Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so upset at SIL saying I was strict with my children and she finds it ‘scary’

112 replies

MakeEconomyScream · 16/02/2024 17:22

Am away on holiday with DB, SIL and their children. I am here without DP but with my DC. I have always had a lovely relationship with SIL…until today! We were talking on a walk when she started saying her dad was very relaxed and so was she but my DB was a bit stricter with the DC. She said my parents were strict with me and my DB/DS. I agreed and then she said (TWICE - so obviously really wanted to say it): ‘you’re strict with your children and I find it a bit scary’. OUCH. I wanted to cry. I may be strict - maybe even too strict (who knows?) - I’m muddling my way through a full time job, two young children (one of whom doesn’t sleep, the other of whom is pretty challenging at times) and away for a week without my DP. If she really thought this couldn’t she just slag me off to my DB rather than hit me in the gut with her words? I feel really uncomfortable being around her now and am questioning my parenting and myself. Is this what she wanted? (For context, she has said similar to me about my DSis and her partner before, but to my knowledge has never said it to their faces)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tengreenbottles2 · 17/02/2024 11:38

Just another perspective, to say she didn't necessarily mean anything negative when she said you are "strict" -

I have in the past referred to my SIL and BIL as "strict" .. .what I mean by that is they are very firm, and are much more able to hold boundaries than me or DH ever seem to manage. (I don't mean strict in the sense of shouting constantly, having endless arbitrary rules and not letting kids be kids). When I say they are strict, it's not a bad thing in my book, it's a GOOD thing! I am envious of how they are, and I'm always subtly observing to see if I can pick up some tips.

Whenwordsfail · 17/02/2024 10:35

We avoid spending time with my BIL + SIL because of their "strict " parenting.

We decided not to go on holiday with them again because we could tolerate them shouting constantly. It's really disruptive to be trying to do anything when an adult is constantly shouting near you. Frankly we don't want our kids around the level of tension they bring

They seem to be a real passion for "because I told you so" and arbitary rules so spend a lot of the time telling their kids what to do, so then it's really easy for the kids to "disobey". Everything is a battle ground with a wrong way to do it. Even simple stuff like why have you put your coat on before your shoes, you must keep your slippers on at all times"

To the extent at christmas I bought a craft activity and felt really bad because the kids got told off repetitively for "doing it wrong" because they weren't decorating them according to the parents preferences. It wasn't shouting just constant "listen" "not like thst" "you're spoiling it" "you need to put these sequins here" "we will pack it away if you don't do it properly" in authoritive tones etc
They asked for a noisy toy for Christmas and we didn't get it because we knew it would be a new battleground of its to early to play with that, too late, not while adults are talking etc

Weve tried to gently have a conversation about it, but now just dont spend much time with them because its too stressful.

We've no idea what to do about it. It's a sad situation all round

Anniegetyourgun · 17/02/2024 10:18

It's good you and SIL were able to clear the air. It's also good that you each found something admirable about the other's parenting style which it sounds as though you could both learn something from. Mind you, sometimes what we learn from other parents is what NOT to do...

Towerofsong · 17/02/2024 08:55

I just want to say that if she is a gentle sort of person and has said something and risked upsetting /annoying you, maybe she feels very strongly that something needed to be said. You may be offended but it's worth some self reflection of how your strictness may land with a child.

I grew up with parents who were 'strict'. A couple of minor daily examples: I'd be put to bed early, before I was tired and told that if I wasn't asleep in 10 minutes my dad (who always seemed tense, angry and on the edge) would be back to smack me. I wasn't allowed out of bed to go to the loo overnight. I grew up afraid, controlled and anxious. Aunts, uncles, teachers and grandparents knew it was too much and they knew I wasn't happy, (they quietly told me so in my late childhood) but nobody said anything to my parents so they wouldn't offend them.

I wish someone had cared enough or had the guts to say something.

Frasers · 17/02/2024 08:32

Can I ask gently why you habe to try so hard to be kind to your own kids?

i find some of your wording concerning, and it does feel like possibly the sil has climbed down to avoid a family war.

being kind to your kids should be the default, being unkind as default and you need to work to avoid it, is a concern

RedToothBrush · 17/02/2024 08:24

Why take it as a criticism?

Maybe take it as a compliment.

Friends in teaching hold the view that a decline in parental discipline at home is having a massive negative impact on behaviour in classrooms.

Maybe you have the right idea and she doesn't.

RatatouillePie · 17/02/2024 08:20

The correct response is that kids need clear boundaries so you're just providing what they need.

ColdButSunny · 17/02/2024 08:14

Your update is good, OP. I think it's positive that you and your SIL were able to discuss it, and it's good if both of you are using this as an opportunity to reflect on your parenting.

I do think you may have misunderstood 'scary' - you took it to mean that your children are scared of you which would be a negative thing. But she may have meant (like a pp says) that she finds the idea of being firm with people scary, which is more a comment about her than you.

Kind but with boundaries sounds like an excellent aim for all of us as parents.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 17/02/2024 06:34

“What do you mean by that?” Would have been my response.

