Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dentist removing me as NHS patient?

89 replies

Collienova · 16/02/2024 17:06

Are there any dentists or dental practice managers that could advise on whether I'm being unreasonable here please?

Backstory...sorry it's a longer one but I'm trying not to drip feed.
I have a certain apprehension about going to the dentist (probably from childhood), but I have been trying to get better. Anyway, I had the last proper checkup in 2018 and was due one in 2020 which was cancelled by the practice due to Covid restrictions. I have been seeing a hygienist at this practise and then at a different private one as I didn't get on with the hygienist at the one this relates to. I have been taking my children every 6 months and at the last visit this week, I thought I'd better get over my fear and make another appointment. There have been no reminders or any communication by the practice about a check up being due or anything else. I was at that point informed that I would have to go private as I haven't been for a check up in 2 years and there is an apparent rule set by the NHS that you have to go every 2 years or they strike you off the NHS patient list. When I queried that they hadn't sent me any reminders or given me notice of any sort they stated that reminders are a goodwill gesture and that it's my responsibility.

I don't have a problem taking that responsibility, but my issue is that I can't find anything on the practice website, their Facebook page, the NHS website or my local ICHB website about this 2 year rule? I'm happy to stick to that, but they're refusing to reinstate me saying that they would lose their NHS contract if they do? I have to doubt that as a friend of mine had the same situation and she managed to speak to the practice manager at the time and was reinstated when she complained. I asked for the practice manager, but I was told I have to complain by email and they would get back to me within 28 days.

Could anyone shed any light on the rules here so I can craft a meaningful email please? I know I should've gone earlier, but i think it's not right to strike someone off the patient list without letting them know what the rules are and without giving them any notice? many thanks in advance!

OP posts:
Lollygaggle · 16/02/2024 22:01

Soupit · 16/02/2024 21:53

I am obsessive about keeping my nhs dentist. They stopped sending reminders years ago saying they weren't obliged to (I bet their private patients get reminders). To get round this I book my next appointment while I'm still there.
I've drilled in to DC that they must keep up to date with dentists and though they have moved away they come home for dental appointments. Many of their friends have lost access to dentists.

Private patients get reminders because a dental practice can add the considerable cost onto the cost of treatment. Just the licence for the software is around £500 a month plus the cost of texts etc

NHS pays so little whatever is not essential is stripped out, otherwise a practice would lose more money than they already do on NHS treatment.

gamerchick · 16/02/2024 21:56

I make my next appointment while I'm there after checkup. They're every 9 months now but they send reminders when it's due. They wouldn't send reminders to make an appointment.

WandaWonder · 16/02/2024 21:54

Wouldn't it be simpler to just go

Soupit · 16/02/2024 21:53

I am obsessive about keeping my nhs dentist. They stopped sending reminders years ago saying they weren't obliged to (I bet their private patients get reminders). To get round this I book my next appointment while I'm still there.
I've drilled in to DC that they must keep up to date with dentists and though they have moved away they come home for dental appointments. Many of their friends have lost access to dentists.

gamerchick · 16/02/2024 21:52

Pretty much what the ones around here do..if you don't go for checkups, you get struck off with no warning.

Instead of looking for a loophole, you probably should put the effort into finding a dentist OP.

Meagainnewname · 16/02/2024 21:48

Where I live all dentists are now private, we’ve not got 1 NHS dentists in the area!

Bs0u416d · 16/02/2024 21:47

Collienova · 16/02/2024 19:30

Yes, I genuinely thought that's how it works! As with your GP surgery. I registered with the practice and I would remain on their patient list. Clearly a naive thought. I didn't grow up in the UK and the system here still manages to baffle me 🤷‍♂️

Where did you grow up OP? Its interesting to hear how dental provision works else where so as to compare where we stand at home? Assume Europe somewhere that assures more secure access to state funded or subsidised dental care? (Genuine question, not goading)

Parentofeanda · 16/02/2024 20:33

to be fair it may have been at the bottom of your list but its at the top of other peoples lists who don't have a dentist because they cant get one, these dentists need to be booked up and people are always just keeping they're spot on the list without actually ever going in meaning they are losing out on that money from a client, and whilst someone may be in agony they cant get seen because someone else has had it at the bottom of they're list for the last 4 years

Lollygaggle · 16/02/2024 20:29

SurferRona · 16/02/2024 20:22

This is NOT a thing. There is no registration in NHS dentistry, it’s not like your GP. You are a patient for as long as you are getting treatment identified in your check up. Anyway, I heard on the news last week that the Gvt are now paying dentists a bonus to see people like you OP, I’m sure that your dentist may now be happy to see you 😶 kerching kerching

Actually not kerching , kerching as the money will not be available to all dentists and with it costing at least £140 an hour to run a room in a dental practice an extra £15 to £50 to treat a high needs patient who needs multiple appointments it won't even begin to scratch to surface of costs .

