Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To worry that she hasn’t got autism - but will get diagnosed

282 replies

Laughterbutchaos21 · 16/02/2024 19:37

I am fully aware that I may be jumped on and I’m willing to accept that.

I have a daughter who is in year 5, she never really shows any traits at home ( does have strong interests ) she has great conversations/ eye contact / no sensory issues to clothes. I am aware it is a spectrum.
school had some difficulties with being overly passive / struggling with certain situations so wanted her to be assessed. This was 2 years ago and I genuinely didn’t think much of it.
stop to a few weeks ago we got an appointment through for an ados assessment followed by an assessor with a community paediatrician.
we went to ados and I sat at the back of the room, but was allowed in as long as I didn’t talk to her etc
I mean the test was done with someone she has never met before I think any child would have found it strange and been anxious.
some of the toys / sections were quite young like watch her play with figures etc.
it was really interesting to see the assement.
fast forward to the community paeds consultant appointment, she asked me a bunch of questions and then told me at the end that although she can’t give me the ADOS score until the the review appointment when the SLT who did the ados will also be there but that she already has the report
and based on his report / school questionnaire and her assessment that the likelihood is that she will be diagnosed.
now I am not saying it’s a bad thing, she is still the same child I love dearly today as she was yesterday but I’m generally shocked and a little confused.
I asked if it was anything that I said that lead to this outcome and she laughed and said no you said the opposite to everyone else.
how does someone in 1 hour long ADOS assessments see more than I have in 10 years ??
can this ADOS assessments tell between it just being an anxious child at the time ?
I think I’m just concerned that she is being diagnosed with something for the rest of her life when I am unsure

OP posts:
Laughterbutchaos21 · 17/02/2024 11:01

@MolkosTeenageAngst school say
that she likes having friends but struggles to set up communication
she will play with 1 or 2 children at playtime if it is set up by her 1-1.
she does not start conversations, she also doesn’t speak when there is a convo about something she is not interested in. ( I am aware this is an issue ) she is very interested in a specific country and everything to do with it which does take over around 90 percent of our life.
she is very well behaved, she hates getting in to trouble so in class she is not causing disruption but often looks unengaged / not interested and loses focus.
she is distracted by noise and movement, and gets stressed out if the class is overly noisy.
she can’t do assembly because the noise so has never managed to attend.
she does show empathy and knows when someone is crying that she is upset like she would give me a cuddle if I was crying. Someone would physically need to be crying though for her to know they are upset.
if her school friends Were crying she may comfort them or she may not depending if she thinks it’s appropriate for them to be crying
Example friend got hit by a ball and cried, she didn’t comfort her because she said the ball only hit her in the leg.
erm not sure what the ados picked up

OP posts:
Laughterbutchaos21 · 17/02/2024 10:53

regards to “ mild “ they didn’t mention this as she couldn’t give me a break down of feedback without the SLT present who did the ADOS.
all I know is that less than 1/4 of the way through our appointment she said “ I don’t think you could really leave here without a diagnosis “
she then ar the end obviously said she has the ados result but wouldn’t disclose it and when I asked if it was anything I said that made her come to that decision she said no I think you have said the opposite to a lot of the people and they you have significantly underplayed how much this would be effecting her.
she did say though that she was intelligent and in terms of progress she will have every ability if it is something she is interested in to succeed. She also said with support that she could attend mainstream with correct support

OP posts:
Tanger1neDream · 17/02/2024 10:52

High functioning/ low functioning is offensive too and not something our NHS provider used. You can’t be high functioning to get a diagnosis. If you’re high functioning your daily life isn’t going to be impaired or restricted.

Watercolourpapier · 17/02/2024 10:51

Tanger1neDream · 17/02/2024 09:55

“a lot of “mild” cases being diagnosed and people being told they still have to work etc which undermines the difficulties experienced by those with profound autism or adhd who simply cannot go to work.”

As you’re choosing to ignore this is highly offensive and inaccurate. Nobody gets a “mild” diagnosis.

In addition to this, since when is it ok to judge disabled people on whether they're able to work or not? Me having adhd/asd and holding down a job does NOT undermine disabled people who can't work. We are different people with different needs.

Any way, is that the only measure of success or ability in this world?

Can work: not disabled
Can't work: disabled

That is not how it should work.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 17/02/2024 10:50

Eye contact is just a tiny tiny part of an autism diagnosis and not every autistic person finds it difficult. It’s also right that it’s about how eye contact is made and not whether it is made at all, sometimes the issue can be that eye contact is too intense/ frequent etc rather than it not being present at all. Also bear in mind your DD may find some things easier to do with her mother than she does in other settings.

