Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell MIL to stop with the comments

542 replies

mariaem · 16/02/2024 21:48

More of an "how to do this" not AIBU

I'd rather not have my husband with me during the birth. I prefer he drops me off at the hospital or heads home when the intense contractions start, and then returns once the baby and I are cleaned up. This is just how I feel, and I'm not really up for debating it, so please let's not turn this post into a discussion of pros and cons of partners being at the birth. The question is about MIL's comments and how to address them.

So, I'm about 28 weeks pregnant, and every time I see my MIL, she just won't let up with the comments like, 'Are you still planning not to have him present?' or 'Do you think he'll regret not being there?' or 'Perhaps you'll change your mind when you feel more maternal towards the end of pregnancy' I've been trying to brush it off for the past 20 weeks with responses like, 'I don't see myself changing my mind' or 'Yeah, it's what we've decided,' but she's persistent.

My husband thinks she's just shocked and wants to express her feelings, but he's never been one to stand up to her. He's more of a 'mom's always right' kinda guy. We've talked about it, and he's cool with whatever makes me comfortable on the day, ultimately I'm the one doing the work.

How can I gently but firmly address her comments? I've tried telling her that the topic makes me uncomfortable and that we've made our decision, but she seems to ignore it.

OP posts:
ParanoidGynodroid · 17/02/2024 10:52

What a depressing thread.

All the "What about the poor menz?" posters, and the somewhat confused and incorrect use of the word "rights". Clue: when it comes to giving birth, men have NONE.

OP, you'll have to be firmer with MIL. You don't have to be patient and nice; she isn't with you.
"NOT your business" repeated as often as necessary whenever she pipes up about the subject.

Terzani · 17/02/2024 10:50

But I don’t think we should be celebrating cultures that still follow the tradition that men should not be at birth of their child if that culture is based on misogynistic beliefs.

Are you OP's MIL?
It doesn't even have to do with women's rights. Maybe it really boils down to what the health system can afford to offer, don't you think? If there is such an emphasis on fathers' rights to be at birth, on MILs rights and grandma's rights and extended family's rights (as others Mumsnet threads show, when the future mother tries to please both her family and DH's family and doesn't dare to exclude anyone when she ”decides” who will be present at birth), perhaps NHS in fact DOES need all those fathers, MILs and grannies to do its job by assisting the woman at birth. And everyone keeps talking instead about rights or misogyny or other cultures that they don't know about, when in fact it's just about money and the NHS culture.

PrincessTeaSet · 17/02/2024 10:47

cbuew9 · 17/02/2024 10:42

I assume this is your first child OP?

All I would kindly say to you is things don't always go to plan and you might be grateful of your husband's support.

My first labour should have been straight forward, but I ended up being induced, was in labour for just over 24 hours, my baby's heartbeat started slowing, and I ended up having an emergency caesarean, which was terrifying and unexpected.

I got through all of this because of my wonderful husband's support, he didn't leave my side, I would have hated to be alone.

Please carefully think of all the possibilities.

Wishing you all the best....

People get through every other kind of surgical and medical procedure without their partner by their side.

In fact lots of people have their second child alone because their partner is at home with the first one!

Naunet · 17/02/2024 10:46

RandomPoster456 · 17/02/2024 10:40

Yep, this 100% YABVU. If this was something that purely only affected your life entirely and not your DHs in such a huge way I’d be saying differently. So, you want your DH to drive you to the hospital and be at your beck and call when you decide but you are willing to deprive your husband of the best moment of his entire life? Unless you’re withholding an enormous drip feed like he’s an alcoholic, drug addict or abusive (in which case he shouldn’t be driving you anyway) you’re incredibly selfish. Your MIL may be unreasonable with her other comments but I’m for once with MIL here. You can’t dictate how your MIL should feel or the types of comments you receive on here. This is a public forum and we’re all entitled to our opinion rightly or wrongly. If you’re going to stonewall people into not putting forward their opinion when the context is important and relevant to people’s answers then Mumsnet really isn’t for you.