To put it into context , before tax, insurance , indemnity , registration costs etc etc a dentist will earn an extra £5 to £17 or less for taking on a patient who may well need hours of treatment.

There are many NHS treatments already in which a dentist loses money ..... root treatment, dentures , multiple fillings . A single file to do root treatment costs £30 on its own . This extra money won't even cover the cost of dental inflation which is running at 10 to 15% a year .

SecretSquare · 16/02/2024 20:24

SurferRona · 16/02/2024 20:22

This is NOT a thing. There is no registration in NHS dentistry, it’s not like your GP. You are a patient for as long as you are getting treatment identified in your check up. Anyway, I heard on the news last week that the Gvt are now paying dentists a bonus to see people like you OP, I’m sure that your dentist may now be happy to see you 😶 kerching kerching

But she's not getting treatment as she's not had a checkup?

SurferRona · 16/02/2024 20:22

This is NOT a thing. There is no registration in NHS dentistry, it’s not like your GP. You are a patient for as long as you are getting treatment identified in your check up. Anyway, I heard on the news last week that the Gvt are now paying dentists a bonus to see people like you OP, I’m sure that your dentist may now be happy to see you 😶 kerching kerching

Flottie · 16/02/2024 20:09

Pretty standard if you haven’t had a check up for years…

FUPAgirl · 16/02/2024 19:50

Op no one is judging you for not going to the dentist! However your excuses don't make sense - of course you knew that dentists were open as you've been attending the hygienist and taking the DC to the dentist. You had time for that so could have easily had your appt at the same time as DC. You need to own up to your mistake instead of making excuses!

Lollygaggle · 16/02/2024 19:38

Actually if you are not under a course of treatment a dentist doing NHS work can refuse to see you.

The problem is what the NHS pays will not cover the cost of providing care when in a cheap area of the country to run one room in a surgery will cost £140 an hour . The only money a practice gets to cover all costs (staff, training, materials, buildings , training, it, equipment , compliance etc etc etc ) is what is paid for treatment when a patient is in the chair. Most practices only stay open because they subsidise the costs with income from private work.

JaneLawrence · 16/02/2024 19:38

Collienova · 16/02/2024 19:30

Yes, I genuinely thought that's how it works! As with your GP surgery. I registered with the practice and I would remain on their patient list. Clearly a naive thought. I didn't grow up in the UK and the system here still manages to baffle me 🤷‍♂️

I think that part of the reason that dentists these days don’t keep patients on their list indefinitely is down to the severe shortage of NHS dentists.

There's been plenty of talk about this in the news etc and it’s a problem that’s been growing for well over a decade.

But the result is that the remaining NHS dental practices will almost certainly all have massive waiting lists - my (NHS) dentist has closed its waiting list as it’s grown so long - so most NHS dentists now will take inactive patients off their books to make room for one of the many, many patients on the waiting list.

DottieMoon · 16/02/2024 19:37

Completely your fault. You’ve left it too late. It’s not the dentist’s responsibility to reminder prompt you, you are an adult and responsible for your own appointments. It’s standard that you get removed if you don’t have regular check ups, tbh I thought it was less than two years so no excuse!

CatchAButterfly · 16/02/2024 19:36

No one is a “judgie”. You cocked up and there’s nothing wrong with that. We all make mistakes. But it’s you kicking off at the dentist and acting like you’ve been wronged when it’s your mistake. Own your mistake and the consequences of your actions.