Broadly speaking autism is characterised by difficulties in social communication and interaction, eye contact is just one small aspect of social communication/ interaction, difficulties in maintaining eye contact can be a sign of autism but it could also be due to something else and equally some autistic people can make eye contact. I have autism and have never had anybody tell me I don’t make eye contact or that I present any differently to someone neurotypical in this regard.

Aside from eye contact what other points raised by the school and other professionals do you disagree with?

Watercolourpapier · 17/02/2024 10:46

Just because someone else's autism or adhd may affect them more severely than mine does me, it doesn't invalidate my diagnosis. I struggle more than than some other people with the same diagnosis. It doesn't mean they don't have it, or that they're not deserving of accommodation and understanding. I have no right to feel aggrieved because some people say they have adhd but they cope with it better, or are less affected by it than me. Stop trying to make disabled people feel like they don't deserve help.

Emeraldrings · 17/02/2024 10:45

You can't be mildly autistic and you can't be just a little bit autistic. People who use those phrases really piss me off.
The correct wording is high functioning or low functioning. Yes it's a massive spectrum but the word mild doesn't belong when you're talking about autism. I have two autistic children, one who is high functioning and one who is low functioning. My DD doesn't have a mild case of autism and its actually incredibly insulting to suggest she does.

FloorWipes · 17/02/2024 10:36

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 10:03

I used “mild” because another poster said that they experienced being told they could work ‘like other people diagnosed’ where this was not possible for them, their condition is very profound. She was saying there are more milder cases being diagnosed where people are able to work. That’s where the word mild came from- meaning less severe. It’s not “highly offensive “ at all it’s descriptive. Have considered counselling to look into why you are so easily offended and triggered?

It's not straightforward to compare severity. One person might be able to work yet their internalised presentation puts them at risk for severe mental health issues and even suicide. The impact is still severe, but possibly less observable to others. That's just one example. Things also fluctuate a lot depending on people's life situations - one minute you are functioning, the next you are not.

I'm not triggered by anyone but it's just a bit tedious with folk who seem not being be very informed about autism which is fine but also aren't interested in learning and want to espouse views without referring to any kind of basic evidence.

greyflannel · 17/02/2024 10:33

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 09:59

You are calling someone discriminatory where it is totally unfounded and unreasonable. That also needs challenging. You are trying your best to take the moral high ground when you don’t have one because there is nothing ableist in what the poster said. They were giving their observation and opinion from their experience. They were speculating, there was no discrimination. The only one whinging is you, because there are people on here that don’t agree with you.

Calling a historically underdiagnosed disabling condition a "bandwagon" is light years beyond offensive.

Abelism is real, and it blights and constrains lives, just like racism and sexism.

Willyoujustbequiet · 17/02/2024 10:28

Tanger1neDream · 17/02/2024 05:09

But it’s not just 1 hour ADOS.

In my case it was an initial referral form which was long
3 hour session with family member looking at developmental history
developmentsl history form( v long)
2x 3 hour sessions
ADOS which was a lot longer than an hour

children would have input from school too

I'm aware.

But even after all that with us they still got it wrong. Mistakes happen.

Tanger1neDream · 17/02/2024 10:13

Dismissing any disability which limits and impairs everyday functioning as “mild”
is hugely offensive and incorrect.

Your reference to counselling is just patronising, nasty and goady.

zingally · 17/02/2024 10:12

If she gets a diagnosis, so what?

You're under no obligation to acknowledge it, and nor is she under any obligation to disclose it in the future.

Hughs · 17/02/2024 10:09

And looking back on many posters- the list of professionals involved repeatedly mentioned: SLT, psychologists, occupational therapists and PHYSIO. Funny that you’ve missed that one. Oh but you know best don’t you, since you think a physio in mental health is as qualified and experienced as a GP receptionist. I’d say that poster has way more clout than you and your personal opinions.

Are you the same poster?
Physios are not involved in the diagnosis of autism, it's quite mind blowing that you think they are. In terms of autism diagnosis, yes they are as qualified and experienced as a GP receptionist, or a heart surgeon, or a paramedic.

Here's a useful link which explains which health professionals are involved:

www.autism.org.uk/advice-and-guidance/topics/diagnosis/professionals-involved/non-clinical-professionals

greyflannel · 17/02/2024 10:07

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 10:03

I used “mild” because another poster said that they experienced being told they could work ‘like other people diagnosed’ where this was not possible for them, their condition is very profound. She was saying there are more milder cases being diagnosed where people are able to work. That’s where the word mild came from- meaning less severe. It’s not “highly offensive “ at all it’s descriptive. Have considered counselling to look into why you are so easily offended and triggered?

Calling a historically underdiagnosed disabling condition a "bandwagon" is light years beyond offensive.

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 10:03

Tanger1neDream · 17/02/2024 09:55

“a lot of “mild” cases being diagnosed and people being told they still have to work etc which undermines the difficulties experienced by those with profound autism or adhd who simply cannot go to work.”

As you’re choosing to ignore this is highly offensive and inaccurate. Nobody gets a “mild” diagnosis.

I used “mild” because another poster said that they experienced being told they could work ‘like other people diagnosed’ where this was not possible for them, their condition is very profound. She was saying there are more milder cases being diagnosed where people are able to work. That’s where the word mild came from- meaning less severe. It’s not “highly offensive “ at all it’s descriptive. Have considered counselling to look into why you are so easily offended and triggered?

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 09:59

greyflannel · 17/02/2024 09:53

How dare you whinge on behalf of people who hold discrimatory attitudes. They need challenging.

You are calling someone discriminatory where it is totally unfounded and unreasonable. That also needs challenging. You are trying your best to take the moral high ground when you don’t have one because there is nothing ableist in what the poster said. They were giving their observation and opinion from their experience. They were speculating, there was no discrimination. The only one whinging is you, because there are people on here that don’t agree with you.

Tanger1neDream · 17/02/2024 09:55

“a lot of “mild” cases being diagnosed and people being told they still have to work etc which undermines the difficulties experienced by those with profound autism or adhd who simply cannot go to work.”

As you’re choosing to ignore this is highly offensive and inaccurate. Nobody gets a “mild” diagnosis.

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 09:53

Hughs · 17/02/2024 09:42

She was giving an opinion which differed to other posters and then was grilled on what she did as a profession. She wasn’t claiming that it had anything to do with her opinions

When asked if she actually knew anything about autism she said:

I’m in the medical profession. I know enough to form an opinion.

So yes, she was claiming that her medical expertise had something to do with her opinions. People were quite naturally suspicious of "in the medical profession" compared to other professionals saying they were psychologists / completed assessments all the time. So they asked what she did. And it turns out she's a bloody physio, exactly the same as a doctor's receptionist in terms of experience with and expertise of autism, ie none.

There may be people reading who think, oh a medical professional says people are reading up on autistic behaviours and then feigning autism to get a diagnosis, it must be true. This kind of shit absolutely must be called out and I can't imagine why anyone is defending it, or indeed defending a poster who has had so many posts deleted.

“so they asked what she did. And it turns out she's a bloody physio, exactly the same as a doctor's receptionist in terms of experience with and expertise of autism, ie none.”

Actually I think if she’s got 20 years working in mental health as a health care professional- she has got experience more than a receptions. Educate yourself.

And looking back on many posters- the list of professionals involved repeatedly mentioned: SLT, psychologists, occupational therapists and PHYSIO. Funny that you’ve missed that one. Oh but you know best don’t you, since you think a physio in mental health is as qualified and experienced as a GP receptionist. I’d say that poster has way more clout than you and your personal opinions.

greyflannel · 17/02/2024 09:53

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 09:47

Talk about living in a make believe world. The poster was not ableist at all. There was zero discrimination in those post so how dare you compare it to racism or sexism. She was saying that in her experience- she notices a lot of people SELF DIAGNOSING adhd and a massive increase in recent referrals. A current obvious trend. Also speculation that the assessments are not always hard evidence as they are subjective without any specific objective results and there have been, as pps say, many cases of misdiagnosis and some assessments being fairly quick. As another poster said, a lot of “mild” cases being diagnosed and people being told they still have to work etc which undermines the difficulties experienced by those with profound autism or adhd who simply cannot go to work.
Reslise that there is a thing called free speech and you can’t just censor someone for airing their views and speculating on current trends if they are not hateful or discriminatory, like the pps. Just because you are overly offended doesn’t mean you are right and they are wrong and you can brand it “ableist” when it is clearly not.

How dare you whinge on behalf of people who hold discrimatory attitudes. They need challenging.

