Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Evicted for the 2nd time in less than a year!

254 replies

EvictedAgain · 17/02/2024 13:28

AIBU to think this is just untenable?

Lsst landlord wanted to sell but did it really sneakily insisting we allowed viewings 4 months into a one year contract. We didn’t of course so were served with a Section 21 after 6 months.

We had to take current property last August (£500 month more than last place as nowhere else available). Now been served another Section 21 as landlord is not happy that we refused to pay for a professional gardener (his mate) which wasn’t in contract, or allow him to take the toilet seat that’s been in the property. This is revenge because he was unhappy about having to fix the shower and faulty dishwasher!

We are a large family and have loads of stuff. I can’t believe we’re having to pack up and move again!

AIBU to think that LL’s shouldn’t have the power to kick people out of their homes at whim and notice should be 6 months not two months?

OP posts:
willstarttomorrow · 17/02/2024 23:22

Bloody hell, this thread is depressing. OP is 'a nightmare tenant' because they do not want to pay for gardening that is not part of the original agreement and let the landlord remove a fancy loo seat which was part of the original listing. This is OP's home and when landlords accept a tenant and take their money that is the contract they enter into. Yes there are bad tenants etc and mumsnet seems to attract all the amazing landlords in the UK because they all tell us they are amazing. The rental market is a complete shitshow in the UK, loads of amateur landlords who buy cheap property and thought it was easy money and have no idea what they are doing. Costs have gone up massively and this is just being passed on to tenants. It is not sustainable.

Tatonka · 17/02/2024 22:56

Also it's a pain for a landlord to get another tenant so they usually only do this if they feel they have to, it sounds like there's been alot of issues so LL has probably decided to cut their losses. Most landlords go above and beyond for good tenants.

Tatonka · 17/02/2024 22:54

EvictedAgain · 17/02/2024 14:05

Garden has a 10ft high leylandi fence surrounding it. We had trimmed it in the autumn (we have a hedge trimmer) but landlord was sent pictures from his mate across the road who then said we had to get a professional (his mate) to do it and NOT do it ourselves. We said if he didn’t want us to do it, he should get his mate to do it and pay for it himself.

Toilet seat is one of those intelligent heat up bidet ones. Was fitted long before tenancy (quite few years old), was shown at viewing, is listed in inventory. When plumber came back to fit part for leaking shower, he said he had been told to disconnect it and take it with him. Letting agent said landlord wanted it taken as he couldn’t afford to fix it if it was broken. It wasn’t broken. We said it’s part of the tenancy and plumber’s not taking it. Knew it was because LL was pissed off about repairs and hedge.

Who exactly was the unreasonable one here?

Tenants should be protected from this shit, no?

Sorry but being this petty about a toilet seat probably wasn't worth it. You sound like a PITA. This is why I wouldn't want to ever be a landlord

Mumof2teens79 · 17/02/2024 22:52

GuinnessBird · 17/02/2024 22:46

No tenant has to allow viewings, even if it's in the contract, the contract cannot override law.

OP I have sympathy but you're not coming across very well.

No, but as a LL and property owner if you need to sell and the Tennant doesn't allow viewings then your only real option is to evict.
Not all LL are greedy multi-millionaires. There are legitimate reasons to sell.

Also no.idea what is "sneaky" in OPs words about asking them to allow viewings for a prospective sale? Would selling without mentioning anything, no viewings or evicting them first have been better?

GuinnessBird · 17/02/2024 22:46

Mumof2teens79 · 17/02/2024 22:37

I think your first mistake was refusing viewings on the original house.
What did you expect? The LL to.just go "never mind"? You could have allowed viewings amd ended up with a new landlord in same house, or had 6 months to a year to find somewhere. Instead you ended up rushed.

Have you considered that your current LL (who lives abroad and doesn't know you) is getting a really bad impression of you? They could even be reading your posts on MN and thinking you sound like a nightmare.

No tenant has to allow viewings, even if it's in the contract, the contract cannot override law.

OP I have sympathy but you're not coming across very well.

Mumof2teens79 · 17/02/2024 22:37

I think your first mistake was refusing viewings on the original house.
What did you expect? The LL to.just go "never mind"? You could have allowed viewings amd ended up with a new landlord in same house, or had 6 months to a year to find somewhere. Instead you ended up rushed.