BobbyBiscuits · 16/02/2024 19:35

They could well be drastically reducing the scope of NHS services they offer. Basically trying to phase it out kind of thing. So if anyone fails to show for 18 months, then they are out. That place is now effectively redundant so no longer exists for you to re-join. The dentists are making this choice as they presumably make so much more money with private patients. They cannot refuse you as an NHS patient (once you actually are one) any other way really, so they just hope a bunch of people don't come so they can be off the books! I think that's the case for nearly all NHS dentists now. I got chucked out of 2 practices, even though I had regularly attended, just because they discontinued the NHS service entirely.

Lollygaggle · 16/02/2024 19:35

If you look at NHs dental information it clearly says that dental surgeries are not compelled to offer you an appointment

"Once you find a dental surgery, you may have to fill in a registration form at your first visit, which is just to add you to their patient database. But that does not mean you have guaranteed access to an NHS dental appointment in the future"

from

https://www.nhs.uk/nhs-services/dentists/how-to-find-an-nhs-dentist/

nhs.uk

How to find an NHS dentist

Find out how to access NHS dental services.

https://www.nhs.uk/nhs-services/dentists/how-to-find-an-nhs-dentist/

Collienova · 16/02/2024 19:30

Yes, I genuinely thought that's how it works! As with your GP surgery. I registered with the practice and I would remain on their patient list. Clearly a naive thought. I didn't grow up in the UK and the system here still manages to baffle me 🤷‍♂️

OP posts:
SecretSquare · 16/02/2024 19:28

Collienova · 16/02/2024 19:23

I am taking responsibility for myself (and for a whole load of vulnerable people I care for). I would expect a fair notice what the rules were and none of my documentation contains that. I was on 2 year checkups and was attending hygienist appointments. I do dc by 'neglect' my oral care and now expect a whole load of treatment on the nhs. I have anxiety about seeing the dentist (which my practice was aware of). They used to send reminders and then stopped. Mumsnet clearly decided Im being unreasonable. Thanks for all the helpful responses. Hope the judgies never find that they messed up.

Don't be so touchy. You asked if you were being unreasonable and everyone agreed that yes - you are!

SecretSquare · 16/02/2024 19:27

Collienova · 16/02/2024 19:23

I am taking responsibility for myself (and for a whole load of vulnerable people I care for). I would expect a fair notice what the rules were and none of my documentation contains that. I was on 2 year checkups and was attending hygienist appointments. I do dc by 'neglect' my oral care and now expect a whole load of treatment on the nhs. I have anxiety about seeing the dentist (which my practice was aware of). They used to send reminders and then stopped. Mumsnet clearly decided Im being unreasonable. Thanks for all the helpful responses. Hope the judgies never find that they messed up.

But what if you hadn't contacted them? Would you seriously have expected them to keep you on indefinitely? Come on OP.

FriendlyNeighbourhoodAccountant · 16/02/2024 19:25

Collienova · 16/02/2024 19:23

I am taking responsibility for myself (and for a whole load of vulnerable people I care for). I would expect a fair notice what the rules were and none of my documentation contains that. I was on 2 year checkups and was attending hygienist appointments. I do dc by 'neglect' my oral care and now expect a whole load of treatment on the nhs. I have anxiety about seeing the dentist (which my practice was aware of). They used to send reminders and then stopped. Mumsnet clearly decided Im being unreasonable. Thanks for all the helpful responses. Hope the judgies never find that they messed up.

Nobody is judging you for messing up. They are judging you for thinking that it's the dentist's problem to fix your mistake. It isn't.

Collienova · 16/02/2024 19:23

I am taking responsibility for myself (and for a whole load of vulnerable people I care for). I would expect a fair notice what the rules were and none of my documentation contains that. I was on 2 year checkups and was attending hygienist appointments. I do dc by 'neglect' my oral care and now expect a whole load of treatment on the nhs. I have anxiety about seeing the dentist (which my practice was aware of). They used to send reminders and then stopped. Mumsnet clearly decided Im being unreasonable. Thanks for all the helpful responses. Hope the judgies never find that they messed up.

OP posts:
Libertysparkle · 16/02/2024 19:21

It is your responsibility to make appointments.

No judgement as I am now private because of my error.

Dentists offering NHS patients are telling people to come back in 6 months time to see if they have spaces.

I did email practice manager but was told similar to you especially as my children had still been going every 6 months (apart from covid)

I've just sucked it up as it's my fault and I have to own it. No one else to blame than myself.