Watercolourpapier · 17/02/2024 09:52

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 09:47

Talk about living in a make believe world. The poster was not ableist at all. There was zero discrimination in those post so how dare you compare it to racism or sexism. She was saying that in her experience- she notices a lot of people SELF DIAGNOSING adhd and a massive increase in recent referrals. A current obvious trend. Also speculation that the assessments are not always hard evidence as they are subjective without any specific objective results and there have been, as pps say, many cases of misdiagnosis and some assessments being fairly quick. As another poster said, a lot of “mild” cases being diagnosed and people being told they still have to work etc which undermines the difficulties experienced by those with profound autism or adhd who simply cannot go to work.
Reslise that there is a thing called free speech and you can’t just censor someone for airing their views and speculating on current trends if they are not hateful or discriminatory, like the pps. Just because you are overly offended doesn’t mean you are right and they are wrong and you can brand it “ableist” when it is clearly not.

Why has that poster had so many posts deleted on this thread if they weren't disablist?

The posts you can see now might not be outwardly disablist. But without doubt, that poster has been disablist and offensive.

FloorWipes · 17/02/2024 09:52

My point is why should not fitting in with societal “norms” be considered a condition

Autism is so so much more that not fitting in with societal norms!

I personally found this lecture really illuminating to understand more about what autism actually is and I sometimes refer back to it It does address questions like "aren't we all a bit autistic" just after the hour mark. Well worth a listen. I'm sure some of it is by now out of date but I still think it's a really helpful lecture to orient yourself in the science and the general theories of autism which put you in a more informed place to debate things like diagnosis thresholds.

Francesca Happe, Ph.D.: Why study the mind if genes cause autism? (2018)

Francesca Happe, Ph.D., from King's College London asks the question Why study the mind if genes cause autism?Part of the 2017-2018 Distinguished Lecturer Se...

https://youtu.be/R0im3TaTGgc?si=DDZ-FIgNSt9-zmTQ

Howbizarre22 · 17/02/2024 09:47

greyflannel · 17/02/2024 09:35

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia had it right:

Calling a historically underdiagnosed disabling condition a "bandwagon" is light years beyond offensive.

Disseminating abelist views, just like racist, sexist, homophoic views etc is offensive and needs calling out. Invoking medical expertise as basis for said views takes it to a whole other level.

Talk about living in a make believe world. The poster was not ableist at all. There was zero discrimination in those post so how dare you compare it to racism or sexism. She was saying that in her experience- she notices a lot of people SELF DIAGNOSING adhd and a massive increase in recent referrals. A current obvious trend. Also speculation that the assessments are not always hard evidence as they are subjective without any specific objective results and there have been, as pps say, many cases of misdiagnosis and some assessments being fairly quick. As another poster said, a lot of “mild” cases being diagnosed and people being told they still have to work etc which undermines the difficulties experienced by those with profound autism or adhd who simply cannot go to work.
Reslise that there is a thing called free speech and you can’t just censor someone for airing their views and speculating on current trends if they are not hateful or discriminatory, like the pps. Just because you are overly offended doesn’t mean you are right and they are wrong and you can brand it “ableist” when it is clearly not.

SecretSquare · 17/02/2024 09:46

mitogoshi · 17/02/2024 09:12

@TheSnowyOwl

Unfortunately the trend now for diagnosis based on mild traits is devaluing and belittling to a certain extent those with profound difficulties as result of their autism. My DD's autism is moderate I suppose, she struggles to work, forming friendships is more challenging, she certainly can't read the room at all, can be a grown up stroppy toddler basically - she has made progress in many ways but when she is rejected for support because "she can work" benefits don't recognise her difficulties now whereas even 5 years ago it wasn't a problem. I state her issues and she is told "others work" they haven't seen her problems (50 years ago she would have been institutionalised I suspect) so yes these "mild" cases annoy me

Though the severity of symptoms will of course vary across a spectrum, autism is binary.

You're either autistic or you're not. Like being pregnant or not. You're not a little bit autistic. You just have traits that are more subtle, or more internalized.

FFS as a parent of a ND individual you really should know this.

olderthanyouthink · 17/02/2024 09:45

"1 hour long ADOS assessments see more than I have in 10 years ??"

Ask all the adults getting diagnosed 😅20-50 years of their parents knowing them didn't pick it up but an assessment with a stranger did.

Also having looked at DD hard and read around the topic a lot DP and I are pretty sure we are autistic too so what's normal for us isn't what's NT.

DD makes fairly normal looking eye contact with us and other people when she's comfortable and otherwise she looks shy or disrespectful 🙈

SecretSquare · 17/02/2024 09:43

Tanger1neDream · 17/02/2024 09:28

And you can’t get a “mild ” diagnosis, you either have it or you don’t with traits needing to impair and restrict life.

Exactly. Autistic people have common traits but at different levels (3 officially). Girls especially often have an 'internalised' presentation which may appear very very subtle indeed to others especially if they don't know them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread