - again, assessment), IT teacher wanted him to do his GCSE early & he's doing his further maths in his own time.

It's all about motivation (even though youngest is via definite ND & I suspect aspergers among other things). These are ordinary state schools, youngest's school just had some of the worst results for the entire county. But he's unhealthily driven.

Ultimately it comes down to the individual, ND or NT, & their motivation to work at their best.

Bunnycat101 · 18/02/2024 14:37

And even at primary the cohort matters. My eldest is in a lovely school but has a difficult class. They undoubtedly don’t get through as much as they should because of disruption so the bright ones aren’t being pushed as much as they otherwise would in an easier class group. Some of the kids in her year will be very challenging indeed when they’re older. Her sister’s class by contrast is a dream.

Bunnycat101 · 18/02/2024 14:33

I think it’s bollocks. To a certain extent I did meet this (bright kid that got the string of A*s from a not great but not totally shit comp). However, I have no doubt a number of my friends underperformed and would have done infinitely better at a grammar or private school. I also think I’d have come out a more confident person from a better school- I spent more time hiding my ability than really shining.

PrimitivePerson · 18/02/2024 14:21

ApplesAndPearsTheFruits · 18/02/2024 14:18

Agree. There was another recent thread about the 11 plus where the OP was told if her kid didn’t get a private tutor or spend months revising independently then he would have no chance of getting in as he wouldn’t know the material.

Oh, yeah. Tutoring was always rife - my parents spent a fortune on it trying to get me through the exams, and that was in 1985!

There's something fundamentally wrong with state funding of something that is now so elitist and exclusionary. If you want to send your kid to an elite school, go private and cut the hypocrisy.

ApplesAndPearsTheFruits · 18/02/2024 14:18

PrimitivePerson · 18/02/2024 12:55

Personally I think grammars are outdated, ineffective and grossly unfair, especially to the poorer kids they were originally supposed to help, and it's high time we got rid of them.

Agree. There was another recent thread about the 11 plus where the OP was told if her kid didn’t get a private tutor or spend months revising independently then he would have no chance of getting in as he wouldn’t know the material.

NancyJoan · 18/02/2024 14:17

It’s too simplistic. My bright, gregarious, slim, musical daughter would do well anywhere. My bright, introverted, anxious and possibly ND son would not.

IamaRevenant · 18/02/2024 14:14

I think when people say this they're focusing on teaching quality rather than the influence of other pupils.

The school I went to until the start of year 9 (moved abroad after) was very big, I think 6 classes in my year, and had a bad rep. We had a tutor group and then were in sets for everything else. I was in top set for all subjects so was mainly with relatively well behaved, studious kids and did thrive.

My tutor group was another story. I remember one boy lighting up a spliff in class at age 13, another turned up drunk around the same age and it was all kids shouting, throwing things, ignoring the teacher etc. I know that one of the lower sets (with several kids from my tutor group) bullied a pregnant teacher so badly she had a breakdown and had to go off sick for the last three months of her pregnancy.

God knows how I'd have done if I was in my tutor group the whole time.

soupycustard · 18/02/2024 14:08

No. I said that for years but I was wrong - brightness on its own is not enough. I think there can be a sweetspot where a child is bright, neurotypical, not too much of a 'nerd' (or able to hide it) and has one or two other things to help them 'fit in', say being interested in tiktok/sex/drinking/partying or something else that makes them 'cool'.
It's very very tough being bright, neurodiverse and nerdy.

Chylka · 18/02/2024 14:02

The will do well anywhere child was me, I was bright from a supportive background. But I was lazy. I went to a comprehensive school, but a “good” one with an intake that was largely from the same background as me. I did do well - As and Astars at GCSE AAAB at A level (no A star at A level in my day). This was on the bare minimum and included chatting at the back of the class with the naughty boys when I could get away with it. But generally time in lessons was productive- we had good teachers in a generally well controlled environment (particularly because I was in top set for Maths and sciences, which was the only subjects they set for). I could definitely have done better in a selective environment, because I’m competitive so would have pulled my finger out, rather than coast. However, ultimately, given it was a good school, this didn’t matter for me and I did well enough. But I’m a sink school? I suspect I would have done significantly worse. Probably more like Bs and Cs if the lesson time (which was invaluable to me because I did not independent study except for a lot of reading for pleasure) was not productive. And with those grades I would have been cut off from my eventual career which is highly competitive.

