Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell MIL to stop with the comments

542 replies

mariaem · 16/02/2024 21:48

More of an "how to do this" not AIBU

I'd rather not have my husband with me during the birth. I prefer he drops me off at the hospital or heads home when the intense contractions start, and then returns once the baby and I are cleaned up. This is just how I feel, and I'm not really up for debating it, so please let's not turn this post into a discussion of pros and cons of partners being at the birth. The question is about MIL's comments and how to address them.

So, I'm about 28 weeks pregnant, and every time I see my MIL, she just won't let up with the comments like, 'Are you still planning not to have him present?' or 'Do you think he'll regret not being there?' or 'Perhaps you'll change your mind when you feel more maternal towards the end of pregnancy' I've been trying to brush it off for the past 20 weeks with responses like, 'I don't see myself changing my mind' or 'Yeah, it's what we've decided,' but she's persistent.

My husband thinks she's just shocked and wants to express her feelings, but he's never been one to stand up to her. He's more of a 'mom's always right' kinda guy. We've talked about it, and he's cool with whatever makes me comfortable on the day, ultimately I'm the one doing the work.

How can I gently but firmly address her comments? I've tried telling her that the topic makes me uncomfortable and that we've made our decision, but she seems to ignore it.

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 17/02/2024 11:51

@Iwasafool but the midwife ignored a potentially serious problem twice, when she was in the room with both of us. The midwife suggested DH went to get a sandwich/drink and once he left, said she was going to get something to eat. She should not have left me alone. Once I had the epidural labour advanced very quickly - I went from barely dilated to 8cm in about 35 minutes. I recall her noting when the epidural was in that we had a long night ahead and things would be several hours.

DS2 was quick and premature and no time for an epidural. DD followed exactly the same pattern as DS1 but we were wiser then and I had insisted either on an elective caesarean or an experienced midwife. I got the latter as I had consultant led care. Even she was surprised when I went from a standing start to pushing in half an hour.

crumblingschools · 17/02/2024 11:47

But is the OP making a free choice, if she has been conditioned by her culture that her husband shouldn’t be there? Is she part of a culture that deems anything to do with women’s bodily functions are dirty/unclean and she had to be cleansed before her husband can see her again

onlythebrave3 · 17/02/2024 11:46

NoOrdinaryMorning
I find your attitude appalling. Of course the Dad doesn't have a right to be in the room during their child's birth. In most of the world and throughout history giving birth has been a female affair. In recent history men were invited into labour wards as a support to their partner, giving birth is not a spectator sport!

Iwasafool · 17/02/2024 11:44

StaringAtTheWater · 17/02/2024 09:13

Gosh OP, I know you didn't want a discussion about it, but wouldn't it be better to have someone with you? If not your DH, a friend or doula? I don't want to scare you, but giving birth in an NHS hospital can be a scary and stressful experience. It can be difficult to advocate for yourself when you're tired and in lots of pain. I certainly would not want to go in alone.

Good job you are allowed to make that choice then just like the OP can make her choice.

Iwasafool · 17/02/2024 11:41

RosesAndHellebores · 17/02/2024 11:35

It is entirely a decision for the couple and the mother's preference prevails.

Our DC are grown up. DH was with me for two of the three births (the 2nd was early, unexpected and the baby was born before he could get there). He sat by the bed, he gave me sips of water, we chatted in the boring bits. He kept well away from the business end.

In an ideal world I don't think there should be a need for the father or partner to be there. But we don't live in an ideal world and the father or partner plays a principal role as carer, soother, advocate and facilitator.

What will you do @mariaem if the midwife leaves you, the baby's heartbeat dips and you can't reach the call button. It happened to us nearly 30 years ago - DH went to get a drink, I couldn't reach. He came back, it happened again, the midwife said it was the belt and hoiked it up, it happened again and she hoiked it up again. I hadn't been that fussed about DH being there. When it happened the third time, DH strode to the door and yelled for a Dr immediately. A senior midwife appeared and hit the red button. The room filled with clinicians.