Have you considered that your current LL (who lives abroad and doesn't know you) is getting a really bad impression of you? They could even be reading your posts on MN and thinking you sound like a nightmare.

justasking111 · 17/02/2024 22:35

@keirakilaney67

" They are now trying to push small private LL's out and have their corporate mates buy up all the properties instead. I lived in flats owned by shell companies in ME countries and that was much worse, they knew enough of the rules to get away with things that were legal but morally wrong."

I saw a report last year that because of rent smart Wales bringing in the new rules, small landlords were selling up. There was a landlords conference in Cardiff. The international presence from Germany and Holland who have scooped up many properties and were in the market for more was a surprise. I'll try and find it. There are some ME landlords but not a high percentage.

Bossladywood · 17/02/2024 22:33

Ilovemyshed · 17/02/2024 14:18

Someone who doesn't want it trimmed between March-September due to bird activity.

Sorry OP but reading this, if you were my tenants, I would serve notice, you sound a pain.

What you need to always remember is that whilst it is your temporary home, it is NOT and never will be your property. LL has a right to protect that.

Exactly this.

NotQuiteNorma · 17/02/2024 22:26

Sworntofun · 17/02/2024 19:14

You are SO NOT being unreasonable.
Some landlords are appalling.

Some tenants are obstructive, awkward, needlessly picky and then get surprised when the landlord writes them off as trouble and fucks them off..

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 17/02/2024 22:04

Sworntofun · 17/02/2024 19:14

You are SO NOT being unreasonable.
Some landlords are appalling.

We have a mastermind on MN.😯

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 17/02/2024 22:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Babyroobs · 17/02/2024 21:57

BlindurErBóklausMaður · 17/02/2024 19:51

I don't think either of the posters you are quoting are landlords.

Just because someone thinks a tenant is being an arse, doesn't mean they're a landlord. I'm not, and I do.

The poster I quoted just confirmed they own and rent out 11 properties.

keirakilaney67 · 17/02/2024 21:42

PrinnyPree · 17/02/2024 19:44

I'm with you OP but mumsnet is chocker with landlords and I'm alright Jack types.

The law needs changing, definitely speak to Shelter about your options. Xx

I say this as someone who is a homeowner but who rented for 10 years in my 20s from some right shocking twats who did some very illegal things (including entering my property for God know what reason when I was at work regularly) but that I put up with for the sake of deposit/references. My experiences as a tenent do make me sympathise with the guillotine memers lol.

Actually MN usually hates LL's. I'm somewhat surprised to see all the responses on here.
I'm just a bit confused by the OP's timelines.

@Orangeandgold Private rental was never meant to replace council house 30+ years it was for everyone. Nowadays in most areas only for those in the most dire circs and whole families in BnB's. Government opened up market for BTL market and happily pushed blame onto LL's absolving themselves of responsibility.

They are now trying to push small private LL's out and have their corporate mates buy up all the properties instead. I lived in flats owned by shell companies in ME countries and that was much worse, they knew enough of the rules to get away with things that were legal but morally wrong.

Housing is too important to be left in private hands. But with a lot happily sold off via Right to Buy and not much new building what is left to do?

coooperboom · 17/02/2024 21:22

Go on Tenants voice UK Facebook group. You will get good advice.

Orangeandgold · 17/02/2024 21:08

Also I asked to have my toilet seat changed. It was miscoloured and stained. LL didn’t want to change mine so I bought one. I’m sorry but as someone planning to live somewhere long term there are minor hygiene factors that don’t cost much.

Orangeandgold · 17/02/2024 21:02

I’m on your side OP. It’s tiring that there are so many landlords that have multiple properties and simply see it as a business without taking into account that some of their “customers” need long term stability. It is very hard to find these days because the private rental market is so messed up.

As a tenant with a family I’ve had to leave three times in 7 years as each of my contracts have had a 2 year clause. Although on all occasions I was told the LL was looking for long term tenants they changed their minds each time - mainly because they decided to sell.

I get it - it’s their property etc - but why not just air bnb or advertise short term let’s as opposed to families. There needs to be more protection for families from the government. It costs so much to uproot and organise a move. This issue is just getting much worse.