So in short, I think the old trope that bright kids will do well anywhere is bollocks. (That’s before you even get me started on bright kids with SEN…)

1offnamechange · 18/02/2024 13:31

I agree with you OP. In my primary school there were 5 of us in the 'top table' (this was in the late 90s so everyone was pretty aware of what table was which 😂) in a small, friendly village primary. As far as I remember we were all pretty bright - at one point we did a pre-mensa assessment (can't remember why) 1 boy scored very highly and another 2 of us got a high enough score to have been accepted had it been the real thing. We all got straight 5s in our SATs etc.

We all went to the nearest comp - again at that time and place that was just what you did, this was an area of the UK where there weren't any grammar schools nor private schools in this or the neighbouring counties so no other alternative. Comp was ok but not 'good' let alone excellent - there were 37/38 pupils in most of my classes, even up to A level, other than maths, english science none of the subjects were 'set' so an absolute mix, many of whom just did not want to be there and made fun of anyone who did want to work.

I absolutely hated it, went through a phase of school avoidance and stealing etc. At least 1 of the others was really badly bullied. Within a few years 1 of the boys was expelled for high drug use, another girl had been suspended and was also having sex with the PE teacher.

From at facebook/friends/the last time we saw each other, the expelled guy has never really worked. The others are working as a ski instructor, managing a golf club, 1 is a pharmacist and I'm mid level civil service - in our mid 30s. So all decent enough jobs but not setting the world alight - I'm positive that had we gone to a naice grammar or private school or even a leafy comp several of us would have been potential Oxbridge candidates, and gone on to high level careers - just because of the increased expectations and encouragement. Also suspect most of us would have had much happier teenage years.

Obviously it's not the be all and end all and as I say everyone seems happy enough now but for most of us it was definitely a case of scraped through despite the school rather than did well as a result of it.

Pansyblue · 18/02/2024 13:24

I agree with you OP. It’s like saying to an adult “if you’re bright, you’ll make a lot of money in any career”. Maybe true for some, but it’s a hell of a lot easier and more enjoyable along the way if you choose a career that actually pays well, offers training, opportunities for progression etc etc.

TeapotTwister · 18/02/2024 13:21

Totally disagree, you take a bright ND child and put them in the wrong school for them and good chance they will burnout and leave.

For some smart children being in a highly pressurised academic environment is utterly soul destroying and they think they are “thick” because they aren’t in the top set - this in turn impacts grades.

You take a neurotypical child, socially aware, sporty, average IQ, they probably will do well in most schools (save for ones with extreme behaviour problems).

Dogfisher · 18/02/2024 13:09

Allywill · 18/02/2024 12:38

i think years ago it was basically true. now with the high disruption levels and poor behaviour in the classroom that many schools suffer with it’s not.

Agree.

Ihadenough22 · 18/02/2024 13:07

One of my friends had a child that was been bullied in national school. The bullies were going to the local rough secondary school. My friend decided to apply for an accedemic school in the nearest big town.

The school is popular as it has good teachers, good pastoral care, has a wide range of subjects and extra curricular activities.
Her child needed some resource help as well. She also has younger kids who are bright.
Since her child went to this school she told me that their exam results are getting better.
They have friends. She said as well that her child is mixing with kids whose parents are working in good jobs and want their kids to do well in school so homework and doing your best in exams is important.
She told me that she was glad to get them away from from the bullies and they are doing far better now both socially and exam wise.

RecentError · 18/02/2024 13:02

PrimitivePerson · 18/02/2024 12:55

Personally I think grammars are outdated, ineffective and grossly unfair, especially to the poorer kids they were originally supposed to help, and it's high time we got rid of them.

Absolutely agreed. Sadly there is no money to change it. As with everything this shitty government hasn’t spent any money on.

PrimitivePerson · 18/02/2024 12:55

Personally I think grammars are outdated, ineffective and grossly unfair, especially to the poorer kids they were originally supposed to help, and it's high time we got rid of them.

RecentError · 18/02/2024 12:40

PrimitivePerson · 18/02/2024 12:34

Grammar schools are only really suited to a small subset of even the kids that get into them. Sure, some people really thrived at my school, but they were nothing like me. They generally had a lot of sporting or music talent, of which I have none, and were far more confident and outgoing than I was.

And FWIW my DC is talented at neither sports or music. And neither are the majority of their friends. My DC is also not outgoing, nor bookish. But has a big circle of friends.

RecentError · 18/02/2024 12:39

PrimitivePerson · 18/02/2024 12:34

Grammar schools are only really suited to a small subset of even the kids that get into them. Sure, some people really thrived at my school, but they were nothing like me. They generally had a lot of sporting or music talent, of which I have none, and were far more confident and outgoing than I was.

I think there is nuance in the term “grammar school” here.

Our area is a grammar county, so 25% of DC go to one. This creates a wholly different school to a superselective one that perhaps is for the top 1-5%.

Swipe left for the next trending thread