Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP guilting me about spending a lot of money

144 replies

Symphonique · 16/02/2024 23:06

It’s my birthday today. I’ve spent a lot of money, and DH is now making me feel guilty.

I’m a professional musician, I work hard, I earn a reasonable about of money. DH is an architect and does well too. We are comfortable financially and have savings.

I’ve wanted to buy an additional violin for a while, because it’s my passion and although I love my existing violin, I’ve wanted a second (less expensive) instrument because it would be a good back up and I wanted to choose an instrument with a very different sound.

We’ve talked about it on and off for a couple of months and agreed a budget. I have had a wonderful day playing different violins at the shop and bought one I absolutely adore.

He’s since made snide comments like, oh it may take a while to build up the money you’ve spent today, or it just means things we want to spend a lot of money on (eg new bathroom) will have to be put back now.

I’m now feeling guilty, and a bit cross as he was totally supportive and fine about what we agreed. However, now he doesn’t seem fine about it at all. I feel I’ve made a huge mistake. But at the same time am so delighted with my purchase.

AIBU or is he?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MayThe4th · 17/02/2024 16:14

Tbh I think it depends.
assuming you have hundreds of thousands in the bank £10k is just an expenditure. But if you cleaned out the bank account then it’s understandable that he might be miffed.
and did you actually agree that you were going to spend that much? Or was it a conversation more along the lines of that being how much you would spend, and your DP didn’t actually think of it as being agreed that you were going to go out and spend 10 grand.

WhereYouLeftIt · 17/02/2024 16:02

Symphonique · 16/02/2024 23:10

We have joint accounts so our money is pooled, I’m just wondering if he feels like he’s not getting a treat too?

Well when it's his birthday, he can have a treat.

Seriously - he's making snide comments because you bought the birthday present you'd discussed at length together? Is he six?

DoIhavegreeneyes · 17/02/2024 15:52

If you care for your violin it will always have a reasonable value. Not like a computer or gadget that might be superseded by a change of technology. It is not like a holiday that will be gone in 2 weeks time. It is not like a £10,000 car that will be down to £100 after 6 years.
Enjoy it.

candyisdandybutliquorisquicker · 17/02/2024 14:24

I'm warming to my theme here ... especially reading responses saying, "You spent how much!" "It's family money!" What's life about really, if it's not the moments of indulgence and delight now and then? You can afford it, you wanted it, he agreed, you did it! And now you have something that brings you joy.

Life is about more than trudging through the quotidian, punctuated by the odd home improvement purchase. Life is short, we have to do the things that make us happy. You aren't struggling to make rent or feed your children.

Do what you love.

WigglyVonWaggly · 17/02/2024 14:21

Enjoy your violin and happy birthday! £10k is obviously a huge amount of money to most people but you're a professional and it’s no different to a pro golfer having a set of quality clubs or a pro chef having a superb oven set up at home. It’s an investment which will be used forever. The key thing is that you both agreed on it beforehand. You didn’t just drop 10k of shared money. He has no right to complain after the event.

Mirabai · 17/02/2024 14:19

For those who weren't aware how much one can reasonably spend on professional level violins

They should bear in mind that Strads sell for millions…

Pythonesque · 17/02/2024 14:16

For those who weren't aware how much one can reasonably spend on professional level violins, I am reminded of the time some 20 years back when my sister was trying to get established as an orchestral violinist. There are major instrument auctions every 6 months, and she had a sum of money earmarked for the purchase of a suitable instrument. Or alternatively it would be their (hefty) house deposit.

OP - enjoy your violin, and next time your DH says something unkind and tries to claim it as a joke, do make it clear that it was not funny and he should knock it off immediately.

As an aside I came to violin teaching in my late 30s, having always discounted music as a career (for lots of reasons including knowing I didn't have my sister's talent nor dedication). It has turned into such a joy and I am very amused that my reaction to "would you stop working if you won the lottery" threads, is to imagine setting up a music teaching hub ...

candyisdandybutliquorisquicker · 17/02/2024 14:15

Take his comments at face value - and enjoy your lovely new violin! The whole experience sounds delightful!

Mirabai · 17/02/2024 14:05

Just remind him of Min-Jim Kym’s Strad that was pinched at Waterloo station.

You need a second violin.

FictionalCharacter · 17/02/2024 14:04

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 17/02/2024 13:23

Just ignore him and if he says it again say 'we agreed to that spending , unless you're suggesting we can't afford it and want to return it, I don't want to discuss it any more as it's getting in the way of me enjoying my birthday treat'

Perfect!

FictionalCharacter · 17/02/2024 14:03

Symphonique · 16/02/2024 23:10

We have joint accounts so our money is pooled, I’m just wondering if he feels like he’s not getting a treat too?

Why should he get a treat for YOUR birthday?!

Symphonique · 17/02/2024 14:02

tanstaafl · 17/02/2024 14:00

OP
please learn ‘the world’s smallest violin’ song to play if he brings up the expenditure again.

Like this 😂

OP posts:
tanstaafl · 17/02/2024 14:00

OP
please learn ‘the world’s smallest violin’ song to play if he brings up the expenditure again.

Mr. Krabs - The world’s smallest Violin

https://youtu.be/GiSFWDBqDn8?feature=shared

askmenow · 17/02/2024 13:51

Symphonique · 16/02/2024 23:15

Thanks ☺️- not sure about tax write off, but it’ll definitely be going through my books so hopefully my tax bill will be very low next time!

Of course its offset against tax bill given its a work tool.
Make it very clear to him, this is what you wanted, you both agreed on it so he's to STFU!
Tosser spoiling your Birthday!
Life's difficult enough without this snide undermining. You work for it....you deserve it.

Suchagroovyguy · 17/02/2024 13:31

Symphonique · 16/02/2024 23:10

We have joint accounts so our money is pooled, I’m just wondering if he feels like he’s not getting a treat too?

What a horrible shit he is. It’s your birthday. You’ve discussed it. He’s just furious he isn’t getting something too. That is vile and so immature.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 17/02/2024 13:23

Just ignore him and if he says it again say 'we agreed to that spending , unless you're suggesting we can't afford it and want to return it, I don't want to discuss it any more as it's getting in the way of me enjoying my birthday treat'

BetterWithPockets · 17/02/2024 12:16

If he makes any more comments I will play something melancholic in a dramatic fashion.

Love this comment of yours, OP! Im
sorry your DP’s comments took a little of the shine off your day/purchase. Perhaps you’re right that he is a little envious. We can all have off days where we have little digs about things, I guess. It sounds as though you generally have a very good relationship though.

gamerchick · 17/02/2024 12:14

Symphonique · 17/02/2024 10:55

You sound angry and a little unkind.

Yeah hard to get tone through text. Doesnt mean I'm wrong. It's your posts thats painted a picture of your bloke OP.

laclochette · 17/02/2024 12:00

@Eleganz See this is the thing. If my husband needed to buy a new £10k laptop for his work, I would expect him to have done his accounts properly, and the conversation would go something like, "I've got a lot of business expenses this year so I won't be making as much profit, which unfortunately is going to affect our household income to XYZ extent, I'll be contributing less to the household budget as a result so shall we sit down and run the joint numbers together so we both understand what that looks like." That's the sensible and mature way to manage these things I think.

Eleganz · 17/02/2024 11:56

CampingWithInTent · 17/02/2024 11:45

But it’s also a work expense? If he bought a second laptop for work would you be angry?

False comparison. Very few women would be happy if their husbands went out and spent £10k on a back up work laptop and that this a ridiculous scenario that wouldn't happen.

Anyway, I wonder how the discussion around the budget actually went. Was it an open discussion about the need for the instrument first then agreement on budget or was it a case that OP was set on getting a new fiddle and it was more about a haggle on the budget. Those two discussions are very different and the reasonableness of continuing to have reservations about the need for the purchase is very different between the two types of discussion.

Of course, what the DH should be doing is being open and honest about his concerns rather than making offhand remarks.

laclochette · 17/02/2024 11:53

I'm interested as to whether your violin is, as professional musician, actually a purchase for your job. It's complicated when your job is also your passion, in your case, but I wonder if it might be worth making more effort to separate business and personal expenses. I wouldn't want or expect my partner to buy business equipment out of our joint funds. He is a freelancer and works at home some of the time on a specific computer setup which he also uses for non-work things, but if he wanted a new monitor or whatever, I would expect him to buy that out of his business accounts and treat it as a business expense.

This is slightly separate to the emotional question of your husband subtly acting like he's going back on an agreement you had made, but I think it's connected.

It might be a good idea to have all your business income and outgoings go through a business account specific to you, from which you can pay yourself a "salary" and then this goes into your shared personal pot?

I think the blurred lines are important because it's confusing things. On the one hand this is an object that you want for your profession, on the other hand it's come out the shared personal pot and so affects your buying power as a couple. I feel like your husband is flickering between the two ways of understanding it.

If you had a set amount of money you allocated from your income for business costs, then you would be able to spend that income any way you wanted, and it wouldn't affect your shared spending power because you'd calculate your "salary" that went into the shared pot based on having already made allowances for these costs.

Cookiecrumblepie · 17/02/2024 11:50

If your husband agreed to the expense it is mean to make snide comments after the purchase. If he had issues he should have said so beforehand.

sounds like he has a nasty streak and I would tell him so. He’s just bringing you down.

life is for living and buying a lovely violin and enjoying it is a wonderful way to enjoy your life. I don’t see the issue. You husband should want to see you happy and he should try to make yoh happy. It seems to me like he’s taking your happiness away.

rookiemere · 17/02/2024 11:45

If he does mention it again, I wouldn't be going down the jokey "I'm worth it" route.
I would say something like "DH you've made a number of remarks about how expensive the violin is, and how it will impact other things like getting the house done. I'm a bit confused as we agreed the expense, and your attitude is sucking the enjoyment out of this. Are you concerned about finances or is there something I should know ?"

CampingWithInTent · 17/02/2024 11:45

But it’s also a work expense? If he bought a second laptop for work would you be angry?

caringcarer · 17/02/2024 11:44

It's a tool for you to earn your living. If he wasn't happy he should not have agreed with it. This is a special day for you, tell him to stop ruining it for you. Play your violin and enjoy it. Surely an instrument would be tax deductible for a musician?

Swipe left for the next trending thread