Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To worry that she hasn’t got autism - but will get diagnosed

282 replies

Laughterbutchaos21 · 16/02/2024 19:37

I am fully aware that I may be jumped on and I’m willing to accept that.

I have a daughter who is in year 5, she never really shows any traits at home ( does have strong interests ) she has great conversations/ eye contact / no sensory issues to clothes. I am aware it is a spectrum.
school had some difficulties with being overly passive / struggling with certain situations so wanted her to be assessed. This was 2 years ago and I genuinely didn’t think much of it.
stop to a few weeks ago we got an appointment through for an ados assessment followed by an assessor with a community paediatrician.
we went to ados and I sat at the back of the room, but was allowed in as long as I didn’t talk to her etc
I mean the test was done with someone she has never met before I think any child would have found it strange and been anxious.
some of the toys / sections were quite young like watch her play with figures etc.
it was really interesting to see the assement.
fast forward to the community paeds consultant appointment, she asked me a bunch of questions and then told me at the end that although she can’t give me the ADOS score until the the review appointment when the SLT who did the ados will also be there but that she already has the report
and based on his report / school questionnaire and her assessment that the likelihood is that she will be diagnosed.
now I am not saying it’s a bad thing, she is still the same child I love dearly today as she was yesterday but I’m generally shocked and a little confused.
I asked if it was anything that I said that lead to this outcome and she laughed and said no you said the opposite to everyone else.
how does someone in 1 hour long ADOS assessments see more than I have in 10 years ??
can this ADOS assessments tell between it just being an anxious child at the time ?
I think I’m just concerned that she is being diagnosed with something for the rest of her life when I am unsure

OP posts:
concretevase · 16/02/2024 21:32

Hi, I do ADOS assessments for a living and I have a PhD in autism. I also think I am on the spectrum/ or have been. I believe we women are good at mimicking and passing as neurotypical - to the extent that we no longer meet the diagnostic criteria and therefore do not 'have' the autism. It's an unpopular opinion but I really do believe this and can back it up.

A few things

  • ADOS has to be done by a stranger as you have to understand the child's reactions in certain social situations.
  • You can and might want to challenge the report or ask for a second opinion. I think the professionals you talk to should know everything you have said here
  • Autism diagnostic criteria are that the symptoms are SO persistent they interfere with every day functioning. Do they?
  • If she hits the diagnostic criteria it's no biggie. Nothing changes and she's still the same person. It's all about how you and her deal with the diagnosis that matters the most.
  • The ADOS isn't the gold standard anymore. DISCO is much better.
hiredandsqueak · 16/02/2024 21:27

My son was diagnosed 26 years ago on the cusp of the increase in numbers. The year before son was diagnosed the diagnostic team saw four children a month, the year of his diagnosis they saw four children a week. School has just referred my four year old grandson to the same team (if he is I have missed it) and the wait is three and a half years. My daughter was diagnosed at 2, 19 years ago, in y5 she would have been described much like OP's daughter. Without the dx most people would have had no inkling of her difficulties.

Emeraldrings · 16/02/2024 21:24

My DD used to copy her sister and cousin so up until she was 8 I really had no idea. She suffered a year of bullying and then the signs began to appear.
She was diagnosed at age 11. It was a tough 3 years and tbh getting the diagnosis didn't make things any easier.
Like you said she is still the same person and my DD has learned ways to manage her condition and we've learned ways to support her. She is high functioning and often people don't even realise she's autistic as she still masks in public but then has a meltdown at home.
It's incredibly hard to get a diagnosis for any child. My DS has been displaying signs of autism since he was 2. He's now 3.7 and we're still no closer to getting a diagnosis or even seeing anyone apart from padeateic doctor
Your DD won't get a diagnosis unless they are sure. Honestly anyone who says they just give autism as an easy answer has never been through the process.

ImARubbishNickKnowles · 16/02/2024 21:24

After DS1's first assessment session, DH said he still didn't see why we were there.

Clinical Psychologist: most children would say/do X, he did Y
DH: that's just him though
CP: Autistic children would say/do X
DH: well he's always done X
CP: 😐
DH: I always do X
CP: 🙄

I think after multiple assessments: history, forms from school, forms from parents, ADOS - if the data is there, then yes of course.

We had another diagnosis after 15 mins in person with only an online form from us as school refused to engage. That one did feel too easy.

BigDogEnergy · 16/02/2024 21:20

Laughterbutchaos21 · 16/02/2024 21:07

See I can honestly say this was not based on what her parent said. The opposite the dr said I said the opposite to what her reports from others did or not the opposite but downplayed hugely.
I don’t think I said anything that wasn’t truthful.

@Laughterbutchaos21 if you answered the questions honestly then you've done your bit. Despite what some posters may think, an autism diagnosis isn't given out willy-nilly on the basis of one person's opinion.

My son is autistic, and quite severely impacted by it. Our home life naturally is what he needs though, so he comes across at home as having quite low needs - we've just instinctively adapted to what those quite significant needs actually are. E.g. he's an only child so he gets all our focus. The environment is always what he needs it to be - if he needs calm he does calm activities, if he needs stimulation, he does stimulating activities. There's no other children in the house to upset that balance that he needs, when he needs it. It wasn't until I had to do things like a DLA claim and his EHCP stuff that I realised just how much we adapt because of his needs - it feels very normal and very natural to us. It's half term this week and we've been to the park to poke the same stick into the same puddle for hours 4 days on the trot now 😵‍💫

Dostadning · 16/02/2024 21:18

As a physio in mental health, you'll be rehabilitating patients with comorbid mental health conditions. CAMHS in my area weren't working with patients with ASC. It would be interesting to know what you are basing your anecdotal evidence on and how many patients with autism or ADHD you've dealt with.

You'll be aware that many with ASC have a comorbidity of ADHD or anxiety or sensory processing disorder. Anxiety presents in many girls on the spectrum.
I despair when people like you are in the field in the same way I despair whenever I meet anyone in education claiming "we're all a bit quirky, aren't we?"

Providing actual data to back up your opinion would go a long way.
The OP was questioning their child's diagnosis. They could get a second opinion but the majority on here are saying it is highly unlikely that the psychologists have got it wrong/given out a diagnosis on spec. If you knew anything about the pathways, you'd know how hard it is to get even as far as an ADOS in the first place. Most schools don't push in the same way the OP's appears to have done. It costs both time and money that many SENDCOs just don't have.

Bunnyhair · 16/02/2024 21:12

You don’t need to do anything with the diagnosis beyond using it to get support in school - which it sounds like she needs. Teachers won’t take on the hassle of EHCP asnub unless they are certain the child will struggle without that support.

My DH was baffled that our DS was diagnosed autistic - because he’s just like everyone in DH’s family, and DH didn’t spend much time with other children (and thought most children were freaks anyway 😂). DH couldn’t see the extent to which DS’s ‘shyness’ and literal mindedness and pedantry was unusual and extreme, because he could relate to it: that’s how he was when he was little. In his mind you’d have to be pathologically confident (and a bit dim) to be any other way.

Meanwhile I would be approached in parks sometimes by other parents who recognised that DS was autistic - way before we had a diagnosis. It is generally pretty clear to people who have an intimate understanding of how autism presents.

Saymyname28 · 16/02/2024 21:11

My mum was adamant I wasn't autistic, I had to chase my own diagnosis as an adult and the assessor was very clear that I had very obvious autism, ADHD and bonus OCD.

I am very confident she is also autistic. Although she did the same thing when school raised concerns over my reading, again, when I chased my own diagnosis in high school I was diagnosed with dyslexia and am in the bottom 2% for reading speed.

So I csn believe that mums don't always see this stuff

Tanger1neDream · 16/02/2024 21:11

wellhello24 · 16/02/2024 21:06

The diagnostic process in adults relies heavily on subjective information and reported behaviours by the patient. Also on answers given during interview and behaviours exhibited by the person. Well documented behaviours and signs. 🤔🤔🤔

And a lengthy session with a family member able to answer questions about early childhood and an ADOS assessment.

Your point being?

SecretSquare · 16/02/2024 21:10

The diagnostic process in adults relies heavily on subjective information and reported behaviours by the patient. Also on answers given during interview and behaviours exhibited by the person. Well documented behaviours and signs. 🤔🤔🤔
*
Well yes - isn't that the point!!*

Laughterbutchaos21 · 16/02/2024 21:07

See I can honestly say this was not based on what her parent said. The opposite the dr said I said the opposite to what her reports from others did or not the opposite but downplayed hugely.
I don’t think I said anything that wasn’t truthful.

OP posts:
wellhello24 · 16/02/2024 21:06

Tanger1neDream · 16/02/2024 21:03

So literally zero expertise in autism or ADHD then.