He doesn’t want to be there, he’s not bothered, like many men. What’s weird and selfish is women like you trying to insist he must be.

PrincessTeaSet · 17/02/2024 10:46

NoOrdinaryMorning · 16/02/2024 22:20

@Bex5490 Wow! Just wow.

I'll say it again IT IS HIS CHILD TOO!!!!!!!

That's completely irrelevant. If the child needs surgery shortly after birth neither parent will be able to stay. The woman giving birth can't see the child being born anyway.

The purpose of the partner being there is to provide support during labour, nothing else.

OssieShowman · 17/02/2024 10:44

Just don’t tell her. No need for her to know. Your decision.

Nanny0gg · 17/02/2024 10:43

confusedaboutclothes · 17/02/2024 10:11

Maybe she shouldn’t have gone into this then knowing she was perhaps a bit too sensitive to have her partner at the birth of their child.

Its not HER birth, its the babies and just because women by default the carrier, doesn’t mean that morally it should be taken away from him because it would make her feel uncomfortable 🤦‍♀️ But having a group of strangers in the form of midwives, potentially males, and male doctors i’m sure is fine…

Maybe don’t be with the man if his presence would make you feel uncomfortable

Woman as incubator...

cbuew9 · 17/02/2024 10:42

I assume this is your first child OP?

All I would kindly say to you is things don't always go to plan and you might be grateful of your husband's support.

My first labour should have been straight forward, but I ended up being induced, was in labour for just over 24 hours, my baby's heartbeat started slowing, and I ended up having an emergency caesarean, which was terrifying and unexpected.

I got through all of this because of my wonderful husband's support, he didn't leave my side, I would have hated to be alone.

Please carefully think of all the possibilities.

Wishing you all the best....

Nanny0gg · 17/02/2024 10:41

confusedaboutclothes · 17/02/2024 09:43

Yep you’re right - and then they changed that rule because they realised it was completely batshit! All the man haters on here that have also chosen to have sex with a man to create a baby together, to then say it’s ok that OP has said sorry you can’t be there to witness the birth? It’s just so selfish i can’t get my head around it

It wasn't a 'rule' as such.

It was a convention.

And conventions change.

Like, it's perfectly normal to eat in the street - it wasn't then. Height of bad manners

Some things were considered 'private' and birth was one of them - then the 60s arrived and everything changed.

RandomPoster456 · 17/02/2024 10:40

MamaToABeautifulBoy · 16/02/2024 22:35

I can see why she’s upset, you have placed an embargo on the father of BOTH your child from being at their child’s birth. A child you both had a 50% part in creating. That’s bloody harsh and if your son were my DH, I’d be very hurt and upset on his behalf. You cannot police her feelings just as you have v stridently proclaimed that she has no right to have an opinion on the, frankly unreasonable, demands you are making on the day BOTH your child is born.

The moment my son was born was the best moment / day of my DH’s life.

By the way. You cannot post something so contentious and frankly utterly absurd on a public forum and control the responses you receive 🤷🏻‍♀️

Yep, this 100% YABVU. If this was something that purely only affected your life entirely and not your DHs in such a huge way I’d be saying differently. So, you want your DH to drive you to the hospital and be at your beck and call when you decide but you are willing to deprive your husband of the best moment of his entire life? Unless you’re withholding an enormous drip feed like he’s an alcoholic, drug addict or abusive (in which case he shouldn’t be driving you anyway) you’re incredibly selfish. Your MIL may be unreasonable with her other comments but I’m for once with MIL here. You can’t dictate how your MIL should feel or the types of comments you receive on here. This is a public forum and we’re all entitled to our opinion rightly or wrongly. If you’re going to stonewall people into not putting forward their opinion when the context is important and relevant to people’s answers then Mumsnet really isn’t for you.