DS, in the birth canal, was being strangled by the cord. Too far out to push back up. I was given one push while the Dr got the forceps ready. I will never know how I did it, but ds was born on that push. He was purple and they had to work on him to resuscitate him. He spent the first night in SCBU and Dr's checked him frequently over the next few days. The day after the birth, the director of children's services came to see me to check I was happy with everything. Only with hindsight did that resonate. DS was fine but I never ever trusted a midwife again.

On the other hand if your husband hadn't been there the midwife might have spent more time with you and things could have been sorted out sooner.

When I laboured alone (2 of my 4 births) I got so much support from the midwives and formed a much stronger bond with them than with the births where my husband was present. My husband being present was also the two births with complications, forceps and an EMCS. Who knows how these things might have worked out if we'd done something different.

Rachie1973 · 17/02/2024 11:40

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 17/02/2024 02:09

Is a father who isn't a trained medical professional actually allowed to do that?

Indeed. I cut one of my granddaughters cords (at her mother’s invite). The midwives clamp it and show you where to cut.

Eleganz · 17/02/2024 11:40

PrincessTeaSet · 17/02/2024 10:46

That's completely irrelevant. If the child needs surgery shortly after birth neither parent will be able to stay. The woman giving birth can't see the child being born anyway.

The purpose of the partner being there is to provide support during labour, nothing else.

A birth partner can also advocate for the mother should she not be able to do so herself. Of course this can be done by anyone the woman chooses but I do hope she has someone there with her.

As is often the case with these things people are confusing the the right of women to choose whomever they want to be their birth partner (or indeed no-one) and the impact on the marriage of excluding a husband that wants to be present at the birth from doing so. It is entirely possible to act well within your rights and still being hurtful to those around you. We have the right to make these decisions, we do not have the right for them to be free of consequence.

Of course, OP insists that her DH is fully onboard so we are forced to conclude that her MIL is being a busybody. It maybe that that is not the case but we can't know.

RosesAndHellebores · 17/02/2024 11:35

It is entirely a decision for the couple and the mother's preference prevails.

Our DC are grown up. DH was with me for two of the three births (the 2nd was early, unexpected and the baby was born before he could get there). He sat by the bed, he gave me sips of water, we chatted in the boring bits. He kept well away from the business end.

In an ideal world I don't think there should be a need for the father or partner to be there. But we don't live in an ideal world and the father or partner plays a principal role as carer, soother, advocate and facilitator.

What will you do @mariaem if the midwife leaves you, the baby's heartbeat dips and you can't reach the call button. It happened to us nearly 30 years ago - DH went to get a drink, I couldn't reach. He came back, it happened again, the midwife said it was the belt and hoiked it up, it happened again and she hoiked it up again. I hadn't been that fussed about DH being there. When it happened the third time, DH strode to the door and yelled for a Dr immediately. A senior midwife appeared and hit the red button. The room filled with clinicians.

DS, in the birth canal, was being strangled by the cord. Too far out to push back up. I was given one push while the Dr got the forceps ready. I will never know how I did it, but ds was born on that push. He was purple and they had to work on him to resuscitate him. He spent the first night in SCBU and Dr's checked him frequently over the next few days. The day after the birth, the director of children's services came to see me to check I was happy with everything. Only with hindsight did that resonate. DS was fine but I never ever trusted a midwife again.

Nanny0gg · 17/02/2024 11:32

Fairydustandsparklylights · 17/02/2024 11:23

You have made a decision for your husband. He misses out on a life changing moment due to your selfishness. I’m not surprised your Mil is making comments. Luckily, it sounds like he’ll have somewhere to go when he sees the light and dumps you.

Or, he understands and is happy to support the mother of his child in her wishes.

So instead of being so spiteful to a total stranger, maybe think the OP knows him and his opinion

For all we know, this was all discussed before she even got pregnant

Iwasafool · 17/02/2024 11:31

RandomPoster456 · 17/02/2024 10:40

Yep, this 100% YABVU. If this was something that purely only affected your life entirely and not your DHs in such a huge way I’d be saying differently. So, you want your DH to drive you to the hospital and be at your beck and call when you decide but you are willing to deprive your husband of the best moment of his entire life? Unless you’re withholding an enormous drip feed like he’s an alcoholic, drug addict or abusive (in which case he shouldn’t be driving you anyway) you’re incredibly selfish. Your MIL may be unreasonable with her other comments but I’m for once with MIL here. You can’t dictate how your MIL should feel or the types of comments you receive on here. This is a public forum and we’re all entitled to our opinion rightly or wrongly. If you’re going to stonewall people into not putting forward their opinion when the context is important and relevant to people’s answers then Mumsnet really isn’t for you.

If you can't be selfish and put your own wishes first when you are giving birth I don't know when you can.

AliCatWalk · 17/02/2024 11:30

WOW, there are some SERIOUSLY shitty and narrow-minded takes in this thread (a lot of "random" and "confused" people for instance). Birth plans are individual women's decisions based on all kinds of unique personal and logistical factors. By the logic some of the truly terrible opinions here, single pregnant women or women whose partners couldn't be present at birth for one reason or another wouldn't stand a chance 🙄The person giving birth should have whoever they want there to support them, whether it be their partner, family member, friend, etc, in the best interests of the mother and the baby. Women whose partners are there by mutual decision? Great. Women who find it best for them not to have partner there? Also great. The best support a partner can give to the mother and child during birth is to understand and respect the needs of the one giving said birth.

As far as practical advice goes though @mariaem maybe you could put on a concerned look if your MIL asks again and pretend to be worried about her memory? 😅something along the lines of "I did tell you this when we last spoke on (day[s]), don't you remember?" or "Is everything alright? I'm noticing you repeating yourself a lot lately, maybe you should go for a checkup?" 😇

Chouquettes · 17/02/2024 11:29

mariaem · 16/02/2024 21:48

More of an "how to do this" not AIBU

I'd rather not have my husband with me during the birth. I prefer he drops me off at the hospital or heads home when the intense contractions start, and then returns once the baby and I are cleaned up. This is just how I feel, and I'm not really up for debating it, so please let's not turn this post into a discussion of pros and cons of partners being at the birth. The question is about MIL's comments and how to address them.

So, I'm about 28 weeks pregnant, and every time I see my MIL, she just won't let up with the comments like, 'Are you still planning not to have him present?' or 'Do you think he'll regret not being there?' or 'Perhaps you'll change your mind when you feel more maternal towards the end of pregnancy' I've been trying to brush it off for the past 20 weeks with responses like, 'I don't see myself changing my mind' or 'Yeah, it's what we've decided,' but she's persistent.

My husband thinks she's just shocked and wants to express her feelings, but he's never been one to stand up to her. He's more of a 'mom's always right' kinda guy. We've talked about it, and he's cool with whatever makes me comfortable on the day, ultimately I'm the one doing the work.

How can I gently but firmly address her comments? I've tried telling her that the topic makes me uncomfortable and that we've made our decision, but she seems to ignore it.

Just say yeah I’ll see nearer the time and then do what you want?

TorroFerney · 17/02/2024 11:29

MamaToABeautifulBoy · 16/02/2024 22:35

I can see why she’s upset, you have placed an embargo on the father of BOTH your child from being at their child’s birth. A child you both had a 50% part in creating. That’s bloody harsh and if your son were my DH, I’d be very hurt and upset on his behalf. You cannot police her feelings just as you have v stridently proclaimed that she has no right to have an opinion on the, frankly unreasonable, demands you are making on the day BOTH your child is born.

The moment my son was born was the best moment / day of my DH’s life.

By the way. You cannot post something so contentious and frankly utterly absurd on a public forum and control the responses you receive 🤷🏻‍♀️

Your opinion - watching my daughter being born (because of circumstances) was the most traumatic thing my husband had ever been party to -and this is someone who in his job has found decomposing bodies in houses, cut people down from trees, seen awful things.

It is almost like we are all different isn't it .

Iwasafool · 17/02/2024 11:27

Fairydustandsparklylights · 17/02/2024 11:23

You have made a decision for your husband. He misses out on a life changing moment due to your selfishness. I’m not surprised your Mil is making comments. Luckily, it sounds like he’ll have somewhere to go when he sees the light and dumps you.

What about the OP missing out on the birth she wants, doesn't that matter.

SomeCatFromJapan · 17/02/2024 11:25

Luckily, it sounds like he’ll have somewhere to go when he sees the light and dumps you.

That's a really unpleasant thing to say, and you're wishing a broken home on a not even born yet child.

Iwasafool · 17/02/2024 11:24

NoOrdinaryMorning · 16/02/2024 22:09

That's really unfair and dare I say it, a bit selfish to ban your DH from being at the birth of his own child. I mean yeah it's your body so you can absolutely do it, but I think it's unfair. Particularly when you could just say to him to be quiet, not to touch you and keep a lot profile in the room, etc. Some ground rules. But to ban him completely? I'm not surprised his DM is upset, she's upset for her DS ☹️

I used to work with a guy, police officer with some years service so he'd seen some bad stuff in his time. His wife wanted him at the birth so he was there. He hated the whole thing, couldn't have sex with her afterwards and eventually they divorced.

Don't push people to do what they don't want to do because you think it is right, it won't be right for everyone.

Fairydustandsparklylights · 17/02/2024 11:23

You have made a decision for your husband. He misses out on a life changing moment due to your selfishness. I’m not surprised your Mil is making comments. Luckily, it sounds like he’ll have somewhere to go when he sees the light and dumps you.

SerafinasGoose · 17/02/2024 11:22

NoOrdinaryMorning · 16/02/2024 22:14

@Bex5490 Absolutely I would unless he was violent or abusive. It's his child! He has every right to see him/her born. As long as he's respectful of the mother and stands well back if she wishes him to.

You are wrong: legally, medically, and by any other criteria. This is not about parental 'rights'. It's about a medical procedure and the wishes of a patient undergoing a major physical trauma who is therefore vulnerable. In this situation - if in no other circumstances as parents where both have an equal say - what OP wants takes top trumps. This isn't about the men. The baby's father can see the baby immediately after s/he is born. FWIW, my DH was with me when I gave birth but this was because it was my wish.

As far as MiL is concerned, as PPs upthread have suggested she needs to be on an immediate information diet. She doesn't need to know the circumstances of the birth: who is your birthing partner, or whether it was a vaginal birth or a CS or any other of your private medical information. If DH is divulging this you need an agreement from him that he'll stop, but nonetheless be very firm this these topics are off limits and will not be discussed by you.

Wishing you all the best and a smooth pregnancy and delivery.

DuoTulip · 17/02/2024 11:14

NoOrdinaryMorning · 16/02/2024 22:14

@Bex5490 Absolutely I would unless he was violent or abusive. It's his child! He has every right to see him/her born. As long as he's respectful of the mother and stands well back if she wishes him to.

No, sorry. This is BS. Whilst I would hope most people want their partners at the birth, he certainly doesn't have any right to be at the birth any more than he has the right to attend any other personal and invasive process surrounding the mother's body.

crumblingschools · 17/02/2024 11:05

Looking back at the history of childbirth in this country, not sure it was all about being private, surely it was more about it not being seen as important (didn't even warrant having anyone medical there just some woman in the village who only had herbs to help with any difficulties). No wonder so many women died in childbirth. Men didn't have much of a role in parenting (women's work) so didn't need to be at the birth and the mother to be didn't need anyone to advocate for her., as she was not that important.

PrincessTeaSet · 17/02/2024 11:00

RandomPoster456 · 17/02/2024 10:56

It’s not weird whatsoever that I’ve called her selfish, what’s weird is your reaction to me giving an opinion that’s obviously supported by the majority here. Nice odd attempt to gaslight me, but no dice im afraid. The OP hasn’t said he’s a useless father, abusive, an addict so we have to assume he’s a perfectly run of the mill good husband. So with that in mind. You say he’s not bothered, that’s not what OP said - she’s said he’s cool with it. He’s respectful of the fact she doesn’t want him there because he clearly loves and values her feelings above his own. I don’t know many men that would be. You can tell by OPs tone that even if he wasn’t okay with it she wouldn’t give a flying toss. Why do people think women get the right to dictate the feelings of others just because they’re the only one physically able to carry the child. I’m sure she didn’t get pregnant by herself and every time you have sex you risk getting pregnant so by default so she should have thought about that before effectively using him as a glorified sperm donor. This wasn’t a one night stand, she’s his wife. She clearly has no respect for her husband’s emotional wellbeing or feelings. Might as well divorce him for the lack of respect she has for him. Good enough to get her pregnant and ferry her to and from the hospital when she demands AND do his part in raising his child (as he should) but not be there to see the child born. Revolting behaviour.

Edited

This is literally the most ridiculous post I have ever read on here!

PrincessTeaSet · 17/02/2024 10:59

confusedaboutclothes · 17/02/2024 09:39

Why do people always go so over the top with these threads 😂 imagine quoting the law because god forbid OP decided to let a man in her vagina and now doesn’t want him there to see what happens at the end of this pregnancy. Nobody said he’s going to be there without ‘consent’ i just think it’s absolutely and completely ridiculous. She didn’t care about him seeing her body when they made the child did she 🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️

Presumably you've never given birth, it isn't like the opposite of sex as you seem to think

RandomPoster456 · 17/02/2024 10:56

Naunet · 17/02/2024 10:46

He doesn’t want to be there, he’s not bothered, like many men. What’s weird and selfish is women like you trying to insist he must be.

It’s not weird whatsoever that I’ve called her selfish, what’s weird is your reaction to me giving an opinion that’s obviously supported by the majority here. Nice odd attempt to gaslight me, but no dice im afraid. The OP hasn’t said he’s a useless father, abusive, an addict so we have to assume he’s a perfectly run of the mill good husband. So with that in mind. You say he’s not bothered, that’s not what OP said - she’s said he’s cool with it. He’s respectful of the fact she doesn’t want him there because he clearly loves and values her feelings above his own. I don’t know many men that would be. You can tell by OPs tone that even if he wasn’t okay with it she wouldn’t give a flying toss. Why do people think women get the right to dictate the feelings of others just because they’re the only one physically able to carry the child. I’m sure she didn’t get pregnant by herself and every time you have sex you risk getting pregnant so by default so she should have thought about that before effectively using him as a glorified sperm donor. This wasn’t a one night stand, she’s his wife. She clearly has no respect for her husband’s emotional wellbeing or feelings. Might as well divorce him for the lack of respect she has for him. Good enough to get her pregnant and ferry her to and from the hospital when she demands AND do his part in raising his child (as he should) but not be there to see the child born. Revolting behaviour.

Iamnotawinp · 17/02/2024 10:54

This might sound crazy but I was taught it by a trained clinical psychologist.

I have a ex that won’t take no for an answer.

She told me to stand in a strong pose before him, put my hand up, palm facing and say “stop” in a calm voice. You can follow up with words like - I don’t want to talk about this/I’ve made my mind up etc, etc.

The strong body stance and hand conveys the message more effectively when they no longer actually listen to you. It’s like a visual aid!

Plus your husband needs to be telling her to shut up about it too.

PrincessTeaSet · 17/02/2024 10:53

AnnaSewell · 17/02/2024 10:12

I think there is a problem about focusing solely on one parent's wishes right at the start.

This is because one is incredible vulnerable and dependent after giving birth.

You need support when healing after the birth, when breastfeeding, when too exhausted to do all sorts of things, when you have to focus on the baby rather than going out there earning money,

So if you start off say, 'It might be your sperm, but actually it's all about me and what I need, not you and you are not involved', then I think it's harder to turn round in the days and weeks and months to say, 'Well this is your baby. You are the Dad. You should be doing this, that and the other.'

I'm not saying that childbirth should be about centring the father rather than the mother. The mother does come first. I'm just saying that the business of shared parenting, which involves a lot of compromise, goes on for years and it is good to start off - if at all possible - with an arrangement where everyone's feelings have been understood.

Are you talking about a different situation? Because it is clear in the OP that the decision has been made by both parents and they are both happy with it . Or are you suggesting the mil's feelings should take precedence over both parents, just in case she retaliates by not helping later on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread