Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To worry that she hasn’t got autism - but will get diagnosed

282 replies

Laughterbutchaos21 · 16/02/2024 19:37

I am fully aware that I may be jumped on and I’m willing to accept that.

I have a daughter who is in year 5, she never really shows any traits at home ( does have strong interests ) she has great conversations/ eye contact / no sensory issues to clothes. I am aware it is a spectrum.
school had some difficulties with being overly passive / struggling with certain situations so wanted her to be assessed. This was 2 years ago and I genuinely didn’t think much of it.
stop to a few weeks ago we got an appointment through for an ados assessment followed by an assessor with a community paediatrician.
we went to ados and I sat at the back of the room, but was allowed in as long as I didn’t talk to her etc
I mean the test was done with someone she has never met before I think any child would have found it strange and been anxious.
some of the toys / sections were quite young like watch her play with figures etc.
it was really interesting to see the assement.
fast forward to the community paeds consultant appointment, she asked me a bunch of questions and then told me at the end that although she can’t give me the ADOS score until the the review appointment when the SLT who did the ados will also be there but that she already has the report
and based on his report / school questionnaire and her assessment that the likelihood is that she will be diagnosed.
now I am not saying it’s a bad thing, she is still the same child I love dearly today as she was yesterday but I’m generally shocked and a little confused.
I asked if it was anything that I said that lead to this outcome and she laughed and said no you said the opposite to everyone else.
how does someone in 1 hour long ADOS assessments see more than I have in 10 years ??
can this ADOS assessments tell between it just being an anxious child at the time ?
I think I’m just concerned that she is being diagnosed with something for the rest of her life when I am unsure

OP posts:
Hughs · 17/02/2024 09:42

She was giving an opinion which differed to other posters and then was grilled on what she did as a profession. She wasn’t claiming that it had anything to do with her opinions

When asked if she actually knew anything about autism she said:

I’m in the medical profession. I know enough to form an opinion.

So yes, she was claiming that her medical expertise had something to do with her opinions. People were quite naturally suspicious of "in the medical profession" compared to other professionals saying they were psychologists / completed assessments all the time. So they asked what she did. And it turns out she's a bloody physio, exactly the same as a doctor's receptionist in terms of experience with and expertise of autism, ie none.

There may be people reading who think, oh a medical professional says people are reading up on autistic behaviours and then feigning autism to get a diagnosis, it must be true. This kind of shit absolutely must be called out and I can't imagine why anyone is defending it, or indeed defending a poster who has had so many posts deleted.

greyflannel · 17/02/2024 09:35

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 09:31

That’s not what happened though is it. She was giving an opinion which differed to other posters and then was grilled on what she did as a profession. People were saying “I bet you’re a GP receptionist “ etc so she gave her profession. She wasn’t claiming that it had anything to do with her opinions, she was being jumped on about it. Again there was nothing ableist in her posts she was making observations about current trends which she is perfectly entitled to do-but because people were triggered there was a pile on, which is why MNHQ stepped in.

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia had it right:

Calling a historically underdiagnosed disabling condition a "bandwagon" is light years beyond offensive.

Disseminating abelist views, just like racist, sexist, homophoic views etc is offensive and needs calling out. Invoking medical expertise as basis for said views takes it to a whole other level.

Tanger1neDream · 17/02/2024 09:32

No she said as a medical professional inferring she had some insider knowledge which she clearly didn’t.

She then continued to goad.

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 09:31

greyflannel · 17/02/2024 08:39

I think you should be concerned that a poster is trying to leverage their role 'in the medical profession' to give out misleading and abelist information about neurodisabilities. Generally I think MN should be giving our warnings where people are invoking medical expertise that bona fides have not been established.

That’s not what happened though is it. She was giving an opinion which differed to other posters and then was grilled on what she did as a profession. People were saying “I bet you’re a GP receptionist “ etc so she gave her profession. She wasn’t claiming that it had anything to do with her opinions, she was being jumped on about it. Again there was nothing ableist in her posts she was making observations about current trends which she is perfectly entitled to do-but because people were triggered there was a pile on, which is why MNHQ stepped in.

Tanger1neDream · 17/02/2024 09:28

And you can’t get a “mild ” diagnosis, you either have it or you don’t with traits needing to impair and restrict life.

Tanger1neDream · 17/02/2024 09:27

Diagnostics have got far far better with women and girls now coming forward. I think it was only 2011 that ADHD traits in women were recognised. Women form 50% of the population. Posters have explained this over and again. You’re choosing to ignore it.

Tanger1neDream · 17/02/2024 09:24

It’s way more than not fitting into societal norms.

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 09:23

mitogoshi · 17/02/2024 09:12

@TheSnowyOwl

Unfortunately the trend now for diagnosis based on mild traits is devaluing and belittling to a certain extent those with profound difficulties as result of their autism. My DD's autism is moderate I suppose, she struggles to work, forming friendships is more challenging, she certainly can't read the room at all, can be a grown up stroppy toddler basically - she has made progress in many ways but when she is rejected for support because "she can work" benefits don't recognise her difficulties now whereas even 5 years ago it wasn't a problem. I state her issues and she is told "others work" they haven't seen her problems (50 years ago she would have been institutionalised I suspect) so yes these "mild" cases annoy me

This. So many ‘mild’ cases in recent years. Definitely a recent trend but a lot of posters on here seem to be denying this observation and the fact it does undermine genuine profound difficulties.

