Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend forged her mother's will

219 replies

Beautynamechange · 17/02/2024 01:13

I have recently learnt that my friend who I have known since forever forged her late mother's will.

I don't want to go into too much detail about how I learnt this as it will be too outing.

It was nearly 4 years ago when her mother was most vulnerable on her death bed little over a week before she passed. There was another will put in place for around 20 years before this new will and that previous will was destroyed by my friend. Both wills were made at home.

It has nothing to do with me, but my friend took advantage of her dying mother, and now I feel different towards her because of this. I am supposed to be her bridesmaid at her wedding in a few months and I cannot get past how someone could do that for her own advantage. I have known this friend since nursery. We are both late 20's now.

Is it wrong of me to feel different about my friend? I understand this has nothing to do with me but it's the fact she has done it. How cruel towards her other family members.

OP posts:
MamaAlwaysknowsbest · 17/02/2024 11:00

And so , nobody but you know this and this friend gobbled up all the money in this illegal way or were the authorities made aware ?

puffyisgood · 17/02/2024 10:58

This sort of thing might very occasionally be defensible If the old will had been hugely overtaken by events e.g. it'd very obviously been made on a daft whim at the time or had been massively blown out of the water by subsequent births, deaths, or estrangements.

Generally, though, this sounds like despicable behaviour, the sort of thing that for me would easily justify cutting off all ties.

oakleaffy · 17/02/2024 10:53

Chouquettes · 17/02/2024 08:40

Aren’t there supposed to be witnesses that sign a will ?

Yes, there are...I signed my neighbour's Will, along with another neighbour, and said '{Name, you should REALLY be getting a solicitor to do your Will''....however, when neighbour died, there was no come back on us, the witnesses.

No one checked.

However.. I assumed the house {quite valuable} was given to her daughter and granddaughter.
This was who sold the house in the end, so they must have been the beneficiaries.

Gwenhwyfar · 17/02/2024 10:49

4YellowDaffodils · 17/02/2024 09:57

Agree. I never understand why people try not to spend money on wills. DH and I got wills in 2019 and it would have cost £250 for both of them from the law firm i then worked for (it was free as i worked there but that was the actual cost for clients).

I have had friends - rich friends- ask me to do their wills for them at 'mates rates'. What is a fucking mate rate? These people spent £5k on a garden designer to just draw a picture of what they could do to their garden. (Not provide plants or grunt work). £250 plus VAT for a pair of valid wills is chump change FFS.

Here is what you should spend money on. Wills.

Obviously depends how complicated your life is. I have no dependants so it's not really something I'll worry about, certainly not spend £500 on.

OOBetty · 17/02/2024 10:48

Not a will but a similar situation.

My uncle ( one of 7 ) forged the transfer of my grandads house into his name.
He then burnt the house down whilst he knew my grandad would be in church ( remote place in Ireland )
He then used insurance to build nice new house and waited.
Grandad died a few years later having spent those years mourning the loss of his family home and spending his days just sitting on its doorstep as that was all that was left.
After my grandad died my uncle then tried to sell the house and it’s at this point his siblings realised what he had done, the will was useless as grandad no longer owned the house

However
Divine retribution moment
My uncle didn’t realise the house and land were on two separate deeds and he only owned the house.

So he couldn’t sell the house as legally he couldn’t access it as it was surrounded by land now owned by his siblings as well.

And there to this day sits the house in a ploughed field with a 1m walkway around it.

The whole affair tore apart a once close family and all for greed!

So I would step away OP, she’s shown her true colours

BlackBean2023 · 17/02/2024 10:37

If you're 28 now, your friend would have been 24 when the new Will was made. The old Will would have been written when she was 4. A lot can change in 20 years and assuming she was early 20's when she lost her mum the mother would have been young and perhaps not thought she would need to worry about a new will.

Scenario 1- old will leaves her house and cash savings to an ex partner of 10 years.

Scenario 2- old will leaves money split equally between siblings and new will leaves everything to your friend.

I'd need more context before drawing an opinion on whether this would be friendship ending for me.

DespairAgony · 17/02/2024 10:32

Her siblings can and will be able to contest her mother's will and ironically she will be left with even less than her mother left to her in the first place after legal fees. Don't worry, OP, her comeuppance will arrive in due course.

Channellingsophistication · 17/02/2024 10:29

I couldnt continue a friendship with someone like that… what would be the point.

keirakilaney67 · 17/02/2024 10:27

honeylulu · 17/02/2024 10:11

My first thought - what an awful human being. It sounds like she removed bequests to other family members to increase her own share.

Second thought - why has she told you this? She must be as thick as pigshit.

Third thought - how did she deal with the need for witnesses to sign/attest? Did she fake all three signatures?

Agree with everyone saying get your wills sorted. A few years ago someone was outside Tescos promoting Wills Week and offering a reduced fixed fee for a limited time. I told him I already had one (I'm a solicitor- not a probate one but my bequests were simple so I did my own) and he said the majority of people he'd spoken to didn't. I expressed surprise and said I wondered why. He said the most common reason us it makes people "think they are going to die". Well no shit Sherlock, that's inevitable!

Well surely it depends on the demographics he'd been speaking to?
Many younger people have no savings and can't even afford a house. What's the point of making a will if you have nothing to leave anyway.

ThinWomansBrain · 17/02/2024 10:23

Why has it only become a dilemma four years on?
You've stayed close enough friends with her all this time and now it's a problem because she's asked you to be her bridesmaid?

lizzowhiz · 17/02/2024 10:21

Well, she's commited a criminal offence; hopefully there'll be bigger consequences than you not being her bridesmaid OP

TellMeWhoTheVillainsAre · 17/02/2024 10:17

How did you find out? Did she tell you?

TheFutureMrsWolowitz · 17/02/2024 10:17

eilaka · 17/02/2024 10:14

What kind of forgery - one her mother wanted?

Presumably as the dead lady's daughter, the money was coming to her anyway?

I'm trying to figure out what kind of deception has occurred.

Really? You can't think of it? Other siblings for example? Money left to charities dear to her heart?

When FIL died BIL snuck out of the church during the funeral service and cleared the house of all valuables and then denied it. If he had been able to forge the will he would have done so.

People who are amoral arseholes walk among us.

eilaka · 17/02/2024 10:14

What kind of forgery - one her mother wanted?

Presumably as the dead lady's daughter, the money was coming to her anyway?

I'm trying to figure out what kind of deception has occurred.

FrenchFancie · 17/02/2024 10:13

I’ve seen cases where wills have been amended close to death - either through fraud or because someone had a last minute change of heart. It’s very hard to prove wrongdoing and very expensive.

that being said, I wouldn’t be able to be friends with someone who did this.

edited because I can’t spell

honeylulu · 17/02/2024 10:11

My first thought - what an awful human being. It sounds like she removed bequests to other family members to increase her own share.

Second thought - why has she told you this? She must be as thick as pigshit.

Third thought - how did she deal with the need for witnesses to sign/attest? Did she fake all three signatures?

Agree with everyone saying get your wills sorted. A few years ago someone was outside Tescos promoting Wills Week and offering a reduced fixed fee for a limited time. I told him I already had one (I'm a solicitor- not a probate one but my bequests were simple so I did my own) and he said the majority of people he'd spoken to didn't. I expressed surprise and said I wondered why. He said the most common reason us it makes people "think they are going to die". Well no shit Sherlock, that's inevitable!

Georgyporky · 17/02/2024 10:07

I hope the siblings have been told, & can challenge the will.