The diagnostic process in adults relies heavily on subjective information and reported behaviours by the patient. Also on answers given during interview and behaviours exhibited by the person. Well documented behaviours and signs. 🤔🤔🤔

TheSnowyOwl · 16/02/2024 21:05

And @wellhello24 how many of these epic numbers have you then assessed (with your equally relevant and experienced expertise) to confirm that the numbers are wrong and which medical journal can we read up on your (peer reviewed) findings?

BigDogEnergy · 16/02/2024 21:05

wellhello24 · 16/02/2024 21:00

Physiotherapist in mental health for the past 20 years.

I've worked in mental health for 10 years, I'm not remotely medically qualified though. If you are in a patient facing role then I feel very sorry for any neurodivergent patients that you may come into contact with given the opinions you've shared here

TheSnowyOwl · 16/02/2024 21:04

wellhello24 · 16/02/2024 20:26

I’m not disputing that. What I’m saying is autism and ADHD are real disorders and are very problematic but the hoards of people being diagnosed with it the past few years because they have “quirks” or differences or traits that can be explained fully by anxiety depression or social anxiety is on an epic scale.

So you are saying the multiple qualified and experienced medical professions who work together for a diagnosis to be reached are all systematically and epically failing at their job and misdiagnosing?

Tanger1neDream · 16/02/2024 21:03

wellhello24 · 16/02/2024 21:00

Physiotherapist in mental health for the past 20 years.

So literally zero expertise in autism or ADHD then.

Spendonsend · 16/02/2024 21:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What's the relevance of your view on self diagnosis of adhd on quirks got to do with a thread about a child going through the medical diagnosis who has a question mark over whether she will manage mainstream though

wellhello24 · 16/02/2024 21:00

BigDogEnergy · 16/02/2024 20:59

"Working in the medical profession" presumably not a role with a recognised qualification then? Otherwise you'd say doctor/psychologist/nurse/occupational therapist

My money is on GP receptionist

Physiotherapist in mental health for the past 20 years.

BigDogEnergy · 16/02/2024 20:59

"Working in the medical profession" presumably not a role with a recognised qualification then? Otherwise you'd say doctor/psychologist/nurse/occupational therapist

My money is on GP receptionist

SecretSquare · 16/02/2024 20:59

And in terms of interchangeable/common traits...yes, absolutely. Which the robust, multifaceted assessment process is there to work out.

You're coming across as more of a twit each time you post.

SecretSquare · 16/02/2024 20:57

@wellhello24

As a medical professional (dubious), you surely know the difference between self diagnosis/labelling/loose terminology versus "diagnoses being handed out like sweets"...

Dostadning · 16/02/2024 20:56

What job in medicine/health do you do?

wellhello24 · 16/02/2024 20:55

Dostadning · 16/02/2024 20:50

Hoards of people? Epic scale? Source?
There's been a backlog of referrals to wade through because of Covid.
To the extent that some authorities have deliberately changed assessment criteria to bring down the waiting lists, which are years long.
The amount of hoops to jump through is onerous and overwhelming.
If you have actual figures of new diagnoses given out/confirmations of autism in young people, in the last two years then please share them.
Whilst I can find governmental reports on waiting times, and newspaper reports that referrals have increased, a referral does not equate to a diagnosis.
119,821 pupils in England had ASD in a 2017 census, 0.19% more than suggested previously. 700 000 adults and children according to the government - 1% of the population.
Where, as a medical person, is your source that actual diagnoses have increased on an epic scale? I don't mean referrals, I mean actual diagnoses.

Perhaps that’s what I’m noticing then- a boom in people self diagnosing without an official diagnosis. A lot of people saying they have adhd where they actually haven’t yet been diagnosed but they are recognising a couple of the traits that can be very interchangeable with general
or social anxiety disorders.

Dostadning · 16/02/2024 20:50

Hoards of people? Epic scale? Source?
There's been a backlog of referrals to wade through because of Covid.
To the extent that some authorities have deliberately changed assessment criteria to bring down the waiting lists, which are years long.
The amount of hoops to jump through is onerous and overwhelming.
If you have actual figures of new diagnoses given out/confirmations of autism in young people, in the last two years then please share them.
Whilst I can find governmental reports on waiting times, and newspaper reports that referrals have increased, a referral does not equate to a diagnosis.
119,821 pupils in England had ASD in a 2017 census, 0.19% more than suggested previously. 700 000 adults and children according to the government - 1% of the population.
Where, as a medical person, is your source that actual diagnoses have increased on an epic scale? I don't mean referrals, I mean actual diagnoses.

wellhello24 · 16/02/2024 20:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.