Hope you find somewhere long term soon x

caringcarer · 17/02/2024 20:04

Babyroobs · 17/02/2024 19:24

You landlords owning multiple properties really can never see how you are part of the problem can you ? How many are you up to now, must be around 12??

Still 11.

Kickstartplease · 17/02/2024 19:59

Sorry meant section 8 not section 9 - mistyped & phone won't let me edit

BlindurErBóklausMaður · 17/02/2024 19:51

Babyroobs · 17/02/2024 19:24

You landlords owning multiple properties really can never see how you are part of the problem can you ? How many are you up to now, must be around 12??

I don't think either of the posters you are quoting are landlords.

Just because someone thinks a tenant is being an arse, doesn't mean they're a landlord. I'm not, and I do.

PrinnyPree · 17/02/2024 19:44

I'm with you OP but mumsnet is chocker with landlords and I'm alright Jack types.

The law needs changing, definitely speak to Shelter about your options. Xx

I say this as someone who is a homeowner but who rented for 10 years in my 20s from some right shocking twats who did some very illegal things (including entering my property for God know what reason when I was at work regularly) but that I put up with for the sake of deposit/references. My experiences as a tenent do make me sympathise with the guillotine memers lol.

Kickstartplease · 17/02/2024 19:39

This is all very combative from the OP & Landlord's really do get a hard time.
But I would also say the UK system doesn't work well
The term 'no fault' eviction is misleading - there are usually reasons but the section 8 (fault process) doesn't work so Landlord's use this instead as this process has set time frames.
To take rent arrears as an example 2 months arrears are required if the tenant takes it £1 below that on the day they appear in court the landlord has to start again & the rent could be due the next day & the tenant chooses not to pay it.
A full Section 21/order for possession/warrant for possession/Bailiffs takes a minimum of 6 months & can take longer a section 9 takes years & years
Yes I am a Landlord - I am now evicting for only the second time & I am using a Section 21 however the tenant is 3 months in arrears, has even told me they have caused £10k worth of damage to my property (how they know this when they have never owned or maintained a property is interesting) including removing cupboards, drilling through window frames, fire damage to carpets - I can't get workmen to work in the property as it is filthy - the list goes on & so do the costs.
They have already told me they won't go until the bailiffs arrive & are not paying in full so the arrears amount will increase before I actually get them out
The UK process is rubbish from both sides both landlords & tenants should be held accountable

caringcarer · 17/02/2024 19:36

passiveaggressivenonsense · 17/02/2024 15:16

In France if you rent an unfurnished house you can keep it 3 years and this will roll over again unless the landlord can prove they want to sell or live in it themselves ( or a close relative ) . They can only serve you notice 6 months before your 3 years is up and if they don't you automatically get another 3 years. The tenant can give 6 months notice at any time.

In the UK.a tenant only has to give 1 month notice unless signed up for a 1 year or 6 month tenancy.

caringcarer · 17/02/2024 19:30

I've never had to do a section 21 eviction but I'm picky over my tenants. I pick those with not just bland but warm references. I've never asked a tenant to leave either. I prefer tenants who just want to quietly get on with their lives, don't cause structural damage to property, pay rent on time, and are pleasant and allow the gas people in each year for boiler service and new certificates. I handle any issues myself as I have a maintenance man who will do minor repairs quickly for me. If a tenant text me a photo of something broken I just get my maintenance person to repair/replace usually within 24 hours. I do know some EA take forever to get minor repairs done. The LL in this instance should have removed this heated toilet seat before letting out the house. Once an item is in the inventory that should be it. I let out houses with integrated appliances and just accept occasionally they will need a repair or replacement. If a LL just replaces they can write it off against tax so I never quite understand why some make such an issue about it. Tax people expect some repair/replacements.

BloodandGlitter · 17/02/2024 19:28

Landlords are greedy scum.

Babyroobs · 17/02/2024 19:24

caringcarer · 17/02/2024 19:15

But surely most tenants wouldn't have the deposit to buy? If they did many would have already bought a house of their own already.

You landlords owning multiple properties really can never see how you are part of the problem can you ? How many are you up to now, must be around 12??