Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so upset at SIL saying I was strict with my children and she finds it ‘scary’

112 replies

MakeEconomyScream · 16/02/2024 17:22

Am away on holiday with DB, SIL and their children. I am here without DP but with my DC. I have always had a lovely relationship with SIL…until today! We were talking on a walk when she started saying her dad was very relaxed and so was she but my DB was a bit stricter with the DC. She said my parents were strict with me and my DB/DS. I agreed and then she said (TWICE - so obviously really wanted to say it): ‘you’re strict with your children and I find it a bit scary’. OUCH. I wanted to cry. I may be strict - maybe even too strict (who knows?) - I’m muddling my way through a full time job, two young children (one of whom doesn’t sleep, the other of whom is pretty challenging at times) and away for a week without my DP. If she really thought this couldn’t she just slag me off to my DB rather than hit me in the gut with her words? I feel really uncomfortable being around her now and am questioning my parenting and myself. Is this what she wanted? (For context, she has said similar to me about my DSis and her partner before, but to my knowledge has never said it to their faces)

OP posts:
Fionaville · 16/02/2024 18:51

It depends what she finds scary. My SiL and BiL used to smack and shout loudly at their kids (similar aged to ours) and I hated it. I don't think people realise that other people don't want to see kids being disciplined harshly. A smack on the leg or shouting loudly might be the norm for some parents, but its not for me and mine. I don't want to see it and I don't want my kids around it.

MurderMitts · 16/02/2024 18:43

BeaRF75 · 16/02/2024 17:58

If she thinks you're strict, you're probably doing it right. You should be proud - your children will grow up to be polite and responsible adults, and not over-indulged.

This. I'd probably take it as a compliment. Most parents are verging on negligent these days.

BeaRF75 · 16/02/2024 17:58

If she thinks you're strict, you're probably doing it right. You should be proud - your children will grow up to be polite and responsible adults, and not over-indulged.

AnnaMagnani · 16/02/2024 17:51

PutThatDownNowPlease · 16/02/2024 17:42

Most times I hear people judging other parents for being too “strict” it’s because they have a lack of discipline with their own kids. This comment seems to be more about her than you. I would ignore it.

This.

The 'strict' parents in our family appeared to be perfectly normal but got accused of being scary by the 'relaxed' ones.

Saymyname28 · 16/02/2024 17:49

If your parenting is scary to an adult then it's more than just being strict.
She may be trying to tell you that your parenting is concerning.
Strict is maintaining firm boundaries, there should be nothing scary.

PicaK · 16/02/2024 17:47

💐💐💐

Odingodof · 16/02/2024 17:47

Op as much as I would be upset I would also use this as an opportunity to reflect on my parenting.

Are you strict? Do you need to be? Could you relax more?
Is your sil too laid back? Is there a compromise.

PicaK · 16/02/2024 17:47

Can't judge on whether you are a scary control freak or not, sorry.
Can judge your sil who has said something hurtful when you are on your own.
Step away from worrying about whether it's justified or not. Call her out on her words and her timing.
Deflect the inevitable ins and outs. Get it back to "How would you feel if someone described your parenting as scary when you were on your own? "
But decide what you want. An apology (a real one). Or something else.

Fwiw if you need independent assessment ask school for early help. Trust them. Do not ask for opinions on parenting from anyone else!

Hugs.kind of thing my ex sils would do. Stamp on it now with the bravery and clarity I never had. They helped considerably with my slide into depression.

Tell your dh. Your sil used very specific negative language to describe our parenting.

I'd go home. Don't take crap because it will grow and grow.

Checkeringin · 16/02/2024 17:46

It depends what you mean by strict. I had a friend who was otherwise lovely, but called herself strict. This basically involved screaming at her DC and very little in the way of actual boundaries. If you generally have a close relationship and she cares about your DC, she may be trying to highlight your behaviour.

Foxblue · 16/02/2024 17:45

That must have been hard to hear, especially as it all sounds full-on for you at the moment.
What sticks out to me is that she mentioned your parents and your sister, and then said it twice. That does seem to indicate she thought about it before saying it. Which, while this may be tough to hear, means that it might be worth taking a step back and assessing yourself a bit? Did you ask her for examples, or could you? She could genuinely be concerned for the stress you are under, and while i understand it must hurt, if she's doing it out of love for you and your family then it's worth thinking about, as let's face it, it's easy to lose sight of things sometimes, and we're not always great at judging ourselves. From what you've written, it does sound like you think there might be a grain of truth there? Can you think of anything that might have happened to prompt her to say this?

Nori10 · 16/02/2024 17:45

This is a tough one. If you were raised by strict parents (overly strict?), then I guess unless you make a concerted effort to be different, it's likely you'll parent in a similar way to how you were raised (we all have a tendency to do this). Of course you're trying your best, as we all are, but if something has felt confronting (like this seems to have felt for you), it could be because you recognise some truth to it? There is a difference between strict and firm and there is lots of parenting research that shows that authoritarian parenting, does not have the best outcomes.

Of course, without knowing you and your style of parenting, the above could be true or it could just be that she has a much softer approach and so perceives your parenting as 'strict' when it's actually not overly. You could prove her further or ask an honest friend for feedback?

Frasers · 16/02/2024 17:43

ChildofSunday · 16/02/2024 17:31

Being strict is not a bad thing generally. It certainly shouldn’t be ‘scary’.
Having rules and boundaries you and your partner stick too consistently should in theory make parenting easier in the long run, is it easier to loosen the reins as they get older than suddenly tighten them!
Is her parenting style very different to yours? What would you say to her if you could without offending her?

Simply Having rules and boundaries ia not being strict. And yes it can be very bad indeed, controlling, not allowing children to learn, demanding obeyance, no flexibility, those are the kids who grow up and run.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 16/02/2024 17:42

Without any specific examples it's impossible to say.

I remember a few incidents from my childhood where I found my dad scary and it's not a nice feeling. I also remember one of my friends' mums seeming especially strict and being terrified of going to her house as a result.

PutThatDownNowPlease · 16/02/2024 17:42

Most times I hear people judging other parents for being too “strict” it’s because they have a lack of discipline with their own kids. This comment seems to be more about her than you. I would ignore it.

MermaidEyes · 16/02/2024 17:41

sprigatito · 16/02/2024 17:30

Is there any truth in it? Are you "scary" in the way you handle your kids? If someone said that to me, I would have a good soul-search and decide whether I thought they had a point or not. If I really didn't think so, I would conclude that they were a prat and ignore them.

This. Some things are worth being strict over (safety). Some things really aren't (food, clothing choices).

Frasers · 16/02/2024 17:41

Muddling along isn’t ok, are you too strict, scary strict? Instead of being all offended, reflect on is It true and how do you treat your own kids, is she right if so get it sorted, if not, then ask her to explain why she thinks that.

AnnaMagnani · 16/02/2024 17:41

Don't go on holiday with them again, lesson learned.

DH's siblings have both parented very differently. All the kids have turned out OK, probably we prefer the ones who had 'strict' parents.

The 'relaxed' ones used to bitch to us about the 'strict' ones and avoided spending time together as a family. They were also the most convinced that their way was the best way, rather than just muddling along like most parents do.

Don't take it personally but don't give her the opportunity to slag you off again without defending yourself.

takealettermsjones · 16/02/2024 17:40

I know for a fact that my SIL thinks I'm too strict. I think she's lax. I also know that my DSis thinks I'm lax 😆 Opinions are like arseholes.

Agree with PPs though that it's almost impossible to comment without examples.

Anahenzaris · 16/02/2024 17:40

Are there noticeable differences between how the two groups of children are able to enjoy the holiday? Are you always the one ending fun/play or reminding children of responsibilities? Are your children ever scared of your response to things?

It’s never easy to hear criticism - but if your parenting does scare her as being overly strict - isn’t it better she say something? If her husband was overly affected by strict parenting, and refers to it a lot in their parenting discussions, she might have felt it important to not just silently watch you behave similarly. She may have been trying to think how to raise a really sensitive topic - and ended up saying it twice cause sure was rehearsing it in her head how to do this. You’ve said she’s mentioned your sister - maybe she’s saying something direct because she doesn’t think you got the indirect references and sure is genuinely concerned.

Strict is a vague definition - it can mean everything from child isn’t allowed to go parties full of drunk teens, or child is expected to keep their room clean, to child experiences a level of control that is abusive and leaves them afraid to misstep. And a lot in between.

I think you should take a step back and look at how “strict” plays out for you. Is it not letting your kids run wild? Or does it control your kids too much? Maybe talk to your brother privately - it could be that they have spoken together about this topic. He might be in full agreement with his wife’s comments.

It might also be, when you calmly evaluate things, that your conclusion is B&SIL go too far the other way and parent in a way you think is not good for their kids.

NewmummyJ · 16/02/2024 17:39

It's so subjective and so many things at play here. I suspect one of my friend's feels I'm too strict with my son, but she literally has no boundaries with her daughter as she can't tolerate distress (i.e. that she might cry or tantrum is she doesnt allow her 2-3 ice creams a day). Boundaries are good for children, and consistently maintaining them make them feel secure and safe. Being excessively authoritarian and punitive is not however. Only you and those around you will know where you sit, but her comment may have been as much as about her as it is you.

Octavia64 · 16/02/2024 17:39

I can imagine it didn't feel good.

FWIW some parenting can come across as scary - my ex FIL was a shouty father and a shouty grandpa and he could be quite unpleasant to be around.

I hope that it's her being unreasonable.

Iloveacurry · 16/02/2024 17:38

Well look at it this way, you’re on holiday parenting by yourself and she’s with her DH. You’re doing double the work load so to speak. Perhaps you’ve been unable to relax as much as she has!

Quartz2208 · 16/02/2024 17:37

So rather than point out that maybe muddling through means that you can possibly be too strict/scary you wanted her to talk behind your back.

having clearly defined boundaries is good

strict maybe not it all depends

Hmindr68 · 16/02/2024 17:37

Or. Is her parenting style particularly un-strict? Does she lack discipline/boundaries? She may have noticed something lacking in her own methods, and is justifying it to herself, by branding your style as “scary”.

Ihaterhymingrabbit · 16/02/2024 17:36

It’s hard to advise without examples.

My dad was too strict and I’ve never forgotten it. Being too strict can create anxiety and stress for children and give a feeling of a lack of control and the need to take back that control by rebelling or destructive behaviour. Even over eating or under eating.