Itslegitimatesalvage · 17/02/2024 10:39

@JemimaTiggywinkles

There was no such thing as rape in marriage. That crime didn’t exist. Before the 90s, if you were married then you didn’t have a legal right to say no. You could say no, your husband could have forced sex with you /and there was nothing you could do as it wasn’t a crime. So your Gran was right about it back then.

Nanny0gg · 17/02/2024 10:39

Swipernoswipingg · 17/02/2024 09:37

I’m team MIL. Think she’s completely reasonable in the question she asks.

It's none of her bloody business!

LookItsMeAgain · 17/02/2024 10:37

mariaem · 16/02/2024 22:30

@ChunkyTofu oh he's welcome to stay in the hospital (he knows this), just thought he'd be more comfortable at home.

I don't particularly mind where he passes the time as long as he is comfortable and arrives fit, healthy, sober once the child is born.

This comment of yours speaks volumes to me at least.

Who thought he'd be more comfortable at home? Was this his suggestion or yours?

Why did you use the comment 'as long as he is comfortable and arrives fit, healthy, sober once the child is born'. Does your DH have an issue with drink or with drinking too much???

While you have a MiL issue whereby she keeps asking, she is doing it because she thinks her son, the father of the baby you two are having together, should be in the room when your baby is born. It's none of her business at the end of the day but she is trying to advocate for her son here. He probably spoke to her, son to mother, saying something.
I also think you have a DH issue here, firstly because some things (not everything) should be kept between husband and wife, and secondly, if he has an issue with his drinking, then you have a much harder conversation further down the road. I sincerely apologise if I picked up that comment from your post and I'm way wide of the mark here.

I wish you all the best in the coming weeks, months and years.

youmustrememberthis · 17/02/2024 10:33

JemimaTiggywinkles · 17/02/2024 10:22

It’s just so selfish i can’t get my head around it

You can’t get your head around it because your brain is struggling with the idea of a woman’s needs being more important than a man. It is deeply misogynistic to think that way.

It is a good thing that men are allowed in if the labouring woman would like him there. It is a good thing that women are allowed to say no to anyone seeing them naked and in distress. It is categorically not selfish to refuse to allow anyone access to your naked body.

The “she was fine with him seeing her naked to make the baby” comments, or “he’s her husband so he ought to be allowed to see her naked and in pain, even though she doesn’t want it” are absolutely sickening. They are, frankly, comments I’d expect from my gran (who thought that marriage meant you had no right to say no to sex).

No man has a right or need to watch a woman in labour. If a woman does not want him there then the discussion should end. It is simply wrong to try to bully a woman into changing her mind on this.

Completely agree with this.

It's the woman's body therefore it's woman's choice and that's where it ends.

As an aside, your grandmother was unfortunately right in terms of the law until about 1991 regarding rape in marriage not being illegal.

Nanny0gg · 17/02/2024 10:29

Moonwatcher1234 · 17/02/2024 07:07

I doubt her husband really is comfortable with this actually - maybe his mum knows this. Very weird Victorian attitude not to allow the father in until you’re “cleaned up” Also from another “eastern” culture and I think times have changed even in those countries.

Not Victorian

My BiL wasn't at the births of his children in the 60s.

And in the 50s, absolutely not.

It is relatively recent

Nanny0gg · 17/02/2024 10:27

Fairyliz · 17/02/2024 06:39

Seems like he’s changed one bossy opinionated woman who always thinks she right for another.

Oh fgs.

Women NEED to be heard and listened to. And not have their wishes and decisions trampled over.

If a woman is pregnant and doesn't want to be there is an outcry if someone suggests that the father should be part of the decision because 'her body, her choice'

Well this is 'her body, her choice'

wronginalltherightways · 17/02/2024 10:27

NoOrdinaryMorning · 16/02/2024 22:14

@Bex5490 Absolutely I would unless he was violent or abusive. It's his child! He has every right to see him/her born. As long as he's respectful of the mother and stands well back if she wishes him to.

