Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dentist removing me as NHS patient?

89 replies

Collienova · 16/02/2024 17:06

Are there any dentists or dental practice managers that could advise on whether I'm being unreasonable here please?

Backstory...sorry it's a longer one but I'm trying not to drip feed.
I have a certain apprehension about going to the dentist (probably from childhood), but I have been trying to get better. Anyway, I had the last proper checkup in 2018 and was due one in 2020 which was cancelled by the practice due to Covid restrictions. I have been seeing a hygienist at this practise and then at a different private one as I didn't get on with the hygienist at the one this relates to. I have been taking my children every 6 months and at the last visit this week, I thought I'd better get over my fear and make another appointment. There have been no reminders or any communication by the practice about a check up being due or anything else. I was at that point informed that I would have to go private as I haven't been for a check up in 2 years and there is an apparent rule set by the NHS that you have to go every 2 years or they strike you off the NHS patient list. When I queried that they hadn't sent me any reminders or given me notice of any sort they stated that reminders are a goodwill gesture and that it's my responsibility.

I don't have a problem taking that responsibility, but my issue is that I can't find anything on the practice website, their Facebook page, the NHS website or my local ICHB website about this 2 year rule? I'm happy to stick to that, but they're refusing to reinstate me saying that they would lose their NHS contract if they do? I have to doubt that as a friend of mine had the same situation and she managed to speak to the practice manager at the time and was reinstated when she complained. I asked for the practice manager, but I was told I have to complain by email and they would get back to me within 28 days.

Could anyone shed any light on the rules here so I can craft a meaningful email please? I know I should've gone earlier, but i think it's not right to strike someone off the patient list without letting them know what the rules are and without giving them any notice? many thanks in advance!

OP posts:
SecretSquare · 16/02/2024 19:13

You're bloody cheeky even considering complaining OP.

Most people are DESPERATE to get an NHS dentist.

You have responsibility for your YOURSELF.

Just why do you think it's their problem because they cancelled an appointment 4 years ago?! It's NOT their responsibility you've "put it to the bottom of your to do list" for FOUR years.

What is wrong with everyone on here lately taking zero responsibility for themselves. It gives me the absolute rage.

JaneLawrence · 16/02/2024 19:11

Our NHS dentist also kicks patients off the list if they haven’t attended for 2 years.

They didn’t include non-attendance during Covid closures towards that 2 years - so e.g someone who’d had their last checkup 18 months before the Covid closures would have had another 6 months after they reopened for adult checkups before being kicked off their lists.
But if i remember right my dentist resumed routine adult checkups around June or July 2022 so that’s more than 18 months ago now. And we didn’t get any reminders about booking appointments when they resumed adult appointments either.

They did however keep on doing children’s checkups every 6 months as soon as Covid restrictions allowed, and every time I took the DC there for checkups I asked for an update on whether they’d started doing adult appointments yet. Which is something that you could easily have done when you were taking your DC for their appointments.

I can’t see you getting very far with a complaint about being removed as a patient given that you’ve left it so long to try and book an appointment, and unfortunately I think you’ll struggle to get back in as an NHS patient given the dentist shortages in most of the U.K.

caringcarer · 16/02/2024 19:11

Collienova · 16/02/2024 17:23

I understand that shortage of NHS places for adults, but if they hadn't cancelled my check up in 2020 it wouldn't be 6 years. I'm really trying to verify the argument that they would lose their NHS contract if they reinstated me? How can that be true if they reinstated someone else at the same practice in the same situation? Could anyone shed any light on this?

Even if you'd gone on 2020 it would still be 3-4 years. The cutoff is 2 years. Some people can't get a space at all and you had one and didn't use it. It's better to give it to a person who makes use of it.

RubyWinehouse · 16/02/2024 18:51

I have to drive a 200 mile round trip to see my dentist. Where I live, there aren't any NHS dentists, and I just can't afford to pay to go private. Although its not ideal and going for a routine checkup now takes up around 6 hours of my day instead of 20 mins if I could go to a dentist in my own town I still go for regular appointments as I'm frightened of losing my NHS place. So, in reply to your question, I don't think you will get anywhere by complaining, NHS places are rarer than hens teeth - pardon the pun!

feathermucker · 16/02/2024 18:50

The onus is on you to book an appointment, not to be in a situation where you are reminded by the dentist. If you've been taking your kids, you've had multiple opportunities to book your own appointment. 2020 was 4 years ago, they can't wait forever when there's such a demand for appointments!

Knoblauch1664 · 16/02/2024 18:45

Yabu

Most people are struggling to access NHS dentistry. If you’re not going to go, why should they keep you on when other people are desperate for your spot?

You can craft an email if you want but it’s a pointless, entitled, waste of your time.

Sonora25 · 16/02/2024 18:41

Stop blaming the dentist, you managed to book your kids in so you should have managed to book yourself in too. You had literally years. There are lots of people on the waiting lists and this is well known.

SilverBranchGoldenPears · 16/02/2024 18:39

It’s your fault @Collienova. You have to suck it up. It’s how it goes if you don’t make an appointment. I left the UK 6 years ago and this was the rule at my surgery even then. You can’t complain without making yourself look silly. And nor should you.

Bs0u416d · 16/02/2024 18:36

I should add that your current practice is almost certainly not going to see you as an NHS patient. You may find being accepted as an NHS patient locally very difficult and it might be time to either consider private dental insurance or signing up to a dental plan that covers some or all of your care for a fixed monthly cost (not withstanding any treatment required to get you dentally fit). I should add, I'm a dentist, if that adds any weight to my opinion. I'm sorry your're in this position but I'd take it up with your MP rather than the dentist themselves.

TeenLifeMum · 16/02/2024 18:36

I got kicked off my private dentist list as I didn’t go for 2 years and 3 months during covid when their website had a “only come in emergencies” message. Totally bonkers - the other 4 (dh and 3dc all went but my teeth were fine). Dc now dropped because they’ve stopped doing nhs. Only option is a private family dental plan.

TheSnowyOwl · 16/02/2024 18:34

I think that texting and posting reminders costs money so it’s understandable that it’s scaled back.

The break during covid didn’t even last three months so you were unfortunate that your appointment was during this timeframe but it was widespread in the media when patients could return from early June 2020.

I think that even if you had gone to that appointment, it was almost four years ago and you still would have been removed from their system.

wombat15 · 16/02/2024 18:33

They are ultimately a private business and while they can choose to see NHS patients they probably prefer private. It's probably not cost effective to see people who rarely attend.

As a private business they can choose their customers so don't see the point in complaining. It may be worth asking nicely if you can go on their list though.

amieloue · 16/02/2024 18:31

They can't keep everyone on though.

What if you've moved and use another?

Ideally they should tell people this before though.

Covid is irrelevant. We were all in the same boat.

I had the same dentist for 32 years until they closed and passed us onto someone new. I've been with them ever since (7 years). Me and the kids go twice a year.

My DH joined the military age 18 and he retires this year after 22 years. They have a dentist on camp which he can just walk into to. No payment.

I put him on our dentist waiting list in 2020 and I've emailed every year since to check he's still on the list.

Bs0u416d · 16/02/2024 18:29

There is no longer such a think as being 'registered' at an NHS dentist. There hasn't been for a long time. You are a patient for a course of treatment only. They are not required to see you thereafter.

FriendlyNeighbourhoodAccountant · 16/02/2024 18:28

Collienova · 16/02/2024 17:58

Thanks Luxell934. My dentist was also only taking emergency appointments and didn't let any of their patients know when they reopened. They didn't post on their website or Facebook page which they keep referring me to. I don't buy that they can't text their patients to remind them, their system is perfectly capable of handling that without much extra human input. Tbh, yes, I should have rebooked, but it's been at the bottom of my list as I worked all hours under eye sun during Covid and after and have just managed to keep up with hygienist appointments. I will be complaining, we'll see how it goes.

You've managed to rebook for your children though so you were fully aware that they'd reopened but you haven't made your own appointments a priority. Yes it may have been at the bottom of your list but unfortunately for you with so few NHS places the person next on the waiting list probably has made it a priority.

Your spot will have been given away, you aren't a regular patient and even prior to covid you weren't. An appointment in 2018 and the next one not booked until 2020 shows you aren't going particularly regularly.

Feel free to complain but now you're not a registered patient I'd be very surprised if something came of it. They won't be allowed to bump you to the top of the waitlist.

LIZS · 16/02/2024 18:24

You would probably have been given more time given the pandemic closure but most had reopened by late 2020/2021. Whilst it might have been nice if they had proactively rebooked those who were cancelled there was nothing to stop you doing so when you booked the dc appointments.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 16/02/2024 18:19

Tbh, yes, I should have rebooked, but it's been at the bottom of my list as I worked all hours under eye sun during Covid and after and have just managed to keep up with hygienist appointments. I will be complaining, we'll see how it goes.

But you managed to book appointments for your kids Confused

boredybored · 16/02/2024 18:18

Why not just Accept you are in the wrong and get another dentist with a plan . Dentists aren't making any money from nhs patients so are doing anything they can to get rid of them .

TwylaSands · 16/02/2024 18:15

It’s been four years since appointments were cancelled due to covid. You absolutely could have phoned them and made an appointment since.

i dont fancy your chances of getting another nhs dentist. Private might be your best bet.

Lollygaggle · 16/02/2024 18:09

In England there is no such thing as registration with a dentist. They only have to see you whilst you are under a course of treatment.

In reality most dentists try to save slots for their regular patients.

NHS dental practices have limited contracts, they are only allowed to do so much work a year, any more than that and not only are they not paid they are financially penalised.

There is no compulsion for a practice to spend yet more money , when practice is very cash strapped , in sending out reminders to people who do not keep regular appointments. The software and costs associated come to many hundreds/thousand a month to send reminders .

Unfortunately there are not enough practices offering NHS appointments so any spare space will quickly get snapped up.

unfortunately you have not made an appointment since before 2020 , the practice does not regard you as a regular patient, it is under no compulsion to see you. In fact once you have completed a course of treatment the practice is under no compulsion to see you as registration has not existed in England since 2006 .

Tumbleweed101 · 16/02/2024 18:08

I'm very paranoid about losing my nhs dentist so make sure I attend every six months. During covid when appointments got cancelled I just kept rebooking until they finally re opened. I know for a fact I can't afford private dental fees so need my NHS dentist so ensure I am always up to date and prioritise it.

In your case I think it is probably your misjudgement that has contributed to losing your space by not keeping in touch. If you've made appointments with hygienist it would have been easy to book with dentist around same time too

Etincelle · 16/02/2024 18:05

My dentist is good but we don't get reminders at all. Don't think I've had that for years. We get removed if we don't go for 2 years but I thought that was quite lenient. I had one before where it was 1 year I think. I just remember to book each Christmas and Summer for all of us.
I booked an appointment as soon as I'd had my first covid jab as I felt that would give me some protection. The staff had all been jabbed by then too.

Collienova · 16/02/2024 17:58

Thanks Luxell934. My dentist was also only taking emergency appointments and didn't let any of their patients know when they reopened. They didn't post on their website or Facebook page which they keep referring me to. I don't buy that they can't text their patients to remind them, their system is perfectly capable of handling that without much extra human input. Tbh, yes, I should have rebooked, but it's been at the bottom of my list as I worked all hours under eye sun during Covid and after and have just managed to keep up with hygienist appointments. I will be complaining, we'll see how it goes.

OP posts:
Luxell934 · 16/02/2024 17:51

My dentist tried to do this to me. Last check up was 2019, during Covid they text to say they weren’t offering routine appointments only emergency ones and they would contact you when they started offering routine ones again. They never contacted me so last year I contacted them to make an appointment and they said that I’d been taken off the list. I was fuming, I was also pregnant at the time and called numerous times to complain and speak to the manager who eventually added me back on.

CatchAButterfly · 16/02/2024 17:48

Collienova · 16/02/2024 17:23

I understand that shortage of NHS places for adults, but if they hadn't cancelled my check up in 2020 it wouldn't be 6 years. I'm really trying to verify the argument that they would lose their NHS contract if they reinstated me? How can that be true if they reinstated someone else at the same practice in the same situation? Could anyone shed any light on this?

But you didn’t book another appointment, so it’s been 3-4 years since that cancelled appointment?