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 09:17

greyflannel · 17/02/2024 08:50

This is insensitive to the profound challenges faced by autistic people living in a world organised around the needs and preferences of NT people and the exclusion it perpetuates. Only 10% of autistic adults of working age are working full time and only 30% are working at all. Have a think about those life chances and reflect on whether all differences are equal?

Firstly my post is speculative- I’v put question marks as I’m just speculating. It might seem
insensitive to you but I’m just putting a perspective out there for consideration and discussion.
Secondly- you are making pretty much the same point im making! You are saying that the world is organised around the needs of what is considered socially “normal “ behaviours and thinking patterns. That’s what I’m saying! There are social norms like society is trying to fit people into a box regarding what is considered “normal” behaviour and anyone who deviates from this is considered different and atypical will inevitably struggle and find fitting in with these norms challenging. Yet this is unfair. My point is why should not fitting in with societal “norms” be considered a condition and given a label, why can’t society just be more set up for and excepting/inclusive of peoples differences instead of having very narrow rules about what is “normal.”

mitogoshi · 17/02/2024 09:12

@TheSnowyOwl

Unfortunately the trend now for diagnosis based on mild traits is devaluing and belittling to a certain extent those with profound difficulties as result of their autism. My DD's autism is moderate I suppose, she struggles to work, forming friendships is more challenging, she certainly can't read the room at all, can be a grown up stroppy toddler basically - she has made progress in many ways but when she is rejected for support because "she can work" benefits don't recognise her difficulties now whereas even 5 years ago it wasn't a problem. I state her issues and she is told "others work" they haven't seen her problems (50 years ago she would have been institutionalised I suspect) so yes these "mild" cases annoy me

SENDhelp2023 · 17/02/2024 09:07

its very hard sometimes to see things in your own child because you accept them for the amazing, unique being they are.

greengreengrass25 · 17/02/2024 09:05

TwoWithCurls · 16/02/2024 20:35

@wellhello24 I agree, it seems a lot more common now... my own two children have turned out to have ASD. No one else in my family had it, and we don't think my husband's family either. I personally think there's something going on that's causing this. Perhaps the fact that it's more common in children of older parents and many of us are that these days?

Possibly, DN is autistic and db was over 40 when he was born, and IVF

Is there any links with IVF as well

mitogoshi · 17/02/2024 09:03

My dd was diagnosed young but had to be re diagnosed age 11 because the nhs don't accept USA medical reports Confused anyway there was multiple parts to the diagnosis, a school report, an assessment which a psychiatrist and they interviewed me too because that formed part of the judgement - they had to show the behaviour in 2 settings (so school and home) to meet the criteria.

More recently my dsd had an adult adhd assessment and again her parents needed to submit written reports on her childhood, they don't accept just what a person presents like in a slightly unnerving appointment!

Watercolourpapier · 17/02/2024 09:00

ImaniMumsnet · 16/02/2024 22:07

Hi everyone, please can we avoid focusing posts on one poster. if any posts are concerning, please report them to us.

I thought Mumsnet always told us to educate and respond to people because you won't ban for being persistently disablist.

Lougle · 17/02/2024 08:53

Oblomov24 · 17/02/2024 08:02

Have you actually seen the report.

Have you also read the background on what they test and why? Because you sound like you don't know.

No you don't need to fulfill all parts, you can have a very spiky profile, ie massive in some parts, nothing in others.

Years ago They tested theory of mind, using the Sally-Anne-test. They also tested if the child has the ability to role play and make believe, can you make up a story, pretend you are someone else, a waitress or an astronaut.

The Sally-Ann test isn't always reliable though. DD2 'passed' the SA test because she said Sally would look in her bag. But she had missed the entire story and had just used logic that if Sally was looking for something of hers, she would look in her bag. She had dismissed the point that the naughty bird had flown off with the watch as irrelevant detail.

Watercolourpapier · 17/02/2024 08:53

wellhello24 · 16/02/2024 20:01

There’s been an absolute explosion of people diagnosed with this in the past couple of years- you can’t deny that just a couple of years ago the diagnosis was quite rare to now it being absolutely everywhere. Unless youve been hiding under a rock. A lot of people “self-diagnosing” too which is not ok. And anytime anyone mentions they have a certain trait for example on here if they say they feels disorganised..it’s “ooh you must be ND!!”

You realise this is because until very recently, all diagnostic criteria for ADHD/ASD was based on how these conditions present in boys?

When people bothered to study girls and women they realised that ND females present very differently to male, and there are thousands and thousands of undiagnosed women and girls struggling through life.

But sure, people are just making it up.

I'm one of the ones who will suggest ADHD or ASD as a possible reason why someone is struggling with for example, forgetfulness (along with other symptoms) because my diagnosis has transformed my life. My diagnosis came about because someone talked to me about ADHD and it suddenly made sense. Before that, i thought it was something that only affected little boys and that because I'm not physically hyperactive i couldn't possibly be.

If someone goes away and reads about it and thinks "no, that doesn't fit" then no harm has been done. But a little bit more awareness of what neurodivergency is has been spread by me posting it. If that person reads up, or someone else who reads my suggestion reads up and thinks they might be ND, and they are then able to implement some coping mechanisms to help them, what bloody difference does it make to you? Why would you care? Do you get upset if more people talk about and get diagnosed with cancer or arthritis? Or is it just neurodivergency you object to?

It's not like anyone's handing out free goody bags for being ND! people getting diagnosed or self diagnosing (which they have to because the waiting lists are years and years long!) makes no difference to you at all, but might make a world of difference to them.

greyflannel · 17/02/2024 08:50

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 07:49

That’s what it seems like. That old saying springs to mind “what is normal anyway?” Are we not all just a little different yet society has forced us into a box of what “normal” social behaviour should look like where some of us are better at conforming to this than others? Are people being diagnosed as ND because they don’t meet social norms of behaviour?

This is insensitive to the profound challenges faced by autistic people living in a world organised around the needs and preferences of NT people and the exclusion it perpetuates. Only 10% of autistic adults of working age are working full time and only 30% are working at all. Have a think about those life chances and reflect on whether all differences are equal?

greyflannel · 17/02/2024 08:43

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 17/02/2024 02:52

You know I said "bullshit"?

it seems a lot of people are jumping on the bandwagon it is fairly easy to do so because the diagnostic criteria is subjective

A 2.5y waiting list is not "fairly easy".

Calling a historically underdiagnosed disabling condition a "bandwagon" is light years beyond offensive.

^this

greyflannel · 17/02/2024 08:39

ImaniMumsnet · 16/02/2024 22:07

Hi everyone, please can we avoid focusing posts on one poster. if any posts are concerning, please report them to us.

I think you should be concerned that a poster is trying to leverage their role 'in the medical profession' to give out misleading and abelist information about neurodisabilities. Generally I think MN should be giving our warnings where people are invoking medical expertise that bona fides have not been established.

Hughs · 17/02/2024 08:39

This thread is so depressing. People despising labels and it's just a few quirks and it's so easy to get a diagnosis and suggesting that adults are reading up on the typical behaviours and then feigning autism to get one. And yet it's allowed to continue, with MNHQ popping up briefly to tell off ND posters when they challenge someone making ableist and offensive remarks. I didn't realise MN was such an unfriendly forum for the neurodivergent.

OP, when you read the report, you may well have a eureka moment and learn a lot about your DC's autism. Or you may think the professionals have got it all wrong, in which case you should challenge it.

The reality is that DC are often less obviously autistic at home with their family, who are used to their behaviour, or who make adjustments without realising so that the DC is comfortable, or who may be ND themselves. Her diagnosis may not make much difference to her now but could be invaluable in future if/when she starts to struggle. So keep it up your sleeve is my advice.

greyflannel · 17/02/2024 08:33

TwoWithCurls · 16/02/2024 20:35

@wellhello24 I agree, it seems a lot more common now... my own two children have turned out to have ASD. No one else in my family had it, and we don't think my husband's family either. I personally think there's something going on that's causing this. Perhaps the fact that it's more common in children of older parents and many of us are that these days?

Think though we now know that causality runs the opposite way, and autistic adults on average become parents at a later age, rather than becoming a parent at a later age being implicated in 'causing' autism in offspring?

Tanger1neDream · 17/02/2024 08:12

Role play and make believe doesn’t mean a lot within a whole diagnosis. I lived in a make believe world, my daughter in a role play world and my son has never played with any toys and just couldn’t understand role play never taking part in it ever. We all have an autism diagnosis.

Oblomov24 · 17/02/2024 08:02

Have you actually seen the report.

Have you also read the background on what they test and why? Because you sound like you don't know.

No you don't need to fulfill all parts, you can have a very spiky profile, ie massive in some parts, nothing in others.

Years ago They tested theory of mind, using the Sally-Anne-test. They also tested if the child has the ability to role play and make believe, can you make up a story, pretend you are someone else, a waitress or an astronaut.

Lougle · 17/02/2024 08:02

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 07:49

That’s what it seems like. That old saying springs to mind “what is normal anyway?” Are we not all just a little different yet society has forced us into a box of what “normal” social behaviour should look like where some of us are better at conforming to this than others? Are people being diagnosed as ND because they don’t meet social norms of behaviour?

"Are people being diagnosed as ND because they don’t meet social norms of behaviour?"

They are being diagnosed because they display the diagnostic criteria for a diagnosis. That means that they have "persistent difficulties with social communication and social interaction” and “restricted and repetitive patterns of behaviours, activities or interests” (this includes sensory behaviour), present since early childhood, to the extent that these “limit and impair everyday functioning”.

The ADOS is designed to pick up those features.

ConfusedSheila · 17/02/2024 08:01

how does someone in 1 hour long ADOS assessments see more than I have in 10 years ??
@Laughterbutchaos21 Well, one explanation could be that her autistic traits that are obvious to other people seem normal to you because maybe you/close family members are the same?