Nope

Giving birth is a medical procedure, the mother to be is in a vulnerable position, and its often traumatic for the person going through it (again, the mother to be), and she can have/not have anyone in the room that she likes, end of.

Nanny0gg · 17/02/2024 10:23

Boomer1964 · 17/02/2024 05:58

My only comment here is MIL has given birth in the NHS. OP hasn't. Labour can be long and lonely and I was told 35 years ago to take someone with me in case staff are too busy to spend time with you or you need an advocate.

This is a very valid point.

@mariaem Will you have anyone with you? Because a midwife won't be there all the time.

Could he maybe be there in the early stages?

Has your midwife expressed any views as to you being alone?

Haretodayswantomorrow · 17/02/2024 10:22

Naunet · 17/02/2024 10:10

I like the idea that a man ‘puts a baby inside’ a woman. Rather over egging his part there…

Like a homunculus being delivered out of the end of his penis 🤣

JemimaTiggywinkles · 17/02/2024 10:22

It’s just so selfish i can’t get my head around it

You can’t get your head around it because your brain is struggling with the idea of a woman’s needs being more important than a man. It is deeply misogynistic to think that way.

It is a good thing that men are allowed in if the labouring woman would like him there. It is a good thing that women are allowed to say no to anyone seeing them naked and in distress. It is categorically not selfish to refuse to allow anyone access to your naked body.

The “she was fine with him seeing her naked to make the baby” comments, or “he’s her husband so he ought to be allowed to see her naked and in pain, even though she doesn’t want it” are absolutely sickening. They are, frankly, comments I’d expect from my gran (who thought that marriage meant you had no right to say no to sex).

No man has a right or need to watch a woman in labour. If a woman does not want him there then the discussion should end. It is simply wrong to try to bully a woman into changing her mind on this.

DevotedSisterBelovedCunt · 17/02/2024 10:19

confusedaboutclothes · 17/02/2024 09:39

Why do people always go so over the top with these threads 😂 imagine quoting the law because god forbid OP decided to let a man in her vagina and now doesn’t want him there to see what happens at the end of this pregnancy. Nobody said he’s going to be there without ‘consent’ i just think it’s absolutely and completely ridiculous. She didn’t care about him seeing her body when they made the child did she 🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️

But you are literally advocating for him to be there without her consent, and talking about it being his "right". You can't just then go "nobody's talking about doing anything without her consent".

Honestly this thread is like one long game of "misogynist or just incredibly fucking stupid"

ThePoetsWife · 17/02/2024 10:19

Are you giving birth in the UK? You will be left alone a lot of the time if so.

Also will he be nearby in case things go badly wrong?

Nanny0gg · 17/02/2024 10:19

Copperoliverbear · 17/02/2024 04:25

Also if the boot was on the other foot and men could have children and was stopping the wife from attending, there would be uproar

Utter bloody tripe

(my opinion)

Nanny0gg · 17/02/2024 10:18

Copperoliverbear · 17/02/2024 04:21

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia
And I don't agree I'm entitled to my opinion, it's not all about her, though you can tell from her post everything is always about her.
At no point has this lady mentioned that her husband doesn't want to be there, her post is all me, me, me.
If he wants to be there he should not be denied the opportunity and a chance of bonding even more as a family.
I understand not wanting anyone else there, but your husband is different, he is the baby's father.
As I said if he doesn't want to be there that's different.

Are you a MIL yet?

There are lots of very unsuitable 'fathers' out there

Should they all be at the births?

Nanny0gg · 17/02/2024 10:15

crumblingschools · 17/02/2024 01:21

I can’t understand why if you were happy to have sex with someone you wouldn’t be happy to have them with you when you give birth (if you are still in a loving relationship with them). I would have felt terrible if I hadn’t let DH be there for the moment we became parents.

I also had complications during and after the birth so he was able to advocate for me and look after DS whilst they were fixing the after birth issues.

It's not the same thing...

Swipe left for the next trending thread