WandaWonder · 17/02/2024 01:30

Well if I am not scary then I would assume they have unresolved issues, just because someone says something doesn't make it true and there is no need to turn dramatic over it

If it is wrong change if you want if not move on

HollyKnight · 17/02/2024 00:35

I think she was just making an observation based on her own contrasting experience growing up, rather than making a criticism. But clearly it has hit a nerve with you because, I'm guessing, you feel like you go too far with your children sometimes and it upsets you to think someone else thinks that of you too.

Anele22 · 17/02/2024 00:28

Are your children scared of you? If not then I think this is your SIL putting you down because you have a firmer parenting style than she does. Perhaps she feels inadequate?

Frangipanyoul8r · 17/02/2024 00:09

This all depends on how old your children are and what you mean by “strict”. I have firm boundaries and rules with my own young children but the word “strict” sounds nasty in the context of young children. If you discipline in a way that isn’t age appropriate then that could be something to reflect on.

NewName24 · 16/02/2024 23:29

Thanks for your update.
That's so positive.

In truth, from the OP, I thought your interpretation of what she said was quite different from what I "heard" her say, from your description.
But this is a classic case of - keeping in mind you said "I've always had a lovely relationship with SiL" - why on earth you didn't ask her what she meant at the time.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 16/02/2024 23:09

Could she have meant scary as in 'I wouldn't mess with you you clearly mean business' as in a compliment that you're taken seriously when she isn't? Only you know the tone of voice.

When most people comment on others like that it's a jealousy thing- she is probably jealous that you have children that behave.

Unless YOU think there's a chance your children might be scared of you then I wouldn't give it any more thought

Whycantiwinmillionsandsquillions · 16/02/2024 23:05

Ahhh so she is a parent without boundaries.
That is crap.
Children respect and need boundaries.
Children without them tend to be a nightmare.
How on earth will they ever know right from wrong?
How can they behave at school? Or in society for that matter.
Letting children do as they please us wrong.
If children were capable of making their own decisions then we wouldn’t need laws to protect them would we?
They would be able to di as they please from a very young age.
Goodness me society needs more parents like you op and fewer like your sil.

Mariposistaaa · 16/02/2024 22:59

Are you always very over sensitive? ‘Strict’ doesn’t mean abusive!
FWIW strict is better than wishy washy gentle. If your kids are well behaved, respectful and disciplined you are doing fine.

2chocolateoranges · 16/02/2024 22:57

I’d much rather be a stricter parent who sets boundaries than a parent who has no boundaries and their child walks all over them.

i know a couple who don’t say no, their child rules the house and their child makes the decisions on where they want to go what they want to eat etc, they say they are scared to set boundaries in case their child doesn’t like them! This child is 4!

I also know an 8yr old who has had no boundaries and parents are regretting the choices they have made.

Whoopaday · 16/02/2024 22:54

@MakeEconomyScream you said she said your parents are strict with you. Is that a current thing? As you’re an adult and they should have zero control or say over your life and parenting/adult decisions.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 16/02/2024 22:53

Is she using the 'you' to mean both of you?

Could she be trying to broach the subject that she is scared of how her husband treats the children when there aren't any witnesses?

Sasqwatch · 16/02/2024 22:52

Are you scary OP? Food for thought.

Dacadactyl · 16/02/2024 22:46

Do you feel you know what you're doing?

If so, crack on and don't listen to her.

I rarely question my parenting decisions and I wouldn't let a comment like that from anyone bother me.

Tengreenbottles2 · 16/02/2024 22:35

Everyone takes everything as criticism these days. Sometimes a comment's just that - a comment. It doesn't have to be good or bad. Are you stricter than her? If so, the comment's true. Where's the problem?

Itisverycomplicated · 16/02/2024 22:21

The word scary may be confusing for you but I can believe her explanation. I’m a therapist and I have had clients describe the thought of putting in boundaries with people as terrifying, that it would destroy their relationships, that it would mean they were terrible people. So I get that it’s scary. She may have an admiration but also a fear that she can’t remove from the way she talks about it. For me, the use of the word strict stood out, as that carries negative connotations. But I think the fact she’s sought you out, tried to clarify and tried to reassure you it wasn’t a judgement is all positive. Time will tell.

MakeEconomyScream · 16/02/2024 21:57

Thanks everyone for taking the time to reply. I told my DB and and asked if he thought I could approach his wife about what she’d said. He then went and told her himself and she came and apologised and said it wasn’t what she meant, that she had meant that I have boundaries and stick to them and that she really admired that. Tbh I’m not sure that’s really the whole story as the ‘scary’ thing was unnecessary if it were. She did say she saw herself as a pushover and I wonder if classing me as scary for my approach makes her feel more secure in her ‘pushover-ness’. I have to say I don’t think she’s a pushover, just a kind and very patient mum. I would have said I try and emulate her parenting to a certain degree. I don’t shout at my kids very often at all, but i could be kinder sometimes. This is something I have always worked on.
Regardless of whether what she said is accurate or not, it has made me think about how to improve further as a parent, which is a good thing. I would just never dream of commenting to someone who is obviously really trying on their parenting like that.

OP posts: