Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you grew up with au pairs, did you like it?

37 replies

PlanningWayTooFarAhead · 17/02/2024 08:47

Hi all,

To cut a long story short, DH and I are considering an au pair for the "two set of nursery fee" years. Logistically, it would be manageable. I am also from a different European country and (potentially) having someone else in the house who speaks my language could be quite nice.

My gut feeling is that some kids would do fairly well with au pairs but others might not. We don't really know anyone who grew up that way (or who even uses au pairs now), so I just wondered how you felt about it if your parents hired au pairs to look after you as a child?

I'd prefer nursery for both but for a year or two it would be quite a hefty bill, so just considering our options for the future, especially because we are likely to move in the next two years (i.e. should we plan an extra room etc.)

Don't think I can remove the poll, so might as well make it make sense:
YANBU = I loved having au pairs as a child, get one
YABU = I hated having au pairs as a child, don't get one

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nevermindtheteacaps · 17/02/2024 18:51

You mean a nanny! Au pairs absolutely do not look after young children full time.

A nanny will be more than two sets of nursery fees I am afraid

DonnaHadDee · 17/02/2024 18:37

My experience was not positive, but looking back that was really about a poor match between the au pair and our family needs. We had two German girls at different times, and they were both children of people my father had known from his time serving in the armed forces in Germany. My mother did need extra help, since we lived on a farm. Looking back the girls were probably very isolated, they had no experience of being on a farm, they had limited opportunities to meet other people. We just did not get on at all. I think our case was very very unusual.

therealcookiemonster · 17/02/2024 14:54

it is very individual based. if you need help, get help. actually with the right kind of help you can spend more quality time with the children as opposed to being tired from the various essential chores

I grew up with live in nanny + various staff (I was in Bangladesh and its very common). unfortunately I was therefore slow to learn certain life skills as everything was done for me (children are generally very much babied in bengali culture) but I picked them up pretty sharpish when I had to. probably having just one au pair won't have such an effect anyway and a good childcare provider will teach children to be independent.

tutttutt · 17/02/2024 12:54

Your first mistake is thinking that au pairs bring up children. They aren't nanny's on the cheap and if you attempt to do this you'll be expecting far too much of a young unqualified person and being completely negligent in your role as a parent.

An au pair is an extra pair of hands to help out with light duties usually relating to children. So baby sitting level of responsibility. They can do very basic help around the house but they aren't a skivvy and they are not supposed to be working that many hours.

mondaytosunday · 17/02/2024 12:50

Of course it depends on the au pair! We had one in particular (French) who remained a family friend until she passed away. We adored her. The others I only remember vaguely. But it meant my mother could work so was essential.
My cousin still goes abroad every so often to visit her old au pairs!

Aintnosupermum · 17/02/2024 12:50

The biggest issue is you have babies and au pairs are not a suitable solution for this age.

The other issue is the stupid rules coming in which make live in childcare prohibitive. This is why I have not returned to the US. If you are qualified and working in a professional role, I recommend looking to leave the UK until the eldest child is starting secondary school. Go to Singapore, UAE or KSA. The private schools are good and household help is readily available and affordable as you earn more and pay less taxes.

shoppingshamed · 17/02/2024 12:47

Everyone's experience will be different depending on the person and their circumstance, an au pair isnt like some kind of identikit thing

I had one when my children were younger and they dont remember anything about her

Do you possibly mean a nanny?

SheWasASkaterGirl · 17/02/2024 12:42

We had au pairs when the dc were little (pre brexit). My dh constantly travelled for work, so most of the week I was home alone with a 3yo and newborn. However i was on mat leave, so constantly home. It was more for the extra adult to help out and watch them so I could have a shower, or cook dinner, or pop to the shop for some bread without dragging out a sleeping baby. After my mat leave i became a sahm, but continued hosting au pairs.

We all loved having au pairs, but then i got a load of help from MN on recruiting the perfect one for our family. We're still in touch with them, have since been to their weddings, etc.