4YellowDaffodils · 17/02/2024 09:57

SilverBranchGoldenPears · 17/02/2024 09:50

Having my will done with a solicitor and lodged with Wills Scotland and getting a POA drawn up may end up being the best 500 quid I’ve spent. I’ve remarried and everything I own goes to my kids not to my new husband. I’m pretty sure he can take care of himself.
This case goes to show how important it is to spend a bit of time and money doing it properly.
I couldn’t be friends with someone who I know is a happy fraudster.

Edited

Agree. I never understand why people try not to spend money on wills. DH and I got wills in 2019 and it would have cost £250 for both of them from the law firm i then worked for (it was free as i worked there but that was the actual cost for clients).

I have had friends - rich friends- ask me to do their wills for them at 'mates rates'. What is a fucking mate rate? These people spent £5k on a garden designer to just draw a picture of what they could do to their garden. (Not provide plants or grunt work). £250 plus VAT for a pair of valid wills is chump change FFS.

Here is what you should spend money on. Wills.

SilverBranchGoldenPears · 17/02/2024 09:50

Having my will done with a solicitor and lodged with Wills Scotland and getting a POA drawn up may end up being the best 500 quid I’ve spent. I’ve remarried and everything I own goes to my kids not to my new husband. I’m pretty sure he can take care of himself.
This case goes to show how important it is to spend a bit of time and money doing it properly.
I couldn’t be friends with someone who I know is a happy fraudster.

Sureaseggs44 · 17/02/2024 09:39

Did other family members specifically lose out ? Why did they not realise ?

personally yes I would end the friendship if that’s the case because it’s dishonest and stealing and disrespectful .

DaBlackCatsAreDaBestCats · 17/02/2024 09:38

I have a “friend” who’ll do anything for money. Borrows and never repays. Her late mother didn’t have anything of value to leave her so she treated her badly. No morals. Greedy. Not a nice person. Is now in a marriage for the house and couldn’t give a toss about the bloke. I’m fully aware of her character.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 17/02/2024 09:34

How on earth did this even happen ? Dont wills need to be countersigned by a witness ? So someone else was in this fraud with her ?

TiredCatLady · 17/02/2024 09:28

If this was during Covid then it really wouldn’t surprise me that it didn’t get picked up by probate.

Lots of systems and checks went to ratshit.

If the end result was that your friend benefitted from the will to others detriment then I’d be making a quiet exit from the friendship.

paleontologist · 17/02/2024 09:28

The obvious answer is you wouldn't be wring to cut ties with this person.

However, do you trust your source of information?

Has your friend been charged and proven guilty? Or, has she admitted it to you?

Before writing off a 20-year friendship, I would be careful not to fall for what could end up to be nothing but malicious lies from vindictive relatives.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 17/02/2024 09:27

On the back of this. I used to work as a legal PA/sec in a small high street law firm.

We only really had some beneficiaries of a will contest it. It was a single man who’d died but with a big and extensive estate (lots of different accounts, swings, investments and pension(s). It was lengthy and expensive to process this but the beneficiaries insisted they wanted to do this and I’d joined whilst the case was in full swing.

We also had a charming older man, I think Jamaican who used to bring us chocolates and had a small property portfolio in London. When he suddenly died his son who he was estranged from was straight in our offices with his partner saying he was entitled to everything! Pity that the old man had remarried having no more DC but the son insisted he was entitled to it all and stuff her! Luckily we found the will (the old man had come in regularly to see to this will, made codicils and ensured his properties were in both him and his DW’s name) and to also purchase a new property. We took almost slight pleasure in politely booting the son out of our offices!

I personally would advise a professional looking will be drawn up, any changes to be reflected by a codicil during your lifetime and do not if you have assets to leave not make a will. Even as pp said a diy will or a note preferably signed and witnessed of your wishes and kept in a safe place will suffice. Just ensure there are no duplicates lying around.

It is also very expensive and time consuming and stressful to make a claim on a will And there’s a limit if you’re a beneficiary but left out eg a child of a will and want to challenge it.