SecretSquare · 17/02/2024 12:35

We had several growing up.

Some were amazing and became part of the family and we kept in touch and visited for years after.

Some were awful, clearly had real problems and my mum said she trusted me and my DSis more than the au pair to make grown up decisions. Felt like another child in the house!

Some were in the middle.

We didn't mind them being in the house, though some were much easier than others to have around.

Gettingcolder · 17/02/2024 12:31

It really depends on the au pair. I had one as a child that I am still in touch with 50 years later! My children had au pairs, some were good and some not so good. Au pairs are helpful once the children are at nursery or school but can't be used instead of a nanny as they are inexperienced and are learning the language. They should be treated as part of the family, so take meals with you and go out with you etc. It is like having a big sister for the DC and can provide the parents with a preview of what it will be like to have a teenage daughter! Some are awful!

Pigeon257 · 17/02/2024 11:34

We did - sort of a mixture of an au pair/ nanny, looking back. We were mainly older than nursery age though. It was more for after school plus a bit of looking after my youngest sibling on non nursery days. Tbh they varied a lot - some were really fun, some were really grumpy. The grumpy ones were probably too young and immature and probably missing home, thinking about it now. I know my mum found some of them very hard work and more like an extra kid to look after, with boyfriend woes and the like, while some were absolutely brilliant- there didn't seem to be a middle ground!

Aydel · 17/02/2024 11:28

We had a fabulous au pair. We’re still in touch with her and I visited her a few weeks ago, 17 years after she left us. She still feels like family.

Station11 · 17/02/2024 11:26

I was about to say that au pairs are not a substitute for proper pre-school child care. They work about 30 hours a week and are not qualified to look after babies and toddlers.

However, there are other issues - we don't have au pair visas in the UK, so you can only hire from Ireland, UK and countries which we have Youth Mobility Scheme for, so Australia, New Zealand, Canada. So your pot of au pairs is very small and they can pick and choose the hosts they want.

It also looks like the government is removing the ability to pay domestic workers less if they live as part of the family from 1st April this year.
https://www.parallelparliament.co.uk/mp/shailesh-vara/debate/2024-01-09/commons/general-committees/draft-national-minimum-wage-amendment-no-2-regulations-2023
So, they have to be paid minimum wage anyway.

Debate: Draft National Minimum Wage (Amendment) (No. 2) Regulations 2023 - 9th Jan 2024 - Shailesh Vara extracts

Tue 9th Jan 2024 - Commons - Draft National Minimum Wage (Amendment) (No. 2) Regulations 2023 debate Shailesh Vara contributions to the 9th January 2024 Draft National Minimum W...

https://www.parallelparliament.co.uk/mp/shailesh-vara/debate/2024-01-09/commons/general-committees/draft-national-minimum-wage-amendment-no-2-regulations-2023

Thelightis · 17/02/2024 11:25

An Au Pair is different to a Nanny so you'll have to manage your expectations a bit

Thelightis · 17/02/2024 11:22

We had a couple of Au pairs but they really were just teenage girls who came over to the UK to learn English under the guise of being Au pairs and getting a free room,

They never looked after us as such as we were independent DC from the age of 4 playing outside unsupervised with the neighbourhood DC

Not entirely sure what they did but I remember liking them I just can't remember spending much time with them

honeylulu · 17/02/2024 10:56

Au pairs are only meant to do childcare for limited hours (so filling in the gaps before/ after nursery/ school pick up and drop off) and I think they aren't supposed to have sole care of children under 2. So in reality you'd be paying for nursery AND an au pair.

I think some light domestic duties can be agreed as long as that doesn't go over the recommended hours but they shouldn't be considered in the same vein as "a cleaner" or "a nanny". They should be treated moke akin to a member of the household doing a share of everyday chores.

As others have said Brexit has hugely limited the au pair scheme.

I've never had an au pair but a friend did and she said it was hit and miss. First one great, very efficient and proactive. (German if that's relevant.) Second one was more of a typical teenager and couldn't get up in the morning so friend ended up having to take the kids to school herself anyway or they'd have been late every day. There were also issues with smoking in her room and bringing random lads home. Friend gave up on au pairs after that!

RaspberrSeed · 17/02/2024 10:03

We went round this loop with MIL (from another European country) who insisted we ‘get a teenager’ to look after two-under-two. It’s not only not what au pairs are meant to do (as above it’s a bit of incidental childcare for older kids, not toddlers). It’s also the completely bonkers idea of leaving two tiny children in the care of someone unqualified, probably with no experience of young children, barely older than a child themselves.

If you already have two little kids you’ll know the difficulty of looking after them all day, as well as the very real risks of falling, choking, running under a car, etc.

Get a qualified nanny.

AnnaBegins · 17/02/2024 09:34

Our kids have loved having au pairs and love to visit them in the holidays still.

What worked well when we had a preschooler, was short days in nursery and then the au pair collects them, maybe they have an afternoon nap, so it's a very short time of sole care (ours did 3 hours care for a preschooler with a 1.5hr nap during that time).

It's very difficult since Brexit and demand is higher than supply.

CloudPop · 17/02/2024 09:26

This may be a terminology thing. As others have explained, au pairs are a part time helping hand, distinct from a nanny who would be an alternative to nursery. We used both, had a nanny until the children were upper primary school, then switched to au pairs

Heronwatcher · 17/02/2024 09:24

You need a nanny- an au pair shouldn’t really be looking after kids 4/5 days a week, all day, every day. They are often very very young, no training in childcare/ child development, not especially mature in some cases. I’ve heard some hair raising tales of stuff au pairs got up to- boyfriends around the kids, losing kids in parks, tv all day when au pair had a hangover, secret trips to macdonalds and in some cases basically bribing the kids not to tell parents what was going on! Plus they often leave with very short notice (I have heard equally shocking stories about how au pairs have been treated too).

If you are able to find one (and as others have said, Brexit has made that pretty difficult), I’d only use them for breakfast/ dinner after school/ pre-school and not for tiny babies.

KnickerlessParsons · 17/02/2024 09:23

I was an au pair, and we had a series au pairs for about 8 years to help with our children. It's a fab system and can work very well. You have to be easy going enough to accept a stranger into your home and family though, and also have a spare bedroom for them.

APs aren't there to look after toddlers all day. They need time off for language lessons, and only work something like 25 hours a week. They aren't childminders or nannies.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 17/02/2024 09:16

You need to research what an au pair is. They are meant to so aomething like 5 hours of childcare a day and do things like learn the language on other days . Nursery staff are trained in first aid, child development, child education. An ai pair has a small amount of babysitting experience. You can't replace one with the other. They are for school age kids, doing the school run etc

Catza · 17/02/2024 09:14

I don’t have experience with one as a child but my fiends had an au pair who was slightly older (early 20s) and their kids absolutely adored her. She worked for my friends 30h a week and she also did my cleaning as a part time job. My friend’s kids were aged between 2 and 11 and she was great looking after the little one during the day so I would have no concerns getting an au pair over a nanny based on that experience. The little boy is now 8 and he still calls her all the time for a chat.

HipHipWhoRay · 17/02/2024 09:06

You mustn’t use an au pair as a nanny! They are school leavers/young, unqualified, and usually in the UK to learn English. You are supposed to be giving them board, light jobs, facilitating them going to language school or similar. They are much better for older kids, someone to be there when they get home from school etc. Don’t use them as cheap childcare, it won’t work out for either of you

AnEmbarrasmentofWitches · 17/02/2024 09:04

Catza · 17/02/2024 08:59

It’s the opposite. Au Pair’s duties are looking after the children as part of cultural exchange programme. They should not be doing any duties for the general household.

Thanks, I’m obviously very out of date! ( my au pair experience is also 42 years out of date) 😂😂 Looking back, I guess she did spend a lot of time with us kids, I just wasn’t aware she was ‘looking after’ us 😂😁